These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Warfare & Tactics

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Amarr vs Minmatar Update

Author
Zarnak Wulf
Task Force 641
Empyrean Edict
#101 - 2012-11-29 20:23:24 UTC
Anya Lunebleu wrote:
Amarr > Minnie fight us on their own terms - not our terms. Minnie Suck! Now take that!

Minmatar > kkthxQQ






Trinkets Friend really raised the bar for you. I demand more intelligent trolling.
uredo
Republic Military School
Minmatar Republic
#102 - 2012-11-29 20:35:53 UTC
Pred just look at the mess you have made here.

Bad boy.
Cearain
Plus 10 NV
#103 - 2012-11-29 21:34:48 UTC
Pinky Feldman wrote:
....
The myth of cohesion - The reality of the situation is that both militias have been on a similar level of cooperation and cohesiveness for several months now, the only difference is that the Minmatar have solidly held the warzone so regardless of what is actually happening behind the scenes its easy for public opinion to be swayed into thinking that any decisions made are the right ones, even delusional notions filled with hubris and the continued belief that a militia's ability or will to fight has more than token impact on the warzone as a whole. The truth behind the mechanics is that fights are irrelevant and having people willing to PVE across all timezones is main mechanic behind warzone control is this. .


I think you are saying that the occupancy mechanics are largely a pve mechanic which is by and large seperate from the pvp. In that case I think you are starting to understand the problem with faction war.


Pinky Feldman
.....[b wrote:
Ignoring the propaganda and misinformed[/b] - A lot of the complaining I see comes from people who are inactive and known badposters like Cearain. .


Just because I do not agree with your ideas does not make me a "badposter." Is there some claim I made that you think is bad?

Really there is no need for name calling, I actually think we agree on allot of things.



Pinky Feldman wrote:

.... The reason that many within the Minmatar don't see this cohesion at work is because whenever we form up and actually work together to potentially get some great fights, the Minmatar all stand down and magically disappear, yet despite not getting fights, the Amarr still form 50-100 man gangs when they are called for because supporting each other is important, so don't act like they don't exist just because you refuse to fight them....
The Amarr are entirely capable of forming up to fight Annah Kitheran chestbeating fleets, but there is little reason to organize people and tell them to log on to fight a fleet that you know will stand down and refuse to fight the second you do. Stop acting like the reason you don't see large Amarr fleets is because they don't work together, when you know very well the main reason you don't see them is because you won't fight them.



It is hard to find a fight in faction war when you have a fleet of 50-100 pilots. Yes it happens, but you will spend allot of time online in between those fights.

This is not some secret truth, that you are now revealing. It is well recognized truth since fw started. It may be new to you but that is only because you are new to faction war.

Pinky your post and the others responding to it have been posted over and over about faction war since it started. Really you can go back through years of threads where people complain that they had a fleet with no enemy and then both sides claim the other won't fight unless outnumbered etc. We don't need to shift another thread to this topic.

Bottom line: Until they make the actual occupancy mechanic something that really drives the pvp then this will continue to be the case. I think you are starting to understand the truth in this.

But we will likely disagree about what sort of pvp it should cause. I think the pvp generated should be based on several smaller gangs pvping in plexes throughout the fw area. You will likely think it should involve the side with the largest fleet being able to dominate. I think we already have that in sov null sec. But really at this point it's a high class theoretical problem. Because right now, as you point out, the occupancy war is won by the side that can convince the most people to go pve in plexes.



Make faction war occupancy pvp instead of pve https://forums.eveonline.com/default.aspx?g=posts&m=53815&#post53815

Cearain
Plus 10 NV
#104 - 2012-11-29 21:38:46 UTC
kraiklyn Asatru wrote:
Cearain wrote:
Vordak Kallager wrote:
When a system falls for the Amarr,...


Talk about digging up the past. When was the last time that happened?


Since minmatar had to start actually killing the rats instead of speed taking them, have they fully plexed and taken a single system?

Due to the longstanding imbalances in npcs amarr are used to having to kill all the rats. It seems playing by the same rules does not suit minmatar.


Don't worry it will happen :)



There is no question that minmatar are waiting until they no longer have to plex like the amarr had to plex for years. That is killing all the numerous rats.

Once the rat spawns are reduced to a single rat I anticipate we will see more plexing from the minmatar.

Make faction war occupancy pvp instead of pve https://forums.eveonline.com/default.aspx?g=posts&m=53815&#post53815

Darek Castigatus
Immortalis Inc.
Shadow Cartel
#105 - 2012-11-29 22:52:07 UTC
AndromacheDarkstar wrote:
Darek Castigatus wrote:
People like to win and dont like to lose, it really is that simple sometimes. As much as people may want it to be different unless you have an RvB style 'equal sides' arrangement its never going to stop being an issue and I cant see that happening any time soon.

Its something we're as guilty of as anyone else who flies in the areas involved but its something you just have to deal with.


talking of which you popped one of our dreads last night, good work with that.


we do try, we do try :)

Pirates - The Invisible Fist of Darwin

you're welcome

Gunship
Viziam
Amarr Empire
#106 - 2012-11-30 00:09:08 UTC
The mini have more numbers and are better org. than the amarr

we are trying though
kraiklyn Asatru
Sebiestor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#107 - 2012-11-30 00:51:13 UTC
Cearain wrote:
kraiklyn Asatru wrote:
Cearain wrote:
Vordak Kallager wrote:
When a system falls for the Amarr,...


Talk about digging up the past. When was the last time that happened?


Since minmatar had to start actually killing the rats instead of speed taking them, have they fully plexed and taken a single system?

Due to the longstanding imbalances in npcs amarr are used to having to kill all the rats. It seems playing by the same rules does not suit minmatar.


Don't worry it will happen :)



There is no question that minmatar are waiting until they no longer have to plex like the amarr had to plex for years. That is killing all the numerous rats.

Once the rat spawns are reduced to a single rat I anticipate we will see more plexing from the minmatar.



Neglect to notice how Floss was taken? I was busy plexing that while posting that.
Dan Carter Murray
#108 - 2012-11-30 00:55:31 UTC
kraiklyn Asatru wrote:
Cearain wrote:
kraiklyn Asatru wrote:
Cearain wrote:
Vordak Kallager wrote:
When a system falls for the Amarr,...


Talk about digging up the past. When was the last time that happened?


Since minmatar had to start actually killing the rats instead of speed taking them, have they fully plexed and taken a single system?

Due to the longstanding imbalances in npcs amarr are used to having to kill all the rats. It seems playing by the same rules does not suit minmatar.


Don't worry it will happen :)



There is no question that minmatar are waiting until they no longer have to plex like the amarr had to plex for years. That is killing all the numerous rats.

Once the rat spawns are reduced to a single rat I anticipate we will see more plexing from the minmatar.



Neglect to notice how Floss was taken? I was busy plexing that while posting that.


peak was about 45 of you in system with average of about 25. 5 people in the area to defend. grats on taking a system with 0 resistance.

http://mfi.re/?j7ldoco 50GB free space @ MediaFire.com

kraiklyn Asatru
Sebiestor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#109 - 2012-11-30 01:21:22 UTC
Dan Carter Murray wrote:
kraiklyn Asatru wrote:
Cearain wrote:
kraiklyn Asatru wrote:


Don't worry it will happen :)



There is no question that minmatar are waiting until they no longer have to plex like the amarr had to plex for years. That is killing all the numerous rats.

Once the rat spawns are reduced to a single rat I anticipate we will see more plexing from the minmatar.



Neglect to notice how Floss was taken? I was busy plexing that while posting that.


peak was about 45 of you in system with average of about 25. 5 people in the area to defend. grats on taking a system with 0 resistance.



The kills we got paint a different picture. Koza for one did a superb job. In the end that doesnt matter at all this was about taking Floss not about pandering to you. If you don't fight you'll just make it easier since it was a strategic goal. We didn't do it just for fun.
Taoist Dragon
Okata Syndicate
#110 - 2012-11-30 01:47:08 UTC
FW is fine.

and it will still be fine after the patch....I don't see the changes making much of a difference. maybe getting more brawling going on with the button moving closer to warp in but not convinced...hopeful though.


The pvp/pve aspect is getting really old with some people continually re-posting the same crap over and over again. Give it a rest guys.

If pvp is your thing they go out and shoot ppl....if you want to pve and industry and stuff ?? then you can go out and do that. To me it sounds as if more than the fair share of FW guys wear way to many tinfoil hats with all the accusations and smoke and mirros crap going on.....get out....have some fights......plex a little.....get navy ships to fly/sell and have fun!!

now to repeat the important part

HAVE FUN! stop taking it so bloody seriously!

That is the Way, the Tao.

Balance is everything.

Zarnak Wulf
Task Force 641
Empyrean Edict
#111 - 2012-11-30 02:34:23 UTC
Pinky Feldman
Amarrian Vengeance
Ragequit Cancel Sub
#112 - 2012-11-30 03:44:53 UTC  |  Edited by: Pinky Feldman
IHaveCandyGetInTheVan69 wrote:
Colt Blackhawk wrote:
Yep Pinky got the point.
The minnies run always when they do not outnumber us minimum 2:1. In reality they are mostly craven. They completely fear to loose ships.


While I agree with some of your points and I find the blobbing mentality thoroughly boring, I think you are simplifying the problem. With many bored pilots sitting around once there is intel of a fleet around everyone and their mum Xes for a fleet and many FCs are reluctant to reject pilots, which leads to a blob.

I know sometimes blobbing is used intentionally as a strategy to achieve something within the FW mechanics if that is perceived to be more important than a GF. There are still occasions where for whatever reason despite being in a system that allows pilots to earn x00 m ISK / hr there is huge risk aversion, I don't really understand that.

Also I fail to see the advantage of a 2nd or 3rd loki booster, maybe I am doing it wrong?


To clarify, my comment wasn't so much to be commentary on who blobbed who, mostly that i've seen an increasing trend of less and less small gang and fleet fights. Specifically, the increasingly used tactic of "aggressive blueballing". With high-SP well organied groups like SP-DR leaving for Gallente, it ironically hurts the Amarr more than it does the Minmatar IMO, especially when you have a situation where the Amarr are being organized flying together while the Minmatar seem to be working less and less cohesively. My major complaint was i'm tired of hearing the continued propaganda about how the Amarr are terribly unorganized and never work together and don't get along. We fly together when needed and could fly together even more than we do currently, but then we would really never get any fights. More often than not, we don't fly together because we actually do want fights, so don't complain when we're not "blobbing" and you're getting fights. Likewise, when we don't have enough to pull together to fight one of your "blobs" don't try to create a myth about how we are afraid to undock when you guys are the same way.

I agree that many of us are "new" to FW so we don't have years of relationship pre-built, but that doesn't make our working relationships any less valuable or effective. I just stood down from a 70+ man Amarr fleet with noone to fight, despite the fact that between arzad/dal/bosboger/LNA/UK there were easily the number of pilots logged on to contest our gang, HOWEVER, i'm not going to make a snarky comment about how theyre scared to undock because its all part of the same tired rhetoric that people need to get over. Just because we don't have a single "lead" FC, doesn't mean we need one, especially considering that at least half of that 70 man fleet, including myself had never flown with the FC before, but we still joined and were ready to lose ships for him.

@Cearain - Yes I know the problem with a PVE based sov system and have for quite some time. Its why people who join the Amarr side for fights will log in if they hear there is a fight to be had, but don't get that excited when told they can plex a system for hrs with no fights and meager LP. New player retention for FW has always been something I have advocated greatly, but always gets silenced by kool-aid drinkers who insist that all the common complaints you hear from new players in FW aren't because of the mechanics, but because they're frustrated at facing a far superior opponent thus losing and losing isn't fun.

I would hardly call my post bringing up the past post, merely setting the record straight on a lot of the tired propaganda against the Amarr that I still see people go along with and continue to believe.

The reason I call you a badposter Cearain isn't because I disagree with the things you say, but its because you're one of the biggest Amarrian whiners in the history of ever. You whine about everything, even things that don't make sense to whine about or are completely and unfactually true. If you were more active, then things might be a different story, however, you complain and comment on things that you haven't been online for and your statements in themselves show how out of touch you are with whats happening. I've heard you complain about how the Amarr militia not being willing to work together after spending the entire week flying in inter-militia fleets. I've heard you comment on how small gang PVP in FW is dead and all you see the Amarr in now are several 20-30 man blobs and then several posts later complain about how the problem with the Amarr is they don't have the leader that can get a 30 man fleet like they used to. Despite the fact that you do make good points occasionally, you are singlehandedly one of the biggest reasons its been so easy for the Minmatar to marginalize and poke fun at things the Amarr say and do. There can be 5 reasonable forum posts and all someone needs to do to derail the thread so it can go into troll mode is wait for you to post.
Pinky Feldman
Amarrian Vengeance
Ragequit Cancel Sub
#113 - 2012-11-30 03:46:07 UTC
kraiklyn Asatru wrote:
Dan Carter Murray wrote:
kraiklyn Asatru wrote:
Cearain wrote:
kraiklyn Asatru wrote:


Don't worry it will happen :)



There is no question that minmatar are waiting until they no longer have to plex like the amarr had to plex for years. That is killing all the numerous rats.

Once the rat spawns are reduced to a single rat I anticipate we will see more plexing from the minmatar.



Neglect to notice how Floss was taken? I was busy plexing that while posting that.


peak was about 45 of you in system with average of about 25. 5 people in the area to defend. grats on taking a system with 0 resistance.



The kills we got paint a different picture. Koza for one did a superb job. In the end that doesnt matter at all this was about taking Floss not about pandering to you. If you don't fight you'll just make it easier since it was a strategic goal. We didn't do it just for fun.


I wish you guys were US TZ. :(
Milton Middleson
Rifterlings
#114 - 2012-11-30 06:24:33 UTC
I'll be honest. If I logged on and someone told me there was a 70-man Amarr fleet roaming around and we needed to form a fleet to go fight them, I would probably log off again.

Quote:
I wish you guys were US TZ.

You really know how to make someone feel appreciated. :P
Asko Vilenius
Doomheim
#115 - 2012-11-30 06:44:45 UTC
Pinky Feldman wrote:
With high-SP well organied groups like SP-DR leaving for Gallente, it ironically hurts the Amarr more than it does the Minmatar IMO, especially when you have a situation where the Amarr are being organized flying together while the Minmatar seem to be working less and less cohesively.


I cant help it if they are willing to move their whole alliance across space just for me. Or then they are just scared of possible fights in your space, seeing none of them undock without their multiple OGB's. Naturally their blob is not big enough for them either as it seems they have happily blued every local pirate group already Big smile
Bengal Bob
Slymsloot Enterprises
#116 - 2012-11-30 13:03:52 UTC
I can't understand how, given the Amarrian resurgence, it only takes a few of us to cause the Amarr to dock up in Kamela. Ning, Zen and I spent a couple weeks camping the Amarr in Kamela and disrupting the gangs attempting to plex in Lamaa with no real opposition developing. The minmatar can freely camp Kamela gates with no opposition, which doesn't seem like the Amarr are coming back strongly - at least in the EU TZ.

About the only time we were driven off was when a fleet was formed for that purpose, not for PVP, but several cruisers and battlecruisers to push off 3 or 4 frigs and dessies. THis normally takes several hours to form, and then closes within 30 minutes when we won't leeroy frigs into them.

I have also not seen a 50-100 man Amarr fleet since Nephilim left. Interesting stuff.

Amarr are free to chest beat, but when a few frig pilots are able to close down your home system, then clearly things are not going that well for you.
Mehashi 'Kho
New Eden Motion Pictures
#117 - 2012-11-30 13:50:11 UTC
Asko Vilenius wrote:
Pinky Feldman wrote:
With high-SP well organied groups like SP-DR leaving for Gallente, it ironically hurts the Amarr more than it does the Minmatar IMO, especially when you have a situation where the Amarr are being organized flying together while the Minmatar seem to be working less and less cohesively.


I cant help it if they are willing to move their whole alliance across space just for me. Or then they are just scared of possible fights in your space, seeing none of them undock without their multiple OGB's. Naturally their blob is not big enough for them either as it seems they have happily blued every local pirate group already Big smile

All news to me.

There was me thinking we fancied a change from the minamarr warzone. I should have known our leadership was in fact scheming to stalk some random dude.

Fyi our "whole alliance" is our corp. Only now we have the potential to enter AT's should that be something we feel would be fun.

Blued pirates? Surprising news for both us, and the pirates who continue to fight us. Must be that pesky overview standings bug again... *shakes fist* As for OGB's I think you'll find most corps have two or three dudes with boosting alts, and many members without. If you favour removing OGB altogether I agree with you, whoever you are.

As for the state of the warzone, I can only offer a grunts perspective. The minamarr front had become a little stale, tending to fight the same guys in the same ships, having to blueball the same fleet comps/numbers etc etc. I mean this on both sides by the way, people just kind of settled into their way of doing things and stuck with it. That's not necessarily a bad thing if it works for them, but did leave things less than exciting a lot of the time. Things were on the turn as we left though, amarr in the EU timezone have started working a bit more cohesively, and the minnys have tried out some different fleet types which are both great signs for an interesting warzone again. I think to a newcomer or someone who's been away a while things would be pretty exciting about now with lots of potential for change on the horizon if people push for it.

It was a similar situation when we moved to minny from gallente, and as most fw participants realise the two warzones tend to swing from one way to the other. I certainly have no shame about returning home to gal/cal space again as the solo and skirmish action around here has really picked up and the few fights I've managed to get since returning (busy month at work unfortunately) have been great fun and an opportunity to fight new people in new ships, requiring new tactics and so on. I would expect it to be similar if a gal/cal corp switched to min/am in a couple of months time. "Refreshing" is the word.

Give it a month or two for leadership to re-establish itself (from reading some amarr posters I understand there is a slight power vacuum?), the new ships and balances to settle in and I think the minamarr warzone will be looking pretty healthy again for all the guys who like mixed and interesting pvp. If there are any ex amarr tempted to return I would say now is a great time to do so, with the expansion coming up there will naturally be a period of unrest and taking advantage of that to be established when things settle again would be a smart move.

Which ever side you are on, see you in space sometime! If you aren't on any side, join one, fw is awesome. ^.^
AndromacheDarkstar
Integrated Insterstellar Holdings
#118 - 2012-11-30 15:06:41 UTC
Bengal Bob wrote:
I can't understand how, given the Amarrian resurgence, it only takes a few of us to cause the Amarr to dock up in Kamela. Ning, Zen and I spent a couple weeks camping the Amarr in Kamela and disrupting the gangs attempting to plex in Lamaa with no real opposition developing. The minmatar can freely camp Kamela gates with no opposition, which doesn't seem like the Amarr are coming back strongly - at least in the EU TZ.

About the only time we were driven off was when a fleet was formed for that purpose, not for PVP, but several cruisers and battlecruisers to push off 3 or 4 frigs and dessies. THis normally takes several hours to form, and then closes within 30 minutes when we won't leeroy frigs into them.

I have also not seen a 50-100 man Amarr fleet since Nephilim left. Interesting stuff.

Amarr are free to chest beat, but when a few frig pilots are able to close down your home system, then clearly things are not going that well for you.


I call bullshit on that, its takes allot to make us dock up and you will very rarely find our fleets in stations, we are usually whelping them into you guys
Cearain
Plus 10 NV
#119 - 2012-11-30 15:26:01 UTC
Pinky Feldman wrote:

@Cearain - Yes I know the problem with a PVE based sov system and have for quite some time. Its why people who join the Amarr side for fights will log in if they hear there is a fight to be had, but don't get that excited when told they can plex a system for hrs with no fights and meager LP. New player retention for FW has always been something I have advocated greatly, but always gets silenced by kool-aid drinkers who insist that all the common complaints you hear from new players in FW aren't because of the mechanics, but because they're frustrated at facing a far superior opponent thus losing and losing isn't fun.

I would hardly call my post bringing up the past post, merely setting the record straight on a lot of the tired propaganda against the Amarr that I still see people go along with and continue to believe.

The reason I call you a badposter Cearain isn't because I disagree with the things you say, but its because you're one of the biggest Amarrian whiners in the history of ever. You whine about everything, even things that don't make sense to whine about or are completely and unfactually true. If you were more active, then things might be a different story, however, you complain and comment on things that you haven't been online for and your statements in themselves show how out of touch you are with whats happening. I've heard you complain about how the Amarr militia not being willing to work together after spending the entire week flying in inter-militia fleets. I've heard you comment on how small gang PVP in FW is dead and all you see the Amarr in now are several 20-30 man blobs and then several posts later complain about how the problem with the Amarr is they don't have the leader that can get a 30 man fleet like they used to. Despite the fact that you do make good points occasionally, you are singlehandedly one of the biggest reasons its been so easy for the Minmatar to marginalize and poke fun at things the Amarr say and do. There can be 5 reasonable forum posts and all someone needs to do to derail the thread so it can go into troll mode is wait for you to post.



Pinky most of what you said before the above makes sense.

But with the above you must have me mixed me up with another poster - maybe vordak.

I have never complained that the amarr could not work together to get a large fleet together. I don't complain that the amarr are "now in 20-30 man blobs." I haven't complained that amarr doesn't have a leader that can get a 30 man fleet. You are just making this up. Amarr can get 20-30 man fleets and I think that is great. Seriously, stop making false claims about what I post. If you don't like what I post please quote what you don't like and respond.

I never said small gang pvp in fw is dead. I have always maintained it is the best in eve, with the possible exception of rvb. I have complained that it doesn't reliably yield 3-7good fights per 2 hours, like it should. But it never did that, so I wouldn't say its dead. Its more like it never lived.

You suggest I send threads into troll mode. I make post number 44 five days ago. And there are 59 more posts with only 2 or 3 even referencing my post, but I send it into troll mode?

Seriously Pinky your acting like a 2 year old. Just because I disagreed with some of your ideas about faction war you don't need to go into attack mode. Eve/fw doesn't need more petty crap. Oh and I am not singlehandedly the biggest problem that the amarr face. Roll I guess you can keep thinking that if you want but really your credibility is sinking fast.

Make faction war occupancy pvp instead of pve https://forums.eveonline.com/default.aspx?g=posts&m=53815&#post53815

Cearain
Plus 10 NV
#120 - 2012-11-30 15:32:18 UTC
kraiklyn Asatru wrote:
Cearain wrote:
kraiklyn Asatru wrote:
Cearain wrote:
Vordak Kallager wrote:
When a system falls for the Amarr,...


Talk about digging up the past. When was the last time that happened?


Since minmatar had to start actually killing the rats instead of speed taking them, have they fully plexed and taken a single system?

Due to the longstanding imbalances in npcs amarr are used to having to kill all the rats. It seems playing by the same rules does not suit minmatar.


Don't worry it will happen :)



There is no question that minmatar are waiting until they no longer have to plex like the amarr had to plex for years. That is killing all the numerous rats.

Once the rat spawns are reduced to a single rat I anticipate we will see more plexing from the minmatar.



Neglect to notice how Floss was taken? I was busy plexing that while posting that.



You took one system in a month. That doesn't change what I have said.

I still anticipate minmatar will start allot more plexing when its no longer like what amarr traditionally had to deal with (i.e., requires killing lots of rats.) We shall see.

Make faction war occupancy pvp instead of pve https://forums.eveonline.com/default.aspx?g=posts&m=53815&#post53815