These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Missions & Complexes

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
123Next page
 

Level 4s, raven or maelstrom?

Author
Xawiahn Kabej
Brutor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#1 - 2012-04-12 20:27:55 UTC  |  Edited by: Xawiahn Kabej
I know this has been asked a lot of times before, but after using a maelstrom, with my 12mil SP, to do some level 4 missions (a modified version of this since I don't have the cash for the republic gyros) I feel that the tank isn't nearly strong enough to withstand the damage thrown at it, not even whilst boosting.
Once I lost my maelstrom because my drones couldn't kill the warp scramblers faster than my tank was dropping. Because of this I have been reluctant to do any missions alone lately, in fear of losing another ship.

After looking around the net for a bit it I got the impression that the raven was a "much" better ship than maelstrom and started to train towards it.
As off late I've looked around a bit more and it seems like the raven isn't much better than the maelstrom and when comparing my maelstrom fit with a raven fit in EFT, it looks like the tank for the raven is even worse than my maelstrom.

My question is, should I continue to train for a raven in hope that level 4s won't be as hard, or should I continue with my maelstrom?
I don't mind spending more time on a mission as long as I can decrease the risk of losing my ship.
mxzf
Shovel Bros
#2 - 2012-04-12 20:34:05 UTC  |  Edited by: mxzf
How are your support skills? I have a feeling they might be a bit weak and that might be your issue. The Mael and Raven both rely on killing the rats before they're too much for your tank, burst tanking.

Related to that, train up T2 scout drones, they're a must for flying a BS effectively and they will eat up scramming drones with no issues at all.

And, to kinda answer your question, I personally prefer the Mael, but either one can work well if used with the right support skills.
Exploited Engineer
Creatively Applied Violence Inc.
#3 - 2012-04-12 20:57:22 UTC
Xawiahn Kabej wrote:
I know this has been asked a lot of times before, but after using a maelstrom, with my 12mil SP, to do some level 4 missions (a modified version of this since I don't have the cash for the republic gyros) I feel that the tank isn't nearly strong enough to withstand the damage thrown at it, not even whilst boosting.


Of course it's not. It has two invulns that incur stacking penalties instead of two rat-specific hardeners, and no shield boost amplifier.

And if you think this thing has a weak tank, I have some bad news for you: The Ravens tank is even worse. And you'll need to train missile skills, especially cruise missiles, which have few other applications, whereas you can use projectile weapons for basically any task,

tl;dr: Throw out all hardeners in the fit, replace with rat-specific hardeners, fit a shield boost amplifier.
Xawiahn Kabej
Brutor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#4 - 2012-04-12 21:08:07 UTC  |  Edited by: Xawiahn Kabej
mxzf wrote:
How are your support skills? I have a feeling they might be a bit weak and that might be your issue. The Mael and Raven both rely on killing the rats before they're too much for your tank, burst tanking.

Related to that, train up T2 scout drones, they're a must for flying a BS effectively and they will eat up scramming drones with no issues at all.

And, to kinda answer your question, I personally prefer the Mael, but either one can work well if used with the right support skills.

Using T2 Hobgoblins with Drone Interfacing 4. Still my tank dropped way faster than my drones could kill the scramblers.


Exploited Engineer wrote:
Of course it's not. It has two invulns that incur stacking penalties instead of two rat-specific hardeners, and no shield boost amplifier.

And if you think this thing has a weak tank, I have some bad news for you: The Ravens tank is even worse. And you'll need to train missile skills, especially cruise missiles, which have few other applications, whereas you can use projectile weapons for basically any task,

tl;dr: Throw out all hardeners in the fit, replace with rat-specific hardeners, fit a shield boost amplifier.

Using two rat-specific hardeners on my ship and only one adaptive. Should I use three rat specific hardeners instead?
I am lacking the CPU to be able to fit a shield boost amplifier without having to make a big change to the fit. How would you fit your maelstorm?
KardelSharpeye
The Watchtower.
#5 - 2012-04-12 21:57:03 UTC
That fit is great except for a couple of things, always carry light drones in a battleship. I've run a variation of that fit (AB instad of one hardener) and it works great, you probably messed up on the triggers. If you're not confident in your tank lock up the scraming frigates (look them up on eve survival) and pop them while they're aproaching most of the time their transversal should be near 0 so you'll be doing full damage. For a lot of missions 3 mission specific hardeners is the best but there are plenty where you need 2x specific and an invuln. You should also train thermodynamics so you can overheat, it comes in handy and shield boosters can overheat for a while.

I'm also curios, what mission was it that you couldn't kill the frigates fast enough?

Oh and if you're missioning in amarr space you might have an easier time in an armor tanked ship.
Hans Momaki
State War Academy
Caldari State
#6 - 2012-04-12 22:06:24 UTC
If you want a raven, use this fit: http://eve.battleclinic.com/loadout/27770-Perfect-Starter-Lv4-Mission-raven.html

Follow the advices given in that thread + follow EvE-Survival = win
I strongly recommend to get a CNR fast, and a Low cap/medium boost ammount - Shield booster (Gist C-Type XL ftw!)

On top, train support skills asap. Especially sig/explo-radius - skills are needed to get the dmg to fit rigors to get even more dmg!
KardelSharpeye
The Watchtower.
#7 - 2012-04-12 22:30:16 UTC
Hans Momaki wrote:
If you want a raven, use this fit: http://eve.battleclinic.com/loadout/27770-Perfect-Starter-Lv4-Mission-raven.html

Follow the advices given in that thread + follow EvE-Survival = win
I strongly recommend to get a CNR fast, and a Low cap/medium boost ammount - Shield booster (Gist C-Type XL ftw!)

On top, train support skills asap. Especially sig/explo-radius - skills are needed to get the dmg to fit rigors to get even more dmg!


Trying to permarun an X-L booster is stupid and so is that raven fit, that being said investing in cruise missiles is dumb IMO, the only place where you're going to use them is the raven and the CNR, both of which are platforms that aren't good enough to warrant losing time on cruise missiles just for them. Training projectiles will allow him to fly a machariel which is much better for missions than a CNR, it also has the side benefit of unlocking all T2 weapons up to battleship which allows you to fly a ton of other ships well.
Kalli Brixzat
#8 - 2012-04-12 22:41:04 UTC
KardelSharpeye wrote:
Hans Momaki wrote:
If you want a raven, use this fit: http://eve.battleclinic.com/loadout/27770-Perfect-Starter-Lv4-Mission-raven.html

Follow the advices given in that thread + follow EvE-Survival = win
I strongly recommend to get a CNR fast, and a Low cap/medium boost ammount - Shield booster (Gist C-Type XL ftw!)

On top, train support skills asap. Especially sig/explo-radius - skills are needed to get the dmg to fit rigors to get even more dmg!


Trying to permarun an X-L booster is stupid and so is that raven fit, that being said investing in cruise missiles is dumb IMO, the only place where you're going to use them is the raven and the CNR, both of which are platforms that aren't good enough to warrant losing time on cruise missiles just for them. Training projectiles will allow him to fly a machariel which is much better for missions than a CNR, it also has the side benefit of unlocking all T2 weapons up to battleship which allows you to fly a ton of other ships well.


I'm not sure I could disagree any more than I do.

Disclaimer: The Mach is a heck of a bird, so I will not argue on that point.

As for the rest, let's get cracking: Cruise missiles are an EXCELLENT choice for both missions and complex running. In other words, high end PvE. They are also effective in large fleet battles with large ships. The best thing is that you do not need to train "up" to them because missile training doesn't work that way.

As for the Raven/CNR point - they are excellent PvE platforms. Just as missiles are, in general, excellent PvE weapons. Been a while since I flew an arty BS, but I believe cruise missiles (+good skills) will allow you to out-range nearly all rat-damage...while arty will not.
KardelSharpeye
The Watchtower.
#9 - 2012-04-12 22:46:09 UTC
Kalli Brixzat wrote:
KardelSharpeye wrote:
Hans Momaki wrote:
If you want a raven, use this fit: http://eve.battleclinic.com/loadout/27770-Perfect-Starter-Lv4-Mission-raven.html

Follow the advices given in that thread + follow EvE-Survival = win
I strongly recommend to get a CNR fast, and a Low cap/medium boost ammount - Shield booster (Gist C-Type XL ftw!)

On top, train support skills asap. Especially sig/explo-radius - skills are needed to get the dmg to fit rigors to get even more dmg!


Trying to permarun an X-L booster is stupid and so is that raven fit, that being said investing in cruise missiles is dumb IMO, the only place where you're going to use them is the raven and the CNR, both of which are platforms that aren't good enough to warrant losing time on cruise missiles just for them. Training projectiles will allow him to fly a machariel which is much better for missions than a CNR, it also has the side benefit of unlocking all T2 weapons up to battleship which allows you to fly a ton of other ships well.


I'm not sure I could disagree any more than I do.

Disclaimer: The Mach is a heck of a bird, so I will not argue on that point.

As for the rest, let's get cracking: Cruise missiles are an EXCELLENT choice for both missions and complex running. In other words, high end PvE. They are also effective in large fleet battles with large ships. The best thing is that you do not need to train "up" to them because missile training doesn't work that way.

As for the Raven/CNR point - they are excellent PvE platforms. Just as missiles are, in general, excellent PvE weapons. Been a while since I flew an arty BS, but I believe cruise missiles (+good skills) will allow you to out-range nearly all rat-damage...while arty will not.


I'd like a raven/CNR fit (since they're the only ones who use cruise missiles) that outperforms a gunship.
Zhilia Mann
Tide Way Out Productions
#10 - 2012-04-12 22:51:05 UTC
Kalli Brixzat wrote:
As for the Raven/CNR point - they are excellent PvE platforms. Just as missiles are, in general, excellent PvE weapons. Been a while since I flew an arty BS, but I believe cruise missiles (+good skills) will allow you to out-range nearly all rat-damage...while arty will not.


No, they aren't. Raven and CNR are adequate and cruise missiles are honestly some of the worst weapons in the game right now. They do lackluster base damage and have damage application problems. If you're that dead set on range tanking, you might as well just get a Naga. About they only thing they're really good at is negating NPC tracking disruptors.

Put as much time/skilling in to cruises as any other weapon system and the alternative will pretty much always come out ahead.

Having said that, the Raven can do L4s. It isn't fast and it isn't painless, but it will work. The linked fit is **** and from what I recall even Mike has backed off on that one. If you go with a Raven, go cap injection with 3 rigors and 4 BCUs. It's about as tolerable as a Raven is going to get.

I'd personally take a Mael any day if those are the options. You will run in to range management issues if you're not careful, and I'd strongly suggest keeping both AC and arti fits available to change out on a mission-dependent basis.
Kalli Brixzat
#11 - 2012-04-12 22:57:10 UTC
KardelSharpeye wrote:


I'd like a raven/CNR fit (since they're the only ones who use cruise missiles) that outperforms a gunship.


Never said it outperforms. In most cases, it will not. My point was to state that the raven/CNR are good birds if fitted and flown correctly. I've been in plenty of sticky situations in both gun and missile boats. Each have their issues, each their strengths.

For my style, I prefer extreme range combat and the ability to lay hurt without receiving any. I can do that on a regular basis in my CNR, not so in pretty much any gun bot I've ever flown.
Orlacc
#12 - 2012-04-12 23:07:26 UTC
I flew a Mael similar to that and did fine. You are using 800s in the cap booster? Of course rat specific hardeners as mentioned.

"Measure Twice, Cut Once."

Xawiahn Kabej
Brutor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#13 - 2012-04-12 23:36:07 UTC  |  Edited by: Xawiahn Kabej
Using 800 cap boosters and specific hardeners. Can't remember the name of the mission where I lost my ship (Would be good if I did so I could avoid it in the future). Guess I should just try using my maelstrom again and hopefully make enough cash to get a mach or something similar in the future.
drdxie
#14 - 2012-04-12 23:48:48 UTC
My 2 isk.. A raven is easier to use and is quicker to get in to and use effectively. Using guns requires a LOT of support skills to be effective. As to which is ultimately better, will depend on you play style. If you going mach, you going to do a lot of piloting.

Caldari Loving needed.. https://forums.eveonline.com/default.aspx?g=posts&m=1608277&#post1608277

Daniel Plain
Doomheim
#15 - 2012-04-12 23:57:53 UTC
with the information you provided, i cannot explain how you could possibly have tank issues. your tank should be in the 700s and last as long as you have cap booster charges left. you must be doing something wrong, either shooting triggers too soon or shooting the wrong ammo or something. how are your gunnery skills and which faction do you fly against?

I should buy an Ishtar.

Klymer
Hedion University
Amarr Empire
#16 - 2012-04-13 01:57:41 UTC
OP could you please post your character on http://eveboard.com/ so we could have a look at your skills? Saying you have 12m SP tells us nothing honestly as you could have a lot invested in industry. We could then give more specific advice on how to help you since we're all really just guessing as it is. I fly all the ships in question and I'd rather see your char before making any specific suggestions.

Xawiahn Kabej
Brutor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#17 - 2012-04-13 02:49:50 UTC
Klymer wrote:
OP could you please post your character on http://eveboard.com/ so we could have a look at your skills? Saying you have 12m SP tells us nothing honestly as you could have a lot invested in industry. We could then give more specific advice on how to help you since we're all really just guessing as it is. I fly all the ships in question and I'd rather see your char before making any specific suggestions.



http://eveboard.com/pilot/Xawiahn_Kabej there you go. Hope that helps in some way.
Norisha North
Brutor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#18 - 2012-04-13 05:22:42 UTC
IMHO this Mael fitting misses a shield boost amplifier, because of the Meal bonus. I fly mine with cap rigs, 2 Rat specific hardeners, 1 invul and AB. No problem to tank all missions if you are not to stupid with the triggers. And my shield skills are not maxed out.
Gorki Andropov
I Dn't Knw Wht You Wnt Bt I Cn't Gve It Anymre
#19 - 2012-04-13 09:13:34 UTC
My Raven was equipped with the following:

HIGH
06 x Cruise Missile Launcher I
01 x SMALL TRACTOR BEAM 1
01 x SALVAGER I

MEDIUM
04 x LARGE SHIELD EXTENDERS
01 x 'HYPHNOS' ECM
01 x MEDIUM SHIELD BOOSTER

LOW
01 x EMERGENCY DAMAGE CONTROL
01 x ARMOR KINETIC HARDENER I
01 x ARMOR THREMIC HARDENER I
02 x WARP CORE STABILIZER I

DRONES
02 x WARRIOR I DRONES
03 x HAMMERHEAD I DRONES

UPGRADES
01 x ROCKET FUEL CACHE PARTINTION I
01 x BAY LOADING ACCELERATOR I
Babar Baboli
Republic Military School
Minmatar Republic
#20 - 2012-04-13 09:26:59 UTC  |  Edited by: Babar Baboli
I flyt an arty Maelstrom för L4s and I only have around 9m SP and it works just fine.
Rarely have to warp out of missions (the blockade and worlds collide are the only tricky ones)

T2 drones is a _must_ though

[Maelstrom, Arty Mael]
Gyrostabilizer II
Gyrostabilizer II
Gyrostabilizer II
Tracking Enhancer II
Tracking Enhancer II

Domination 100MN Afterburner
'Copasetic' Particle Field Acceleration
X-Large Shield Booster II
Adaptive Invulnerability Field II
Adaptive Invulnerability Field II
Adaptive Invulnerability Field II

1400mm 'Scout' Artillery I, EMP L
1400mm 'Scout' Artillery I, EMP L
1400mm 'Scout' Artillery I, EMP L
1400mm 'Scout' Artillery I, EMP L
1400mm 'Scout' Artillery I, EMP L
1400mm 'Scout' Artillery I, EMP L
1400mm 'Scout' Artillery I, EMP L
1400mm 'Scout' Artillery I, EMP L

Large Semiconductor Memory Cell I
Large Semiconductor Memory Cell I
Large Semiconductor Memory Cell I


Hobgoblin II x10
Hammerhead II x5


I use the domination AB since it use less cap and brings a bit more speed.
123Next page