These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Warfare & Tactics

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Faction Warfare - Resuscitating the Amarr

Author
Veshta Yoshida
PIE Inc.
Khimi Harar
#21 - 2012-07-11 07:18:50 UTC
And why should Amarr take any system at all when plexing has yet to be fixed, incentives are out of whack (x16 difference, Trololololled by Soundwave) and they need to capture everything way deep into Heimatar+ to get highest tier or even second highest.
Someone did the math a while ago: Every system taken equals some absurd number of billions for Shakor as alts farm it back again ..

Also, "lol" at return to 'good fights' .. as long as incentives are as high as they are you'd need some serious mechanics magic to make it more than FarmVille™, Eve Edition. The winter patch may rejuvenate FW if CCP are willing to design it based on more than brainfarts from hung-over Devs/players .. but since it would require almost all of the Inferno changes be axed/heavily modified the chances are slim to none (would be admission of ineptitude).

Tl;dr: FW will remain an Eve version of FarmVille™ for the foreseeable future. Enjoy.

PS: Current state of affairs on both fronts was accurately predicted by us in the common sense/logic crowd and since we are not omniscient one can only conclude that it could have been easily avoided had CCP done their homework.
PPS: Noticing that a lot/most of the people who said "OMG THIS IS AWESOME!" immediately after the patch have applied to be let back into the "Fix FW Club". Please be patient as we ramp up activity again.
Yuri Intaki
Nasranite Watch
#22 - 2012-07-11 07:47:39 UTC
Zarnak Wulf wrote:
This isn't the first time one side has dominated in FW. The winning team invariably moves to greener pastures or starts to fracture as boredom sets in. Barring more imaginative game mechanics that is the historical cycle.


Since when? It's not like many existing people have left FW area despite lopside dominance. What has changed except now they can play the violin while they slowly and tragically drown to an overflowing isk...

Most people leaving FW are entities which come to take a look for a week or two, dont really get integrated into it and move on. Also, apparently XxxPizza fractured to draketrain and Paronit, with Draketrain going for Amarr militia and apparently now leaving it/having already left it.

Nasranite Watch is recruiting of course (already have old Draketrain guys returning) on the levels that I actually had to start reading more corporation management skills because I never expected this many people would want to join Lol

Sigorn MagnarOfThen
Doomheim
#23 - 2012-07-11 07:52:12 UTC
LOL.
If CCP doesn´t do anything within the next 6 months it will be probably bankrupt. Did someone count how many additional players are buying plex now instead of paying with real cash?
I knew some guys who are happy that they have made 10 plexes (30day Pilot License) in only two weeks. In my alts Corp (I am an alt too) there are almost 30 players farming all the time. Probably there are HUNDREDS of players farming and buying Plex for the next two years. Let us assume there are 500 players (I suppose there are a lot more) farming like hell. Well 500 players each probably 5 plex -> 37500 Euros. In only two weeks! And 5 Pilots licenses is really understated. I know people who made over 20 in 2 weeks.
Let this happen half a year and there won´t be eve anymore.
Especially because there are coming more and more farmers. I personally am tired of farming but if I can make about some hundred euros with it... why not.
If CCP doesnt do anything it will loose millions of dollars simply because players do not need to pay for the next some years.
Eve-> Free to play.
Let me farm two further months and I will have possibly gametime till 2020.
THE WHOLE THING IS A MESS!
What we need is a HUGE Minmatar ship nerf and a completely FW restart.
IMEDIALTELY!
Lexmana
#24 - 2012-07-11 07:59:05 UTC  |  Edited by: Lexmana
sYnc Vir wrote:
I would not take out a single plexing roam.

Of course you wont plex for Amarr. You do it with your Minnie alt. What side did you say you were fighting for?
Zarnak Wulf
Task Force 641
Empyrean Edict
#25 - 2012-07-11 08:11:11 UTC
If you have a wallet with several billion isk in it and you can't find the PvP you originally signed up for - you'll go pirate, go null, or possibly even switch sides. Eve101 is keep your troops entertained or at the very least they will stop logging in as often.
Bengal Bob
Slymsloot Enterprises
#26 - 2012-07-11 08:26:28 UTC  |  Edited by: Bengal Bob
THis helpful link demonstrates the current situation nicely. Amarr are of course the Romans, whilst the Minmatar are the Gauls.

http://asterixonline.info/comics/mangas/Asterix%20Comics/23%20-%20Obelix%20and%20Co/23-%20Obelix%20and%20Co%2808%29.jpg

Credit to Merely Runaway for finding this
Tekitha
Esshulls Retirement Club
#27 - 2012-07-11 08:28:50 UTC  |  Edited by: Tekitha
Sigorn MagnarOfThen wrote:
LOL.
If CCP doesn´t do anything within the next 6 months it will be probably bankrupt. Did someone count how many additional players are buying plex now instead of paying with real cash?
I knew some guys who are happy that they have made 10 plexes (30day Pilot License) in only two weeks. In my alts Corp (I am an alt too) there are almost 30 players farming all the time. Probably there are HUNDREDS of players farming and buying Plex for the next two years. Let us assume there are 500 players (I suppose there are a lot more) farming like hell. Well 500 players each probably 5 plex -> 37500 Euros. In only two weeks! And 5 Pilots licenses is really understated. I know people who made over 20 in 2 weeks.
Let this happen half a year and there won´t be eve anymore.
Especially because there are coming more and more farmers. I personally am tired of farming but if I can make about some hundred euros with it... why not.
If CCP doesnt do anything it will loose millions of dollars simply because players do not need to pay for the next some years.
Eve-> Free to play.
Let me farm two further months and I will have possibly gametime till 2020.
THE WHOLE THING IS A MESS!
What we need is a HUGE Minmatar ship nerf and a completely FW restart.
IMEDIALTELY!


Simply wow, you are possibly the stupidest person I've ever come across.

Where exactly do you think those plex are coming from? ... You think CCP seeds them onto the Market. Infact ccp make more money from the buying and selling of plex than they do from subscriptions, since subscriptions are discounted slightly when you subscribe for more than one month at a time.

Protip: think before you write a wall of drivel.
Hidden Snake
Inglorious-Basterds
#28 - 2012-07-11 08:36:22 UTC
sYnc Vir wrote:
Confirming W-BR is the devilTwistedTwisted



Actually not ... u just crippling factions u joined ... no biggie ... I am not paying ur subscription and we all have our special traits. Big smile
Yuri Intaki
Nasranite Watch
#29 - 2012-07-11 08:42:03 UTC  |  Edited by: Yuri Intaki
Bengal Bob wrote:
THis helpful link demonstrates the current situation nicely. Amarr are of course the Romans, whilst the Minmatar are the Gauls.

http://asterixonline.info/comics/mangas/Asterix%20Comics/23%20-%20Obelix%20and%20Co/23-%20Obelix%20and%20Co%2808%29.jpg

Credit to Merely Runaway for finding this


Of course in said comic (One of the best Asterix ones out there) the capitalism which is introduced to Gauls as means to sell/purchase useless item eventually crashes Roman economy too. Then again, it might not happen here since stabber fleet issue is ultimately more useful than a big rock that you cannot even use mining lasers to Big smile
Bad Messenger
Rehabilitation Clinic
#30 - 2012-07-11 08:53:42 UTC
Poetic Stanziel wrote:
Bad Messenger wrote:
No one want to kill good minmatar LP farm.
I do.


If you really want to do that you can join the crusader which is called already.
Markius TheShed
T.R.I.A.D
Ushra'Khan
#31 - 2012-07-11 08:58:04 UTC
Poetic Stanziel wrote:


(tl;dr I propose that Minmatar give up all systems east of Dal, excepting Amamake. Reset faction warfare of our own accord, get back to good fights.)



There is no chance in hell that this is going to happen, Alot of hard work and plexing has been done over many years to get us to the level we are at now, Personally I've been plexing since I joined our corp nearly 2 years ago and now someone who has been in FW for a month is telling me we should give our systems up!!

NOT A CHANCE

**Murientor Tribe** a capsuleer organization composed of radical Minmatar. Since YC107

Thomas Kreshant
Brutor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#32 - 2012-07-11 09:23:25 UTC  |  Edited by: Thomas Kreshant
While I can see where you're coming from Poetic it's a terrible idea.

The Amarr corps leaving to go off and do other things really isn't terrible, people will recover their wallets and get their enthusiasm back while away and at some point the temptation to return is likely to kick in.

FW doesn't need to be going full on 23.5x7, dips in activity are perfectly fine and while our side goes off to do something else the Minmatar can go roaming of various other low sec systems/null etc to keep themselves busy.

As an example just look at the Caldari. A short while before Inferno everyone said their side was totally dead and buried yet now that warzone is vibrant again and they're making a fight out of it.

Patience is the key just give it time.
Yuri Intaki
Nasranite Watch
#33 - 2012-07-11 09:37:42 UTC  |  Edited by: Yuri Intaki
Markius TheShed wrote:
Alot of hard work and plexing has been done over many years to get us to the level we are at now, Personally I've been plexing since I joined our corp nearly 2 years ago and now someone who has been in FW for a month is telling me we should give our systems up!!


You do understand most of the system flipping happened in past few months due to changes in mechanism. Before that your front was more or less stagnated. Amarr owned Siseide/Lantorn for ages and nothing much else happened, except the time PERVS demonstrated how gallente invented plex bug worked and flipped most of Metropolis (which matar retook quickly since no Amarr were there to hold the systems) and the time I was paid 100k isk to flip all systems in Eugidi constellation with Unfamed II.

So even a full reset would actually change very little in regards to "time spent".
sYnc Vir
Wolfsbrigade
Ghost Legion.
#34 - 2012-07-11 09:56:00 UTC
Lexmana wrote:
sYnc Vir wrote:
I would not take out a single plexing roam.

Of course you wont plex for Amarr. You do it with your Minnie alt. What side did you say you were fighting for?


Mission sweetie, Mission. Only 1 of my minnie alts is a new out the can flower. The other joined the Minnies before I joined Amarr. I only plexed to get L4 missions. As for what side I fight for, why that would be my side.

I gave up on General Militia during our final months in Caldari FW. Maybe things have changed but, I'm no longer prepared to find out.

Besides as many others have stated, most of the Amarr are just in it for the pvp. I'll be honest, I'm only in it now because my corp is. Beyond that, I can take it or leave it. Doesn't matter to me who name is on a system, should the one we're living in be lost, there is always the option of living off the alts and the CEO pressing the exit FW button. Eve is abound with choice, we actually already made ours,

Don't ask about Italics, just tilt your head.

IbanezLaney
The Church of Awesome
#35 - 2012-07-11 11:12:46 UTC
Sigorn MagnarOfThen wrote:
LOL.
If CCP doesn´t do anything within the next 6 months it will be probably bankrupt. Did someone count how many additional players are buying plex now instead of paying with real cash?
I knew some guys who are happy that they have made 10 plexes (30day Pilot License) in only two weeks. In my alts Corp (I am an alt too) there are almost 30 players farming all the time. Probably there are HUNDREDS of players farming and buying Plex for the next two years. Let us assume there are 500 players (I suppose there are a lot more) farming like hell. Well 500 players each probably 5 plex -> 37500 Euros. In only two weeks! And 5 Pilots licenses is really understated. I know people who made over 20 in 2 weeks.
Let this happen half a year and there won´t be eve anymore.
Especially because there are coming more and more farmers. I personally am tired of farming but if I can make about some hundred euros with it... why not.
If CCP doesnt do anything it will loose millions of dollars simply because players do not need to pay for the next some years.
Eve-> Free to play.
Let me farm two further months and I will have possibly gametime till 2020.
THE WHOLE THING IS A MESS!
What we need is a HUGE Minmatar ship nerf and a completely FW restart.
IMEDIALTELY!


Someone still buys the plexes and puts them on the market. Plexes cost more than their worth in subscribed game time (unless you pay monthly).

So CCP is already making a killing selling plex - the amount of plex sold in game can't change due to the farming.
Azami Nevinyrall
172.0.0.1
#36 - 2012-07-11 11:25:52 UTC  |  Edited by: Azami Nevinyrall
Tekitha wrote:
Sigorn MagnarOfThen wrote:
LOL.
If CCP doesn´t do anything within the next 6 months it will be probably bankrupt. Did someone count how many additional players are buying plex now instead of paying with real cash?
I knew some guys who are happy that they have made 10 plexes (30day Pilot License) in only two weeks. In my alts Corp (I am an alt too) there are almost 30 players farming all the time. Probably there are HUNDREDS of players farming and buying Plex for the next two years. Let us assume there are 500 players (I suppose there are a lot more) farming like hell. Well 500 players each probably 5 plex -> 37500 Euros. In only two weeks! And 5 Pilots licenses is really understated. I know people who made over 20 in 2 weeks.
Let this happen half a year and there won´t be eve anymore.
Especially because there are coming more and more farmers. I personally am tired of farming but if I can make about some hundred euros with it... why not.
If CCP doesnt do anything it will loose millions of dollars simply because players do not need to pay for the next some years.
Eve-> Free to play.
Let me farm two further months and I will have possibly gametime till 2020.
THE WHOLE THING IS A MESS!
What we need is a HUGE Minmatar ship nerf and a completely FW restart.
IMEDIALTELY!


Simply wow, you are possibly the stupidest person I've ever come across.

Where exactly do you think those plex are coming from? ... You think CCP seeds them onto the Market. Infact ccp make more money from the buying and selling of plex than they do from subscriptions, since subscriptions are discounted slightly when you subscribe for more than one month at a time.

Protip: think before you write a wall of drivel.


This...

But let me take one step further with numbers...

1 month subscription = $14.95 CAD (this is my local currency, do math for yours)
1 PLEX = $19.95

So if you farm and bought PLEX until 2020...that is, from today 102 months. So instead of paying your sub from now until 2020, which would be 14.95 x 102 = $1,524.90. You decided to pay for your sub using PLEX that someone had to buy at 19.95. So the math there is 19.95 x 102 = $2,034.90. Let me say "working as intended"

Sigorn MagnarOfThen wrote:
If CCP doesn´t do anything within the next 6 months it will be probably bankrupt.

CCP goes bankrupt from....I dunno making money? (how the f*ck this works is beyond me)

...

Markius TheShed
T.R.I.A.D
Ushra'Khan
#37 - 2012-07-11 14:03:48 UTC
You seem to have changed your mind about war since you said this Poetic

Poetic Stanziel wrote:
From the Jade conspiracy Blog post...............

Making wars fair is not a design consideration. Why should war be fair? In the history of human existence, when has war been fair? Oh, we have 2 to 1 advantage over you? Oh, you don't have any cavalry? Well, we'll just sit out all our horsemen and half our army, wouldn't be fair otherwise. Sorry about that. Okay, let's start the fighting. EVE is a simulator of human conflict, artificial rules to even playing fields is not EVE, that's some other game, like World of Warcraft, with their battlegrounds and arenas. Go play that if you want a semblance of fairness.



And now you want to make FW fair?? Make your mind up will you.

**Murientor Tribe** a capsuleer organization composed of radical Minmatar. Since YC107

Bad Messenger
Rehabilitation Clinic
#38 - 2012-07-11 14:20:37 UTC
Sigorn MagnarOfThen wrote:
LOL.
If CCP doesn´t do anything within the next 6 months it will be probably bankrupt. Did someone count how many additional players are buying plex now instead of paying with real cash?
I knew some guys who are happy that they have made 10 plexes (30day Pilot License) in only two weeks. In my alts Corp (I am an alt too) there are almost 30 players farming all the time. Probably there are HUNDREDS of players farming and buying Plex for the next two years. Let us assume there are 500 players (I suppose there are a lot more) farming like hell. Well 500 players each probably 5 plex -> 37500 Euros. In only two weeks! And 5 Pilots licenses is really understated. I know people who made over 20 in 2 weeks.
Let this happen half a year and there won´t be eve anymore.
Especially because there are coming more and more farmers. I personally am tired of farming but if I can make about some hundred euros with it... why not.
If CCP doesnt do anything it will loose millions of dollars simply because players do not need to pay for the next some years.
Eve-> Free to play.
Let me farm two further months and I will have possibly gametime till 2020.
THE WHOLE THING IS A MESS!
What we need is a HUGE Minmatar ship nerf and a completely FW restart.
IMEDIALTELY!



CCP made FW changes for people like you who are willing to pay several accounts and farming isk and PLEX.

Whole expansion was about making people swarm more alts, so CCP is not going to change it until subs start to decrease.
Jade Constantine
Jericho Fraction
The Star Fraction
#39 - 2012-07-11 14:57:18 UTC  |  Edited by: Jade Constantine
Poetic Stanziel wrote:
from http://poeticstanziel.blogspot.ca/2012/07/faction-warfare-resuscitating-amarr.html

It was malaise. I was under the impression that the Amarr were giving up systems (as of yesterday, they had six systems under their control, out of over 65 systems) so that their alts could cash in on the T5 warzone control Minmatar achieved on Sunday.

(tl;dr I propose that Minmatar give up all systems east of Dal, excepting Amamake. Reset faction warfare of our own accord, get back to good fights.)

(snipped bits of the argument to make space for the reply -Jade)

Take a look at the following faction warfare map, I'm going to use east/west based on how it's drawn:

(image) http://i.imgur.com/Kj57r.png

I propose pulling all Minmatar assets back to Dal. Give the Amarr one (maybe two) weeks to retake all systems east of Dal (except Amamake). There can still be good fights throughout the week, simply no plexing in the systems we're giving up. We don't snark and snipe at them either "Oh, it took us being charitable to get you back on your feet blah blah blah." **** that. This is as much for our good as it is there's. CCP is to blame for the situation we're in, for not resetting faction warfare when they implemented the new system. The Goons are as much to blame for causing much of the Amarrian malaise. We're to blame for rubbing all of this, which was out of Amarr control, in their face for the last couple months. Which all leads to where we are now: a dude wants to do better by himself, get out of the rut he's in, but can't quite get the leg up he needs, not without a little help from friends.

All it would take to make this happen would be the cooperation of a few of the larger Minmatar FW alliances: Iron Oxide, Late Night Alliance, Defiant Legacy, and a few others. Get the word out, and get people in line, on pain of getting blowed up real good.





Its against some pretty tough competition but this is about the worst blog post you ever made Poetic. For a person who was virtually kissing Soundwave's shadow about the notion that "war in eve wasn't fair" a couple of weeks ago now you think the player base should have to consensually "make it fair" by giving up systems that were hard and honestly fought for in the run up to Inferno and in the weeks since?

Your conclusions are wrong - the Goon impact was pretty minimal in the grand scheme of things, and a reset of FW occupancy for Inferno would have been profoundly anti-sandbox and have made a mockery of the efforts of players in the years before Inferno. You are also pretty clueless on the role that an organization like Fweddit plays in the grand scheme - sure they were amusing to fight for a bit at the beginning when they were taking any fight that was offered and trying to make up with numbers what their members lacked in skills etc etc - but they also have become embittered and risk-averse in recent weeks and now just want to gank or run like the rest. They are nothing special in other words - if they don't want to plex occupancy it simply means they don't want to play FW really - nobody gets rewarded for not playing the game.

More importantly : Eve Online used to be a game about consequences and player-led dynamic outcomes (even in hisec/lowsec) when players achieve things (like dominating an area of the faction warfare warzone) then the storyline should honour that with significance and impact (not just a gamey copout like an occupancy reset) - things should change, the impact should matter, we should leave a mark on this universe by our actions.

If you want to argue that FW mechanics are currently too brutal in punishing the losers then I will tend with agree with you. But the resolution to this issue needs to come from CCP design work and the adjustment needs to honour the principles of the dynamic sandbox and redress the balance while acknowledging the outcome.

Here's a back of a beermat suggestion how that can be done.

"Amarr government issues an emergency press release acknowledging the need for additional imperial funding to support the beleaguered 24th Crusade which otherwise faces total collapse. Effective immediately transaction taxes in all Amarr hisec will be increased to provide additional support to bolster the 24th Crusade loyalty point store. This will have the impact of granting effective tier 3 prices regardless of currently warzone control with a 10% transaction tax penalty in Amarr Hisec while the actual warzone control remains at 1 (reducing to 5% transaction tax penalty if warzone control raises to 2) and normalizing to zero if the 24th crusade can attain a level 3 warzone control. The Empress urges all 24th Crusade Fighters to remain loyal in this time of the crisis for the imperium"

This would give the 24th a chance to cash in their lps at pre Inferno level and fund their fight back. It punishes ANYONE attempting to conduct business in Amarr hisec to represent the fact that the Amarrian Empire is needing to divert massive funding to support the 24th through tax levies on business. It directly provides incentive for the 24th to hold onto their remaining lowsec assets and introduces a mechanic which will in play until the 24th normalizes the warzone."

On the other side of the coin the Matari Republic probably needs to issue some commemorative medals for the achievement. (And CCP should write some fiction and storyline to represent the map dynamic.)

***

And that's a five minute example of how this kind of thing can be addressed without a nonsense consenual surrender of territory on the black of a bleating blog full of half baked misunderstandings and nonsense.

The True Knowledge is that nothing matters that does not matter to you, might does make right and power makes freedom

Poetic Stanziel
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#40 - 2012-07-11 15:09:46 UTC
Markius TheShed wrote:
You seem to have changed your mind about war since you said this Poetic

Poetic Stanziel wrote:
From the Jade conspiracy Blog post...............

Making wars fair is not a design consideration. Why should war be fair? In the history of human existence, when has war been fair? Oh, we have 2 to 1 advantage over you? Oh, you don't have any cavalry? Well, we'll just sit out all our horsemen and half our army, wouldn't be fair otherwise. Sorry about that. Okay, let's start the fighting. EVE is a simulator of human conflict, artificial rules to even playing fields is not EVE, that's some other game, like World of Warcraft, with their battlegrounds and arenas. Go play that if you want a semblance of fairness.
And now you want to make FW fair?? Make your mind up will you.

I'm not asking CCP to make the war fair ... I'm suggesting we perform a reset of our own accord, for long-term health of FW, especially in the south.

Big difference between asking CCP to design fairness, or just doing something ourselves, as players, to keep CCP from butting in with their design changes down the road, if things get too out of whack.