These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

EVE General Discussion

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Battleships: An Elegant Weapon...for a More Civilized Time

Author
Tippia
Sunshine and Lollipops
#21 - 2011-09-26 00:38:25 UTC
mkint wrote:
What I get out of this thread was that the corp/alliance needed a POS bash fleet, but nobody would even train battleships to get the job done. When asked, "speed" was a reason why they wouldn't train one, which for a POS bash is a flat out stupid excuse.
…but you don't train ships for a single fleet. That rather sounds like they're picking tasks that they are not equipped for, or that they are not recruiting for the tasks they are (or are intent on) going on.

You're mixing two different things here. Not wanting to train BS because they're big and slow is a separate matter from picking a ship for one particular outing. So, yes, battleships are not meant to be fast — so why is “they're slow” a bad argument for not training them? It rather sounds like a validation of that argument.
Gul Amarr
Orange County Cruisers
#22 - 2011-09-26 00:42:01 UTC
Maybe they just don't train BS to avoid having to take part in POS bashes?
Hicksimus
Torgue
#23 - 2011-09-26 01:25:48 UTC  |  Edited by: Hicksimus
I'll try to keep this short.

What you found are 20 people that realize the battleship is something you fly if you are one of those big alliance lemmings that likes to fly large ships so people further up the chain can make a massive profit with little to no trickle down.

When they all come bash that pos will they each receive an equal split of moon material production there? Will they each have the option to use 11 lab slots for their 80 days of training they spent on you and countless hours doing the most boring thing in EvE?

Probably not, next problem.


True combat players care about Gate camps, Roaming and Efficiency.

- Battleships are too slow and can't covert cloak you won't get to jump anybody who's near their keyboard.
- When the AAA kitchen sink fleet is derping its way towards you and their scout jumps in if you are in a smaller ship your chances of escape are hugely better than if you have a 10+ second alignment ahead of you
- 4 Battlecruisers rigged and T2 fit cost about as much as 1 Tier 2 BS fit and rigged, but they stand a hugely better chance of escape, they are a cheaper loss and others have less chance of escaping you.

So now some people think heh, Hicksimus, what if I truly enjoy blobbing in Abaddons that I pay for so that others may reap a huge profit? Step back and think how you'd feel in real life as a slave for billionaires being paid $0 and not even fed. You're a troll nobody lets other people do that to them. If your giant alliance didn't hold space you'd be in a smaller corp capable of holding the same small spot you call home and you'd be making more isk.

That was mostly for the OP, I realize that some people get them for Marauders for PvE and Capital ships(like I have) and some people just like to feel big, but people like the OP are just trying to ruin good players for profit.

Recruitment Officer: What type of a pilot are you? Me: I've been described as a Ray Charles with Parkinsons and a drinking problem.

Large Collidable Object
morons.
#24 - 2011-09-26 01:34:46 UTC
Kick those willing to train for a BS because you told them and you'll end up with a corp not full of mindless, blobbing sheep(although I somewhat doubt that's the OPs intent).
You know... [morons.](http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4gjOx65yD5A)
Steph Wing
No Dukks Given
#25 - 2011-09-26 02:04:55 UTC
Name Family Name wrote:

That coming from a member of one of the leading alliances in a coalition that used to be famous for its topsy-turvy rabble fleets is actually quite funny - but yeah - people might change...


Yeah, I know right? I assure you the irony was not lost on me. :D

Anyway, let's see if we can do without the chest-beating of who's part of which alliance bloc. That's what CAOD is for.
Neuntausend
Republic Military School
Minmatar Republic
#26 - 2011-09-26 02:59:51 UTC
Gul Amarr wrote:
Maybe they just don't train BS to avoid having to take part in POS bashes?


wisely spoken. if this game was pos-bashing only, i probably would be willing to pay 15 bucks for not having to play it. Twisted


and then there is the problem, that battleships just lack the versatility that cruiser/battlecruiser-sized ships have. plus - while their use is very limited, compared to medium sized ships, they take a lot longer to train for.

train your advanced medium guns and your race's cruisers, both being x5 skills and you have a good basis for battlecruisers, heavy assault ships, some of the recons and hictors, nice faction cruisers like the cynabal, tech 3 cruisers and even badass in-your-face-command ships further along the line, with recon, hac and battlecruisers each being only a x6 skill. and even a well trained battlecruiser alone is more versatile than a battleship, let alone the lower price.

for battleship you'd have to skill large guns and your races battleships, both being x8 skills, and you get exactly that: battleships with large guns - not more, not less. and if you are not interested in cap ships, marauders or black ops, those skills are a dead end for you.
and i lets face it - both caps and t2 battleships aren't very attractive at the moment. with cap ships it is pretty much the same as with the battleships, if not even worse: very limited use, slow, longer time to skill. and the tech 2 battleships .... well, the one is for carebearing and the other for ninjajumping your fleet around. and while i admit, that the latter one is awesome, for most of the pilots just this single use of a ship is not worth the time it takes, to skill for it.

if flying around in huge bricks, that can't hit anything smaller than an average walmart with parking lot, and even that only when it's not moving is what you want to do - go for it! and if you enjoy shooting huge stationary targets, please feel free to do so. but understand, that most players may choose to dedicate their gametime to more fun and interesting activities.
Headerman
Native Freshfood
Minmatar Republic
#27 - 2011-09-26 03:00:36 UTC
<-- Minmatar BS 5, Caldari BS 5, Gallente BS 5, Amarr BS 5.

I like my BSs.

And as for gate camps, who do you think would win, a dozen Tempests/Geddons, or a dozen BCs?

Australian Fanfest Event https://forums.eveonline.com/default.aspx?g=posts&find=unread&t=90062

Tippia
Sunshine and Lollipops
#28 - 2011-09-26 03:04:05 UTC
Just to go OT for a moment…
Neuntausend wrote:
…that can't hit anything smaller than an average walmart with parking lot, and even that only when it's not moving…
…at 400m sig res, that's a stunningly good (and reasonably accurate) description of how battleship-sized guns perform. I'm going to steal that for future reference. Big smile
Neuntausend
Republic Military School
Minmatar Republic
#29 - 2011-09-26 03:16:09 UTC  |  Edited by: Neuntausend
Headerman wrote:
And as for gate camps, who do you think would win, a dozen Tempests/Geddons, or a dozen BCs?


probably the bcs, as they are locking faster, tracking better and are quicker at running once the locals formed up and the **** starts hitting the fan.

i am not saying that battleships are bad, and that you can't use them for anything besides pos bashing. but most of the time they won't perform much better than a bunch of battlecruisers and t2 cruisers. they have their uses, but they simply aren't worth it for the average player.

with the cruiser skills being x5 and x6 and being at least partially required for battleships, you can skill cruisers, advanced medium guns and 1 or 2 of the battlecruisers/advanced cruisers to V in the same time it would take you to skill large t2 guns and battleships to V. and seing what range of ships you can fly with those skills and the skills you get access to makes the decision easy for many players.


€dit: the battleships might be more interesting, if there were more specialized versions of them, like bs-sized counterparts of the t2- and t3 cruisers. but there aren't any, and to be honest: i don't think, that eve is in desperate need for yet another class of ships just for the sake of keeping the players interested in battleships.
Neuntausend
Republic Military School
Minmatar Republic
#30 - 2011-09-26 03:23:32 UTC
edit-fail
Renan Ruivo
Forcas armadas
Brave Collective
#31 - 2011-09-26 03:26:53 UTC
Neuntausend wrote:
Headerman wrote:
And as for gate camps, who do you think would win, a dozen Tempests/Geddons, or a dozen BCs?


probably the bcs, as they are locking faster, tracking better and are quicker at running once the locals formed up and the **** starts hitting the fan.

i am not saying that battleships are bad, and that you can't use them for anything besides pos bashing. but most of the time they won't perform much better than a bunch of battlecruisers and t2 cruisers. they have their uses, but they simply aren't worth it for the average player.

with the cruiser skills being x5 and x6 and being at least partially required for battleships, you can skill cruisers, advanced medium guns and 2 of the advanced cruisers to V in the same time it would take you to skill large t2 guns and battleships to V. and seing what range of ships you can fly with those skills and the skills you get access to makes the decision easy for many players.


Depends on what kind of gate camp you're talking about. If its a roaming-gatecamp, BC's definatly. If its a planned gate camp in a specific system, with a safespot (like a POS) then tempests/geddons hands down.

Camp tempests and geddons are fitted and rigged to be instalocking, massive alpha monsters. They lock you instantly, and deliver mighty holy wrath from almost 100km away. 5 to 6 of these can wtfpwn any gate, facerape any lone pilot and escape quickly enough to avoid being destroyed if the odds are stacked agaisnt them.


And thats not talking anything about tachyon beam II apocalypses..

The world is a community of idiots doing a series of things until it explodes and we all die.

Abominare
The Hatchery
RAZOR Alliance
#32 - 2011-09-26 04:42:03 UTC  |  Edited by: Abominare
Wot I Think wrote:
So why won't anyone train Battleships?

Twenty plus new pilots, not a single one of them is willing to train battleships.

"I am gonna fly a Tengu"
"I would rather just fly frigates"
"I personally am just gonna do logistics"
"I want a freighter"
"Have Nighthawk, don't need a battleship"
"Sleipnir does everything"
"I don't fly battleships"
"I would train it but I need to get my elite certificates"
"I would rather fly a Hulk"
"I am not in your corp"
"I think a Sac would be better than a battleship, no?"
"All I need is my Drake"
"I fly the drake thats like a battleship"
"If Jeff is gonna fly a Drake so am I"
"Battleships are too slow"
"MWD + Slasher, nuff said"
"I have Caldari Battleship, why do I need another BS?"
"Only reason to train battleships is for carriers and I will never use one"
"It is suicide to fly a battleship outside of high-sec"
"I won't fly a battleship, cause I pay $15 a month, and you can't tell me what to train"
"In all seriousness... you can eat a bag of dicks"
"I won't train it, cause I don't want to train it"

What is the magic hammer argument for "Train a battleship so we can kill POS you dumb mother frackers?"
It would be so cool to have 20 people in Amarr battleships blasting POS to goo, but nobody will train.

I give up Sad




You have to actually give them a good reason to train battleships, if you're only reason to train bships is to shoot at a pos then I'd never train battleships for you. (youre asking for bship skills to do the one of the most boring and inane parts of eve pvp)

Battleships certainly have a time and place but a lot of this depends on your fleet situation and fleet doctrine.

Are you mostly running small gangs? Then battleships are most definitely not for you, unless you're running with an experienced nanogang, in which case you don't want your new guys flying them anyways your seasoned vets, who will inevitably get bored of the their canes and drakes anyways for the chance to do more dmg. Virtually anything else in the small gang arena is asking for a competent fleet to wipe the board with you. (I know you're not because you want amarr)

Are you in a sov holding alliance coalition? Then yes you tell them the price of admission is being able to fit up whatever bship your bloc wants for required ops. They cant/wont fly or train for it? Then you don't want them anyways take their stuff in your space (the fine for wasting your time)and kick them.

You're a carebear corp that occasionally gets war decced? Those battleships will most likely just be kb porn. But hey its your efficiency, but you're better off with a bc gang.

If you're a dedicated pvp (merc/pirate/anti pirate) then you should really work on your recruiting skills to pick out people who fly ships that work with your fleet doctrine.

In all honesty, new people are the last people I'd want flying expensive ships (read ships above bcs) Its pretty standard that no matter how many skill points or supposed experience you have, you will fly frigates until you prove you're not an idiot and have the skills to fully fit t2 on a bc, then you prove you're even better before you fly anything else.
Trainwreck McGee
Doomheim
#33 - 2011-09-26 05:18:17 UTC  |  Edited by: Trainwreck McGee
m
a
e
l
s
t
r
o
m

|


|


|


|


|
instapop

CCP Trainwreck - Weekend Custodial Engineer / CCP Necrogoats foot stool

ShahFluffers
Ice Fire Warriors
#34 - 2011-09-26 05:21:40 UTC  |  Edited by: ShahFluffers
OP... tell your guys this...

"True... you may not use a battleship often, but when you need to use one you REALLY need to use one as few things will substitute a good battleship in a fleet."
Herping yourDerp
Tribal Liberation Force
Minmatar Republic
#35 - 2011-09-26 06:04:39 UTC
meh, frigs, cruisers, and BC ( and t2 varients) are more fun to fly maybe?
Aethlyn
Brutor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#36 - 2011-09-26 08:14:44 UTC
To me this just shows me that - despite whatever people are saying - CCP did a rather good job in making several ship classes interesting and appealing and therefore avoiding everyone just rushing to battleships just to have the biggest ship around. If you want people to fly battleships, get them something interesting to do that can be done in a battleship more effectively (not talking about the POS thingy).

How about something like "Hey, you newcomers? Want to do something together earning lots of isk and having fun? Just train this list of skills, the corp will get you a ship to fly and we'll be heading out bashing some pirates."? Sure, nothing for complete strangers, but for corp mates? Sounds reasonable to me, especially if there's some support or tutorials included, running missions or later on incursions together (even if it isn't THAT effective to do a L4 mission with 2-4 people).

I wouldn't expect sitting there and convincing everyone to fly a battleship just arguing for 1 or 2 minutes or whatever.

Looking for more thoughts? Follow me on Twitter.

Naran Eto
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#37 - 2011-09-26 08:28:08 UTC
I run in a CNR and am thinking of moving to a Navy Scorp (so i can use one of those extra mid slots for an AB :D ) and i love battleships, the one thing that niggles me about them is how slow they move which can be a real PITA for missions with gates a good distance away, and from what i can tell a large majority of people i know that don't like them for exactly that reason, they go for Tengu's instead because although it takes longer to train for and costs a lot more, a tengu can tear its way through level4 missions far quicker than most battleships, so i understand where they're coming from, despite the fact that i will always love my battleships :D
Rico Minali
Federal Navy Academy
Gallente Federation
#38 - 2011-09-26 08:35:37 UTC
Battleships are our fleet ship, you train to fly our fleet, or you lookelsewhere for a corp. This is made clear when you join and guess what? EVERY single corp member can fly or is trainign towards the two battleships we use.

Just make it clear its what you need in your corp, or they are superfluous to your corps needs.

Trust me, I almost know what I'm doing.

Florestan Bronstein
Ministry of War
Amarr Empire
#39 - 2011-09-26 08:41:33 UTC
they don't want to show up in battleships?

just tell them to bring dreads (or supercarriers).
Kunming
Viziam
Amarr Empire
#40 - 2011-09-26 09:01:03 UTC
When in gangs I constantly find my self flying a battleship unless its some specialized gang revolving around a specific tactic, like recon gang or nano gang etc. Amarr BS and pulse lasers are increadibly sweet atm.

Solo, a BS is pretty much out of the question unless its some pimp fit mach or something but then again thats a gank-magnet.

A battleship is a group weapon, once your members can see beyond their futile personal endeavours they will train for it. As I see it your members are too concerned about achieving their own personal dreams.