These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Intergalactic Summit

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

A Crusader is always Neat and Tidy

Author
Azdan Amith
Doomheim
#121 - 2012-08-23 01:26:33 UTC
Benjamin Eastwood wrote:
Azdan Amith wrote:
Henry Kaine wrote:

Do yourself a favor and buy a couple of stocks in a liquor company if you're going to keep the stuffy Amarr religious nut act up.


Who's acting?


I doubt Mr. Kaine is a man of much religion. So then that leaves you, and pretty much the rest of the Summit.


Right, that went completely over your head.

It's not an act, Mister Eastwood. Though I suspect you'll find some way to argue that it is.

~Archon Azdan Amith,  Order of Light's Retribution

Horak Thor
Angry Mustellid
#122 - 2012-08-23 02:50:25 UTC  |  Edited by: Horak Thor
Rodj Blake wrote:
Anabella Rella wrote:
[quote=Rodj Blake]
Where are the Scope reports detailing the lawlessness in Minmatar space?

How about here, here and here?

Those three stories are amongst the most recent half-dozen Minmatar items on the Scope feed.

I could complain about Minmatar ignorance at this point - but you'd probably want news stories to support that as well, despite its self-evident nature.

[quote]You, Blake, are a bigot and a poor propagandist defending that for which there is no defense. Either produce evidence of what you speak of or, stop with the lies.


I've done as you asked, despite the unwarranted insult.

Now, perhaps you'll return the favour and provide some evidence that people are leaving the Federation to settle in the Republic?


Funny what happens when an empire is ripped apart and it attempts to reform after a thousand years, you expect it to be smooth? i believe the deep seated damage you inflicted on my race is unknown even to you.

You look down upon us for a few riots? this republic is formed around a mixture of people born from different backgrounds, some are recently freed from slavery, others have been free for longer.

We havnt had thousands of years to stabilise the tribes, your holy "empire" saw to that.

There are also three tribes without elders, again we have you Amarr to thank for this, another glorious chapter in the long and rotten history of the Amarrian legacy.

.....

Horak Thor
Angry Mustellid
#123 - 2012-08-23 03:08:16 UTC
Azdan Amith wrote:
Anslo wrote:
Since when did anyone need credentials to say "slavery is wrong, you shouldn't decide a people's fate other than your own?" I love how eggers fall back on that bullshit excuse when a fact is stated. "Where's your data hmmm?" **** you, I don't need a 50-page thesis to support that slavery is morally reprehensible and that the Minmatar are deservedly pissed off. I just hope they stomp you people quickly.


I understand that you believe slavery is morally reprehensible, you've been quite vocal about it and I wasn't implying that you need credential to make that assertion as it's entirely opinion-based.

My assertion was saying that someone doesn't know what's good for someone or not is an authoritative statement that does require crediting. A doctor, for instance, can say what is and isn't good for someone; as can a psychiatrist, scientists and yes, even ministers and priests.


Wrong, they can ADVISE a person. a doctor can tell a person to take a certain medicine or they will die, that person can say no i wont take it. it is there choice.

You eliminate the option of personal choice from the equation, therefore abusing the basic human rights of us all.

.....

Makkal Hanaya
Revenent Defence Corperation
#124 - 2012-08-23 06:50:44 UTC  |  Edited by: Makkal Hanaya
If a doctor judges that the person is not in their right mind, or is a danger to themselves or others, there are laws that let that doctor override the stated wishes of that patient. A good example would be the mentally ill or someone who's attempted to commit suicide.

Even the Federation has some mandatory vaccination laws, though I believe there are religious exceptions. Alternatively, many State workers have non-negotiable medical exams and are expected to adhere to any medical treatment proscribed to them. If a company doctor says 'Inject this artificial retro-virus twice a day for the next month,' it's not a suggestion. Failure to comply can result in disciplinary measures.*

Which is all to say that the concept of 'bodily autonomy' varies greatly from culture to culture and calling it a basic human right ignores that it's obviously a cultural construct.


*If anyone from the Federation or State wants to jump in to add corrections/clarifications, please do so.

Render unto Khanid the things which are Khanid's; and unto God the things that are God's.

Azdan Amith
Doomheim
#125 - 2012-08-23 10:52:57 UTC
Horak Thor wrote:

Wrong, they can ADVISE a person. a doctor can tell a person to take a certain medicine or they will die, that person can say no i wont take it. it is there choice.

You eliminate the option of personal choice from the equation, therefore abusing the basic human rights of us all.


Last I checked, advising a person is telling them what's good for them and what's not. Whether or not they choose to follow it is another matter entirely.

As for the elimination of personal choice, that's not entirely accurate. You still possess the ability to choose to listen or rebel and, as with all choices, you face the consequences of either choice. It never ceases to amaze me how people claim it is a basic human right to be free and yet all of us are slaves to something.

~Archon Azdan Amith,  Order of Light's Retribution

Azdan Amith
Doomheim
#126 - 2012-08-23 11:01:11 UTC
Horak Thor wrote:

Funny what happens when an empire is ripped apart and it attempts to reform after a thousand years, you expect it to be smooth? i believe the deep seated damage you inflicted on my race is unknown even to you.

You look down upon us for a few riots? this republic is formed around a mixture of people born from different backgrounds, some are recently freed from slavery, others have been free for longer.

We havnt had thousands of years to stabilise the tribes, your holy "empire" saw to that.

There are also three tribes without elders, again we have you Amarr to thank for this, another glorious chapter in the long and rotten history of the Amarrian legacy.


I would humbly suggest that you start taking responsibility for your own failures. Blaming the Empire for the riots in your streets, the blatant violence against peaceful persons and the difficulties in securing centralized leadership will not help you grow and develop as a people, when you begin to take responsibility rather than defer the blame you will begin to overcome the obstacles facing you.

It doesn't take thousands of years to establish a centralized government and some measure of peace and unity between a people. It can take a few years no doubt, but certainly not thousands. You have those among your number suggesting that you do just that, focus on infrastructure and developing unity among yourselves but the majority of you seem more content to keep waging war and conflict, even you yourself seem more concerned with finding the next fight than actually assisting your people, this is based on your own words.

The Empire has no doubt had an effect on your people but it was your rebellion and now it's your Republic. Take pride in it and accept responsibility for its failures as readily as you accept credit for its successes.

~Archon Azdan Amith,  Order of Light's Retribution

Halete
Sebiestor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#127 - 2012-08-23 11:27:32 UTC
The Republic is consumed by monomania. It's warriors are bloodthirsty and numerous. They attack the Republic's foreign threat with zeal, turning their backs on the battles fought on the home-front. By ignoring the decadent facets of the Republic, these problems are only catalyzed.

Instead of attributing these failures to it's own actions, the one-path minded Republic blames the evil Imperials that it seeks to destroy, creating more racial pressure between it's warriors and the Amarrian populace. I wonder how long that this can continue before attaining critical mass.

It is a tragic state of affairs to watch my brothers and sisters consume themselves with violence and bring suffering and poverty upon their own kindred due to the mishandling of their resources.

I beseech you to reflect inwardly. We will not find peace in the fire. We will come for our own, but we must also give them a home to return to.

"To know the true path, but yet, to never follow it. That is possibly the gravest sin" - The Scriptures, Book of Missions 13:21

Rodj Blake
PIE Inc.
Khimi Harar
#128 - 2012-08-23 11:39:32 UTC  |  Edited by: Rodj Blake
Horak Thor wrote:


Funny what happens when an empire is ripped apart and it attempts to reform after a thousand years, you expect it to be smooth? i believe the deep seated damage you inflicted on my race is unknown even to you.


If you're having some minor surgery done and go a bit mental during the operation, resulting in you being seriously injured who is to blame - you or the surgeon?

Quote:

You look down upon us for a few riots? this republic is formed around a mixture of people born from different backgrounds, some are recently freed from slavery, others have been free for longer.


If the riots are being caused by difficulties in integrating emancipated slaves into your society, then there's a obvious solution to the problem.

Quote:
We havnt had thousands of years to stabilise the tribes, your holy "empire" saw to that.

Perhaps you shouldn't be aiming to have all slaves released. Imagine the instability caused by every single Minmatar slave turning up on your doorstep!

Quote:
There are also three tribes without elders, again we have you Amarr to thank for this, another glorious chapter in the long and rotten history of the Amarrian legacy.


The Empire was without an Emperor for a couple of years not so long ago. I don't recall seeing any riots as bad as we've witnessed in the Republic. If you Minmatars are bloodthirsty savages, perhaps it's an underlying feature of your psyche rather than anyone else's fault.

Dolce et decorum est pro Imperium mori

Ahanu Jolon
Republic University
Minmatar Republic
#129 - 2012-08-23 12:55:44 UTC
Rodj Blake wrote:
Horak Thor wrote:


Funny what happens when an empire is ripped apart and it attempts to reform after a thousand years, you expect it to be smooth? i believe the deep seated damage you inflicted on my race is unknown even to you.


If you're having some minor surgery done and go a bit mental during the operation, resulting in you being seriously injured who is to blame - you or the surgeon?

Quote:

You look down upon us for a few riots? this republic is formed around a mixture of people born from different backgrounds, some are recently freed from slavery, others have been free for longer.


If the riots are being caused by difficulties in integrating emancipated slaves into your society, then there's a obvious solution to the problem.

Quote:
We havnt had thousands of years to stabilise the tribes, your holy "empire" saw to that.

Perhaps you shouldn't be aiming to have all slaves released. Imagine the instability caused by every single Minmatar slave turning up on your doorstep!

Quote:
There are also three tribes without elders, again we have you Amarr to thank for this, another glorious chapter in the long and rotten history of the Amarrian legacy.


The Empire was without an Emperor for a couple of years not so long ago. I don't recall seeing any riots as bad as we've witnessed in the Republic. If you Minmatars are bloodthirsty savages, perhaps it's an underlying feature of your psyche rather than anyone else's fault.


Everyone gets angry over the slave issue me being one of them but you honestly can't expect us a nation and as people to not reason out that the Amarr helped put us right where we are.

For better or worse everything that happens in the Republic is a direct result of our war. Trying to wash your hands of it comes across as not only hypocritical but honestly quite sad.
Halete
Sebiestor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#130 - 2012-08-23 13:05:39 UTC
Ahanu Jolon wrote:

Everyone gets angry over the slave issue me being one of them but you honestly can't expect us a nation and as people to not reason out that the Amarr helped put us right where we are.

For better or worse everything that happens in the Republic is a direct result of our war. Trying to wash your hands of it comes across as not only hypocritical but honestly quite sad.


Trying to argue that the Amarr Empire is not responsible for our anger is sad.

Trying to argue that the ease with which the Republic overlooks the basic requirements of it's own population is the fault of the Empire is tragic.

"To know the true path, but yet, to never follow it. That is possibly the gravest sin" - The Scriptures, Book of Missions 13:21

Rodj Blake
PIE Inc.
Khimi Harar
#131 - 2012-08-23 13:59:20 UTC
Ahanu Jolon wrote:

Everyone gets angry over the slave issue me being one of them but you honestly can't expect us a nation and as people to not reason out that the Amarr helped put us right where we are.

For better or worse everything that happens in the Republic is a direct result of our war. Trying to wash your hands of it comes across as not only hypocritical but honestly quite sad.


The Amarr did not help put you right where you are. The Federation helped put you right where you are. The Jovians helped put you right where you are. But we didn't. If we had our way, we would still be looking after all of you.

But if the Republic is in a bad way, then ultimately it's because the people running it are not suited to the task. It really is that simple.

Dolce et decorum est pro Imperium mori

Anslo
Scope Works
#132 - 2012-08-23 14:04:30 UTC
Rodj Blake wrote:
Ahanu Jolon wrote:

Everyone gets angry over the slave issue me being one of them but you honestly can't expect us a nation and as people to not reason out that the Amarr helped put us right where we are.

For better or worse everything that happens in the Republic is a direct result of our war. Trying to wash your hands of it comes across as not only hypocritical but honestly quite sad.


The Amarr did not help put you right where you are. The Federation helped put you right where you are. The Jovians helped put you right where you are. But we didn't. If we had our way, we would still be looking after all of you.

But if the Republic is in a bad way, then ultimately it's because the people running it are not suited to the task. It really is that simple.


So...you're saying that the years of slavery and war to "reclaim your property" had 0 baring on their current state?...Really?

Rodj.

That's ******* stupid.

[center]-_For the Proveldtariat_/-[/center]

Rodj Blake
PIE Inc.
Khimi Harar
#133 - 2012-08-23 14:14:41 UTC  |  Edited by: Rodj Blake
Anslo wrote:
Rodj Blake wrote:
Ahanu Jolon wrote:

Everyone gets angry over the slave issue me being one of them but you honestly can't expect us a nation and as people to not reason out that the Amarr helped put us right where we are.

For better or worse everything that happens in the Republic is a direct result of our war. Trying to wash your hands of it comes across as not only hypocritical but honestly quite sad.


The Amarr did not help put you right where you are. The Federation helped put you right where you are. The Jovians helped put you right where you are. But we didn't. If we had our way, we would still be looking after all of you.

But if the Republic is in a bad way, then ultimately it's because the people running it are not suited to the task. It really is that simple.


So...you're saying that the years of slavery and war to "reclaim your property" had 0 baring on their current state?...Really?

Rodj.

That's ******* stupid.


Look at it this way...

If the Minmatar hadn't rebelled, they would be well on the way to full enlightenment by now.

Many of them would be enjoying a similar quality of life to the numerous satisifed Ni-Kunni living in the Empire.

But no. They weren't patient. Like a small child they wanted their pudding before they'd eaten their meat. They wanted their freedom before they were ready for it. And now they are paying the price.

Dolce et decorum est pro Imperium mori

Anslo
Scope Works
#134 - 2012-08-23 14:25:03 UTC  |  Edited by: Anslo
Rodj Blake wrote:
If the Minmatar hadn't rebelled, they would be well on the way to full enlightenment by now.

They wouldn't have rebelled if you didn't enslave them and instead tried to ally with them and help them as equals, not animals. And don't say that you did it for their own good and they were treated well. If they were treated anything that could be considered well, the rebellion wouldn't have happened.

Rodj Blake wrote:
Many of them would be enjoying a similar quality of life to the numerous satisifed Ni-Kunni living in the Empire.

Not everyone likes subjugation, let alone invading their home planet and bombarding it from gods damn ORBIT.

Rodj Blake wrote:
But no. They weren't patient. Like a small child they wanted their pudding before they'd eaten their meat. They wanted their freedom before they were ready for it. And now they are paying the price.


They were doing fine, if not BETTER before you showed up. Then you came. You banned their practices, stomped on their culture, and killed their most important figures as a means of subjugation, subversion, fear mongering, and control. If you wanted to act "the parent" as you said, you wouldn't have beat your "child," you'd have helped them, allied with them, provided them good technology and social uplifting in a GOOD way, not a violent one. I'm sure if you had done that, and been tolerant of their practices, your two people may have hit it off well and have been a rather powerful force in the Cluster. But no, you attacked.

You still sound ******* stupid. They weren't kids. They were a flourishing race of people. Sure they didn't advance as others, but who cares? They were doing just fine in their own damn time.

[center]-_For the Proveldtariat_/-[/center]

Rodj Blake
PIE Inc.
Khimi Harar
#135 - 2012-08-23 14:30:22 UTC
Anslo wrote:
Rodj Blake wrote:
If the Minmatar hadn't rebelled, they would be well on the way to full enlightenment by now.

They wouldn't have rebelled if you didn't enslave them and instead tried to ally with them and help them as equals, not animals. And don't say that you did it for their own good and they were treated well. If they were treated anything that could be considered well, the rebellion wouldn't have happened.

Rodj Blake wrote:
Many of them would be enjoying a similar quality of life to the numerous satisifed Ni-Kunni living in the Empire.

Not everyone likes subjugation, let alone invading their home planet and bombarding it from gods damn ORBIT.


I'm glad to hear that you don't like the concept of orbital bombardment. I hear that it's more of a Federation tactic though, so perhaps you should complain to your own government?


Dolce et decorum est pro Imperium mori

Halete
Sebiestor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#136 - 2012-08-23 14:35:17 UTC
Rodj Blake wrote:

I'm glad to hear that you don't like the concept of orbital bombardment. I hear that it's more of a Federation tactic though, so perhaps you should complain to your own government?



But you're smart enough to know it's not 'his Government' who are responsible for that. Yet you still bait with such trite, borderline inflammatory comments.

I'm just going to come out and say it - although by now I'm sure you're used to hearing it.

You're an insufferable **** and your behavior reflects badly on all of your kind, not to mention makes it damned difficult for people like myself who would like to see the Minmatar and the Amarr come to a peaceful resolution.

"To know the true path, but yet, to never follow it. That is possibly the gravest sin" - The Scriptures, Book of Missions 13:21

Anslo
Scope Works
#137 - 2012-08-23 14:35:43 UTC  |  Edited by: Anslo
Rodj Blake wrote:
Anslo wrote:
Rodj Blake wrote:
If the Minmatar hadn't rebelled, they would be well on the way to full enlightenment by now.

They wouldn't have rebelled if you didn't enslave them and instead tried to ally with them and help them as equals, not animals. And don't say that you did it for their own good and they were treated well. If they were treated anything that could be considered well, the rebellion wouldn't have happened.

Rodj Blake wrote:
Many of them would be enjoying a similar quality of life to the numerous satisifed Ni-Kunni living in the Empire.

Not everyone likes subjugation, let alone invading their home planet and bombarding it from gods damn ORBIT.


I'm glad to hear that you don't like the concept of orbital bombardment. I hear that it's more of a Federation tactic though, so perhaps you should complain to your own government?




Don't try to turn this around *******. Not all Gal citizens agreed with what we did with the Caldari. If they didn't want to deal with us, personally, I thought we should have left those guys alone. But then Nouvelle Rouvenior happened, shots taken, people died.

It was all for a stupid, STUPID reason.

So yeah, my government did some stupid crap, but don't try to change the topic here from calling your reasoning out as bullshit.

[center]-_For the Proveldtariat_/-[/center]

Anabella Rella
Gradient
Electus Matari
#138 - 2012-08-23 15:48:58 UTC
Rodj Blake wrote:


How about here, here and here?

Those three stories are amongst the most recent half-dozen Minmatar items on the Scope feed.



You point out 3 scattered and unrelated incidents (one of which was precipitated by Amarrian zealots placing someone deliberately in harms' way, by the way, and then feigning surprise when the inevitable happened) to prove your entire argument? I could point out 3 instances where sadistic holders have brutalized their slaves and extend that to your entire race as well. We both know that would be intellectually dishonest, however.

When the world is running down, you make the best of what's still around.

Rodj Blake
PIE Inc.
Khimi Harar
#139 - 2012-08-23 17:25:19 UTC  |  Edited by: Rodj Blake
Anabella Rella wrote:
Rodj Blake wrote:


How about here, here and here?

Those three stories are amongst the most recent half-dozen Minmatar items on the Scope feed.



You point out 3 scattered and unrelated incidents (one of which was precipitated by Amarrian zealots placing someone deliberately in harms' way, by the way, and then feigning surprise when the inevitable happened) to prove your entire argument? I could point out 3 instances where sadistic holders have brutalized their slaves and extend that to your entire race as well. We both know that would be intellectually dishonest, however.



You asked for evidence, I provided it.

You have made claims, we're yet to see any evidence to back them up.

But anyway, you present yourself as an advocate of freedom. Surely you don't object to people practising their religion? Or does your belief in freedom only extend as far as people doing what you want them to do?

Dolce et decorum est pro Imperium mori

Anslo
Scope Works
#140 - 2012-08-23 17:27:45 UTC
Rodj Blake wrote:
Anabella Rella wrote:
Rodj Blake wrote:


How about here, here and here?

Those three stories are amongst the most recent half-dozen Minmatar items on the Scope feed.



You point out 3 scattered and unrelated incidents (one of which was precipitated by Amarrian zealots placing someone deliberately in harms' way, by the way, and then feigning surprise when the inevitable happened) to prove your entire argument? I could point out 3 instances where sadistic holders have brutalized their slaves and extend that to your entire race as well. We both know that would be intellectually dishonest, however.



You asked for evidence, I provided it.

You have made claims, we're yet to see any evidence to back them up.

But anyway, you present yourself as an advocate of freedom. Surely you don't object to people practising their religion? Or does your belief in freedom only extend as far as people doing what you want them to do?


I'm sure advocacy doesn't include forcing your religion on other people, as I mentioned before and that you so conveniently didn't answer. Also evidence? Do you REMEMBER the Days of Darkness from their history? Look who's talking about lack fo evidence. Now you sound ******* stupid AND like a ******* hypocrite.

[center]-_For the Proveldtariat_/-[/center]