These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Ships & Modules

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
123Next pageLast page
 

Rifters vs Other Frigates - Other Frigates Useless?

Author
Megos Adriano
Aliastra
Gallente Federation
#1 - 2012-04-05 23:55:32 UTC  |  Edited by: Megos Adriano
Hey guys,

So I've been reading lately about how a certain now prominent alliance rose to power through the might of the Rifter. Chiefly, their pilots were all low SP with very little game experience, but they were able to overwhelming capital fleets with sheer numbers of cheaply fitted Rifters. Volumes have been written on the beauty, power, and utility of the Rifter. I've witnessed (via Youtube) 20 or so Rifters mobbing a carrier and within minutes podding it's pilot.

But the other racial frigates... nary a word is spoken about them. Do they genuinely suck, or have they fallen victim to "numbers optimization"?

If "mixed fleets" are a viable option, then what sort of frigate force would it take to overwhelm and destroy a lone pilot flying in, say, a Hurricane or a Vagabond at a gate camp?

And boom goes the dynamite.

Daniel Plain
Doomheim
#2 - 2012-04-06 00:50:53 UTC
anything can kill anything in high enough numbers. i've seen a fleet of rookie ships chew down a tengu. as for the rifter, it just happens to be in the sweet spot between efficiency and versatility that will make you effective in pvp.

I should buy an Ishtar.

Tarn Kugisa
Kugisa Dynamics
#3 - 2012-04-06 00:55:11 UTC
Kestrel can do the same, just with missiles

Its one of the reasons I love frigs, Low cost, High Utility and you can mob carriers with them.

Be polite. Be efficient. Have a plan to troll everyone you meet - KuroVolt

Megos Adriano
Aliastra
Gallente Federation
#4 - 2012-04-06 01:07:21 UTC
Anyone have any ideas on what the fittings would be for them?

Goal: Take down a Vagabond or a Hurricane without letting them warp away

And boom goes the dynamite.

Perihelion Olenard
#5 - 2012-04-06 01:07:32 UTC  |  Edited by: Perihelion Olenard
I for one won't be in any standard tech 1 gallente frigates. Well, unless I want to haul something quickly. The incursus has only two low slots but three mid slots. The others are a bit blah. Now, the federation navy comet is certainly appealing. I'll fly it once I get gallente frigate five. Pirate frigates are amazing and tech 2 frigates seem to be godly and makes for a fantastic tackler of just about anything. I like the tough frigates, but not the simple tech 1 frigates. It doesn't take much more training to get into a much better frigate. Yes, there is pilot skill involved, but the ship makes a difference, too.
Megos Adriano
Aliastra
Gallente Federation
#6 - 2012-04-06 01:13:27 UTC
Well I was thinking more "newbie friendly"... than T2 frigs.

And boom goes the dynamite.

Andrea Griffin
#7 - 2012-04-06 04:05:55 UTC
I love the Merlin. It is a bit slower, but with a standard MSE fit it has far more EHP than a rifter and does good damage for a frigate. It does better damage at the edge of scram range too, thanks to the optimal range bonus and the recent hybrid buffs. But, the Rifter remains popular because:

A) It looks cooler
B) It requires only one weapons system to be effective; Merlin needs hybrids and rockets.
C) Many people believe that Minmatar in general is an I WIN button and everything else is terrible. They're wrong, though.

Me, I'd take a Merlin over a Rifter any day.
Samroski
Middle-Earth
#8 - 2012-04-06 04:35:56 UTC  |  Edited by: Samroski
Two examples of Rifter fits.

[Rifter, Passive shield tank, AB, no web]
Local Power Plant Manager: Reaction Shield Power Relay I
Local Power Plant Manager: Reaction Shield Power Relay I
Local Power Plant Manager: Reaction Shield Power Relay I

Medium Subordinate Screen Stabilizer I
Limited 1MN Afterburner I
J5b Phased Prototype Warp Scrambler I

150mm Light Carbine Repeating Cannon I,Fusion S
150mm Light Carbine Repeating Cannon I,Fusion S
150mm Light Carbine Repeating Cannon I,Fusion S
Limited 'Limos' Light Missile Launcher,Mjolnir Light Missile

Small Core Defense Field Purger I
Small Core Defense Field Purger I
Small Core Defense Field Purger I

In the following armor tanked fit, you could put a 400mm plate instead of the 200mm and replace the armor rep with a hardner or reactor control unit, and put some projectile weapon rigs instead of the meh ones here, which would probably be better for PvP, as tank hardly matters in fleet battles.

Also note that 200mm autocannons may also be fit.

With the 3-3 mid-low slots architecture, you can play around a lot with this ship's fitting.

[Rifter, Armor tank, MWD]
Damage Control I
Small I-a Polarized Armor Regenerator
200mm Reinforced Steel Plates I

Upgraded 1MN Microwarpdrive I
J5 Prototype Warp Disruptor I
'Langour' Drive Disruptor I

150mm Light AutoCannon I,Fusion S
150mm Light AutoCannon I,Fusion S
150mm Light AutoCannon I,Fusion S
Limited 'Limos' Light Missile Launcher,Nova Light Missile

Small Capacitor Control Circuit I
Small Semiconductor Memory Cell I
Small Semiconductor Memory Cell I

Any colour you like.

Churick
Tai-Chi
#9 - 2012-04-06 06:32:31 UTC
Shocked
Crellion
Nano Rhinos
PURPLE HELMETED WARRIORS
#10 - 2012-04-06 06:55:29 UTC  |  Edited by: Crellion
Megos Adriano wrote:
Hey guys,

I've witnessed (via Youtube) 20 or so Rifters mobbing a carrier and within minutes podding it's pilot.

But the other racial frigates... nary a word is spoken about them. Do they genuinely suck, or have they fallen victim to "numbers optimization"?

If "mixed fleets" are a viable option, then what sort of frigate force would it take to overwhelm and destroy a lone pilot flying in, say, a Hurricane or a Vagabond at a gate camp?



1) Fitting for 20 rifters to kill a (not empty module slot) Carrier is= (a) 19 tank and gank standard Rifters and one Rifter capable of deploying a Nyx / Erebus etc or (b) 18 normal rifters 1 rifter capable of deploying a Bhaalgor/Curse and 1 rifter capable of deploying a Dreadnaught.

2) To kill a Vaga / Cynabal you need 2 to 4 T1 frigs with 3 midslots [say 1x dual prop and scram and 2x ab web scram] with just enough tank to survive the time it takes them to kill 5 light drones. Shoe horning a nos on at least one of the web and scram fitted ones helps. If you have additional frigs fit them for high orbit 100+ dps (@ 20+kms) and some EWAR. Job done.

Edit: You will also need capsuleers to fly them and people on pcs knowing how to point and click effectively for pvp
dethleffs
Immortalis Inc.
Shadow Cartel
#11 - 2012-04-06 10:17:48 UTC
Samroski wrote:
Two examples of Rifter fits.

[Rifter, Passive shield tank, AB, no web]
Local Power Plant Manager: Reaction Shield Power Relay I
Local Power Plant Manager: Reaction Shield Power Relay I
Local Power Plant Manager: Reaction Shield Power Relay I

Medium Subordinate Screen Stabilizer I
Limited 1MN Afterburner I
J5b Phased Prototype Warp Scrambler I

150mm Light Carbine Repeating Cannon I,Fusion S
150mm Light Carbine Repeating Cannon I,Fusion S
150mm Light Carbine Repeating Cannon I,Fusion S
Limited 'Limos' Light Missile Launcher,Mjolnir Light Missile

Small Core Defense Field Purger I
Small Core Defense Field Purger I
Small Core Defense Field Purger I

In the following armor tanked fit, you could put a 400mm plate instead of the 200mm and replace the armor rep with a hardner or reactor control unit, and put some projectile weapon rigs instead of the meh ones here, which would probably be better for PvP, as tank hardly matters in fleet battles.

Also note that 200mm autocannons may also be fit.

With the 3-3 mid-low slots architecture, you can play around a lot with this ship's fitting.

[Rifter, Armor tank, MWD]
Damage Control I
Small I-a Polarized Armor Regenerator
200mm Reinforced Steel Plates I

Upgraded 1MN Microwarpdrive I
J5 Prototype Warp Disruptor I
'Langour' Drive Disruptor I

150mm Light AutoCannon I,Fusion S
150mm Light AutoCannon I,Fusion S
150mm Light AutoCannon I,Fusion S
Limited 'Limos' Light Missile Launcher,Nova Light Missile

Small Capacitor Control Circuit I
Small Semiconductor Memory Cell I
Small Semiconductor Memory Cell I


nice fits bro Straight
Roime
Mea Culpa.
Shadow Cartel
#12 - 2012-04-06 10:34:51 UTC
All races have solid combat frigates. Minmatar and Amarr only have one, Gal & Caldari have two. T1 frigs are generally considered well balanced by those who fly them.

Quote:
I for one won't be in any standard tech 1 gallente frigates. Well, unless I want to haul something quickly. The incursus has only two low slots but three mid slots. The others are a bit blah. Now, the federation navy comet is certainly appealing. I'll fly it once I get gallente frigate five. Pirate frigates are amazing and tech 2 frigates seem to be godly and makes for a fantastic tackler of just about anything. I like the tough frigates, but not the simple tech 1 frigates. It doesn't take much more training to get into a much better frigate. Yes, there is pilot skill involved, but the ship makes a difference, too.


Come again, you are really commenting ships you haven't even flown in combat?

.

ACE McFACE
Federal Navy Academy
Gallente Federation
#13 - 2012-04-06 11:26:13 UTC
Merlins beat Rifters

Now, more than ever, we need a dislike button.

Lunkwill Khashour
Ministry of War
Amarr Empire
#14 - 2012-04-06 13:28:49 UTC
The Rfiter is easiest to fit and very forgiving for having low SP. Other frigs however can be equally or more capable.

Common and strong T1 frigs:
Punisher, Rifter, Kestrel, Merlin, Incursus, Tristan

Axel Greye
Unlikely Suspects
#15 - 2012-04-07 04:17:45 UTC
Besides Tank and DPS, Speed is an important element of t1 frig combat, it control who dictates the pace and range of combat and the Rifter being Minmatar, holds the natural advantage. However, since the Gallente hull buff, I have seen Incursus fits that are on par with Rifter speed/combat capabilities.

Alot depends on the pilot, but assuming all pilots are equal and all fits are correct, I would rate t1 frigs thusly:

1. Cookie Cutter Rifter - Pros: Fast, Versatile, Standard DPS Arrow Cons: Less Tank than most
2. Shield Kestrel - Pros: Highest DPS t1 Frigate, Solid buffer Tank, Rockets Arrow Cons: Lack of speed, Lack of Dictation
3. Railgun Incursus (scram range) - Pros: Fast, Good DPS, Good Range Arrow Cons: Tracking, Only 2 lows
4. Cookie Cutter Tristan - Pros: Versatile, Good DPS, Nice Tank Arrow Cons: Slow, Skill Intense, Can be Kited
5. Cookie Cutter Merlin - Pros: Versatile, Good DPS, Very Nice Tank Arrow Cons: Slow, Can be Kited
6. AC Punisher - Pros: Amazing Tank Arrow Cons: Less DPS than most, Slow, Only 2 Mids
7. Blaster Incursus - Pros: Good DPS Arrow Cons: Can by Kited, Only 2 Lows
Megos Adriano
Aliastra
Gallente Federation
#16 - 2012-04-08 01:13:27 UTC
Axel Greye wrote:
Besides Tank and DPS, Speed is an important element of t1 frig combat, it control who dictates the pace and range of combat and the Rifter being Minmatar, holds the natural advantage. However, since the Gallente hull buff, I have seen Incursus fits that are on par with Rifter speed/combat capabilities.

Alot depends on the pilot, but assuming all pilots are equal and all fits are correct, I would rate t1 frigs thusly:

1. Cookie Cutter Rifter - Pros: Fast, Versatile, Standard DPS Arrow Cons: Less Tank than most
2. Shield Kestrel - Pros: Highest DPS t1 Frigate, Solid buffer Tank, Rockets Arrow Cons: Lack of speed, Lack of Dictation
3. Railgun Incursus (scram range) - Pros: Fast, Good DPS, Good Range Arrow Cons: Tracking, Only 2 lows
4. Cookie Cutter Tristan - Pros: Versatile, Good DPS, Nice Tank Arrow Cons: Slow, Skill Intense, Can be Kited
5. Cookie Cutter Merlin - Pros: Versatile, Good DPS, Very Nice Tank Arrow Cons: Slow, Can be Kited
6. AC Punisher - Pros: Amazing Tank Arrow Cons: Less DPS than most, Slow, Only 2 Mids
7. Blaster Incursus - Pros: Good DPS Arrow Cons: Can by Kited, Only 2 Lows


Can you link these fits?

And boom goes the dynamite.

Liang Nuren
No Salvation
Divine Damnation
#17 - 2012-04-08 19:58:23 UTC
Megos Adriano wrote:

If "mixed fleets" are a viable option, then what sort of frigate force would it take to overwhelm and destroy a lone pilot flying in, say, a Hurricane or a Vagabond at a gate camp?


A pair of Imicuses. A Crucifier and a Kestrel. Tons of options here.

-Liang

I'm an idiot, don't mind me.

Wacktopia
Fleet-Up.com
Keep It Simple Software Group
#18 - 2012-04-09 00:09:30 UTC  |  Edited by: Wacktopia
Megos Adriano wrote:
Anyone have any ideas on what the fittings would be for them?

Goal: Take down a Vagabond or a Hurricane without letting them warp away


Both those ships are very good at killing frigates. They both are likely to have neuts and the former is exceptionally good at dictating transversal and range. Autocannons eat up frigates and to boot they are both very likely to have Warrior II drones (if not EC-300s) so you will need to be on your toes and kill them asap.

To tackle these ships you will need to be fast enough to catch them in the first instance and then hard enough to hit whilst you orbit and kill them. The vaga's weakness is it's low HP so once you scram it you should be able to kill it quickly unless it kills you first. The cane is going to be slower but in the shield-variety will be equally as painful in the damage department.

In terms of ships and fits, an AB-only frigate is unlikely to catch either of those ships unless it starts within 9km of them and gets a scram on. Assuming that is not the case then here is some theory-craft....

I would consider looking into a MWD AF with a scram and a TD as an option, however, their slow speed may still leave you getting kited and splatted by the Vaga in particular. Definitely need a nos on it and even then I think you would need to be very careful how and when you used the MWD.

The other option might be a dual-prop frigate with a scram and again a nos. You would hope to get in close and scram and then mitigate damage with the AB.

But, like I said, both of these ships are frigate-killers.

Edit: If there are a few of you vs 1 then I would get ewar heavy on them. Either loads of EC-300 drones or loads of Tracking Disruptors would probably work well.

Kitchen sink? Seriousy, get your ship together -  Fleet-Up.com

Arzaiuc
Deep Core Mining Inc.
Caldari State
#19 - 2012-04-09 03:08:20 UTC
Rifters are like... 1/2 the power of a faction frigate or a t2 frigate but are 1/10 the price.

They've got enough mid-slots to have prop+full tackle
They've got good dps
They have an okayish tank
They have naturally good speed

The other T1 frigates all have some downfall that make them lousy. The Punisher can't fit prop+full tackle, for example, so nobody uses it since it can't catch anything. But a Punisher could kick a Rifter's ass if, for some reason, the rifter couldn't get away.
Voidfinger
Malevelon Haven
#20 - 2012-04-09 03:44:38 UTC
Megos Adriano wrote:
So I've been reading lately about how a certain now prominent alliance rose to power through the might of the Rifter. Chiefly, their pilots were all low SP with very little game experience, but they were able to overwhelming capital fleets with sheer numbers of cheaply fitted Rifters.


You don't say. Wonder who that can be?
123Next pageLast page