These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

EVE General Discussion

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Okay CCP, it's time. Acknowledge the legitimacy of The New Order, James 315, and bumping.

First post
Author
Petrus Blackshell
Rifterlings
#181 - 2012-10-22 16:07:01 UTC
Vanyr Andrard wrote:
I refer you to This Post by James315 , which proves you wrong yet again.

I appear to be wrong. My apologies.

I am not an agent of the Order, I merely support it. I unfortunately cannot participate as CONCORD thinks poorly of my attempts to coerce the populace into donating their ships' modules and contents to my own cause.

Accidentally The Whole Frigate - For-newbies blog (currently on pause)

Vaerah Vahrokha
Vahrokh Consulting
#182 - 2012-10-22 16:08:04 UTC
Nanatoa wrote:
Vaerah Vahrokha wrote:
Your "last night" is not necessarily my "last night".

Not necessarily perhaps, but it is, isn't it? Your posting habits suggest you sleep from about midnight to 06:00 game time.


On last week's Friday my RL trader mentor has started a special project, chose 3 people (me being one of them) and put them to work hard as hell. My posting habits and sleep since then are not exactly... standard. And leave me less time to post on the forums for sure.


Nanatoa wrote:

You called what Solstice Project does 'emergent', but you dismissed what James 315 does as 'nothing new' and 'limited'. There is your double standard. If "bumping some AFK dude" is not emergent then neither is podding some autopiloting dude.
None of your examples have anything to do with this.


Have you actually *seen* what he does? He plays as -10 in hi sec like hi sec was nullsec or at least he makes it look like it is so.
It's awesome!

I have not seen anyone playing how he does. He does not just sit at a gate (he could not) waiting for the noob.
Eugene Kerner
TunDraGon
Goonswarm Federation
#183 - 2012-10-22 16:17:21 UTC
A friendly bump for a service/product I endorse and recommend....would bump again.

TunDraGon is recruiting! "Also, your boobs [:o] "   CCP Eterne, 2012 "When in doubt...make a diȼk joke." Robin Williams - RIP

Petrus Blackshell
Rifterlings
#184 - 2012-10-22 16:23:57 UTC
Vaerah Vahrokha wrote:
Nanatoa wrote:

You called what Solstice Project does 'emergent', but you dismissed what James 315 does as 'nothing new' and 'limited'. There is your double standard. If "bumping some AFK dude" is not emergent then neither is podding some autopiloting dude.
None of your examples have anything to do with this.


Have you actually *seen* what he does? He plays as -10 in hi sec like hi sec was nullsec or at least he makes it look like it is so.
It's awesome!

I have not seen anyone playing how he does. He does not just sit at a gate (he could not) waiting for the noob.

I think the point was that reducing anything to its base actions makes everything boring, not just James' bumping. For instance, Chribba just does trading, no big deal. The Mittani just tells a bunch of people what to do. You just push some buttons on your keyboard and then click a button that says "Post".

Accidentally The Whole Frigate - For-newbies blog (currently on pause)

Solstice Project
Sebiestor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#185 - 2012-10-22 16:32:58 UTC
Vaerah Vahrokha wrote:
Nanatoa wrote:

You called what Solstice Project does 'emergent', but you dismissed what James 315 does as 'nothing new' and 'limited'. There is your double standard. If "bumping some AFK dude" is not emergent then neither is podding some autopiloting dude.
None of your examples have anything to do with this.


Have you actually *seen* what he does? He plays as -10 in hi sec like hi sec was nullsec or at least he makes it look like it is so.
It's awesome!

I have not seen anyone playing how he does. He does not just sit at a gate (he could not) waiting for the noob.

No she hasn't and i wouldn't even blame her for believing i'm just like the average guy.
She can't know that i not only shoot pods, but also actually entertain the people of Hek, when i'm around.

Thank you, Vaerah ! :D


Anyway ... i have to correct my false belief ... connecting "emergent" to "new" isn't even stated in the definition.

Argueing about this makes no sense, tbh. Every action is emergent, as long as it influences the lives of others
and produces new sets of possibilities. Hell, even lack of action can be called emergent, because not doing
something enables others to do it.

I saw that there's a new thread about how boring EvE is ... at least for some people. This is the real problem
we need to address. Our universe lacks content creators more than anything else. It's full of lemmings doing
something that could be seen as their every day job ... ingame ... instead of realising that it's a game, which
enables people to actually not do what they already do anyway ... being a lemming.


Disclaimer: The next paragraph doesn't address anybody who actively tries to influence the lives of others.

I see the flames of people saying "don't tell me how to play" already coming, but that's not what i'm doing.
What i'm telling you is that you ... the general YOU ... actually play far behind your own abilities of having actual
ACTIVE INFLUENCE onto others, instead of the passive, "working as intended" influence you have as the lemming you are.


This thread has no point. People complaining about how others play, demanding that they be left alone so they
can play how they want, while at the same time ignoring that they are demanding from others that they don't
play how they want. People talking bad about those who try to have influence and play the game in ways it allows,
ignoring that they are only pissed off about the mirrored image of their own incapabilities.


In sum, one can say that the lemmings are simply mad about being lemmings and blame those who aren't.
Solstice Project
Sebiestor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#186 - 2012-10-22 16:33:36 UTC
Petrus Blackshell wrote:
I think the point was that reducing anything to its base actions makes everything boring, not just James' bumping. For instance, Chribba just does trading, no big deal. The Mittani just tells a bunch of people what to do. You just push some buttons on your keyboard and then click a button that says "Post".

Could you elaborate on that, please ?
Vanyr Andrard
VacuumTube
#187 - 2012-10-22 16:40:55 UTC
Solstice Project wrote:
Petrus Blackshell wrote:
I think the point was that reducing anything to its base actions makes everything boring, not just James' bumping. For instance, Chribba just does trading, no big deal. The Mittani just tells a bunch of people what to do. You just push some buttons on your keyboard and then click a button that says "Post".

Could you elaborate on that, please ?


Why would you ask him to? It's completely irrelevant, he's arguing against some hypothetical line of debate about which things are more boring, which is inherently pointless and which I haven't even seen being made in this thread. It's a giant pointless strawman fallacy.

Wouldn't it be more productive, if you really were interested in discussing boredom, to find traditionally boring activities, find people who enjoy them, and then ask them why they enjoy them? That would still be way offtopic in this thread, of course, but if you find a place to do that, that would be a way do move it forward in a productive direction.
Petrus Blackshell
Rifterlings
#188 - 2012-10-22 16:42:41 UTC
Solstice Project wrote:
Petrus Blackshell wrote:
I think the point was that reducing anything to its base actions makes everything boring, not just James' bumping. For instance, Chribba just does trading, no big deal. The Mittani just tells a bunch of people what to do. You just push some buttons on your keyboard and then click a button that says "Post".

Could you elaborate on that, please ?

I'm not sure what elaboration it requires. While James is technically doing "nothing new" from a mechanical point of view, I have never heard of a united and profitable anti-AFKer campaign in hisec featuring bumping as its main tactic. Calling it "just bumping miners, which is as old as Eve" is like calling Solstice's stuff or the Goonswarm ice interdiction "just hisec-ganking, which is as old as Eve". It discredits these efforts by reducing them to as simple terms as possible.

As another example, saying Shakespeare "just wrote some words" is technically true, but also quite unfair.

Accidentally The Whole Frigate - For-newbies blog (currently on pause)

Petrus Blackshell
Rifterlings
#189 - 2012-10-22 16:43:24 UTC
Vanyr Andrard wrote:
Wouldn't it be more productive, if you really were interested in discussing boredom, to find traditionally boring activities, find people who enjoy them, and then ask them why they enjoy them? That would still be way offtopic in this thread, of course, but if you find a place to do that, that would be a way do move it forward in a productive direction.

That would be boring.

Accidentally The Whole Frigate - For-newbies blog (currently on pause)

Solstice Project
Sebiestor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#190 - 2012-10-22 16:45:08 UTC
Vanyr Andrard wrote:
Solstice Project wrote:
Petrus Blackshell wrote:
I think the point was that reducing anything to its base actions makes everything boring, not just James' bumping. For instance, Chribba just does trading, no big deal. The Mittani just tells a bunch of people what to do. You just push some buttons on your keyboard and then click a button that says "Post".

Could you elaborate on that, please ?


Why would you ask him to? It's completely irrelevant, he's arguing against some hypothetical line of debate about which things are more boring, which is inherently pointless and which I haven't even seen being made in this thread. It's a giant pointless strawman fallacy.

Wouldn't it be more productive, if you really were interested in discussing boredom, to find traditionally boring activities, find people who enjoy them, and then ask them why they enjoy them? That would still be way offtopic in this thread, of course, but if you find a place to do that, that would be a way do move it forward in a productive direction.

I guess it's none of your business why i asked him.

On a funny sidenote: You ask me to do something productive, while you yourself aren't productive at all. Nice.
Solstice Project
Sebiestor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#191 - 2012-10-22 16:51:45 UTC
Petrus Blackshell wrote:
Solstice Project wrote:
Petrus Blackshell wrote:
I think the point was that reducing anything to its base actions makes everything boring, not just James' bumping. For instance, Chribba just does trading, no big deal. The Mittani just tells a bunch of people what to do. You just push some buttons on your keyboard and then click a button that says "Post".

Could you elaborate on that, please ?

I'm not sure what elaboration it requires. While James is technically doing "nothing new" from a mechanical point of view, I have never heard of a united and profitable anti-AFKer campaign in hisec featuring bumping as its main tactic. Calling it "just bumping miners, which is as old as Eve" is like calling Solstice's stuff or the Goonswarm ice interdiction "just hisec-ganking, which is as old as Eve". It discredits these efforts by reducing them to as simple terms as possible.

As another example, saying Shakespeare "just wrote some words" is technically true, but also quite unfair.

Thank you. Exactly what i hoped for.

In other words:
People have no clue, but believe they have and thus talk crap about things they don't *really* understand.

It's like in the real world. They are totally disconnected with actual reality. Like watching the news and believing to
know what "War" is, because the news shows what "War" is ... ignoring the fact that it's impossible to know what "War"
really is unless one is stuck right in the middle of it.

People who ignore feelings involved in whatever happens and thus reduce everything to a few words
that don't actually express the experiences and depth that is part of the actual reality.

Welcome to "modern" civilization.
Vanyr Andrard
VacuumTube
#192 - 2012-10-22 16:52:47 UTC
Petrus Blackshell wrote:
Solstice Project wrote:
Petrus Blackshell wrote:
I think the point was that reducing anything to its base actions makes everything boring, not just James' bumping. For instance, Chribba just does trading, no big deal. The Mittani just tells a bunch of people what to do. You just push some buttons on your keyboard and then click a button that says "Post".

Could you elaborate on that, please ?

I'm not sure what elaboration it requires. While James is technically doing "nothing new" from a mechanical point of view, I have never heard of a united and profitable anti-AFKer campaign in hisec featuring bumping as its main tactic. Calling it "just bumping miners, which is as old as Eve" is like calling Solstice's stuff or the Goonswarm ice interdiction "just hisec-ganking, which is as old as Eve". It discredits these efforts by reducing them to as simple terms as possible.

As another example, saying Shakespeare "just wrote some words" is technically true, but also quite unfair.


It's not profitable, as an anti-AFK'er campaign. Hardly anyone pays for indulgences.

It's very profitable, as a "pay to join cool club", which is definitely not new. It's obviously emergent gameplay, despite not being new. I think Vaerah is operating with a personal definition of 'emergent' which specifically disallows gameplay which is both not innovative, and consists of getting a group of people together to bully others, from being called emergent. Like Solstice already mentioned, emergent behavior is actually the norm not the exception when it comes to interactions of things which are already wellsprings of emergence, like living things, so any time you start throwing around emergence as a positive worthy goal, these redefinitions are quite common.
Vanyr Andrard
VacuumTube
#193 - 2012-10-22 16:53:49 UTC
Solstice Project wrote:
Vanyr Andrard wrote:
Solstice Project wrote:
Petrus Blackshell wrote:
I think the point was that reducing anything to its base actions makes everything boring, not just James' bumping. For instance, Chribba just does trading, no big deal. The Mittani just tells a bunch of people what to do. You just push some buttons on your keyboard and then click a button that says "Post".

Could you elaborate on that, please ?


Why would you ask him to? It's completely irrelevant, he's arguing against some hypothetical line of debate about which things are more boring, which is inherently pointless and which I haven't even seen being made in this thread. It's a giant pointless strawman fallacy.

Wouldn't it be more productive, if you really were interested in discussing boredom, to find traditionally boring activities, find people who enjoy them, and then ask them why they enjoy them? That would still be way offtopic in this thread, of course, but if you find a place to do that, that would be a way do move it forward in a productive direction.

I guess it's none of your business why i asked him.

On a funny sidenote: You ask me to do something productive, while you yourself aren't productive at all. Nice.


I guess you answered a rhetorical question. Oops.
Petrus Blackshell
Rifterlings
#194 - 2012-10-22 16:56:21 UTC
Vanyr Andrard wrote:
Hardly anyone pays for indulgences.

How do you figure?

Accidentally The Whole Frigate - For-newbies blog (currently on pause)

Solstice Project
Sebiestor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#195 - 2012-10-22 17:04:28 UTC
Vanyr Andrard wrote:
It's not profitable, as an anti-AFK'er campaign. Hardly anyone pays for indulgences.

It's very profitable, as a "pay to join cool club", which is definitely not new. It's obviously emergent gameplay, despite not being new. I think Vaerah is operating with a personal definition of 'emergent' which specifically disallows gameplay which is both not innovative, and consists of getting a group of people together to bully others, from being called emergent. Like Solstice already mentioned, emergent behavior is actually the norm not the exception when it comes to interactions of things which are already wellsprings of emergence, like living things, so any time you start throwing around emergence as a positive worthy goal, these redefinitions are quite common.

I'm not quite sure i really said it that way.

Everyday-people with everyday-lives hardly create new possibilites for others, thus it's not actually "emergent".
It's just "working as intended" without creating any new sets of possibilities.

Have a conscious thought and do something totally out of your normal behavioral patterns,
which influences at least one other person. That's emergent behaviour.

Doing the same thing you do every day, every week, for months until you die ... that's not.

That's what lemmings do and they keep society up with their crap lives,
but calling it emergent makes it look like everybody is actually awesome,
although 99% of the people are just boring assholes only caring about themselves.
Nanatoa
#196 - 2012-10-22 17:04:46 UTC  |  Edited by: Nanatoa
Vaerah Vahrokha wrote:
Nanatoa wrote:
Vaerah Vahrokha wrote:
Your "last night" is not necessarily my "last night".

Not necessarily perhaps, but it is, isn't it? Your posting habits suggest you sleep from about midnight to 06:00 game time.


On last week's Friday my RL trader mentor has started a special project, chose 3 people (me being one of them) and put them to work hard as hell. My posting habits and sleep since then are not exactly... standard. And leave me less time to post on the forums for sure.


I checked the exact times of your posts in the last two months. There's a big dip in your posts between 22:00 and 05:00 (sorry I was off a bit with my eyeballed "midnight to 06:00"). In two months, you have never posted between 02:00 and 04:00. So I call BS on your implication that 01:05 might be 'morning' to you. Why don't you just admit it isn't?

Solstice Project wrote:
No she hasn't and i wouldn't even blame her for believing i'm just like the average guy.
She can't know that i not only shoot pods, but also actually entertain the people of Hek, when i'm around.

Indeed I have not seen you in action; in any case I have no problem at all with what you do, whatever you do exactly. My point is that it is idiotic for Vaerah Vahrokha to praise what you do while dismissing what James 315 does, because you are doing the same thing James 315: using the game to entertain people, which is great. My qualification of your actions as just "podding some autopiloting dude" was to compare it to Vaerah Vahrokha's qualification of James 315's actions as just "bumping some AFK dude"

(tl;dr: what Petrus Blackshell said)

"Stay the course, we have done this many times before." - (CCP) Hilmar, June 2011

Solstice Project
Sebiestor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#197 - 2012-10-22 17:05:34 UTC  |  Edited by: Solstice Project
Vanyr Andrard wrote:
I guess you answered a rhetorical question. Oops.

You're a hater. No point in talking to you any further.
Solstice Project
Sebiestor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#198 - 2012-10-22 17:07:45 UTC
Nanatoa wrote:
Indeed I have not seen you in action; in any case I have no problem at all with what you do, whatever you do exactly. My point is that it is idiotic for Vaerah Vahrokha to praise what you do while dismissing what James 315 does, because you are doing the same thing James 315: using the game to entertain people, which is great. My qualification of your actions as just "podding some autopiloting dude" was to compare it to Vaerah Vahrokha's qualification of James 315's actions as just "bumping some AFK dude".

Ahhh ... mhm mhm.
Vanyr Andrard
VacuumTube
#199 - 2012-10-22 17:13:19 UTC
Petrus Blackshell wrote:
Vanyr Andrard wrote:
Hardly anyone pays for indulgences.

How do you figure?



See, we keep having these debates, over the facts of the matter. I trained ice mining on an alt, and moved my ice miner to Halaima, both recently, with the goal of observing the social interactions between the miners and the agents. You didn't make an alt to go observe, and your main has poor sec status so you don't take him to Halaima.

I'm not saying that you should stay out of the discussion for this reason, there's a practical side and a theoretical side, and I'm not trying to privilege one over the other. I'm not saying that my personal experience is more valuable than anyone else's personal experience, either. If an agent comes out and says "oh, tons of people pay", then he and I will in effect be calling each other liars, and it will be up to the reader to decide whom to believe.

I'm just saying, I keep making statements that are obviously based on my personal observations, and you keep asking me how I figure them. The answer is always the same. I was there. I may be lying, and I may be a poor observer, although I'll tell you now that neither of those is true. My personal observation is that half of the miners that stayed in the NewOrder systems were there to observe how it all played out, and the other half stayed to petition the NewOrder repeatedly. Then of course you had the odd person newly arrived, mining is a profession most do early and then leave after a time...but there was no rational reason to keep mining in Halaima, when you could jsut move somewhere else. Since part of paying the 10m was putting a statement of support in your bio for the new order, it was easy to see who had paid, or who pretended to pay and just put the statement in their bio, which would have the same effect, of course. I would mine for days without seeing a single person pay, watching many bumpers come through. It was my observation that the bumpers would mainly claim they were doing it to stop botting, but that around 80% of them were actually more interested in starting arguments with the real at the computer miners, just trying to gather tears. Not that tear gathering doesn't have a long and storied history in EVE, but I found it ironic that these 'bumpers' would make fun of the miners for playing in hisec mining in safety, when they themselves had chosen to come to hisec and bump as their method of tear-gathering. In that sense, I found the bumpers and the ice miners to be more alike than different.
Vanyr Andrard
VacuumTube
#200 - 2012-10-22 17:17:30 UTC
Solstice Project wrote:
Vanyr Andrard wrote:
I guess you answered a rhetorical question. Oops.

You're a hater. No point in talking to you any further.



Solstice Project wrote:
although 99% of the people are just boring assholes only caring about themselves.



I think the above quotes speak for themselves. "For tis the sport to haue the enginer / Hoist with his owne petar."