These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Intergalactic Summit

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

The Gallente Problem II

Author
Stitcher
School of Applied Knowledge
Caldari State
#21 - 2012-11-24 02:38:41 UTC
Seri, you're doing that thing again where you assume that [insert human activity] is a Gallentean invention that the rest of us savages are emulating. EVERY culture has mechanisms in place for discussing the status quo and searching for a better one. If they didn't, flint-knapping would still be the state-of-the-art. As it is, it's just cutting edge technology.

Ideas are everybody's right to express, but not everybody's right to choose. If you just let the drongos (I love that word, it's a quality Minmatar product) fly the frigate by committee, then you're doomed to veer straight into the nearest asteroid. Your democracy has checks and balances in place to mitigate that effect.

The Caldari take the view that the best person to put in charge is somebody competent. Among the first hallmarks of competence is recognizing your own limitations and deferring to the expertise and opinion of others who are better informed. In other words, a competent leader is one who listens to what people are saying and picks the best ideas out of the intellectual marketplace.

Where your system fails is in giving all opinions equal weight. Ours recognizes that some people's opinions are, frankly, bloody stupid and not worth listening to.

AKA Hambone

Author of The Deathworlders

Vikarion
Doomheim
#22 - 2012-11-24 03:04:14 UTC
Stitcher wrote:
...flint-knapping would still be the state-of-the-art. As it is, it's just cutting edge technology.


Stop that. Right now.
Stitcher
School of Applied Knowledge
Caldari State
#23 - 2012-11-24 03:08:53 UTC
I make no apologies.

AKA Hambone

Author of The Deathworlders

Valerie Valate
Church of The Crimson Saviour
#24 - 2012-11-24 08:58:39 UTC
The problem with Gallente Prime is that it is full of Gallente.

Doctor V. Valate, Professor of Archaeology at Kaztropolis Imperial University.

Diana Kim
State Protectorate
Caldari State
#25 - 2012-11-25 11:12:27 UTC
Stitcher wrote:

Genes aren't important. At all. The more important categories - the ones that truly define us as people - are those we place ourselves in by choice, not by an accident of birth. All joking about the Manly Civire Jaw aside, my racial heritage has precisely zero meaning to me. I am in no particular order a capsuleer, a Watch veteran, a former Ishukone citizen, a State loyalist, a hobbying nanotechnologist, an industrialist, a combat pilot, a fleet commander, a Liberal and a Karnola Galaxy fan.

Now, this part, that genes aren't important, is completely nonsence.
Genes makes us who we are. They define ourselves, they set our limits, they allow genii to born.
Of course, you choose your path, but your genes dictate what you will do better, and what you will do worse. You can't change it. If you will try, you won't remain yourself (ask Sanshas, they might do it for you, if you want... and let Maker have pity on your soul!)
Genes make all of us DIFFERENT. Genes allow us to follow our destiny, and work better for the State, than grey 'equal' among themselves gallentes work for their rotten federation, where voice of a scientist is equal to voice of a common lowlife worker.
You should pay more respect to your ancestors, even if your heritage 'means zero' to you!

Valerie Valate wrote:
The problem with Gallente Prime is that it is full of Gallente.

With this I completely agree. This is the main problem. Can you try to offer some kind of solution, maybe we would be able to solve it together...

Honored are the dead, for their legacy guides us.

In memory of Tibus Heth, Caldari State Executor YC110-115, Hero and Patriot.

Deacon Abox
Black Eagle5
#26 - 2012-11-25 17:16:04 UTC  |  Edited by: Deacon Abox
You can call it a satanic grin if you want, and if you want the roleplay, I'll dye my hair blue,

But I'd soooo like to go full out bastardization bonobo with either of you, GP and Diana. And better yet, at the same time!

Send a mail if interested. Smile

CCP, there are off buttons for ship explosions, missile effects, turret effects, etc. "Immersion" does not seem to be harmed by those. So, [u]please[/u] give us a persisting off button for the jump gate and autoscan visuals.

Andreus Ixiris
Center for Advanced Studies
Gallente Federation
#27 - 2012-11-25 20:50:54 UTC
Diana Kim wrote:
You should pay more respect to your ancestors, even if your heritage 'means zero' to you!


As with everything else you attempt, grasping the point Stitcher was making is something you've failed spectacularly at.

Andreus Ixiris > A Civire without a chin is barely a Civire at all.

Pieter Tuulinen > He'd be Civirely disadvantaged, Andreus.

Andreus Ixiris > ...

Andreus Ixiris > This is why we're at war.

Stitcher
School of Applied Knowledge
Caldari State
#28 - 2012-11-26 02:31:52 UTC  |  Edited by: Stitcher
Diana Kim wrote:
stuff.


I disagree completely. I am defined by my choices, my decisions and my opinions, not by the complicated strip of acid in each of my cells which itself is just a careful high-fidelity copy of the one that occupied my original body which in any case became an interesting smear of organic compounds on the leading edge of a smartbomb detonation about seven years ago.

Every time a pilot clones, they prove that the body and the DNA contained with in it are completely unimportant. It's the brain-state that matters, and there is nothing stopping me from using a blank "stock" clone not seeded with my genetic profile, if I so wish. The result would be functionally identical - Verin Hakatain, the infomorph would still be walking around and doing what he does, but instead of the handsome and hirsute appearance I have chosen to maintain (which is, I freely admit, an... "enhanced" version of the original), I'd be a pale featureless everyman.

Now, I have considerable respect for my ancestors, as should all Caldari. But if I don't consider my DNA to be important for anything more than maintaining a certain physical appearance that I have, again, chosen to retain, then my regard for my ancestors is NOT for the DNA they contributed to my birth body, but instead for the culture they built, the history they wrote and the legacy I'm trying to find a place in.

As I said - it's the brain-state that matters, and I've even tweaked that with neural remapping technology in the last few years. There is nothing about my physical being that is not open to modification, augmentation and improvement. Has that changed me as a person? I would argue no more so than living from day to day did. A person is not a static and unchanging thing, our reality is an ever-moving moment of subjectivity, and I'm privileged to have a tighter and more direct control over that moment than is afforded to most people. I have greater freedom to choose who I am and wish to be, and have exercised it.

I would expect a fellow infomorph to at least grasp the concept of mind/body dualism and to recognise that it is the FORMER that matters.

AKA Hambone

Author of The Deathworlders

Streya Jormagdnir
Alexylva Paradox
#29 - 2012-11-26 05:59:28 UTC
Natalcya Katla wrote:

More worthy, I would say. In our modern society, procreation belongs in the medical laboratory, not in the bedroom.


Down with this sort of thing. There is a science in the bedroom all its own, and it is beautiful. Not saying those born in tubes or whatever are less worthy, but if I'm to bring a child into this world I'd rather bear it myself. Personal preference, of course.

I am also a human, straggling between the present world... and our future. I am a regulator, a coordinator, one who is meant to guide the way.

Destination Unreachable: the worst Wspace blog ever

Seven Noctis
#30 - 2012-11-26 06:19:03 UTC
Natalcya Katla wrote:
More worthy, I would say. In our modern society, procreation belongs in the medical laboratory, not in the bedroom.

Their worthiness will be determined by their deeds. One could argue they have greater inherent potential, yes. But how they unfold it and to what end they later apply it is not programmed from birth.
Diana Kim
State Protectorate
Caldari State
#31 - 2012-11-26 07:34:45 UTC
Stitcher wrote:

I disagree completely. I am defined by my choices, my decisions and my opinions, not by the complicated strip of acid in each of my cells which itself is just a careful high-fidelity copy of the one that occupied my original body which in any case became an interesting smear of organic compounds on the leading edge of a smartbomb detonation about seven years ago.

Every time a pilot clones, they prove that the body and the DNA contained with in it are completely unimportant. It's the brain-state that matters, and there is nothing stopping me from using a blank "stock" clone not seeded with my genetic profile, if I so wish. The result would be functionally identical - Verin Hakatain, the infomorph would still be walking around and doing what he does, but instead of the handsome and hirsute appearance I have chosen to maintain (which is, I freely admit, an... "enhanced" version of the original),

You may be defined by your "choices", but the choices you make depend on your genes. Your abilities and limitations, gifts and flaws, both physical and mental, all are encoded in these strips of acid. Because these strips of acid encode proteins, and these proteins govern all functions of your organism, every second you live. All effing functions. All, without exceptions. And these include enzymes to generate and decompose neuromediators, that are working in synapses of your brain. Should you alter these proteines, and chemical reaction rates will alter as well, practically changing how your mind works.

Stitcher wrote:

I'd be a pale featureless everyman.

That will fit exactly into egalitarianistic gallentean gray mass. J.Roden smiles than you say stuff like this.
Bleargh.
Disgusting.

Stitcher wrote:

Now, I have considerable respect for my ancestors, as should all Caldari. But if I don't consider my DNA to be important for anything more than maintaining a certain physical appearance that I have, again, chosen to retain, then my regard for my ancestors is NOT for the DNA they contributed to my birth body, but instead for the culture they built, the history they wrote and the legacy I'm trying to find a place in.

This DNA is the best gift they bestowed on you, and this is much more than just physical appearance! Our history, culture and legacy show us, whom we were, and what we must strive to achieve. While our DNA defines who we are.

Stitcher wrote:

As I said - it's the brain-state that matters, and I've even tweaked that with neural remapping technology in the last few years. There is nothing about my physical being that is not open to modification, augmentation and improvement. Has that changed me as a person? I would argue no more so than living from day to day did. A person is not a static and unchanging thing, our reality is an ever-moving moment of subjectivity, and I'm privileged to have a tighter and more direct control over that moment than is afforded to most people. I have greater freedom to choose who I am and wish to be, and have exercised it.

I would expect a fellow infomorph to at least grasp the concept of mind/body dualism and to recognise that it is the FORMER that matters.

Mind and body are bound together. Your mind can't think when there is no body: it is just data. Your body can't think when there is no mind: it is just meat. You can think of mind as a program and a body as a hardware to run this program. Will you agree, that you can't run quality program on a flawed hardware?

Honored are the dead, for their legacy guides us.

In memory of Tibus Heth, Caldari State Executor YC110-115, Hero and Patriot.

Scherezad
Revenent Defence Corperation
Ishuk-Raata Enforcement Directive
#32 - 2012-11-26 08:03:26 UTC  |  Edited by: Scherezad
The spiral fingered arms of helicase will mould
All life and thought, all beating hearts will yield.
Yet in that lover's grasp, all thoughts enfold
And blossom forth from Xanadu, old laws appealed
To find new suns, new worlds,
A brighter day,
And not to lose ones path along the way.
Natalcya Katla
Astropolitan Front
#33 - 2012-11-26 08:56:08 UTC
Streya Jormagdnir wrote:
Down with this sort of thing. There is a science in the bedroom all its own, and it is beautiful. Not saying those born in tubes or whatever are less worthy, but if I'm to bring a child into this world I'd rather bear it myself. Personal preference, of course.

If your personal preference is to gamble with the life of your offspring, a life you do not own, you are of course within your legal rights to do so.
Stitcher
School of Applied Knowledge
Caldari State
#34 - 2012-11-26 12:00:09 UTC  |  Edited by: Stitcher
Diana Kim wrote:
Your abilities and limitations, gifts and flaws, both physical and mental, all are encoded in these strips of acid.


Maybe at first, when we are still developing. But I am no longer an embryonic being. I could choose to abandon my DNA if I so chose, and doing so would have zero noticeable impact upon my abilities, limitations, gifts and flaws.

Besides, even if we go back to my first body, even that did not have entirely natural DNA. My parents paid for a course of in-utero genegineering that fixed my maximum body fat percentage, boosted my natural muscle tone and density, compensated for family histories of myopia, bipolar disorder, aortic stenosis and diabetes mellitus, and prevented a femoral anteversion before it ever even developed. They also made damn sure I'd inherit my father's blue eyes. My siblings underwent the precise same therapy. It won't be long before such antenatal genegineering programs begin to include the genetic components necessary for capsule use.

You can continue to assert that genes are important if you wish, but repeated assertion is not a route to factual accuracy. I can demonstrate through argument and reason why my genetic heritage simply isn't important. The best you can do is continue to assert your irrational belief that it is.

Our genes aren't important: they're a tool.

Quote:
Will you agree, that you can't run quality program on a flawed hardware?


I will absolutely not agree that! There are brilliant scientists out there whose bodies are wasted and all but useless thanks to the effects of some genetic condition that was only detected too late to be corrected. One of the women responsible for the modern starship jump drive can only speak thanks to the medical implants in the speech centers of her brain. It's a well-established historical fact that the re-discovery of calculus on Caldari Prime was accomplished by an individual described by contemporary commentators as "a cripple".

The only hardware that counts is the brain, and that gets precisely copied and reassembled upon cloning without regard for the genetic composition of the body around it. If by some accident you were to be cloned into a body that had been prepared for a Gallentean pilot, I think your reaction would be completely predictable. Why? Because your bigoted little mind is in no way influenced by the body it's in, but by the brain, which is copied with extreme fidelity when you are cloned. You would still be Diana Kim in all her narrow-minded and nationalist glory, no matter the shape of your cheekbones.

AKA Hambone

Author of The Deathworlders

Alain Colcer
Nadire Security Consultants
Federation Peacekeepers
#35 - 2012-11-26 12:42:23 UTC
I find it entertaining to be told we have a problem, its like being a celebrity on GalNet, if there is drama, we are there as stars...

What better outcome for a Gallentean than to always be the center of people's focus!
Unit XS365BT
Unit Commune
#36 - 2012-11-26 15:07:17 UTC
Diana Kim wrote:

Mind and body are bound together. Your mind can't think when there is no body: it is just data.



Incorrect.

We Return

Unit XS365BT. Designated Communications Officer. Unit Commune.

Tiberious Thessalonia
True Slave Foundations
#37 - 2012-11-26 15:15:48 UTC
Unit XS365BT wrote:
Diana Kim wrote:

Mind and body are bound together. Your mind can't think when there is no body: it is just data.



Incorrect.

We Return


Do you mean "Incorrect, a meat body is not required for a mind to think and a subsitute can be used" or "Incorrect, a mind is freely capable of thinking without being tied to a physical vessel of some kind."

If the latter, I am going to have to ask to see some proof.
Diana Kim
State Protectorate
Caldari State
#38 - 2012-11-26 15:49:00 UTC
Stitcher wrote:
Diana Kim wrote:
Your abilities and limitations, gifts and flaws, both physical and mental, all are encoded in these strips of acid.


Maybe at first, when we are still developing. But I am no longer an embryonic being. I could choose to abandon my DNA if I so chose, and doing so would have zero noticeable impact upon my abilities, limitations, gifts and flaws.

Well, then I'd like to remind our 'no longer embryonic being', that the moment you abandon your DNA, generation of proteins will stop, cells will stop working, and die, and so will you.
Have a nice sleep.

Stitcher wrote:
You can continue to assert that genes are important if you wish, but repeated assertion is not a route to factual accuracy. I can demonstrate through argument and reason why my genetic heritage simply isn't important. The best you can do is continue to assert your irrational belief that it is.

So I was trying to demonstrate too. But whatever, it's your genes, do with them whatever you want. As for me, I am proud to be who I am.

Stitcher wrote:

The only hardware that counts is the brain, and that gets precisely copied and reassembled upon cloning without regard for the genetic composition of the body around it.

I think I already told you that cells can't function without DNA. DNA affects proteines, proteines affect reactions, rate of reactions affect power of apprehension. There is a number of different neuromediators, affecting different signals. Thinking is not just a couple of electrical signals, it is a complex network of different and balanced chemical reactions, catalyzed by your proteins, synthesized from your DNA. Easy like that. You can copy current state of the brain, but further evolution will depend on DNA in brain cells.

Honored are the dead, for their legacy guides us.

In memory of Tibus Heth, Caldari State Executor YC110-115, Hero and Patriot.

Diana Kim
State Protectorate
Caldari State
#39 - 2012-11-26 15:53:55 UTC
Alain Colcer wrote:
I find it entertaining to be told we have a problem, its like being a celebrity on GalNet, if there is drama, we are there as stars...

What better outcome for a Gallentean than to always be the center of people's focus!


I'd really prefer to have you in a center of my gun sight.


Unit XS365BT wrote:
Diana Kim wrote:

Mind and body are bound together. Your mind can't think when there is no body: it is just data.



Incorrect.

We Return

Syntax error.

Argument not found.

Retry, abort, ignore?

Honored are the dead, for their legacy guides us.

In memory of Tibus Heth, Caldari State Executor YC110-115, Hero and Patriot.

Stitcher
School of Applied Knowledge
Caldari State
#40 - 2012-11-26 16:04:22 UTC  |  Edited by: Stitcher
you're either deliberately misinterpreting me for what you think is comic effect, or you just suck at basic reading comprehension.

When I say "abandon my DNA" I don't mean abandon DNA in general. I mean abandon MY DNA. The particular sequence that I had when I was born. I don't have to have it. So long as my genetic code falls inside the spectrum of the human genome, it doesn't technically matter which specific genes I inherited and from whom I inherited them, other than for reasons of nostalgia.

The fact that I have Civire genes is completely irrelevant to the good functioning of my body. They are, effectively, cosmetic.

AKA Hambone

Author of The Deathworlders