These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Market Discussions

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
123Next page
 

My assessment of scamming and trolling in the game.

Author
Space Therapist
Better Days Ahead
#1 - 2012-07-12 03:06:39 UTC
After giving it a little bit of thought. I thought I would state my views on some sticky areas of this game that I thought deserve some looking at.

I realize by taking on the issue of trolling will invite many of you to take a personal interest in doing your best work for the sake of this peculiar activity.

First, on the issue of scamming.

Recently i attempted to propose a scamming victim's relief fund of some sort in Market Place (in the forums). It was of course shot down.

But comments made in support of the activity as well as a bit of trolling left me trying to determine why there are so many individuals that take on selfish or troll-type positions. I do believe the balance of support is in favor of these types and well I would like to propose looking at this part of the game dynamic from a different perspective.

(continued)

See my bio for rates and services.

Pipa Porto
#2 - 2012-07-12 03:13:16 UTC
There are scammers, pirates, can-flippers, and all sorts of meanie nasty players in EvE because CCP expressly endorses that kind of play because it fits their vision for the game.

EvE: Everyone vs Everyone

-RubyPorto

Space Therapist
Better Days Ahead
#3 - 2012-07-12 03:24:00 UTC
Oh. my disclaimer on spelling and grammar(for those troll types and or people with real concerns their comprehension abilities)... I do my best..if u can understand the point I am making. I am satisfied...if u would like to point out corrections feel free to do so... if this is something you like to do. It is free advertisement for the information I am writing this thread for discussion on a important game dynamic...more reads the better.

Okay. Think of the story i am about to tell as a model. It is not specifically intended to categorize people or state who is better than who...it just more to demonstrate dynamics. The selection of using a 5th and 4th grade classroom is more for the purposes of simplification not intended to suggest :you are all a bunch of 4th and 5th graders"...please take that into consideration.

In this 5th grade classroom one day the teacher does not show up. And it turns out that they had to put the 5th graders in with the 4th graders and today they had to finish the task of making a perfect letter "h".

there's a 5th grader that stands up at the chalk board...he can draw the most perfect "h". He gloats to his buddies...hey look at my "h" it's perfect...no one can make em that good! His best buddy turns to him and says hey look at the fourth graders "h"s they are so bad!!! And they both start laughing at the 4th graders abilities.

{continued..might be long)

See my bio for rates and services.

Space Therapist
Better Days Ahead
#4 - 2012-07-12 03:37:22 UTC  |  Edited by: Space Therapist
So one 5th grader also see's the 4th graders struggling so he goes into their midst and starts helping out the struggling fourth graders. he does pretty well demonstrating to most of the fourth graders...but he gets to one 4th grader and he doesn't know what to do..he explains that they are backwards and the "h" still comes out backwards...the 5th grader moves on to another 4th grader and he can't finish making the letter...it kind of ends like an "r".......

in the mean time the 5th grader who can draw the perfect "h" with his buddy are laughing hysterically watching this all unfold.

the 5th grader demonstrates again to the boy who makes it look like an "r" and it's still not working. so he' starts to talk to the boy and has a conversation with him...and after a bit of talk about the process the struggling boy begins to understand and after a few tries...he can now draw a pretty good "h".

at the board the boy who can make a perfect "h" is swelling with a false sense of superiority (I will explain why it is a "false" sense at some point). His buddy is beginning to take action on these 4th graders...their "h"s are getting better. So he walks up the boy who make's a backward "h" and he holds it up shows the whole class and ridicules the "h" and the boy starts bawling.

Another 5th grader says..hey..stop..that's not right..he'll get it in time let him practice on his own..it's the best way...he will learn the hard way.

(continued)

See my bio for rates and services.

Space Therapist
Better Days Ahead
#5 - 2012-07-12 03:51:05 UTC  |  Edited by: Space Therapist
The next day the teacher shows up. And the 5th grader that tried to help the 4th graders explains...there was this one boy...his "h" kept coming out backwards. she takes note of it and explains..of he can't help it is dyslexia. The boy is like "Oh Okay."

He then wants to explain to the two who were making fun of him that the poor boy has something called dyslexia..he can't help it. So he does...Then the two boys amused by this sort of thing take action...they are off laughing hysterically about dyslexia and the one who likes to take action on the seemingly weaker 4th graders....makes time to ridicule him even more...trying for more tears. His buddy is still laughing about it...he absolutely loves when people demonstrate their inferiority. But what's interesting is that the boy that can make the perfect "h"...a few years ago he couldn't tie his shoe laces....and his mother had to help him. His father laughed at him hysterically much like he now does when he see's such things.

Now the boy who likes...to make boys cry a lot for laughs with his friend...he had some difficult problems in his earlier years with abuse. And he cried so much that it made him almost impervious to emotional pain...but for some reason...now he enjoys seeing other people's emotional pain through tears etc..

(continued)

See my bio for rates and services.

Pipa Porto
#6 - 2012-07-12 03:59:03 UTC
Wait, so now falling for a scam because you're greedy is a mental disorder?

EvE: Everyone vs Everyone

-RubyPorto

Space Therapist
Better Days Ahead
#7 - 2012-07-12 04:14:24 UTC
Now years pass.... and the boy who liked to gloat with false superiority becomes terminally ill with cancer. And it turns out the boy who was making his "h"s like "r" ends up being a doctor with the cure to cancer. He by the luck of someone figuring it out...had a different learning style than other people and is able to overcome his hurdles and actually help the boy that laughed at him repeatedly in grade school.

Now..I'll stop here. (trolling will ensue I know)

I had more to tell about that story...but my point is.

My experience in Market Place forums made me think...that there are a lot of players that are at the chalk board..laughing and creating tears and equating inexperience with ignorance.

The story i told is a model...and yes the abundance of support is heavily weighted in the whole idea that being "cruel" and "harsh" is what eve is i suppose.

But it does not mean that some hope can exist for those that an unlike the mob.



See my bio for rates and services.

Space Therapist
Better Days Ahead
#8 - 2012-07-12 04:19:44 UTC
Pipa Porto wrote:
Wait, so now falling for a scam because you're greedy is a mental disorder?


no read the whole thread...I am reacting to peoples equating "inexperience with ignorance" and the reactive process of ridiculing others in order to reinforce a superiority complex.

If it's unclear I can live with that. i did my best.

See my bio for rates and services.

Space Therapist
Better Days Ahead
#9 - 2012-07-12 04:21:10 UTC
Space Therapist wrote:
Now years pass.... and the boy who liked to gloat with false superiority becomes terminally ill with cancer. And it turns out the boy who was making his "h"s like "r" ends up being a doctor with the cure to cancer. He by the luck of someone figuring it out...had a different learning style than other people and is able to overcome his hurdles and actually help the boy that laughed at him repeatedly in grade school.

Now..I'll stop here. (trolling will ensue I know)

I had more to tell about that story...but my point is.

My experience in Market Place forums made me think...that there are a lot of players that are at the chalk board..laughing and creating tears and equating inexperience with ignorance.

The story i told is a model...and yes the abundance of support is heavily weighted in the whole idea that being "cruel" and "harsh" is what eve is i suppose.

But it does not mean that some hope can exist for those that are unlike the mob.



See my bio for rates and services.

Pipa Porto
#10 - 2012-07-12 04:25:54 UTC
Space Therapist wrote:
Pipa Porto wrote:
Wait, so now falling for a scam because you're greedy is a mental disorder?


no read the whole thread...I am reacting to peoples equating "inexperience with ignorance" and the reactive process of ridiculing others in order to reinforce a superiority complex.

If it's unclear I can live with that. i did my best.



Space Therapist wrote:
He then wants to explain to the two who were making fun of him that the poor boy has something called dyslexia..he can't help it.


That doesn't sound like you're talking about either inexperience OR ignorance. Last I checked, dyslexia was a mental disorder.


By the way, ignorance is one of the hallmarks of inexperience. If you pay attention around here, legitimately new players with questions who aren't being total jerkoffs tend to be treated pretty well. Old players who should know better, because they've passed the point where inexperience is a legitimate excuse tend to be treated less well (especially if they're confused about a concept like HS-isn't-safe. And of course, the jerkoff OP brigade is roundly beaten, regardless of experience level because, well, they're jerkoffs and deserve it.

EvE: Everyone vs Everyone

-RubyPorto

Space Therapist
Better Days Ahead
#11 - 2012-07-12 04:31:55 UTC  |  Edited by: Space Therapist
dyslexia is a reading impairment.

See my bio for rates and services.

Abditus Cularius
Clancularius Industries
#12 - 2012-07-12 04:39:48 UTC
Threads like these are a proof of why community colleges are a bad thing.
Space Therapist
Better Days Ahead
#13 - 2012-07-12 05:01:11 UTC
my gosh I intended this thread to go into general discussion.

Shocked

I guess it happens...lol

See my bio for rates and services.

Bad Bobby
Bring Me Sunshine
In Tea We Trust
#14 - 2012-07-12 05:09:55 UTC
Space Therapist wrote:
But comments made in support of the activity as well as a bit of trolling left me trying to determine why there are so many individuals that take on selfish or troll-type positions.

In my experience there aren't an excessive number of trolling/scamming/selfish individuals in EVE. Looking at the forums, local channels (Jita in particular) or the contract system may suggest otherwise but that's the nature of the medium. Only a very small portion of the EVE playerbase participates in those areas and it's self selecting for "those people".

There are plenty of inexperienced, ignorant, niave, bigoted and diluded people in EVE, however I think that's entirely to be expected. Some people have the excuse of being young or new to the game and others do not. It seems to reflect real life pretty accurately.

By the way I'm dyslexic, dyscalculic, bipolar and epileptic. The attitude that "you can't help it" isn't generally very helpfull, partly because it's pessimistic and mainly because it's incorrect.
Space Therapist
Better Days Ahead
#15 - 2012-07-12 05:56:04 UTC
Bad Bobby wrote:
Space Therapist wrote:
But comments made in support of the activity as well as a bit of trolling left me trying to determine why there are so many individuals that take on selfish or troll-type positions.

In my experience there aren't an excessive number of trolling/scamming/selfish individuals in EVE. Looking at the forums, local channels (Jita in particular) or the contract system may suggest otherwise but that's the nature of the medium. Only a very small portion of the EVE playerbase participates in those areas and it's self selecting for "those people".

There are plenty of inexperienced, ignorant, niave, bigoted and diluded people in EVE, however I think that's entirely to be expected. Some people have the excuse of being young or new to the game and others do not. It seems to reflect real life pretty accurately.

By the way I'm dyslexic, dyscalculic, bipolar and epileptic. The attitude that "you can't help it" isn't generally very helpfull, partly because it's pessimistic and mainly because it's incorrect.



Thank You Bad Bobby..for that constructive correction. And yes I do realize these things can be helped. I share the attitude that "there are ways to help".

See my bio for rates and services.

Pipa Porto
#16 - 2012-07-12 06:30:24 UTC
Space Therapist wrote:
dyslexia is a reading disability NOT a mental disorder...check again. Mental disorders are things such as schizophrenia and manic depression.


Mental Disorder. 2 words.
First Word: Mental: Of, or Dealing with the Brain-bits
Second Word: Disorder: Ain't working right.

Dyslexia is a Mental Disorder, since it's a problem of the brain incorrectly processing its inputs. It's not a particularly severe one (usually), and can often be overcome or dealt with through various means. Most reading disorders are Mental disorders (vision deficits being the major exception).

That said, you were comparing trolling and scamming ADULTS who have CHOSEN to play EVE to making fun of Dyslexic CHILDREN in an environment that they are FORCED to attend.

I went ahead and bolded the words that should make clear exactly where your comparison went wrong.

EvE: Everyone vs Everyone

-RubyPorto

Korgan Medel
Brutor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#17 - 2012-07-12 07:44:30 UTC
Abditus Cularius wrote:
Threads like these are a proof of why community colleges are a bad thing.


This!!! the moment I started reading I thought to myself well done you took an open university course on psychology (Open University is home study courses in the UK)
Bad Bobby
Bring Me Sunshine
In Tea We Trust
#18 - 2012-07-12 07:50:00 UTC
While we are on the tangential subject of dyslexia, it's effects are not limited to reading. Nor are dyscalculia's effects limited to arithmetic. I have poor short-term memory which is attributed to my dyslexia and I can't read an analog clock and find it extremely difficult to filter out unwanted auditory and olfactory stimuli which is attributed to my dyscalculia. The average uninformed person has only a very approximate understanding of these conditions and are only really aware of their most well known and pronounced symptoms. The fact is that the brain is a very complex and inter-related thing and damage or defect in any area of it will generally have a wide variety of effects.
Space Therapist
Better Days Ahead
#19 - 2012-07-12 08:14:21 UTC  |  Edited by: Space Therapist
interesting info Bobby..thank you for helping me understand your impairment (i hope that's an appropriate word for it).

I am reluctant to call dyslexia a Mental Disorder...I apologize if it is. I read the word impairment..it seemed like a better description or word than the use of the word disorder . I am not claiming to be a professional on these matters...I went on what I read on the subject.

good night!

edited...that I am reluctant to call dyslexia a Mental Disorder.

See my bio for rates and services.

Pipa Porto
#20 - 2012-07-12 08:16:48 UTC  |  Edited by: Pipa Porto
Space Therapist wrote:
interesting info Bobby..thank you for helping me understand your impairment (i hope that's an appropriate word for it).

I am not ready to call dyslexia a Mental Disorder...I apologize if it is. I am not claiming to be a professional on these matters...I went on what I read on the subject.

good night!


Then what's your definition of a Mental Disorder?

Mine's a broad definition, but it lends itself to subcategories which invite precision.

EvE: Everyone vs Everyone

-RubyPorto

123Next page