These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Player Features and Ideas Discussion

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

New Contract Feature - LOANING!

Author
Ninja Nuke
The Northerners
Pandemic Horde
#1 - 2012-08-16 17:32:49 UTC  |  Edited by: Ninja Nuke
Anyone else want a loan feature so we can borrow from each other?
Only catch would be that there is collateral and hourly/daily payments.
Sigras
Conglomo
#2 - 2012-08-16 18:13:49 UTC
They had loan contracts, nobody used them because the only loan a thinking person would give out would have collateral >= the amount loaned out which means the person could have just sold the item for cash and bought it back again later. (or the reverse in the case that they're borrowing the item)

The only place this might be applicable is out in 0.0 where there is not a ready market for everything, but even so you could have a trader haul it in for you, or just use a verbal agreement as youre in the same alliance and should just be able to talk to the person.
Ninja Nuke
The Northerners
Pandemic Horde
#3 - 2012-08-16 21:10:02 UTC
I think it might be used a bit more than it was before. I say just put them back in there and whoever wants to use it can use it. To be honest, people may need to use a freighter to move some stuff, use a hulk to mine with corpies, use an Orca to help mining corpies, etc. Maybe someone wants to rat, and all they have is a Drake. They can afford a well fit Tengu (with faction mods n stuff), but they don't feel like going through the trouble of selling the faction mods and whatnot. There are ALWAYS times when people want to just use a ship for a few days/hours and no more.
Jett0
Ministry of War
Amarr Empire
#4 - 2012-08-17 00:06:29 UTC  |  Edited by: Jett0
I like this idea. It's something I would definitately use. Maybe like this:

Lender puts items in a contract and sets price-per-day.
Lender sets loan duration, and also the "late fee" price-per-day.
*Edit: No collateral can be set. If items are destroyed, you better find new ones. Hopefully you didn't borrow faction stuff.

Borrower accepts contract. As far as the game is concerned, those items now belong to the borrower.
Borrower's wallet takes a hit every 24 hours until they return an identical item set.

If borrower runs out of money, their wallet gets flagged. All incoming deposits are auto-transferred to lender until all fees are paid and items are returned.

I think this system would create a new profession, and it's semi-exploitable, to fit in with the sandbox.

Occasionally plays sober

Eperor
Machiavellian Empire
Test Alliance Please Ignore
#5 - 2012-08-17 07:16:16 UTC
i wuld like this feature to lone out ships for pvp in 0.0 to members hoo needs them.

But there is one more ting scaming, if you run like in top presented eny loners wil get scamed, by borrowing items and not giving back just seling them and leave char that char for ever.

Afcors its posible to implement in game that borrowed items not posibul to sell any way. not posible repage, reprocess. if so that culd work.
Michael Loney
Skullspace Industries
#6 - 2012-08-17 13:53:23 UTC

  1. Create contract for a faction fit ship
  2. Set price at 80% the market cost to buy said ship and modules
  3. Get second character to gank the borrower and salvage what's left
  4. Get repaid for loan with new ship / isk
  5. ???
  6. Profit !


Doing the above would be fast and easy to scan. I like the Idea of loans but until there is a way to have your wallet garnished --or-- make the loan account wide ( Char A cant pay loan so Char B picks up the tab ) this can be gamed.
Ninja Nuke
The Northerners
Pandemic Horde
#7 - 2012-08-17 18:37:13 UTC  |  Edited by: Ninja Nuke
A collateral would make the system fairly hard to find loopholes in. I honestly thing collateral would be the best thing. I thought about CCP flagging accounts (and debt, etc), but then you'd have useless alts getting the contract and putting themselves in debt, while their main gets rich and doesn't need to worry about paying.

This system is fairly simple, kinda like the courier system. Lots of people would want to borrow a freighter for a day for maybe 20m ISK, with the collateral set around 800m ISK. As long as the freighter stays alive, the person just completed their own courier by borrowing a freighter, and may have even saved himself a bit of money.

If this feature is released in the future, my hopes are that loan prices will be low. If they are low, then it will monopolize the courier market, making moving stuff around much easier and available to everyone with 30 days worth the skills (freighter).

Also, if someone wants loyalty points, and they want full benefits of a fully faction fit Tengu, (as long as they have 2B ISK) they can borrow one. If they had bought one and bought some faction mods with it, it would be difficult to sell them off.

This would also be a good benefit for corps to reduce griefing slightly. This would allow a CEO to loan a Hulk for 0 ISK/day but also set a collateral to 150m+. This will allow CEOs to feel that there's less risk letting someone borrow a Hulk (maybe because the nearst one on the market is 10 jumps away, etc). This will especially benefit corporation who needs to let a member borrow an Orca for support.

SCAMMING ISSUE: Scaming won't be an issue. I'd expect the item to be "character bound," as it would be completely pointless to let them trade items. Also, if the items are to be tradeable, then I can imagine the collateral will kick in - meaning the owner of the item will be paid, and the person borrowing the item will be charged the collateral.

What I expect from this is the rental time will be determined (by the person borrowing) before the item contract is accepted. After it is accepted, the person borrowing the item will have the option to extend it or reduce it. The owner will have the right to some how request it back if he needs it (if you're loaning out an item, you shouldn't need it at all - it should be as if you are selling it and will never see it again). If the buyer doesn't return the item within 72 hours of the request/promised date, then the owner has the right to charge collateral. The person borrowing the item will have to return the item in the same station it was borrowed from.
Gizznitt Malikite
Agony Unleashed
Agony Empire
#8 - 2012-08-17 18:47:34 UTC

1.) Automatic repayments would have to stop when a player's wallet hits zero. If you allow a player's wallet to go below zero with this mechanic you'll create a "create money from nothing" loophole that WILL be exploited on alts...

2.) Requiring collateral on a loan might secure the loan... but most people won't bother with the loan if they have to put up collateral....

So, what's the point of this loan type? Either you already trust a person enough to give out the loan (and perhaps do an item exchange contract for any collateral), or you don't, in which case this loan type doesn't solve or do anything....

Ninja Nuke
The Northerners
Pandemic Horde
#9 - 2012-08-17 18:50:21 UTC  |  Edited by: Ninja Nuke
Gizznitt Malikite wrote:

1.) Automatic repayments would have to stop when a player's wallet hits zero. If you allow a player's wallet to go below zero with this mechanic you'll create a "create money from nothing" loophole that WILL be exploited on alts...

2.) Requiring collateral on a loan might secure the loan... but most people won't bother with the loan if they have to put up collateral....

So, what's the point of this loan type? Either you already trust a person enough to give out the loan (and perhaps do an item exchange contract for any collateral), or you don't, in which case this loan type doesn't solve or do anything....


Collateral is held as soon as the item is rented, just as a courier's collateral is held as soon as you accept one. If their wallet hits 0, then they will not receive their collateral back, but they can keep the ship. That is why I'd suggest making the collateral slightly more than the ship is worth, to make them want to return it and save some money.

Also, this isn't a courier. In a courier, items go to one designated place by a designated time, and there's only so many routes that you'd be willing to take. It is completely different. You can take the ship where ever you'd like. It's not like you'd get suicide ganked just because you took an item loan.

Most people would understand the collateral is just for security, and that it should not influence their decision of accepting the contract or declining it. The key is checking the ship's modules before you rent it, and make sure that the collateral is reasonable. As I said before, this will most likely be used mostly for corporate loaning.
MushroomMushroom
State War Academy
Caldari State
#10 - 2012-08-17 20:17:01 UTC
You can already 'rent' almost anything if you have the isk for collateral and are willing to travel to Jita. Your rental fee is the price difference between the lowest sell order and the highest buy order + sales tax.

Using that logic, if I want to borrow a Charon, I can get a loaner Charon for 73m-123m isk, can hold onto it for as long as I want, then sell it. If we used the ~2% price for item exchange contracts as a baseline, someone loaning out the same Charon would pay 30.7m in fees for each loan contract, so it would cost me 30m + what ever the lender wanted to make as profit to borrow one. Now the reason there is such a large spread on charons is that many people expect them to decline in price, in the case of a loan, this risk is born by the lender, so they will want to take on a decent premium to cover that exposure, particularly considering that if the price goes up, the borrower will just keep the ship, pay out the collateral and make a profit. The lender wont see any of the gain, and will need to purchase a new ship at the higher price. They could raise the colleteral to compensate, but that will raise the listing fees, and make it less attractive to the borrower.

Ok, maybe it would work for very shiny ships, and in remote areas with limited market access, but loan contracts wont work for most of eve, and so would be a wasted effort.
Ninja Nuke
The Northerners
Pandemic Horde
#11 - 2012-08-17 21:03:42 UTC  |  Edited by: Ninja Nuke
MushroomMushroom wrote:
You can already 'rent' almost anything if you have the isk for collateral and are willing to travel to Jita. Your rental fee is the price difference between the lowest sell order and the highest buy order + sales tax.

Using that logic, if I want to borrow a Charon, I can get a loaner Charon for 73m-123m isk, can hold onto it for as long as I want, then sell it. If we used the ~2% price for item exchange contracts as a baseline, someone loaning out the same Charon would pay 30.7m in fees for each loan contract, so it would cost me 30m + what ever the lender wanted to make as profit to borrow one. Now the reason there is such a large spread on charons is that many people expect them to decline in price, in the case of a loan, this risk is born by the lender, so they will want to take on a decent premium to cover that exposure, particularly considering that if the price goes up, the borrower will just keep the ship, pay out the collateral and make a profit. The lender wont see any of the gain, and will need to purchase a new ship at the higher price. They could raise the colleteral to compensate, but that will raise the listing fees, and make it less attractive to the borrower.

Ok, maybe it would work for very shiny ships, and in remote areas with limited market access, but loan contracts wont work for most of eve, and so would be a wasted effort.


Again, I'll go back to going to referring to corporate interests. I can imagine after corps get the hang of this, they'll use it as an anti-grief tool.

Also, where I live, a contract/sell order on a freighter is a miracle. Again, that would go back to corporate interests. People in corps would want to loan out carriers/freighters without worrying about them getting stolen.

I am not really "enthusiastic" about the idea. I just think it'd be a cool feature. If one person benefits from it, then it was a good idea. If they add this feature, there will be quite a few people along with myself who use it.

Real quick, I will also bring back the faction part. People like me might want to borrow a full fit faction Tengu for a couple of hours to do some LP farming. A couple of hours - no more. To buy a Tengu off the market fit mostly with faction mods is something lots of people will not do... not because of price, but because of time. It takes a while to sell high end mods sometimes. Someone who is visiting high sec for a day may want to do missions for a few hours... he either uses his Drake (10m ticks), or he uses a rented Tengu (15m ticks).

Say the Tengu costs 10m/hr. At that rate, you are saving money (as long as you don't lose it), and you are still making small profit, along with TONS more LP because of the 50% bonus to speed you'd get with a Tengu (Tengu > Drake). And by not buying a Tengu on the market then hunting down some faction mods (and worrying about selling them), you saved a lot of time and money.

This feature is pretty nice to have in my opinion. I'd use it.
Alara IonStorm
#12 - 2012-08-17 21:17:00 UTC  |  Edited by: Alara IonStorm
I just trust people. If they break my trust I blacklist them. Adding a nanny mechanic that removes most of the need for trust seems silly.

More risk and more fun to trust people.
Ninja Nuke
The Northerners
Pandemic Horde
#13 - 2012-08-20 22:26:40 UTC
Alara IonStorm wrote:
I just trust people. If they break my trust I blacklist them. Adding a nanny mechanic that removes most of the need for trust seems silly.

More risk and more fun to trust people.

If it has a collateral, this can be a job for some people. Just like car rental... they have your credit card info for collateral :p.
Emperor Salazar
Remote Soviet Industries
Insidious Empire
#14 - 2012-08-20 22:28:41 UTC
Sandbox says no.
Herping yourDerp
Tribal Liberation Force
Minmatar Republic
#15 - 2012-08-20 23:10:37 UTC
won't work
borrow 1 bil isk
send isk to main
delete character you borrowed with

rinse and repeat
Ninja Nuke
The Northerners
Pandemic Horde
#16 - 2012-08-22 05:34:04 UTC  |  Edited by: Ninja Nuke
Herping yourDerp wrote:
won't work
borrow 1 bil isk
send isk to main
delete character you borrowed with

rinse and repeat


Who says anything about borrowing ISK? LOL!
And it would still work as a collateral, meaning that you need the ISK in your wallet before you accept it. There is no loophole with a collateral system. When you "Borrow 1 bil ISK," you should be paying a collateral of 1 bil (If the person loaning is smart, that is :))

It would be pointless to put ISK in this kind of system.
Tenris Anis
Schattenengel Clan
#17 - 2012-08-22 06:41:22 UTC
Ninja Nuke wrote:
Anyone else want a loan feature so we can borrow from each other?
Only catch would be that there is collateral and hourly/daily payments.


That is not a new feature, it is an old one that got removed.

Remove insurance.

Bad Messenger
Rehabilitation Clinic
#18 - 2012-08-22 07:18:38 UTC
Why you want to loan isk if you have assets for collateral?