These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

EVE General Discussion

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

The Dubious Threadnaught of the IHI vs. Incarna and CCP

First post
Author
Abdiel Kavash
Deep Core Mining Inc.
Caldari State
#21 - 2011-10-23 13:28:21 UTC
The problem isn't that people suddenly don't like walking in stations anymore.

The problem is, we have been promised vast, varied multiplayer environments. Board games. Bar fights. Manufacturing of clothes and equipment and handheld weapons. Black market trade and undercover agents offering lucrative missions. Customisable player-run stores and corporate offices to attract your customers and recruits. Interactive starmaps for alliances to coordinate an invasion.

To accomplish this, the EVE we all knew and loved was "put on the back burner" for almost two years.

At the beginning of 2011, CCP said that "they have no clear idea what they want WiS to be". Then we were promised singleplayer-only environments in the summer. Then just the racial CQ. In the end, what we got was one tiny, dirty, rusty room, which ran poorly on top-end graphics cards and literally fried the low-end ones, and was nothing but a storefront for a horribly overpriced MT shop.
Renan Ruivo
Forcas armadas
Brave Collective
#22 - 2011-10-23 13:36:42 UTC
WiS was released before it was ready because CCP wanted a quick money injection, and a sharp increase in subscriptions.

It did not happened. They got a sharp drop in subscriptions instead.


Management would have done what they did even if there was no EVE-O forums. You fail at understanding.

The world is a community of idiots doing a series of things until it explodes and we all die.

Renan Ruivo
Forcas armadas
Brave Collective
#23 - 2011-10-23 13:39:58 UTC
Abdiel Kavash wrote:
The problem isn't that people suddenly don't like walking in stations anymore.

The problem is, we have been promised vast, varied multiplayer environments. Board games. Bar fights. Manufacturing of clothes and equipment and handheld weapons. Black market trade and undercover agents offering lucrative missions. Customisable player-run stores and corporate offices to attract your customers and recruits. Interactive starmaps for alliances to coordinate an invasion.

To accomplish this, the EVE we all knew and loved was "put on the back burner" for almost two years.

At the beginning of 2011, CCP said that "they have no clear idea what they want WiS to be". Then we were promised singleplayer-only environments in the summer. Then just the racial CQ. In the end, what we got was one tiny, dirty, rusty room, which ran poorly on top-end graphics cards and literally fried the low-end ones, and was nothing but a storefront for a horribly overpriced MT shop.



You have been promised that. And you have been fooled into believing it was ready. It is not. On this expansion you received a single racial CQ and nothing else, and you would get other racial CQ's (still getting) and maybe.. maybe estabilishments. However i highly doubt you would get any sort of multiplayer environment before the next summer exp.

CCP would have to dedicate three to four expansions to fully fleshing this thing out, at the expense of proper EVE gameplay development. After the first expansion in that series of necessary expansions, they got a sharp decrease in subscriptions. If they were to keep up with it there would be no EVE for the complete WiS experience.

The world is a community of idiots doing a series of things until it explodes and we all die.

Kengutsi Akira
Doomheim
#24 - 2011-10-23 14:12:53 UTC
Renan Ruivo wrote:


CCP would have to dedicate three to four expansions to fully fleshing this thing out, at the expense of proper EVE gameplay development. After the first expansion in that series of necessary expansions, they got a sharp decrease in subscriptions. If they were to keep up with it there would be no EVE for the complete WiS experience.


This paragraph seems unweildy, hard to say.
See sig, itll make things easier

"Is it fair that CCP can get away with..." :: checks ownership on the box ::

Yes

Reilly Duvolle
Hydra Squadron
#25 - 2011-10-23 14:35:58 UTC  |  Edited by: Reilly Duvolle
Vyl Vit wrote:
In steps the I Hate Incarna minority, and with a pre-planned resistance movement SWAMP the forums


You one of those guys that claim the US government fabricated 9/11 too? You sure seem to love your conspiracy theories.

Personally I'd love to see Incarna work. I have even posted threads about it. BUT, CCP made one critical mistake. They designed the full body avatar environment to attract a new type of player, instead of leveraging FiS and existing gameplay to expand the EVE Online universe. So, instead of a "seamless space simulator" you get two different games - one with cutthroat backstabbing and eternal conflict, and one with space barbie. It HAD to fail.

Now, this was a situation that CCP possibly expected. With two so utterly dissconected features like WiS and FiS it should come as no surprise that their existing fanbase would disapprove (I dare say a lot more players than your "elite" got engaged in the June uprising). But CCP banked on attracting vast amounts of new people getting exited about playing dress up in a sci fi game, as a sorry excuse for engaging gameplay. To their dissapointment, they found that that player segment simply does not exist.

So there they were, attracting few new customers while simultaneously pissing off their existing fanbase. They HAD to do something. They made the right choice. Personally I'd still like to see Incarna. But Id like to see the EVE online version of it.
Mashie Saldana
V0LTA
OnlyFleets.
#26 - 2011-10-23 14:45:52 UTC
Abdiel Kavash wrote:
The problem isn't that people suddenly don't like walking in stations anymore.

The problem is, we have been promised vast, varied multiplayer environments. Board games. Bar fights. Manufacturing of clothes and equipment and handheld weapons. Black market trade and undercover agents offering lucrative missions. Customisable player-run stores and corporate offices to attract your customers and recruits. Interactive starmaps for alliances to coordinate an invasion.

Exactly, after being promised this and this but got this, is anyone surprised people ended up really annoyed with CCP especially as it had taken so many resources away from the spaceship development in the process?
Kengutsi Akira
Doomheim
#27 - 2011-10-23 16:29:43 UTC
Reilly Duvolle wrote:
Vyl Vit wrote:
In steps the I Hate Incarna minority, and with a pre-planned resistance movement SWAMP the forums


You one of those guys that claim the US government fabricated 9/11 too? You sure seem to love your conspiracy theories.

Personally I'd love to see Incarna work. I have even posted threads about it. BUT, CCP made one critical mistake. They designed the full body avatar environment to attract a new type of player, instead of leveraging FiS and existing gameplay to expand the EVE Online universe. So, instead of a "seamless space simulator" you get two different games - one with cutthroat backstabbing and eternal conflict, and one with space barbie. It HAD to fail.

Now, this was a situation that CCP possibly expected. With two so utterly dissconected features like WiS and FiS it should come as no surprise that their existing fanbase would disapprove (I dare say a lot more players than your "elite" got engaged in the June uprising). But CCP banked on attracting vast amounts of new people getting exited about playing dress up in a sci fi game, as a sorry excuse for engaging gameplay. To their dissapointment, they found that that player segment simply does not exist.

So there they were, attracting few new customers while simultaneously pissing off their existing fanbase. They HAD to do something. They made the right choice. Personally I'd still like to see Incarna. But Id like to see the EVE online version of it.


Incarna was only launched to Beta the tech they were gonna use for WoD
If WoD Hadnt been aquired, Im betting we'd still be talking like "hey CCP wheres that ambulation you promised?"
When they shelved WoD, they shelved Incarna. How is this hard?

"Is it fair that CCP can get away with..." :: checks ownership on the box ::

Yes

Tallian Saotome
Nuclear Arms Exchange Inc.
#28 - 2011-10-23 16:52:31 UTC
This refocus can't stay permanent. Its not a viable business decision. Development on Incarna and WoD WILL resume eventually. The hope is that that don't over-extend again, and instead maintain a full development staff on eve, while hiring full dev staff for WoD(which will end up completing Incarna). If they divert significant resources from Eve again, I think the company will crash and burn. If they build up to a second(and only one FULL development project, like DUST or WoD) project the right way, instead of being overly ambitious about what a limited staff can do in both areas, then they can succeed in expanding in the directions they want to.

If properly supported in this, they might even be able to bring back the 20%, but we have to be sure they stay on track with what the playerbase expects in terms of priorities. Nothing can have higher priority than Eve(equal priority is perfectly fine, ofc).

Now that CCP has realized their mistakes, it is time to stand back and support them, including an understanding of the business needs that drive the things they have to do while changing.

Inappropriate signature removed, CCP Phantom.

Mehrdad Kor-Azor
Doomheim
#29 - 2011-10-23 16:56:37 UTC
People didn't like Incarna because it had no content. And the NeX store didn't help matters much either. And the leaked newsletter was worst of all.

If CCP had delivered was promised( instead of the little rusty room), and also hadn't neglected some obvious issues with internet spaceships, everything would have been just peachy.

Get over it, OP.
Lumiukko
Center for Advanced Studies
Gallente Federation
#30 - 2011-10-23 17:16:23 UTC
ok, so imagine you live in a rented house.

every month you pay your rent, and in return, your landlord comes along every 6 months or so and does some maintainance and maybe improves some aspects of the house. he upgrades to double glazing, he upgrades the insulation, he installs all kinds of fancy energy efficient appliances etc.

now, for quite some time you have been asking him to re-decorate the place, and to repair some small but annoying problems.

then, one day, he says that he is going to redecorate the house, but that he needs time to save up the money and get the stuff together to do it, so you happilly wait, while those small annoying problems get worse, but thats ok, because he fixes anything that actually becomes a major issue, and you know your going to be decorated soon, so you put up with it.

then, at long last, after 7 years of waiting, you get the promised redecoration, but whats this? you come home and open the door to find that a bunch of perfectly good furnature has been broken, none of the pre-redecoration stuff has been fixed, every room has been painted the same colour, when you ask about this you find out that there will be more colours coming eventually, and that the only reason you got painted in the first place is that the landlord has another house he is building, and he wanted to see what the paint would look like in the new place, so tried it out in yours. then, to add to that, you go into your living room and look out the window, only to find that he has painted over that too, so you cant enjoy the view you had before, and now have no choice but to look at the paint job he so very kindly had done.

you'd probably be pissed, right?

well, then, when you try to raise the issue with him, he ignores you completely. then you get a call from a friend who has just heard him down the pub talking about how you are a whiney little *****, how he things the paintjob is fantastic, and how he isnt going to take any notice of what you say, because you wont actually do anything.

you'd definately be pissed then right?

thats kinda what the whole incana thing was to me, i waited 7 years for some stuff to be fixed, in that time alot of decent stuff got broken, so i waited again for that broken stuff to be fixed, and somewhere in there was this idea that i would get ambulation, but it was just something that would be cool, not something that would be nessecarry. then i have 2 years of nothing whatsoever, and eventually i get the ****** version of the "cool" ambulation, which it turns out was a beta for another game all together, which runs like **** on a rig that will run the space part of the game perfectly, all of which i could have forgiven, if it wasnt for the fact that people had been saying for ages that the test server had all of these problems and ccp totally ignored them. then, to add to all of that, we get a response from CCP saying we shoud stfu because we all wear $1000 dollar jeans, and a bunch of leaked stuff about how we should all quit or stfu.

In my eyes, that is what caused all the issues, not the content or lack there of, not the issues arising in the patch, but the total lack of comunitaction skills.

and maybe, just maybe, there were only a small "vocal minority" or "self appointed elite" talking on the forums, because a crapton of people agreed with them, and, just like me, saw no need to cloud the issue with more rabble rabble rabble?

the fact is that CCP ****** up, they drastically changed their own behaviour from what we had come to expect from them, and the trust that we had built up over years was burned to the ground. Now they have accepted this and admitted their mistakes, and are well on the way to making amends, and people are bitching because content which has existed for a matter of months is taking a back burner to things which have needed fixing for years? explain that?
Vyl Vit
#31 - 2011-10-23 19:06:22 UTC
Reilly Duvolle wrote:
Vyl Vit wrote:
In steps the I Hate Incarna minority, and with a pre-planned resistance movement SWAMP the forums
You one of those guys that claim the US government fabricated 9/11 too? You sure seem to love your conspiracy theories.


Ah, yeah...it's just this kind of statement that justifies my obvious contempt.

Paradise is like where you are right now, only much, much better.

DeMichael Crimson
Republic University
Minmatar Republic
#32 - 2011-10-23 19:12:24 UTC
Large Collidable Object wrote:
DeMichael Crimson wrote:
RAW23 wrote:
The problem is that Incarna is a graphics demo with no gameplay content and CCP have admitted that they also had no decent (i.e. actually fun) gameplay content even planned for it for the foreseeable future.


There are a lot of excellent gameplay content ideas for Incarna.

Problem was a few loudmouthed forum whoriers decided it was better to crash the party before it even got started.



Aww - need a barbie-hug?


On a side note: As much as I'd like the idea of my constant expression of disdain for incarna on the forums had an impact, I can't drink myself to the required levels of naivity and feeling of being important.

Forum posting had nothing to do with incarna being shitcanned - inarna being **** and subsequent unsubs did.


Large Collidable Object, this reply isn't directed just towards you, it's for everyone.

Funny how when someone says they liked the idea of WiS and Incarna, they're all of a sudden branded as a station sitting Barbie hugging noob.

For almost 3 1/2 years I've been a very active member of this community and have contributed a lot of Exploration and Cosmos info to the Evelopedia..I've completed countless missions achieving over +5.00 standing with almost all Empire Factions. I also created a standings repair guide that's been greatly accepted by the Eve Community. Hell, ever since I started playing this game I've practically lived in my spaceship 23/7.

I already know all about the different problems, bugs, rushed deployment, lack of content, failed PR, bla bla bla associated with the Expansion release so please don't even bother.

Talking down to me while trying to make yourself look superior doesn't change the fact that the mass unsubs were directly influenced and encouraged by Forum rage posting. There were tons of threads constantly being posted telling players to unsub. All started by a small group of players who even now continue to be the fuel keeping the rage fire burning.

No subscriptions = no money = no CCP = no Eve

FYI - I turned off CQ a few days after it's release due to all the problems. Doesn't mean I didn't like it nor do I want it removed from the game. I want to see it fully developed and integrated into Eve. I believe it has endless possibility's for adding lot's more depth and variety to game play. I've watched the CCP Videos with Dev's giving progress updates and demonstrations about Incarna and Dust.

Maybe I'm wrong but this is what I got from watching all those video demonstrations and interviews:

Incarna is a visionary step to turn a PC mmo spaceship simulation into a real time based sci-fi virtual reality.
Dust is a visionary step to turn a Console mmo FPS simulation into a real time based sci-fi virtual reality.
Joining these two totally different control applications together to work simultaneously would transform Eve Online into the ultimate real time based sci-fi virtual reality universe.

This should usher in a whole new era and revolutionize the gaming world as we know it.

As for new game play content, here's a couple of scenarios.

While in your Captains Quarters, an alarm activates informing you an invasion force has attacked and captured a PI facility on one of your planets. You call up the Dust Commander and inform him to meet you in the war room of the Planetary Command Center to plan a counter attack and regain control. In the war room are 3-D visual maps of the Planet, the PI facility's and surrounding areas. You both examine the maps, verify the enemy position and mark the drop zones for supplies. After forming a plan of attack, you load the supplies into your ship while the Dust Commander rejoins his team who are waiting at the 1st drop zone.

With the supplies loaded in your ship, you travel to the planet, enter into atmospheric flight and drop the supplies at the 1st drop zone. While en-route back to the station, you encounter a small blockade of enemy player ships. You make a call to your corporation and are quickly joined by a couple of Fleet mates. Small gang PvP combat starts happening in space while the ground forces engage each other.

As the battle in space continues, you receive a call from the Dust Commander requesting supplies to be dropped at the 2nd drop zone. You and your Fleet mates have almost killed all enemy player ships when more enemy player ships warp in and you find yourself locked and tackled. Dust Commander contacts you again saying they need those supplies now.

or

You log into the game with the sound of alarms going off in your Captains Quarters. The main viewscreen informs you that the station is under Security Lockdown (no docking or undocking) due to an Invasion force (Sansha?). You and other players trapped inside the station must go deck by deck, seeking out and killing all invaders encountered. Players must make their way to the Central Command Center to deactivate the Security Lockdown allowing access to the docking bay. Question is: What will you do? Do you attempt this solo? Create a gang with other players for tactical combat and support? Stay inside your Captains Quarters and hope somebody else deactivates the Security Lockdown?


There are many different game play possibility's that could happen. I for one hope and pray that CCP is successful in making their dream a reality for us to enjoy. I wanna be able to say - Eve is Real.
Amro One
One.
#33 - 2011-10-23 19:17:25 UTC
So what did that guy say?
Kumq uat
Aliastra
Gallente Federation
#34 - 2011-10-23 19:28:31 UTC
I guess it will be even longer till I can purchase $1000 jeans for my avatar. Are there Japanese boutiques in space?
Tallian Saotome
Nuclear Arms Exchange Inc.
#35 - 2011-10-23 19:52:43 UTC
DeMichael Crimson wrote:
::words::

All very pretty, and most of us, even those who are raging would love to see this.

There is a problem, and that is how CCP has been running their business. If you do your research, you will discover that since picking up Incarna development, in addition to neglecting their flagship product, CCP has been burning cash faster than they can make it. Their Debts are coming due(it was either in Oct, or Dec, don't remember) and they have to cut things. More than that, they have demonstrated to their investors that their model over the past couple years has been unsustainable, and have realized for themselves that they have been forcing feature with no content on us, just because they blinded themselves with ::shiny::.

No wall of text about how great it could be is ever going to change the fact that they failed to deliver, and failed to meet their financial obligations due to the mistakes they made.

Incarna will eventually come back, and maybe when it does, they will give us something to do with it other than walk in circles, or hack the client to watch ponies.

Til then, we need to support CCP, and make sure they don't lose track of the fact that I am not going to pay a sub to sit in a room, or even sit in a bar(cool as the bar will be), I pay my sub to fly spaceships and make blow up other peoples. The rest is just gravy(some pretty tasty gravy is some cases, and with potential to always get better).

Inappropriate signature removed, CCP Phantom.

Flamespar
State War Academy
Caldari State
#36 - 2011-10-23 22:49:42 UTC
Are you allowed to call a thread a threadnaught before it becomes one? What does the EULA have tyo say on this :)

Brujo Loco
Brujeria Teologica
#37 - 2011-10-23 23:27:30 UTC
So here I am showing my face, still saying the same things as before, but now with a small truce flag, waiting for eve to be railed back on track and hoping the trainwreck was just a small detour and not a total loss.

Your post, which is as smearing as many trolls smeared others during Monoclegate, is as supportive or informative as me quoting Dickens here. (bet you dont get this either)


It was not a hate crusade, and I am sadly disappointed that there are people out there that see it thus.

Using your analogical logic, a lot of people asked for poker, brothels, custom paint jobs, and a myriad other things, I can go back to the Carrier nerf era of NERFALATION xpac ... and yes thats the whole statement, what? what else? Oh I once wished eve to have a flying meteor ship that disguised in minefield so I could BOOGEY BOO miners attempting to mine me. yes, incredible.

So what? they toyed with the idea and then out of the blue, as it was being developed and tested, THERE WERE SO MANY COMPLAINTS thrown in the forums before it even went live , that CCP simply decided to ignore them and keep on going.

They were planning such atrocities for the game , that they had to scale back and reform and then pretend they were never real and just "ideas" being discussed that I honestly fail to understand where are you coming from. If you are trolling good for you, I fell and fed you a good chunk of my man meat., hope you had lulz, I have had mine here, and I'm having it now too.

If not, son, you need IV shots of Risperdal and right away seclusion for at least 6 months.

Thats my professional opinion on the matter in an internet forum, take it as you will, I also want the medal and fries.

Inner Sayings of BrujoLoco: http://eve-files.com/sig/brujoloco

Ranka Mei
TANoshii Incorporated
#38 - 2011-10-23 23:57:30 UTC
Well said, Vyl.

Leave it to CCP to go overboard like this! Either they ignore the community completely, or they totally cave to a small, but vocal minority (to paraphrase my favorite space Captain: "That sounds like CCP: unite all the planets under one rule, so that everybody can be interfered with or ignored equally.")


-- "All your monies AUR belong to us!" -- CCP

Haulin Aussie
Imperial Academy
Amarr Empire
#39 - 2011-10-24 02:20:15 UTC
DeMichael Crimson wrote:


For almost 3 1/2 years I've been a very active member of this community and have contributed a lot of Exploration and Cosmos info to the Evelopedia..I've completed countless missions achieving over +5.00 standing with almost all Empire Factions. I also created a standings repair guide that's been greatly accepted by the Eve Community. Hell, ever since I started playing this game I've practically lived in my spaceship 23/7.

I already know all about the different problems.....


No you don't, your previous paragraph proves you have absolutely no idea about any of the problems not related to carebearing (ie none).

Skunk Gracklaw
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#40 - 2011-10-24 02:38:48 UTC
Vyl Vit wrote:
step right up and show us who you are

It's me. I'm the "I hate Incarna" faction.