These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Science & Industry

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

T2BPO why they should be removed and how.

First post
Author
shar'ra matcevsovski
Doomheim
#1041 - 2012-09-04 14:12:18 UTC  |  Edited by: shar'ra matcevsovski
Azrael Dinn wrote:

It's worth mentioning every single time it is mentioned just so that no one never forgets that someone in CCP *****d *p real bad. And what proof do YOU have that all of those prints where removed? none.


IT was wrong, yes but its still a game after all, right? the way you and your friend brewlar mentioning it almost sounds like we are tlking about the holocaust.
Since the website who found that out defentily wasnt working together with CCP to that point, im sure they would have mentioned it. proof enough for me tbh.

Azrael Dinn wrote:

And no I do not have solutions to it. Neither do you. Only thing I have are my opinions which from your point of view sucks and your solutions form my point of view sucks, so no point talking about those.

I dont see a problem that need to be fixed, there for i have never offered a solution for a not existing issue.

Azrael Dinn wrote:

So mayby something needs to be done about this so the topic would go away once and for all. I'll settle on what ever CCP says as long as they address the matter in some way..


to achieve that goal you would have to remove envy from of the human nature, wich is the only reason why ppl are complaining at all.
Azrael Dinn wrote:

And not saying anything is not an answer.

there has been so much discussion about that topic over the years... but there are just these special snowflakes that dont want to understand, so its understandable that they dont wase their time to explain it over and over again instead of fixing real issues.

shar'ra phone home

Tivookz
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#1042 - 2012-09-04 14:28:16 UTC  |  Edited by: Tivookz
The people yelling for T2 BPO's to be removed should first spend 15 bil buying one, as a future investment.

We, the people who spent hard earned cash on T2 bpo's, don't want our investments to dissapear into thin air.

I didn't win any lottery, I didn't rob anyone. I spent serveral years playing the market, mining and ratting to buy my T2 BPOs. I dont own many and quite frankly I have yet to earn any money from them.

You need to understand that most T2 BPO's have long production timers and or near zero profit.

Take my Berserker II BPO, it might be valued at around 25 bil give or take but I earn nothing producing them because the profit is next to zero compared to how much you need to spend to buy such a BPO.

To give you some numbers to think about:

I can produce 16200 Berserker II's in a year if the BPO is in production 24/7.

Manufacture cost(16200 Runs): 7 795 576 663.43 ISK
Manufacture cost one unit: 481 208.44 ISK
Minimum sell cost (16200 Runs): 7 951 488 196.70 ISK
Minimum sell cost one unit: 490 832.60 ISK
Market profit (16200 runs): 571 075 336.57 ISK
Market profit one unit: 35 251.56 ISK
ISK/h: 65 319.07 ISK
Profit %: 7.33%

This is what I spend and earn per YEAR from my Berserker II BPO. 571 mil in profit per year from a 25 bil investment.

If we assume that the value of said BPO is 25 bil then at the current market prices it will take me 43,7 years to earn 25 bil in pure profit from it.

43,7 Earth years. Yes.

Please rethink your reason for creating this plead to remove T2BPOs.
Korg Tronix
Mole Station Nursery
#1043 - 2012-09-04 16:04:17 UTC
Tivookz wrote:
The people yelling for T2 BPO's to be removed should first spend 15 bil buying one, as a future investment.

We, the people who spent hard earned cash on T2 bpo's, don't want our investments to dissapear into thin air.

I didn't win any lottery, I didn't rob anyone. I spent serveral years playing the market, mining and ratting to buy my T2 BPOs. I dont own many and quite frankly I have yet to earn any money from them.

You need to understand that most T2 BPO's have long production timers and or near zero profit.

Take my Berserker II BPO, it might be valued at around 25 bil give or take but I earn nothing producing them because the profit is next to zero compared to how much you need to spend to buy such a BPO.

To give you some numbers to think about:

I can produce 16200 Berserker II's in a year if the BPO is in production 24/7.

Manufacture cost(16200 Runs): 7 795 576 663.43 ISK
Manufacture cost one unit: 481 208.44 ISK
Minimum sell cost (16200 Runs): 7 951 488 196.70 ISK
Minimum sell cost one unit: 490 832.60 ISK
Market profit (16200 runs): 571 075 336.57 ISK
Market profit one unit: 35 251.56 ISK
ISK/h: 65 319.07 ISK
Profit %: 7.33%

This is what I spend and earn per YEAR from my Berserker II BPO. 571 mil in profit per year from a 25 bil investment.

If we assume that the value of said BPO is 25 bil then at the current market prices it will take me 43,7 years to earn 25 bil in pure profit from it.

43,7 Earth years. Yes.

Please rethink your reason for creating this plead to remove T2BPOs.


What i find really funny is i earn more from invented damage controls each month than you do from your bpo in a year

Evil: If I were creating the world I wouldn't mess about with butterflies and daffodils. I would have started with lasers, eight o'clock, Day One! [zaps one of his minions accidentally, minion screams]

Kara Books
Deal with IT.
#1044 - 2012-09-04 16:05:06 UTC
Tivookz wrote:
The people yelling for T2 BPO's to be removed should first spend 15 bil buying one, as a future investment.

We, the people who spent hard earned cash on T2 bpo's, don't want our investments to dissapear into thin air.

I didn't win any lottery, I didn't rob anyone. I spent serveral years playing the market, mining and ratting to buy my T2 BPOs. I dont own many and quite frankly I have yet to earn any money from them.

You need to understand that most T2 BPO's have long production timers and or near zero profit.

Take my Berserker II BPO, it might be valued at around 25 bil give or take but I earn nothing producing them because the profit is next to zero compared to how much you need to spend to buy such a BPO.

To give you some numbers to think about:

I can produce 16200 Berserker II's in a year if the BPO is in production 24/7.

Manufacture cost(16200 Runs): 7 795 576 663.43 ISK
Manufacture cost one unit: 481 208.44 ISK
Minimum sell cost (16200 Runs): 7 951 488 196.70 ISK
Minimum sell cost one unit: 490 832.60 ISK
Market profit (16200 runs): 571 075 336.57 ISK
Market profit one unit: 35 251.56 ISK
ISK/h: 65 319.07 ISK
Profit %: 7.33%

This is what I spend and earn per YEAR from my Berserker II BPO. 571 mil in profit per year from a 25 bil investment.

If we assume that the value of said BPO is 25 bil then at the current market prices it will take me 43,7 years to earn 25 bil in pure profit from it.

43,7 Earth years. Yes.

Please rethink your reason for creating this plead to remove T2BPOs.


This is the best argument against removal that has touched this topic to date, very nice, the smalltime Industrialists moving into their bigtime is a warm sight to see, I bet this is exactly how CCP intended this T2 Lottery to Play out, but in fact, its not this pretty 95% of the time.

Far earlier into this subject, I have mentioned several times, that if there is a T2 removal or Massive change to the entire segment, the option to refund owners the estimated amount should be considered and a good long thought should be given before making any changes to the T2 BPO project are to be made, to avoid Volatility and possible catastrophic results to the Market ecosystem are just some "Ingame reasons"

The result CAN aim for More players to be recruited into the CCP 514/EvE project, ample but profitable supply of all goods to be available to the general playerbase and the ability to make anything from scratch all on your own should be an important Tertiary goal, The later half CCP is actually doing a superb job, and very minimal Market interruption is being incurred.

10/10 excellent job.

But all games Aside, this is my main reason Why im here, fighting for this "Option" and is my response to your compelling argument.

Several months ago we began to see a drop in New blood entering the game, CCP responded with a solid decision to Protect newbies for at-least a few days while they learn to control their ships, how to scan and most importantly so they can focus on making their first friends in the game in hopes of retaining these new customers long enough to for them to see just how unique and incredible this game really is at its very heart once they actually head out and run into the likes of me on the forums or you on the Niarja gate as some random examples.

If CCP, where to make a strong push, which they likely will with DUST514, players can flood the eve servers by the tens of thousands and retaining them longer then 6 months could mean actually doing whatever needs be done to really hook them, and you,(large scale) T2 BPO holders, may actually want to consider this a viable tradeoff.

like most if not all of the posters here on this topic, Removal, Modification or otherwise Giving them something very special is a Legitimate option within options we CANNOT ignore and I believe CCP has is closely following this topic because they already understand exactly that, its in yours, mines and their best interests to Nab as many new players into this game as possible and retain them for (hopefully) years.

This is one of these subjects that CCP can use to gain and retain a stronger and solid player base in the case they decide to pursue a very certain type of advertisement campaign but only if certain circumstances and accurances actually take place.
Brewlar Kuvakei
Adeptio Gloriae
#1045 - 2012-09-04 16:17:16 UTC  |  Edited by: Brewlar Kuvakei
CCP will tire of noobie industrialist players leaving the game when they find out about T2BPO and will eventual stem the blood flow that is pissing out of the eve economy and player base. It may take many years and eve might slip further down the ladder but eventual they will fix the problem, If they don't eve will die and it won't matter any more.
sodney
Tactical Feed.
Pandemic Horde
#1046 - 2012-09-04 16:28:12 UTC
Brewlar Kuvakei wrote:
CCP will tire of noobie industrialist players leaving the game when they find out about T2BPO and will eventual stem the blood flow that is pissing out of the eve economy and player base. It may take many years and eve might slip further down the ladder but eventual they will fix the problem, If they don't eve will die and it won't matter any more.


Or eve will grow and live like it did the past 7 years aswell with T2 BPO`s as they are Roll
Zifrian
The Frog Pond
Ribbit.
#1047 - 2012-09-04 16:51:09 UTC
Brewlar Kuvakei wrote:
CCP will tire of noobie industrialist players leaving the game when they find out about T2BPO and will eventual stem the blood flow that is pissing out of the eve economy and player base. It may take many years and eve might slip further down the ladder but eventual they will fix the problem, If they don't eve will die and it won't matter any more.

So does this mean you are quitting?

Maximze your Industry Potential! - Download EVE Isk per Hour!

Import CCP's SDE - EVE SDE Database Builder

Lara Dantreb
Reisende des Schwarzschild Grenze
#1048 - 2012-09-04 21:31:33 UTC
Brewlar Kuvakei wrote:
CCP will tire of noobie industrialist players leaving the game when they find out about T2BPO and will eventual stem the blood flow that is pissing out of the eve economy and player base. It may take many years and eve might slip further down the ladder but eventual they will fix the problem, If they don't eve will die and it won't matter any more.


I suspended 13 accounts and have not played EVE for 3+ months, and my 25 T2BPOs are taking dust unproducing. for 2 reasons :

- Diablo 3 (basic and fun, no headaches, no spreadsheets)
- Sheer amount of bad faith and stupidity from bitter complainers who don't understand the basics of the game and spend their time giving advices that nobody asked for.


---   Buying T2 ship bpos since 2005  ---

shar'ra matcevsovski
Doomheim
#1049 - 2012-09-04 22:03:02 UTC
Brewlar Kuvakei wrote:
CCP will tire of noobie industrialist players leaving the game when they find out about T2BPO and will eventual stem the blood flow that is pissing out of the eve economy and player base. It may take many years and eve might slip further down the ladder but eventual they will fix the problem, If they don't eve will die and it won't matter any more.


you said that every new player will quit as soon he will hear about t2 BPO`s. I think you heard about them and are apparently a new player, so why are you still playing the game?

shar'ra phone home

Brewlar Kuvakei
Adeptio Gloriae
#1050 - 2012-09-04 22:14:59 UTC  |  Edited by: Brewlar Kuvakei
shar'ra matcevsovski wrote:
Brewlar Kuvakei wrote:
CCP will tire of noobie industrialist players leaving the game when they find out about T2BPO and will eventual stem the blood flow that is pissing out of the eve economy and player base. It may take many years and eve might slip further down the ladder but eventual they will fix the problem, If they don't eve will die and it won't matter any more.


you said that every new player will quit as soon he will hear about t2 BPO`s. I think you heard about them and are apparently a new player, so why are you still playing the game?


I was looking forward to doing T2 industry and even though select t2 fields are open to noobs where demand surpasses T2BPO production numbers I choose not to engage in the activity. I don't see why I should be offered the scraps while CCP has selected a player to have first pickings and a monopoly over that item.

I do however produce T2 rigs and other items where CCP has not given a chosen player the ability to out perform noobs. Yet I still hope CCP introduces BPO's for rigs and for T3. As all of you lot are saying T2BPO's don't harm the game what so ever and are all round amazing so please CCP seed T3 BPO's and rig BPO's because as you can see they are great just ask idiots such as shar'ra matcevsovski . She'll explain why gifted BPO's are great for the game.
Pipa Porto
#1051 - 2012-09-04 22:55:10 UTC
Brewlar Kuvakei wrote:
I was looking forward to doing T2 industry and even though select t2 fields are open to noobs where demand surpasses T2BPO production numbers I choose not to engage in the activity. I don't see why I should be offered the scraps while CCP has selected a player to have first pickings and a monopoly over that item.

I do however produce T2 rigs and other items where CCP has not given a chosen player the ability to out perform noobs. Yet I still hope CCP introduces BPO's for rigs and for T3. As all of you lot are saying T2BPO's don't harm the game what so ever and are all round amazing so please CCP seed T3 BPO's and rig BPO's because as you can see they are great just ask idiots such as shar'ra matcevsovski . She'll explain why gifted BPO's are great for the game.


1. Most T2 items have demands that far outstrip the capacity of their BPOs.

2. So you want CCP to remove T2 BPOs from some items, but add them for others? What kind of strawman are you building up to now?

3. Ah. There's the straw filled payoff. Something not being a problem does not mean that adding more of that something is a good idea.

4. You still don't seem to understand the concept of a lottery.

The existence and use of T2 BPOs don't cause any significant economic problems for inventors. Do you have any evidence to suggest otherwise (or evidence of the existence of a time machine)? Do you have any evidence to support your bizarre claim that T2 BPOs drive new players away from the game?

EvE: Everyone vs Everyone

-RubyPorto

Traedar
InterStellar Trading Syndicate
#1052 - 2012-09-05 03:03:28 UTC
I think a system could work where invention would be "newb" T2 production with low barrier to entry and then vets would be able to buy expensive T2 BPOs from NPCs just like any other BPO is available from NPCs. The prices on them could be relatively high compared to build cost.
Katerwaul
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#1053 - 2012-09-05 03:46:55 UTC
Brewlar Kuvakei wrote:
Hello,

I posted in the morning when the world was begun
I posted from the Moons and the stars and the Suns
I came down from Heaven and I danced on the Earth
At Caldari Institute 5 moon 3 I had my birth:

I posted for the bitter vets and the Devs of CCP
But they would not post back and they wouldn't follow me
I posted for the noobs and for the good Kugu
They came with me and the thread went on:

Post, post, wherever you may be
I am the lord of the T2BPO whine thread, said he
And I lead you all, wherever you may be
And I lead you all in the thread, said he

I posted on a Friday when the world turned black
It's hard to find time to post with invention on your back
They buried my thread, they thought it was gone
But this is a thread that will never ever die and so the posts go on!

They cut me down and I leapt up high
I am the life that will never, never die
I'll whine with you if you'll whine with me
I am the Lord of the T2BPO whine thread.

End T2BPO it was unfair then it's unfair now and detrimental to the game.


It now feels more like a support group and less like an eight-ball of pent up angst waiting for some twitchy newb to find it and become addicted to the disquieting cry of "It's not FAIR".

As long as we can agree that this is the T2BPO whining thread I suppose I can't argue with you.
Working with everyone to improve New Eden -- Internet Spaceships Iz Serious Business.
Pipa Porto
#1054 - 2012-09-05 08:51:04 UTC
Traedar wrote:
I think a system could work where invention would be "newb" T2 production with low barrier to entry and then vets would be able to buy expensive T2 BPOs from NPCs just like any other BPO is available from NPCs. The prices on them could be relatively high compared to build cost.


That would be fine until T2 BPOs reached the saturation point, then the bottom would fall out from invention.

Look at the Supercap and Titan BPC markets. A Titan BPC used to sell for about 20b so everyone and their brother who could afford to bought Titan BPOs for copying and now they sell for ~4b. The decline happened effectively overnight as the number of BPCs available reached and exceeded the demand for them.

Seed unlimited new T2 BPOs and people will buy them and knock the bottom out of the Invention market.

EvE: Everyone vs Everyone

-RubyPorto

Tivookz
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#1055 - 2012-09-05 10:29:32 UTC
Korg Tronix wrote:
Tivookz wrote:
The people yelling for T2 BPO's to be removed should first spend 15 bil buying one, as a future investment.

We, the people who spent hard earned cash on T2 bpo's, don't want our investments to dissapear into thin air.

I didn't win any lottery, I didn't rob anyone. I spent serveral years playing the market, mining and ratting to buy my T2 BPOs. I dont own many and quite frankly I have yet to earn any money from them.

You need to understand that most T2 BPO's have long production timers and or near zero profit.

Take my Berserker II BPO, it might be valued at around 25 bil give or take but I earn nothing producing them because the profit is next to zero compared to how much you need to spend to buy such a BPO.

To give you some numbers to think about:

I can produce 16200 Berserker II's in a year if the BPO is in production 24/7.

Manufacture cost(16200 Runs): 7 795 576 663.43 ISK
Manufacture cost one unit: 481 208.44 ISK
Minimum sell cost (16200 Runs): 7 951 488 196.70 ISK
Minimum sell cost one unit: 490 832.60 ISK
Market profit (16200 runs): 571 075 336.57 ISK
Market profit one unit: 35 251.56 ISK
ISK/h: 65 319.07 ISK
Profit %: 7.33%

This is what I spend and earn per YEAR from my Berserker II BPO. 571 mil in profit per year from a 25 bil investment.

If we assume that the value of said BPO is 25 bil then at the current market prices it will take me 43,7 years to earn 25 bil in pure profit from it.

43,7 Earth years. Yes.

Please rethink your reason for creating this plead to remove T2BPOs.


What i find really funny is i earn more from invented damage controls each month than you do from your bpo in a year


Yes. You see, T2BPO's only appear to be game breaking.. often its quite the contrary.

T2 BPO's don't need to be removed because they are not a problem.
Zifrian
The Frog Pond
Ribbit.
#1056 - 2012-09-05 11:53:35 UTC  |  Edited by: Zifrian
Brewlar Kuvakei wrote:
shar'ra matcevsovski wrote:
Brewlar Kuvakei wrote:
CCP will tire of noobie industrialist players leaving the game when they find out about T2BPO and will eventual stem the blood flow that is pissing out of the eve economy and player base. It may take many years and eve might slip further down the ladder but eventual they will fix the problem, If they don't eve will die and it won't matter any more.


you said that every new player will quit as soon he will hear about t2 BPO`s. I think you heard about them and are apparently a new player, so why are you still playing the game?


I was looking forward to doing T2 industry and even though select t2 fields are open to noobs where demand surpasses T2BPO production numbers I choose not to engage in the activity. I don't see why I should be offered the scraps while CCP has selected a player to have first pickings and a monopoly over that item.

I do however produce T2 rigs and other items where CCP has not given a chosen player the ability to out perform noobs. Yet I still hope CCP introduces BPO's for rigs and for T3. As all of you lot are saying T2BPO's don't harm the game what so ever and are all round amazing so please CCP seed T3 BPO's and rig BPO's because as you can see they are great just ask idiots such as shar'ra matcevsovski . She'll explain why gifted BPO's are great for the game.

If you choose not to engage in the activity, then why do you care to comment on it? What gives you any weight to your opinion if you do not do it? That's like me commenting on faction warfare and how unfair it is, which I have chosen not to engage in.Roll

My theory is that you like the attention, good or bad. That's why after three months of no one posting in this thread you go and copy it on another forum and link it back here. I mean as you said earlier, if you posted it in the general forum you would have got a lot more posts. That's what matters right? Not your poorly informed, logic defficient arguments - its all about the attention and post count.

Maximze your Industry Potential! - Download EVE Isk per Hour!

Import CCP's SDE - EVE SDE Database Builder

Kara Books
Deal with IT.
#1057 - 2012-09-05 13:07:32 UTC
Zifrian wrote:
Brewlar Kuvakei wrote:
shar'ra matcevsovski wrote:
Brewlar Kuvakei wrote:
CCP will tire of noobie industrialist players leaving the game when they find out about T2BPO and will eventual stem the blood flow that is pissing out of the eve economy and player base. It may take many years and eve might slip further down the ladder but eventual they will fix the problem, If they don't eve will die and it won't matter any more.


you said that every new player will quit as soon he will hear about t2 BPO`s. I think you heard about them and are apparently a new player, so why are you still playing the game?


I was looking forward to doing T2 industry and even though select t2 fields are open to noobs where demand surpasses T2BPO production numbers I choose not to engage in the activity. I don't see why I should be offered the scraps while CCP has selected a player to have first pickings and a monopoly over that item.

I do however produce T2 rigs and other items where CCP has not given a chosen player the ability to out perform noobs. Yet I still hope CCP introduces BPO's for rigs and for T3. As all of you lot are saying T2BPO's don't harm the game what so ever and are all round amazing so please CCP seed T3 BPO's and rig BPO's because as you can see they are great just ask idiots such as shar'ra matcevsovski . She'll explain why gifted BPO's are great for the game.

If you choose not to engage in the activity, then why do you care to comment on it? What gives you any weight to your opinion if you do not do it? That's like me commenting on faction warfare and how unfair it is, which I have chosen not to engage in.Roll

My theory is that you like the attention, good or bad. That's why after three months of no one posting in this thread you go and copy it on another forum and link it back here. I mean as you said earlier, if you posted it in the general forum you would have got a lot more posts. That's what matters right? Not your poorly informed, logic defficient arguments - its all about the attention and post count.


because we would like to but on fair terms, [we] the 99%
shar'ra matcevsovski
Doomheim
#1058 - 2012-09-05 13:40:05 UTC
Kara Books wrote:
Zifrian wrote:
Brewlar Kuvakei wrote:
shar'ra matcevsovski wrote:
Brewlar Kuvakei wrote:
CCP will tire of noobie industrialist players leaving the game when they find out about T2BPO and will eventual stem the blood flow that is pissing out of the eve economy and player base. It may take many years and eve might slip further down the ladder but eventual they will fix the problem, If they don't eve will die and it won't matter any more.


you said that every new player will quit as soon he will hear about t2 BPO`s. I think you heard about them and are apparently a new player, so why are you still playing the game?


I was looking forward to doing T2 industry and even though select t2 fields are open to noobs where demand surpasses T2BPO production numbers I choose not to engage in the activity. I don't see why I should be offered the scraps while CCP has selected a player to have first pickings and a monopoly over that item.

I do however produce T2 rigs and other items where CCP has not given a chosen player the ability to out perform noobs. Yet I still hope CCP introduces BPO's for rigs and for T3. As all of you lot are saying T2BPO's don't harm the game what so ever and are all round amazing so please CCP seed T3 BPO's and rig BPO's because as you can see they are great just ask idiots such as shar'ra matcevsovski . She'll explain why gifted BPO's are great for the game.

If you choose not to engage in the activity, then why do you care to comment on it? What gives you any weight to your opinion if you do not do it? That's like me commenting on faction warfare and how unfair it is, which I have chosen not to engage in.Roll

My theory is that you like the attention, good or bad. That's why after three months of no one posting in this thread you go and copy it on another forum and link it back here. I mean as you said earlier, if you posted it in the general forum you would have got a lot more posts. That's what matters right? Not your poorly informed, logic defficient arguments - its all about the attention and post count.


because we would like to but on fair terms, [we] the 99%


The conditions are as fair as they could be...but making isk with T2 BPO´s is kindoff Indy-engame gameplay so you cant complain as a newer or casual player that you cant get in there yet. I know you do anywayBig smile

shar'ra phone home

Pipa Porto
#1059 - 2012-09-05 14:19:19 UTC  |  Edited by: Pipa Porto
Kara Books wrote:
because we would like to but on fair terms, [we] the 99%


You can acquire a T2 BPO the same way most of the current owners acquired them.

You can also make more ISK with any given amount of Capital through Invention than through BPO ownership (meaning that, no matter how you acquired the BPO, selling it and switching to invention will result in a higher potential income).

What's unfair about a process whose only significant effect is reducing the cost of flying niche ships and fitting niche modules?

EvE: Everyone vs Everyone

-RubyPorto

Obsidiana
Atrament Inc.
#1060 - 2012-09-05 15:35:15 UTC
Leave them in. Just buff Invention and make T2 BPOs obsolete.