These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

EVE Alliance Tournament Discussion

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

A Plea to Reason: Allow Hydra and Outbreak to compete

Author
Copine Callmeknau
Dirty Vagrants
Intergalactic Space Hobos
#21 - 2012-05-27 01:45:19 UTC
Cheat less and you might not get barred from tourny's



This is like a steroid-pumped sprinter being barred from the olympics, and then complaining about it Lol

There should be a rather awesome pic here

Grath Telkin
Amok.
Goonswarm Federation
#22 - 2012-05-27 03:56:59 UTC
Karbox Delacroix wrote:


Except we can't read their minds. Presumably the CEOs of Outbreak and Hydra are different people. The same cannot be said for PL and Waffles.


Hi, you're dumb, the CEO of Pandemic Legion is Shamis Orzoz, the CEO of waffles is not, nor has it ever been, Shamis Orzoz.

I hope this helps you understand how stupid you look, because you have absolutely NO idea what you're talking about and didn't even have the reading comprehension skills to understand what CCP wrote.

You should read it again, the CEO of waffles is a PL memeber, of course we would have a man from PL as the headmaster to the school, but we weren't colluding, I see you may have a problem understanding what that word means, you should look it up, and know that IT is the reason you should be angry....at Hyxra.

Malcanis - Without drone assign, the slowcat doctrine will wither and die.

Gunnar Twenty
Doomheim
#23 - 2012-05-27 04:01:31 UTC
Zastrow wrote:
Do you remember the year that my alliance was disqualified because we couldn't add to 100?

Or the time my alliance was disqualified because we sent our entrance fee to the wrong CCP alliance?

I find it a little hard to be sympathetic to a team that deliberately and intentionally tried to toe the rules line and got disqualified, especially when the rule was created specifically for them. Lesson learned, and there's always next year.


I'm ignorant of much of the history of this game, but based on what you say, it does sound extremely unfortunate to hinder players' endeavors on such trivial technicalities as you bring up. I wouldn't have wished those outcomes for your alliance. I question the need to repeat past mistakes. There is no need for CCP to endure in such consistent callousness towards its player base.

These measures only serve to permeate an aura of negativity. I am a proponent of constructive rather than destructive solutions. I'm not defending the actions of my alliance. I'll accept the fact they screwed up, or cheated if you prefer. But there's over a month to go before the tournament starts. In no way has the upcoming tournament been irreversibly tarnished by their actions. Excluding these players from participation is the harshest sanction you could possibly impose as this is the element of the game they are most passionate about, and serves no constructive benefit, meanwhile fostering much ill will.

Couldn't some compromising form of punishment be reached? This isn't a comprehensive brainstorm of alternatives by the way, but a couple examples off the top of my head:

  • Monetary Fine
  • Suspended Sentence to be imposed on any future misbehavior

Hroya
#24 - 2012-05-27 04:52:17 UTC
@Gunnat Twenty,

Well written and a pleasure to read eventhough english isnt my native language.
I am going to agree with you for what it's worth. And in my personal opinion the majority of players, as far as i noticed on these forums, usually tend to act like midieval lynchmobs when someone screams heretic.

Good luck with your plea, though i doubt it will change much.


You go your corridor but.

Karbox Delacroix
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#25 - 2012-05-27 04:54:26 UTC
Grath Telkin wrote:
Karbox Delacroix wrote:


Except we can't read their minds. Presumably the CEOs of Outbreak and Hydra are different people. The same cannot be said for PL and Waffles.


Hi, you're dumb, the CEO of Pandemic Legion is Shamis Orzoz, the CEO of waffles is not, nor has it ever been, Shamis Orzoz.

I hope this helps you understand how stupid you look, because you have absolutely NO idea what you're talking about and didn't even have the reading comprehension skills to understand what CCP wrote.

You should read it again, the CEO of waffles is a PL memeber, of course we would have a man from PL as the headmaster to the school, but we weren't colluding, I see you may have a problem understanding what that word means, you should look it up, and know that IT is the reason you should be angry....at Hyxra.


To quote the great Skreegs, you should read the stickies. As for colluding, I don't really care about that. If I was mad about colluding, I would have to be mad about blokes that bumped Titans out of POS shields. The meta game is what it is, you live by it, you die by it. This is especially true when the most insidious forms of collusion are undetectable because it occurs via private emails and chat.
Wheedily
Megaton Inc.
#26 - 2012-05-27 05:46:36 UTC
I'm supporting the OP, of course. Only Goons (and their Dev alts) and PL are not Big smile

David Magnus wrote:
JEFFRAIDER wrote:
Actually let's repurpose this thread:

A Please to Reason: Please stop deleting posts from the locked "Open Letter" thread, you've literally removed 10/25 pages so far. . .


Yeah, as I was reading through it the page count kept dropping until I finally stopped reading since all the good posts were obviously removed.


Yes this. Christ CCP this didn't work last time /o



Blahblah

Destination SkillQueue
Doomheim
#27 - 2012-05-27 05:58:25 UTC  |  Edited by: Destination SkillQueue
I felt Hydra and Outbreak has always had good teams in the tournament. It was a shame their leadership had so little confidence in the abilities of their pilots, that they felt they couldn't compete against other alliances without resorting to cheating. It must feel terrible being backstabbed like that, but that's how things roll sometimes. They break the rules, you suffer with the consequenses.
Grath Telkin
Amok.
Goonswarm Federation
#28 - 2012-05-27 06:10:05 UTC
Karbox Delacroix wrote:
Grath Telkin wrote:
Karbox Delacroix wrote:


Except we can't read their minds. Presumably the CEOs of Outbreak and Hydra are different people. The same cannot be said for PL and Waffles.


Hi, you're dumb, the CEO of Pandemic Legion is Shamis Orzoz, the CEO of waffles is not, nor has it ever been, Shamis Orzoz.

I hope this helps you understand how stupid you look, because you have absolutely NO idea what you're talking about and didn't even have the reading comprehension skills to understand what CCP wrote.

You should read it again, the CEO of waffles is a PL memeber, of course we would have a man from PL as the headmaster to the school, but we weren't colluding, I see you may have a problem understanding what that word means, you should look it up, and know that IT is the reason you should be angry....at Hyxra.


To quote the great Skreegs, you should read the stickies. As for colluding, I don't really care about that. If I was mad about colluding, I would have to be mad about blokes that bumped Titans out of POS shields. The meta game is what it is, you live by it, you die by it. This is especially true when the most insidious forms of collusion are undetectable because it occurs via private emails and chat.


What, no fool, they put the friggin rule in that specifically says NO COLLUDING, so no, jumping everybody into a single corp, is simply colluding, it was obvious and they shouldn't have done it.

Malcanis - Without drone assign, the slowcat doctrine will wither and die.

Karbox Delacroix
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#29 - 2012-05-27 06:18:58 UTC
Grath Telkin wrote:
Karbox Delacroix wrote:
Grath Telkin wrote:
Karbox Delacroix wrote:


Except we can't read their minds. Presumably the CEOs of Outbreak and Hydra are different people. The same cannot be said for PL and Waffles.


Hi, you're dumb, the CEO of Pandemic Legion is Shamis Orzoz, the CEO of waffles is not, nor has it ever been, Shamis Orzoz.

I hope this helps you understand how stupid you look, because you have absolutely NO idea what you're talking about and didn't even have the reading comprehension skills to understand what CCP wrote.

You should read it again, the CEO of waffles is a PL memeber, of course we would have a man from PL as the headmaster to the school, but we weren't colluding, I see you may have a problem understanding what that word means, you should look it up, and know that IT is the reason you should be angry....at Hyxra.


To quote the great Skreegs, you should read the stickies. As for colluding, I don't really care about that. If I was mad about colluding, I would have to be mad about blokes that bumped Titans out of POS shields. The meta game is what it is, you live by it, you die by it. This is especially true when the most insidious forms of collusion are undetectable because it occurs via private emails and chat.


What, no fool, they put the friggin rule in that specifically says NO COLLUDING, so no, jumping everybody into a single corp, is simply colluding, it was obvious and they shouldn't have done it.


No, it is not obviously colluding. Being in the same corp is meaningless because CCP cannot monitor the out of game communications. By allowing sparring, they are allowing the sharing of information. Short of an email from Garmon telling the CEO of Outbreak to bite his lip and think of England, you are not going to be able to prove collusion.

If the appearance of impropriety is enough to warrant a ban, then having a PL alt being the CEO of YVDC is a problem. I also have no idea how to disentangle the thorny mess that is DekCo or the various Russians.
Time Funnel
Just a side dish
Outspoken Alliance
#30 - 2012-05-27 07:13:13 UTC  |  Edited by: Time Funnel
Karbox Delacroix wrote:

No, it is not obviously colluding.


It is blatantly obvious they are colluding just like they did last year. Your argument is "you can't prove that they are intending to". Well their actions are ample proof they are colluding. Then your further argument is "everyone is doing it, why pick on these guys?"

MY opinion is that generally alliances that are competing this year are spying / stealing setups, some are sparring, and there may even be a well hidden B team or two out there somewhere.

But NOBODY even comes close to what Hydra and Outbreak were/are doing. Not even close. They are the archetype, the name brand. They showed everyone how it was done, and started doing it again.

Edit: Not sure if you are trolling but just think for a minute what would happen if we allowed teams to operate like Hydra and Outbreak do. You couldn't "prove" that the 8 alliances that all were in a single corp in a wormhole practicing together, fielding the same setups, sharing logistics at a level that would give them an unfair advantage is not some form of collusion? Really? "But we have our own pilots" "But we don't arrange fights for mutual advantage" "But we have no 'intention' of doing anything like this" and "we don't share intel". I think it would be blatantly obvious that those 8 alliances were working together enough to be considered one single team. And that would make it against the rules.
Intigo
Imperial Academy
Amarr Empire
#31 - 2012-05-27 07:47:35 UTC
CVA & 4th were practicing in a wormhole too. They were considering joining a single corporation to facilitate testing just as we did because they thought it was well within the rules (just as we did).

hydra provail

Time Funnel
Just a side dish
Outspoken Alliance
#32 - 2012-05-27 07:57:32 UTC  |  Edited by: Time Funnel
Intigo wrote:
CVA & 4th were practicing in a wormhole too. They were considering joining a single corporation to facilitate testing just as we did because they thought it was well within the rules (just as we did).


CVA and 4th were imitating last year's champions and doing everything that last year's champions did. By your wording I assume that they did not actually join the same corporation. You are now guessing their intentions? Don't you hate it when other people do that?

They were following your lead. My starting point was doing the same thing, taking all your setups I could find and watching all the matches. Obviously wormholes are too much :effort: for us.

If you want to be successful you will generally find an archetype that has been successful and imitate them.

Life is unfair. At least you have next year to look forward to.

You can also whine until your account gets muted and then deleted. Then you can get more mad and burn a bunch of alts until they eventually ban you completely. Then you can get even madder and make a bunch of threats and insults against CCP employees. That is the path to freedom! The only way to win EVE.
Intigo
Imperial Academy
Amarr Empire
#33 - 2012-05-27 08:05:05 UTC
Guessing their intentions? No, I'm basing it off a post by a CVA member that states they were planning to do so until the banhammer landed on HYDRA & Outbreak:

https://forums.eveonline.com/default.aspx?g=posts&t=113071&find=unread

Your posting is so aggressive when you know I'm right. :')

hydra provail

Time Funnel
Just a side dish
Outspoken Alliance
#34 - 2012-05-27 08:11:20 UTC
Intigo wrote:
Guessing their intentions? No, I'm basing it off a post by a CVA member that states they were planning to do so until the banhammer landed on HYDRA & Outbreak:

https://forums.eveonline.com/default.aspx?g=posts&t=113071&find=unread

Your posting is so aggressive when you know I'm right. :')


I think you are wrong. Completely in the wrong on this whole issue.

And I also think you are in the minority. You can rally all the noob corp supporters you want, and start as many threads as you want.

You don't have the mass you need to make a threadnaught, and you are slowly alienating the same people who will decide if you are ever let in again.

But it is your life m8. o7

Intigo
Imperial Academy
Amarr Empire
#35 - 2012-05-27 08:24:59 UTC
This is not about gathering support, it's about getting a response from CCP on the issues we've presented to them. You post much like Sreegs, ignoring every fact presented to you only to try and make petty jabs instead.

Also, there were very few threads made by HYDRA people in here. We consolidated most of the questions in already created threads (which were then locked, for no apparent reason).

You seem to be a tiny bit confused.

hydra provail

Dr Robertson
Viziam
Amarr Empire
#36 - 2012-05-27 08:34:36 UTC
Time Funnel wrote:
Intigo wrote:
Guessing their intentions? No, I'm basing it off a post by a CVA member that states they were planning to do so until the banhammer landed on HYDRA & Outbreak:

https://forums.eveonline.com/default.aspx?g=posts&t=113071&find=unread

Your posting is so aggressive when you know I'm right. :')


I think you are wrong. Completely in the wrong on this whole issue.

And I also think you are in the minority. You can rally all the noob corp supporters you want, and start as many threads as you want.

You don't have the mass you need to make a threadnaught, and you are slowly alienating the same people who will decide if you are ever let in again.

But it is your life m8. o7



I doubt they will want to try ever again, there will always be chance they will be banned without proper reasons, they already trusted senior GM and it turned out to be bad decision.

Everyone here knows posts wont change anything in this case, so tbh there is no point in posting here (:effort:), i guess most people who posted already are: hydra/ob members - hydra/ob haters, friends on both sides, trolls + people who appreciate work done by both ally on making eve more interesting place (esp. in solo/skirmish pvp). While following a few community forums i can see most people disagree with CCP on this case, especially on way how CCP handled this one.

Also LuLz @ CCP deleting posts including dev replies.
Ladel Teravada
Caldari Independent Navy Reserve
Curatores Veritatis Alliance
#37 - 2012-05-27 08:44:42 UTC
Intigo wrote:
CVA & 4th were practicing in a wormhole too. They were considering joining a single corporation to facilitate testing just as we did because they thought it was well within the rules (just as we did).


Bah. Gotta answer this.

What actually happened (as I was in charge of communications with CVA) was that we agreed to run a few practices with CVA. We had a system that we were gonna run this in and everything was cool. CVA however was really worried about spies and had a wormhole of theirs setup. They offered us to use it if we wanted and if we needed access to their pos instead of setting up our own, we would have to join them. I said no both to using WH and to joining corp and that was it. A suggestion that was never realized.

But please continue to use this as your favorite personal injustice Intigo. I for one am sad Hydra/Outbreak isn't in as I enjoy fighting you and if we (not very likely at all) win, it won't be without keeping in mind that we never got to meet two of the best teams.
Intigo
Imperial Academy
Amarr Empire
#38 - 2012-05-27 08:50:03 UTC  |  Edited by: Intigo
Ladel Teravada wrote:
Intigo wrote:
CVA & 4th were practicing in a wormhole too. They were considering joining a single corporation to facilitate testing just as we did because they thought it was well within the rules (just as we did).


Bah. Gotta answer this.

What actually happened (as I was in charge of communications with CVA) was that we agreed to run a few practices with CVA. We had a system that we were gonna run this in and everything was cool. CVA however was really worried about spies and had a wormhole of theirs setup. They offered us to use it if we wanted and if we needed access to their pos instead of setting up our own, we would have to join them. I said no both to using WH and to joining corp and that was it. A suggestion that was never realized.

But please continue to use this as your favorite personal injustice Intigo. I for one am sad Hydra/Outbreak isn't in as I enjoy fighting you and if we (not very likely at all) win, it won't be without keeping in mind that we never got to meet two of the best teams.


I was just basing it off the post in question, thanks for clarifying. I am not trying to spin it one way or another, I just feel that the fact that others have felt the rules were very vague was a good indication of how harsh the ruling was after ignoring all attempts at communication.

Why did you decline? Did you feel it was too close to the colluding rule? If so, I guess only CVA was confused about the rule as well as HYDRA & Outbreak.

I am not trying to dig you into a hole here, you guys did nothing wrong - I posted something wrong, my apologies. :) I feel bad for the CVA guys who spent so much time preparing in their wormhole only to have the guy who was supposed to bid for them not actually bother showing up for the auctions, it seems.

hydra provail

michael boltonIII
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#39 - 2012-05-27 08:55:57 UTC
Gunnar and Intigo, if you wish to have a logical argument for your case, I feel I have made a particularly solid argument in post #9 of this thread that has gone completely unaddressed by proponents of your cause.
Ladel Teravada
Caldari Independent Navy Reserve
Curatores Veritatis Alliance
#40 - 2012-05-27 09:01:25 UTC
We declined because honestly... Why bother? The top metagaming teams (and they do exist, trust me.. I received notes from Raivi on Hydra-team at8) are focusing on spying on the biggest/"best" teams. We're not one of them. CVA isn't one of them. No spies ever showed up for our irregular excercises. Another reason is also our pride. We love CVA and they've been among our closest allies for the past 7-8 years, but we don't leave our corps to join another alliance. Not on TQ, not on SiSi. If we had been spied on and went to a WH, we would have set up our own base instead.