These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Market Discussions

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Market PVP tactics ?

Author
Kandreath
De Re Metallica
#1 - 2011-10-19 12:24:20 UTC
I'm using my 3rd slot to try out some market trading and getting some interesting results.

There appears to be two tactics used where I'm trading and I'm curious what they are trying to do. Don't get me wrong here, I'm all for the market PVP, I just want to know what's going on here and perhaps learn a few tricks too.

First is a "0.01 ISK better price but only one item in the order". This order is not just a one-of but is maintained and keeps being updated to keep it in pole position. What would be the benefit from this? Trading one item is surely a waste of time. Is it checking if I'm a bot? Is it trying to manipulate a price outcome?

Second is the "big profit slash order". I find a good trade but someone jumps in and literally halves the profit by putting in a buy order well above the current "pole position". Again, what is the point of slashing the profit on an item? Is it to show you're serious?

Can anyone tell me what these are trying to do specifically?
Tekota
The Freighter Factory
#2 - 2011-10-19 12:54:13 UTC
Quote:
First is a "0.01 ISK better price but only one item in the order". This order is not just a one-of but is maintained and keeps being updated to keep it in pole position. What would be the benefit from this? Trading one item is surely a waste of time. Is it checking if I'm a bot? Is it trying to manipulate a price outcome?


Probably trying to ensure that other larger orders above don't follow down. Ie. if I had an order of 100 waffles and someone selling one waffle undercut me by 0.01 isk I might think "I'll let that one go, don't want to get involved in a bidding war in case they go and get mad and slash profit in half"

Quote:
Second is the "big profit slash order". I find a good trade but someone jumps in and literally halves the profit by putting in a buy order well above the current "pole position". Again, what is the point of slashing the profit on an item? Is it to show you're serious?


This one more difficult to pin down. It's regularly assumed to be "idiots ruining the market for both of us" - whatever the cause never succumb to this line of thinking, it's very dangerous (read, expensive) to presume other's intentions. They might be doing it to "show they're serious" or they might favour cash flow with smaller profit over larger profit at the expense of cash flow, or they might know something you don't about upcoming market swings, or they might indeed be an idiot, or they might be forcing a price down in order to hoover up lots of items for an upswing, or - possibilities are endless.
Adunh Slavy
#3 - 2011-10-19 13:27:44 UTC
Don't over think it. Motives tend to be rather simple

Necessity is the plea for every infringement of human freedom. It is the argument of tyrants; it is the creed of slaves.  - William Pitt

Elise DarkStar
Garoun Investment Bank
Gallente Federation
#4 - 2011-10-19 14:04:38 UTC
I'll share my best selling/buying tactic, I call it "the perfect order".

Instead of playing the 0.01 isk game or making a huge change in price and daring the competitors to follow you, your orders should be of the perfect price and size such that your competitors think, "oh i'll just let that one go". The trick is, you just keep putting that same order size and price reduction up over and over as they sell.

The price has to be significant enough that it would cost them something to follow it down and the order has to be small enough that they think it will quickly be snapped up and it will be their turn.

It takes some getting used to, but it is infinitely better than playing the 0.01 isk game.

I remember we had put together a list of all the little tactics at one point, it would be great to find that on the old forum. There are at least a dozen standard tactics with variations for helping you make moves in the market.
Kandreath
De Re Metallica
#5 - 2011-10-19 20:38:44 UTC
Hmm interesting. I hadn't thought about the small order thing. To be honest, I had exactly that reaction, "Oh I'll just wait until someone fills that order, then it's my turn".

Price slashing is harder to handle especially when part of my selection method is to look at how often orders are updated to see how many people are watching an item. I get into an item, and then a "slasher" enters stage left. What? - Hmm.

I'll be asking uncle google for the forum thread about other market techniques. - Thanks for the hint
malaire
#6 - 2011-10-20 09:44:21 UTC
Kandreath wrote:
Second is the "big profit slash order". I find a good trade but someone jumps in and literally halves the profit by putting in a buy order well above the current "pole position". Again, what is the point of slashing the profit on an item? Is it to show you're serious?

There is discussion here about deep undercuts in trading: Why do people crash markets?

New to EVE? Don't forget to read: The Manual * The Wiki * The Career Options * and everything else

LtCol RTButts
Abandon AII Hope
#7 - 2011-10-20 10:07:07 UTC
best market strategy is to look for a reseller. you cut your margin, but you save the market also so it pays off over the time.
Raeloth Draenor
Aliastra
Gallente Federation
#8 - 2011-10-20 16:27:13 UTC
Kandreath wrote:
I'm using my 3rd slot to try out some market trading and getting some interesting results.

There appears to be two tactics used where I'm trading and I'm curious what they are trying to do. Don't get me wrong here, I'm all for the market PVP, I just want to know what's going on here and perhaps learn a few tricks too.

First is a "0.01 ISK better price but only one item in the order". This order is not just a one-of but is maintained and keeps being updated to keep it in pole position. What would be the benefit from this? Trading one item is surely a waste of time. Is it checking if I'm a bot? Is it trying to manipulate a price outcome?

Second is the "big profit slash order". I find a good trade but someone jumps in and literally halves the profit by putting in a buy order well above the current "pole position". Again, what is the point of slashing the profit on an item? Is it to show you're serious?

Can anyone tell me what these are trying to do specifically?



On the big profit slasher you sometimes want to take into account that some folks want items they are or anticipate using at below the sell order prices in a given area. Sometimes they want the order filled quickly so they put out BO's that are much higher than everyone else, hoping to bait potential sellers into selling their stuff more quickly. In those instances you just have to ride out the buyer. I've seen times though where another seller tries to .01 isk these people and a bidding war starts that's way over what I'm willing to pay. Again, just gotta ride it out imo.

I must say that I am a notorious .01 person though. If you use your trader as an alt or someone that you don't pay much attention to I can see how this would get annoying but it's what keeps me engaged in the markets and not bored to tears. I also get a lot of satisfaction from .01ing someone and then having a huge BO or SO filled just seconds later.

I've also taken and bought a small quantity of items that I know are in a hot market (say POS fuels) for example and then started bidding wars with people just to **** with their profits. It kills me to raise a BO price on something like Nitrotopes by 20 or 30 ISK with an amount like 200, only to see some idiot trump the price with an order for a million units.
SencneS
Viziam
Amarr Empire
#9 - 2011-10-20 20:18:17 UTC
Buy and Hold...


Thought-out the.... years... EVE every so often something bombs in price no one wants it, or there is something better, eventually there is loads of it on the market just slowly getting cheaper and the margin becomes rice paper thin over construction.

Gobble it up, on the cheap or place a close low end buy order for them, people who want to cash out will simply take a small loss. eventually you're left holding the bag on some cheap stuff.. I usually limit the amount of ISK I'll throw into deep dark wells.

At an unknown time in the future something happens or changes that all of a sudden makes your item extremely valuable and you cash in. Every so often someone will manipulate the item you have in inventory there is another chance to cash in as well, but it's usually short lived.

Some may call it crazy but I call it LAZY.. I don't have to micro-manage any orders, cycle though inventory or even care about the items I purchase. It's not for everyone and really only benefits though who play the game long, and have a bag of "old ISK" at their disposal.

I still participate in day to day manipulations and find the deals here and there, but a good part of my inventory apart from BPOs is made up of cheap useless items waiting for their rebirth..
Kandreath
De Re Metallica
#10 - 2011-10-20 20:57:29 UTC
Thanks for the advice everyone. The 0.01 ISK thing is wearing thin with me at the moment. I usually update twice a day and I might get an hour or two at pole on the popular orders.

Perhaps I need to be more willing to ride out the daily bumps.

This might change what I'm looking for in a trade.
Kara Books
Deal with IT.
#11 - 2011-10-21 13:00:39 UTC
Elise DarkStar wrote:
I'll share my best selling/buying tactic, I call it "the perfect order".

Instead of playing the 0.01 isk game or making a huge change in price and daring the competitors to follow you, your orders should be of the perfect price and size such that your competitors think, "oh i'll just let that one go". The trick is, you just keep putting that same order size and price reduction up over and over as they sell.

The price has to be significant enough that it would cost them something to follow it down and the order has to be small enough that they think it will quickly be snapped up and it will be their turn.

It takes some getting used to, but it is infinitely better than playing the 0.01 isk game.

I remember we had put together a list of all the little tactics at one point, it would be great to find that on the old forum. There are at least a dozen standard tactics with variations for helping you make moves in the market.


It works against new players but not against the vets.

Iv seen people crashing the prices on their own items, then only 2 weeks later give up.


My point is, Patience and a 2nd source of revenue are the only rules to the market game.
Raeloth Draenor
Aliastra
Gallente Federation
#12 - 2011-10-21 15:40:00 UTC
Kara Books wrote:
Elise DarkStar wrote:
I'll share my best selling/buying tactic, I call it "the perfect order".

Instead of playing the 0.01 isk game or making a huge change in price and daring the competitors to follow you, your orders should be of the perfect price and size such that your competitors think, "oh i'll just let that one go". The trick is, you just keep putting that same order size and price reduction up over and over as they sell.

The price has to be significant enough that it would cost them something to follow it down and the order has to be small enough that they think it will quickly be snapped up and it will be their turn.

It takes some getting used to, but it is infinitely better than playing the 0.01 isk game.

I remember we had put together a list of all the little tactics at one point, it would be great to find that on the old forum. There are at least a dozen standard tactics with variations for helping you make moves in the market.


It works against new players but not against the vets.

Iv seen people crashing the prices on their own items, then only 2 weeks later give up.


My point is, Patience and a 2nd source of revenue are the only rules to the market game.



This in a nut shell. I actually just started trading on this character a week or so ago and read a few guides here on the forums before I started. Everyone of them mentioned the key to being a good trader is patience, along with some market knowledge (what's selling, profit margins, etc.). Kara is generally very intelligent and also helpful in these matters. She knows her ****.
Elise DarkStar
Garoun Investment Bank
Gallente Federation
#13 - 2011-10-21 16:08:45 UTC
I'd also agree that the absolute and fundamental #1 rule is find a trading routine that you are comfortable with. And this isn't meant as some feelgoodery pablum, you WILL burnout quickly and permanently if you are not conscious of your enjoyment or at least resilience.

You guys are absolutely correct.
Stealing Honest
Stealing Honest Speculation Group LLC
#14 - 2011-10-21 16:26:37 UTC
Nice Thread.


One of the things that i learned long ago, that helps me keep the fun factor is longer term profit planning.

I do not have to make my sale or buy today.

Sometimes i use a target range for my buys and sells, often i don't update for days even weeks if ive learned there are wave patterns... and during the ebb and flow my orders will get picked up or sold.


But most of all .... i make sure im having FUN. As long as its fun you will find ways to make profits Smile
Tesal
#15 - 2011-10-23 03:17:43 UTC
The big profit slash that you are seeing could be from a trader making a judgement that they are better off selling 50 items at 5% profit vs selling 1 item at 20% profit. Its the flip side of the .01 isk war. If you don't want to sit there all day just break the back of whatever the .01 isk warriors are trying to do and reduce the margins to a point where they won't follow. If you do it long enough sometimes you can break the market down so far you can make all the .01 isk warriors move on to another item. Think of it as shock therapy.
Taedrin
Federal Navy Academy
Gallente Federation
#16 - 2011-10-23 16:43:26 UTC
If the market is currently on a downward trend, then once someone undercuts you, your order will never see the light of day again. The big profit slash tactic may be an attempt to drop your prices close enough to the short-term equilibrium that your order will be picked up by regular market cycles.