These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Science & Industry

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

T2BPO why they should be removed and how.

First post
Author
Pipa Porto
#921 - 2012-09-01 04:35:32 UTC
Traedar wrote:
You want a no risk, little effort, ISK-printing Mackinaw BPO? No.

That goes against everything Eve Online is about. In this way T2 BPOs are probably the worst feature in the game. Sorry, T2 BPO owners. With no other meaningful asset can you say "sorry this is mine and you can't have one like it, ever".


Exhumer BPOs come up for sale with some regularity.

If you want a risky (prices are volatile over the course of a month), medium effort (quite a lot of logistics and marketeering if you want to make any money), poor investment T2 BPO, you can buy it.

And they're all poor investments. The best ones make ~3b Isk a month and are worth over 150b Isk if you sell them. So to break even, you need to run it for over 50 months (that's not counting the opportunity cost of not using that manufacturing slot for invention). All the while, risking further enhancement to invention (reducing the relative value of a BPO) or price fluctuations (Hulk BPO owners probably aren't very happy right now).

EvE: Everyone vs Everyone

-RubyPorto

shar'ra matcevsovski
Doomheim
#922 - 2012-09-01 09:41:46 UTC  |  Edited by: shar'ra matcevsovski
Traedar wrote:

Hi. I wasn't going to comment in this thread but I see it's still going. I'm speaking as someone who "won" a T2 BPO years ago and made a nice profit on it.


infact, the discussion ended month ago but somebody necroed it. Congratz you won a T2 BPO, now that we know that, anything u say against them has twice the valueRoll

Traedar wrote:

There are no BPOs for Tech2 BS or Tech3 and the markets for them are fine.


funny you mentioned the T2 BS....There is prolly no market beeing more unstable than these. Before you say anything smart again, try to make a golem and sell it in jita without making a loss.... so bad.

Traedar wrote:

You want to shoot players? Go for it.
You want a BPO for a Tech 1 ship? Buy it.
You want to make special Tech 2 items? Invention.
You want to produce Technetium? Alchemy or claim a Tech moon.


You want to produce from a T2 BPO? buy one on forums and do so <---- whats wrong with that?

Traedar wrote:

That goes against everything Eve Online is about. In this way T2 BPOs are probably the worst feature in the game. Sorry, T2 BPO owners. With no other meaningful asset can you say "sorry this is mine and you can't have one like it, ever".


Oh unique Items are bad and stand (apparently) against anything eve stands for, you say? why is CCP giving new, absolute unique items out every year at the tournies, then?

shar'ra phone home

Traedar
InterStellar Trading Syndicate
#923 - 2012-09-01 20:47:16 UTC

shar'ra matcevsovski wrote:

funny you mentioned the T2 BS....There is prolly no market beeing more unstable than these. Before you say anything smart again, try to make a golem and sell it in jita without making a loss.... so bad.

If the Golem is not profitable then invent something else. If enough people do this then it will become profitable. Just like all other industry in the game. BTW you might want to move out of Jita. I would suggest Lonetrek or maybe the Rens area.

shar'ra matcevsovski wrote:

Traedar wrote:

You want to shoot players? Go for it.
You want a BPO for a Tech 1 ship? Buy it.
You want to make special Tech 2 items? Invention.
You want to produce Technetium? Alchemy or claim a Tech moon.


You want a no risk, little effort, ISK-printing Mackinaw BPO? buy one on forums and do so <---- whats wrong with that?

There's nothing wrong with buying or selling stuff on forums. What I'm saying is, getting something on the forum should be an option, not a necessity. With anything else in the game, I can get it in-game if I work enough towards it.

shar'ra matcevsovski wrote:

Oh unique Items are bad and stand (apparently) against anything eve stands for, you say? why is CCP giving new, absolute unique items out every year at the tournies, then?


They give out unique ships, right (Freki, Mimir, Adrestia, Utu, etc)? I'm not sure how much practical value they have other than bragging rights and being collectors' items. To get practical use out of them, you have to fly them and maybe lose them. So who knows if they are used. A T2 BPO, on the other hand, provides all its benefit while sitting in a station. Not to mention, if you want a ship you can just build or buy another ship to fly but if you want another T2 BPO there is no way to work toward one in the game.

I'd like to add, I'm not saying Tech 2 BPOs should be removed from the game. I'm saying they don't belong as they exist. Removing them is a different question. Before doing that you'd have to consider some problems, like all the players who paid a ton of ISK for them and who would get pissed off.

shar'ra matcevsovski
Doomheim
#924 - 2012-09-02 01:49:53 UTC
Traedar wrote:

shar'ra matcevsovski wrote:

funny you mentioned the T2 BS....There is prolly no market beeing more unstable than these. Before you say anything smart again, try to make a golem and sell it in jita without making a loss.... so bad.

If the Golem is not profitable then invent something else. If enough people do this then it will become profitable. Just like all other industry in the game. BTW you might want to move out of Jita. I would suggest Lonetrek or maybe the Rens area.


lol, so your saying that Marauders market is just fine, but recommend to invent something else because its not profitable?Roll
BTW other T2 Ships (Hulk, Huginn, Scimitar etc.) with BPO`s are still profitable even when selling in Jita...im not making anything of these things anyway, but thanks for the advice

Traedar wrote:

There's nothing wrong with buying or selling stuff on forums. What I'm saying is, getting something on the forum should be an option, not a necessity. With anything else in the game, I can get it in-game if I work enough towards it.

1. wrong again...T2 BPO`s can and are getting purchased via public contracts.
2. titans and supers cant be purchased via market/contracts either...so?

Traedar wrote:

They give out unique ships, right (Freki, Mimir, Adrestia, Utu, etc)? I'm not sure how much practical value they have other than bragging rights and being collectors' items.

Traedar wrote:

With no other meaningful asset can you say "sorry this is mine and you can't have one like it, ever".


what now, the asset has to be profitable to apply to this?




shar'ra phone home

Matarella
Incognito Mode
Brotherhood of Spacers
#925 - 2012-09-02 13:03:27 UTC
oh this thread is back. hello there.
Traedar
InterStellar Trading Syndicate
#926 - 2012-09-02 17:08:26 UTC

shar'ra matcevsovski wrote:

lol, so your saying that Marauders market is just fine, but recommend to invent something else because its not profitable?Roll

Welcome to EvE. Adapt or die.

shar'ra matcevsovski wrote:

BTW other T2 Ships (Hulk, Huginn, Scimitar etc.) with BPO`s are still profitable even when selling in Jita...im not making anything of these things anyway, but thanks for the advice

Yeah that's why I would love to be able to produce one of these from BPO. No risk, little effort income.

shar'ra matcevsovski wrote:

Traedar wrote:

There's nothing wrong with buying or selling stuff on forums. What I'm saying is, getting something on the forum should be an option, not a necessity. With anything else in the game, I can get it in-game if I work enough towards it.

1. wrong again...T2 BPO`s can and are getting purchased via public contracts.
2. titans and supers cant be purchased via market/contracts either...so?


I think you're completely missing my point. I have no problem with trading stuff on market, forum, contracts, Chribba, etc.

My point is that with any item in the game I can work towards building or otherwise obtaining it without relying on getting it from someone who already has it (by hunting for the right officer spawn, by buying a BPO, by starting a factory job or putting up a POS, etc). For instance I can mine or make an alt and train him to help me mine. But I can never create a T2 BPO or create an alt to train him to make one.

Traedar wrote:

what now, the asset has to be profitable to apply to this?


Comparing unique ships from AT, with T2 BPOs is apples and oranges. If I want a unique ship AT reward I can choose to compete in the next Alliance Tournament and have the same chance to get one as anyone else. I don't have to rely on getting it from someone who already has one.

Matarella
Incognito Mode
Brotherhood of Spacers
#927 - 2012-09-02 18:17:08 UTC
no you dont get the chance to get one as anyone else. at every AT they give out a difrent prize. you wont see a state raven being given out again. just like you wont see a T2 BPO being given out again.

and having gotten a state raven at the AT back then is profitable. as people are willing to pay billions to get one.
Pipa Porto
#928 - 2012-09-02 18:23:36 UTC  |  Edited by: Pipa Porto
Traedar wrote:
shar'ra matcevsovski wrote:

BTW other T2 Ships (Hulk, Huginn, Scimitar etc.) with BPO`s are still profitable even when selling in Jita...im not making anything of these things anyway, but thanks for the advice

Yeah that's why I would love to be able to produce one of these from BPO. No risk, little effort income.


Just have to look back a couple pages to find the links to T2 BPO auctions. Including a Scimitar BPO, which sold for 525 Billion ISK. Assuming that you discount the cost of material inputs entirely, you make roughly 7.7 (call it 10) billion ISK per month, so you'd break even after 52 months, or 4 and a half years. Since moon goo you mine is not, in fact, free, your actual profit per month is something like 4 Billion ISK per month so you need to wait ~130 months to break even (that's almost 11 years, for those keeping score).

Now, you might say "well you got it free" or somesuch. Well, in that case, the smart thing to do is to sell the dang thing immediately because you can do much better things with 525 Billion ISK than sink it into something that, with a fair amount of effort to run efficiently, can earn you 4 Billion ISK a month.

And given the number of T2 BPOs that it is unprofitable to manufacture, and the possibility that, sometime in the next 11 years, CCP might do something to further change the balance between BPOs and Invention, owning a T2 BPO is a pretty risky venture. And again, it's a fair bit of effort if you actually want to make money off of it.

Quote:
I think you're completely missing my point. I have no problem with trading stuff on market, forum, contracts, Chribba, etc.

My point is that with any item in the game I can work towards building or otherwise obtaining it without relying on getting it from someone who already has it (by hunting for the right officer spawn, by buying a BPO, by starting a factory job or putting up a POS, etc). For instance I can mine or make an alt and train him to help me mine. But I can never create a T2 BPO or create an alt to train him to make one.


If you are a collector, and want them for their rarity, then making new ones available hurts their rarity.
If you are a producer, then you're goal isn't "use a T2 BPO," your goal is "Produce a T2 Item profitably." Invention works just fine for you.

Oh, and Faction Towers, previous AT prizes, special event prizes. The list goes on of items previously, but not currently able to be brought into existence.

EvE: Everyone vs Everyone

-RubyPorto

Red Teufel
Calamitous-Intent
#929 - 2012-09-02 20:44:50 UTC
eh anything the devs exploited for BoB back in the day should of been removed from game. but you know all those trillions of iskis and t2 bpos from that is still in game cause it would be unfair to remove them or so ccp says.
shar'ra matcevsovski
Doomheim
#930 - 2012-09-02 21:12:36 UTC
Red Teufel wrote:
eh anything the devs exploited for BoB back in the day should of been removed from game. .


IT has been reomved from the game... I think it were only 5ish BPO wich were kinda bad anyways (except the Sabre BPO ofc)
but all of it has been removed fro mthe game and 5-6 years later we could rly stop bring that **** up

shar'ra phone home

Katerwaul
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#931 - 2012-09-03 04:38:55 UTC
By the power and wisdom of the Amaaran empire (whose technology I borrow on occasion) I hereby banish this evil back across the abyss. I incant the names Guiding Hand Social Club, Titans4U, & Phaser Inc. -- may the tears flow back into the endless ether between the stars or curl around the corners of the bulging eyes of this topic's frozen corpse as its mouth curls to utter "but it's not fair" in revelry to the vast silent expanse, so that this too can become simply one page in the endless story that New Eden brings to bear upon the capsuleers and the rest of them may remain untainted until they a corp mate in the research division simply walk away from the corp with all of the corp's donated and fully researched BPOs in their pocket.
Working with everyone to improve New Eden -- Internet Spaceships Iz Serious Business.
Brewlar Kuvakei
Adeptio Gloriae
#932 - 2012-09-03 11:11:15 UTC  |  Edited by: Brewlar Kuvakei
Hello,

I posted in the morning when the world was begun
I posted from the Moons and the stars and the Suns
I came down from Heaven and I danced on the Earth
At Caldari Institute 5 moon 3 I had my birth:

I posted for the bitter vets and the Devs of CCP
But they would not post back and they wouldn't follow me
I posted for the noobs and for the good Kugu
They came with me and the thread went on:

Post, post, wherever you may be
I am the lord of the T2BPO whine thread, said he
And I lead you all, wherever you may be
And I lead you all in the thread, said he

I posted on a Friday when the world turned black
It's hard to find time to post with invention on your back
They buried my thread, they thought it was gone
But this is a thread that will never ever die and so the posts go on!

They cut me down and I leapt up high
I am the life that will never, never die
I'll whine with you if you'll whine with me
I am the Lord of the T2BPO whine thread.

End T2BPO it was unfair then it's unfair now and detrimental to the game.
Kara Books
Deal with IT.
#933 - 2012-09-03 11:11:20 UTC  |  Edited by: Kara Books
But, why remove them?

Seed them on the markets for extravagant amounts in lowsec Select-few tiny handful NPC stations and let a whole new wave of fighting begin.

Several birds with one stone right there.

Edited for some grammar and clarity of message.
Brewlar Kuvakei
Adeptio Gloriae
#934 - 2012-09-03 11:12:41 UTC
Kara Books wrote:
But, why remove them?

Seed them on the markets for extravagant amounts in lowsec Select NPC stations and let a whole new wave of fighting begin.



And you think CCP pets will be happy sharing their private monthly source of CCP welfare?
Kara Books
Deal with IT.
#935 - 2012-09-03 11:17:02 UTC
Brewlar Kuvakei wrote:
Kara Books wrote:
But, why remove them?

Seed them on the markets for extravagant amounts in lowsec Select NPC stations and let a whole new wave of fighting begin.



And you think CCP pets will be happy sharing their private monthly source of CCP welfare?


very good point, but I dont think this is where we want the game to head.
Pipa Porto
#936 - 2012-09-03 11:31:32 UTC
Oh look. He's back.

And still with no new arguments to patch the holes that've been ripped out of his original ones.

EvE: Everyone vs Everyone

-RubyPorto

Kara Books
Deal with IT.
#937 - 2012-09-03 11:33:58 UTC
Pipa Porto wrote:
Oh look. He's back.

And still with no new arguments to patch the holes that've been ripped out of his original ones.


I like your post, and the previous 2 posts you have up there as you read up
Pipa Porto
#938 - 2012-09-03 12:09:58 UTC
Kara Books wrote:
Pipa Porto wrote:
Oh look. He's back.

And still with no new arguments to patch the holes that've been ripped out of his original ones.


I like your post, and the previous 2 posts you have up there as you read up


I'm not sure what you're saying, but seeding new T2 BPOs will simply kill the market for invention, as described in detail earlier in the thread.

The idea to seed them in LS is novel on its face, but all you need to do is JF in, buy the BPO, then jump to a exit system where your Orca is ready. No fighting (except for the guys sitting on the undock to blap cyno ships) involved. So it's really no more risky than any LS logistics. Which means the proposal is the same as Brewlar's "T2 BPOs are unfair because they're expensive, so CCP should give me one seed them."

EvE: Everyone vs Everyone

-RubyPorto

Jorma Morkkis
State War Academy
Caldari State
#939 - 2012-09-03 12:52:55 UTC
Pipa Porto wrote:
I'm not sure what you're saying, but seeding new T2 BPOs will simply kill the market for invention


T2 BPO owners killed invention years ago.
Zifrian
The Frog Pond
Ribbit.
#940 - 2012-09-03 12:56:17 UTC
Jorma Morkkis wrote:
Pipa Porto wrote:
I'm not sure what you're saying, but seeding new T2 BPOs will simply kill the market for invention


T2 BPO owners killed invention years ago.

Funny because I pay for 3 plex + profit doing invention. Too bad you can't figure it out. Maybe all the tears in your eyes are giving you problems seeing?

Maximze your Industry Potential! - Download EVE Isk per Hour!

Import CCP's SDE - EVE SDE Database Builder