These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

EVE New Citizens Q&A

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
12Next page
 

How do you know when to trust a corporation?

Author
Icmalius
Stardust-Guardian
Fraternity.
#1 - 2012-06-12 18:31:18 UTC  |  Edited by: Icmalius
I have recently returned and have started looking at joining a corporation but I do have some hang-ups and trust issues, maybe my mom didn't love me enough.... I hope this is a decent forum to ask this in, maybe I should ask in C&P though?

I have been talking to a recruiter and all my questions were answered thoughtfully and coherently, but a couple flags have gone up, at least to me.

One, getting access to a JF to move articles out to their space seems almost two easy, supposedly they have jumps almost every day. I don't know a lot about JF's, but I would assume moving items every day would be rather expensive and not very cost effective.

Second, asking about opportunities to pad the bank account we of course get on topic of rats, the person seemed almost a little eager saying that my vargur is a great ship to haul out for their main NPC region. Hauling such an expensive ship out to the middle of null when you don't know anyone and are very fresh to a corp just sounds like not so good advice.

Lastly, I tried to do some digging on the corp, the recruiter who has contacted me does not have many posts, and the one post that I have found regarding the corp actually shows up in this forum where a guy believes he was scammed, and after reading reading his post I most definitely agree he was, who pays to join a corp?

Note: they have not asked me to pay, and the member accused of operating the scam is not the person who has contacted me.

So, honest question and I hope for at least one or two honest answers, are those enough red flags that you would back off of joining said corp?

Thank you.
Marjolaine Soucie
Grott Shipyards
#2 - 2012-06-12 18:36:08 UTC
Although I can't really answer your question directly as I have yet to join a corp myself due to the same feelings more or less, I have found this guide that may be of some use to you. https://forums.eveonline.com/default.aspx?g=posts&m=130755#post130755 I wish you the best of luck.
Zoe Athame
Don't Lose Your Way
#3 - 2012-06-12 18:38:58 UTC  |  Edited by: Zoe Athame
Icmalius wrote:

So, honest question and I hope for at least one or two honest answers, are those enough red flags that you would back off of joining said corp?


Yes.

1. The Vargur is purely a mission ship and should never be used for ratting.
2. If someone contacts you about joining and not the other way around, they don't want you, they want your ISK.
Cameron Zero
Sebiestor Tribe
#4 - 2012-06-12 18:41:16 UTC
You asked "How do you know when to trust a corporation?" and the simple answer is "You don't, not completely, not ever. Not in this game."

You can protect yourself and your assets, but absolute trust isn't something that should be given in a game where people pride themselves on gaining another player's trust and then robbing them blind.

JF loads every day? Sure, there are some alliances that do that.

Moving a Vargur out to null for ratting? I dunno, that seems fishy to me, but I can't/don't fly such ships, so maybe I'm just paranoid.

"I've seen things you people wouldn't believe. Attack ships on fire off the shoulder of Orion. I watched C-beams glitter in the dark near the Tannhauser Gate. All those moments will be lost in time, like tears in rain. …"

Icmalius
Stardust-Guardian
Fraternity.
#5 - 2012-06-12 18:42:36 UTC  |  Edited by: Icmalius
Zoe Athame wrote:
Icmalius wrote:

So, honest question and I hope for at least one or two honest answers, are those enough red flags that you would back off of joining said corp?


Yes.

1. The Vargur is purely a mission ship and should never be used for ratting.
2. If someone contacts you about joining and not the other way around, they don't want you, they want your ISK.


Just a quick response to number two, I did make a post in the recruitment forums, this is an alt, I do not want to needlessly give a corp that I know little about a black eye, unless of course I have good reason.

As for the vargur, it is not only for ratting, I believe they said they can do mission ops and such in the NPC portions of space. I don't know if this is even possible off the top of my head, I have never been in a null-sec corp that had NPC space within easy reach.
Zoe Athame
Don't Lose Your Way
#6 - 2012-06-12 18:52:23 UTC
Icmalius wrote:
Zoe Athame wrote:
Icmalius wrote:

So, honest question and I hope for at least one or two honest answers, are those enough red flags that you would back off of joining said corp?


Yes.

1. The Vargur is purely a mission ship and should never be used for ratting.
2. If someone contacts you about joining and not the other way around, they don't want you, they want your ISK.


Just a quick response to number two, I did make a post in the recruitment forums, this is an alt, I do not want to needlessly give a corp that I know little about a black eye, unless of course I have good reason.

As for the vargur, it is not only for ratting, I believe they said they can do mission ops and such in the NPC portions of space.


I still don't see the logic there. Marauders are meant for solo running missions and looting at the same time. A group of players could just bring a dedicated salvager.

There are a few other things you can check out. First being their in-game info. Look up their corp and check the Member Count, if it is very low for who they say they are, it could be another red flag. Also you can see if they are in an Alliance. It's worth checking out the other corps to see if they are also fishy.

Killboards can be a very good tool for surveying combat corps. You can see if there are corpmember kills (griefing without concord intervention) or just no kills at all which would imply that they aren't the PvP corp that they are advertising as. AKA its all a masquerade while they take your stuff.
Forum Clone 77777
Doomheim
#7 - 2012-06-12 19:06:58 UTC
Zoe Athame wrote:

1. The Vargur is purely a mission ship and should never be used for ratting.
2. If someone contacts you about joining and not the other way around, they don't want you, they want your ISK.

Your entire response is just utterly **** to be honest.

1) Ive seen marauders used with great efficiency for ratting, they might be "mission" ships but hey, a vargur is a great ratting ship if you fit it right.

2) A corp might contact someone if theyve taken notice of someone and they like him/her. Could be several reasons why, not all people get recruited through friends or the recruitment channel you know.
Zoe Athame
Don't Lose Your Way
#8 - 2012-06-12 19:21:49 UTC
Forum Clone 77777 wrote:
Zoe Athame wrote:

1. The Vargur is purely a mission ship and should never be used for ratting.
2. If someone contacts you about joining and not the other way around, they don't want you, they want your ISK.

Your entire response is just utterly **** to be honest.

1) Ive seen marauders used with great efficiency for ratting, they might be "mission" ships but hey, a vargur is a great ratting ship if you fit it right.

2) A corp might contact someone if theyve taken notice of someone and they like him/her. Could be several reasons why, not all people get recruited through friends or the recruitment channel you know.


If you want to risk billions in the depths of CFC sov, sure, go for it. But there is no reason not to just use a regular BS in NPC 0.0.

If you managed to impress a corp significantly I think you would be aware of whether they are legitimate or not.
J'Poll
School of Applied Knowledge
Caldari State
#9 - 2012-06-12 19:22:45 UTC
To your concerns:

1.) JF cost money to run, but there are plenty of people who make more then enough to make daily JF runs (given it's clear / safe enough to jump). However be careful, it is also a great way to steal people's assets (not really helping your concerns, but rather be honost here).

2.) Good point, don't take all your ships straight into null. Start small, maybe buy a 2nd ship (doesn't have to be the vargur) and start building up from that. Keep the Vargur in high-sec just in case.

3.) NEVER pay to join a corp. Not many post doesn't mean they are bad though. But do some extend research.

BTW, by any chance the guy you were talking too was part of Goonswarm ????

Marjolaine has a link, read that as it has a great guide on how to find a corp.

Zoe's 2nd point is valid, you must find a corp, a corp never searches for members, they recruit. The times a corp actually hunts for people instead of people looking for corps is very small

Zoe's 1st point, exactly marauders are build to shoot and salvage at the same time, something you can also do while ratting. (salvage isn't just done in missions).



Personal channel: Crazy Dutch Guy

Help channel: Help chat - Reloaded

Public roams channels: RvB Ganked / Redemption Road / Spectre Fleet / Bombers bar / The Content Club

Lost Greybeard
Drunken Yordles
#10 - 2012-06-12 21:10:05 UTC  |  Edited by: Lost Greybeard
You always know when to trust a corp, because the answer to the question is always "Don't. Ever."

Leave a jump clone and enough assets in high sec that you can move back without any trouble, don't contract anything to an unknown third party that you're not prepared to lose. Once you've been in 0.0 playing with them for a couple months and they seem cool, then you can pull in more of your stuff, though, again, I'd still leave enough in high to make moving back trivial.

EDIT: As a wise man once said a few thousand years ago and a thousand have repeated since: Be polite, be professional, have a plan to kill everyone you meet. Welcome to Eve, friend.
Lukriss
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#11 - 2012-06-12 21:55:52 UTC
There are varying degrees of trust. Do i trust that random girl i just slept with to not kill me in my sleep? Sure; Would I bring her home to my place and trust her not to steal any of my ****? Maybe; Would I trust her to take a bullet for me should that come up? Nope.


Same thing applies to eve, I'd just a corp I just joined to jump out a bc for me, but a marauder? No way
Tau Cabalander
Retirement Retreat
Working Stiffs
#12 - 2012-06-12 23:39:35 UTC  |  Edited by: Tau Cabalander
Icmalius wrote:
One, getting access to a JF to move articles out to their space seems almost two easy, supposedly they have jumps almost every day. I don't know a lot about JF's, but I would assume moving items every day would be rather expensive and not very cost effective.

It is safe to setup courier contracts available to the corp or alliance with sufficient collateral to cover the cost of the item(s) moved. If they fail to deliver, you can fail the contract and get all the ISK paid as collateral. [Note: Even if you can't dock at the station, you can still sell an item if you are in the same region.]

If they tell you to put a lower amount or no collateral, tell them to stuff it.

In most cases, you are best taking only ISK and buying from the local markets anyways.

Icmalius wrote:
So, honest question and I hope for at least one or two honest answers, are those enough red flags that you would back off of joining said corp?

Some corps consider it an I.Q. test to see if you are stupid and gullible.

If you think you are getting scammed TELL THEM THAT AND WHY. Also tell them that there is no way they can convince you otherwise! If they don't come clean, find another corp.
Archdaimon
Merchants of the Golden Goose
#13 - 2012-06-12 23:59:05 UTC
It was posted somewhere in Seleene's post but it holds true. Finding the right corp is a bit like marriage. Before you wed you'd like to date a bit first.

Before you give them assets go to their ts. Do they seem like cool folk? Do you like hanging out with them?

Truth be told you don't want to be passively recruited. I never got the "here I am, come get me" posts. They scream for getting scammed. Instead you want to do research. Do what you'd like of your future corp and meet them on the field or seek them out yourself.

Sounds like you want to go to zero. Take care...

Wormholes have the best accoustics. It's known. - Sing it for me -

Peri Simone
Federal Navy Academy
Gallente Federation
#14 - 2012-06-13 00:13:17 UTC
Icmalius wrote:
So, honest question and I hope for at least one or two honest answers, are those enough red flags that you would back off of joining said corp?

Thank you.


If you believe the corp in question has a history of scamming potential new members, which you do, I would back off. Trust your gut instinct. It's not paranoia, etc etc.
Nicolo da'Vicenza
Viziam
Amarr Empire
#15 - 2012-06-13 07:50:42 UTC  |  Edited by: Nicolo da'Vicenza
this all sounds rather normal

just rat in a maelstrom for a bit and if they don't scam you out of your meagre investment and you spend a sufficient amount of time in their corp and feel you can trust them, then bring your vargur down.

also NPC 0.0 is fairly dangerous due to its lack of security, so that's another reason why you might want to start with a regular BS first
Luis Graca
#16 - 2012-06-13 10:52:05 UTC
You can't never trust a corp if you don't know them

However if you need they to do logistic it's very simple start by give them some expendables ships like a cheap ratting ship and also a cheap PvP ship. In time you will gain trust to then and by then and can start asking for them to bring more shinning stuff, if they are scamming you then you will also lose expendable stuff is not good but it also isn't very bad

Quick note: Never make contracts before you're in the corp

Disastro
Wrecking Shots
#17 - 2012-06-13 11:45:01 UTC
Icmalius wrote:
I have recently returned and have started looking at joining a corporation but I do have some hang-ups and trust issues, maybe my mom didn't love me enough.... I hope this is a decent forum to ask this in, maybe I should ask in C&P though?

I have been talking to a recruiter and all my questions were answered thoughtfully and coherently, but a couple flags have gone up, at least to me.

One, getting access to a JF to move articles out to their space seems almost two easy, supposedly they have jumps almost every day. I don't know a lot about JF's, but I would assume moving items every day would be rather expensive and not very cost effective.

Second, asking about opportunities to pad the bank account we of course get on topic of rats, the person seemed almost a little eager saying that my vargur is a great ship to haul out for their main NPC region. Hauling such an expensive ship out to the middle of null when you don't know anyone and are very fresh to a corp just sounds like not so good advice.

Lastly, I tried to do some digging on the corp, the recruiter who has contacted me does not have many posts, and the one post that I have found regarding the corp actually shows up in this forum where a guy believes he was scammed, and after reading reading his post I most definitely agree he was, who pays to join a corp?

Note: they have not asked me to pay, and the member accused of operating the scam is not the person who has contacted me.

So, honest question and I hope for at least one or two honest answers, are those enough red flags that you would back off of joining said corp?

Thank you.



You could always join thier corp and pod yourself down to their home system and buy a ship or two there to use for a bit while you get acclimated to their corp/alliance and get to know the folks in it. You would only be risking a pod and whatever you buy in system. Much less risky than bringing all of your stuff to nullsec with a corp you dont know.

If it is a goon or test corp or one of their affiliates it is, of course, a scam and you should have done your research in advance. If it is not one of theirs then there is a good chance that it is a legitimate offer.
Luis Graca
#18 - 2012-06-13 11:55:01 UTC
Disastro wrote:
Icmalius wrote:
I have recently returned and have started looking at joining a corporation but I do have some hang-ups and trust issues, maybe my mom didn't love me enough.... I hope this is a decent forum to ask this in, maybe I should ask in C&P though?

I have been talking to a recruiter and all my questions were answered thoughtfully and coherently, but a couple flags have gone up, at least to me.

One, getting access to a JF to move articles out to their space seems almost two easy, supposedly they have jumps almost every day. I don't know a lot about JF's, but I would assume moving items every day would be rather expensive and not very cost effective.

Second, asking about opportunities to pad the bank account we of course get on topic of rats, the person seemed almost a little eager saying that my vargur is a great ship to haul out for their main NPC region. Hauling such an expensive ship out to the middle of null when you don't know anyone and are very fresh to a corp just sounds like not so good advice.

Lastly, I tried to do some digging on the corp, the recruiter who has contacted me does not have many posts, and the one post that I have found regarding the corp actually shows up in this forum where a guy believes he was scammed, and after reading reading his post I most definitely agree he was, who pays to join a corp?

Note: they have not asked me to pay, and the member accused of operating the scam is not the person who has contacted me.

So, honest question and I hope for at least one or two honest answers, are those enough red flags that you would back off of joining said corp?

Thank you.



You could always join thier corp and pod yourself down to their home system and buy a ship or two there to use for a bit while you get acclimated to their corp/alliance and get to know the folks in it. You would only be risking a pod and whatever you buy in system. Much less risky than bringing all of your stuff to nullsec with a corp you dont know.

If it is a goon or test corp or one of their affiliates it is, of course, a scam and you should have done your research in advance. If it is not one of theirs then there is a good chance that it is a legitimate offer.



don't pod yourself there if you don't know hows their region market lots on 0.0 have very bad make stuff


Major Trant
Brutor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#19 - 2012-06-13 12:39:24 UTC
I was in a small alliance in NPC Null, we had a weekly JF run and I saw Vargur's used for ratting and running sites. I don't see either of the issues you raised as particularly suspicious. A single corp member running some sort of scam, you don't say what, not even if it was related to recruiting new members. Even if it was, hardly conclusive evidence. At least there wasn't a string of scams uncovered.

However, can you trust them?. That is something you have to decide yourself. But I wouldn't send a Vargur on the first trip and why even consider it if they have daily JF runs? Send a ratting BC on the first run. A Drake is an ideal null sec ratter, if you can't get into a Drake, send an Arty Hurricane. Go down in a Covert Ops ship and spend a week with them, exploring the area, setting up bookmarks and trying out a bit of ratting. After a week get a Maelstrom brought down, that is more than adequate for belt rats and anomalies. As you get more comfortable, ship more gear down in small packets, little and often until you are really sure about them.

Personally, I wouldn't bother sending the Vargur. Leave it in high sec as your back up to return to if it all goes wrong. But even that advice depends on how rich you are and your attitude to loss. Some people do it, lose it and replace it the next day without batting an eyelid.
Sin Pew
Ministry of War
Amarr Empire
#20 - 2012-06-13 12:40:44 UTC
Lost Greybeard wrote:
You always know when to trust a corp, because the answer to the question is always "Don't. Ever."

Leave a jump clone and enough assets in high sec that you can move back without any trouble, don't contract anything to an unknown third party that you're not prepared to lose. Once you've been in 0.0 playing with them for a couple months and they seem cool, then you can pull in more of your stuff, though, again, I'd still leave enough in high to make moving back trivial.

EDIT: As a wise man once said a few thousand years ago and a thousand have repeated since: Be polite, be professional, have a plan to kill everyone you meet. Welcome to Eve, friend.

I'd settle with that and don't move a ship you're really worried of losing. If you feel good within the corp and figure you make enough ISK to afford its loss, then you might consider taking it down there if you have a purpose for it and a good fit, but until you can afford it just keep it high-sec.

[i]"haiku are easy, But sometimes they don't make sense, Refrigerator."[/i]

12Next page