These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Ships & Modules

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
12Next page
 

A Serious Discussion Around ECM

Author
Btr0n
Integritas
xXPlease Pandemic Citizens Reloaded Alliance.Xx
#1 - 2015-08-03 08:59:11 UTC  |  Edited by: Btr0n
Question: does anyone actually enjoy ECM? Does it provide exciting and dynamic player experiences? or is it only enjoyed through how many tears it may extract from a pilot?

Does it make sense that ECM acts as a counter to all other forums of ewar, when other forums of ewar are negated by certain moduals and tactics?


What are potential ideas for changes to ECM to make it less static and chance based?


My personal idea's are for ECM to be changed to a simple reduction in the number of targets a ship can lock. each modual having a chance to reduce the targeted ships number of locked targets by 1, or even a guaranteed reduction in total targets but always allowing the targeted ship one locked target. (or more for a racial specific jammer just a rough idea)

Or perhaps ecm's should be changed so that each racial modual has 0 strength for other races, perhaps this could be enough of a nerf.


Ive also heard talk of a "hard lock" modual, which would allow a ship to have one target locked regardless of the ammount of ECM being applied to the ship.


Any thoughts? (yes i did just lose a ship to ecm. and yes i did go and refit eccms, and was still perma jammed by an unlinked falcon)
Arla Sarain
#2 - 2015-08-03 09:24:55 UTC
Would rather all ECM change to bursts, with a higher power, and a shorter cooldown. Still 1 per ship.


Then ECM ships would have to maneuver around their own gang/fleet so that they are not caught in the blast, have slots to fit tank and no longer have to be passive on grid and more aggressive instead.
Lan Wang
Princess Aiko Hold My Hand
Safety. Net
#3 - 2015-08-03 09:28:23 UTC
think it should be high slots only

Domination Nephilim - Angel Cartel

Calm down miner. As you pointed out, people think they can get away with stuff they would not in rl... Like for example illegal mining... - Ima Wreckyou*

afkalt
Republic Military School
Minmatar Republic
#4 - 2015-08-03 11:59:47 UTC
Btr0n wrote:
Does it make sense that ECM acts as a counter to all other forums of ewar, when other forums of ewar are negated by certain moduals and tactics?


Apparently you've not have fun with damps.

Suuuuure I CAN get within 10km and lock slower than a titan targetting a linked hobgoblin...that's totally....like...an option.

Other EWAR doesn't afford you a chance, other EWAR offers the ILLUSION of chance, whilst being 100% reliable and effective.

Furthermore, other ewar isn't reliant on either a ****** "omni" module or a special snowflake racial one. I don't see gallente flavoured TDs, for example.
Domino Vyse
FeedingMachine
Good Sax
#5 - 2015-08-03 12:00:00 UTC
ECM should have zero chance of success against mismatched races.
Do Little
Bluenose Trading
#6 - 2015-08-03 12:33:11 UTC
EW is a double-edged sword. There is no reason why you can't bring a Celestis to damp my Blackbird. Fights should be combined arms and make effective use of force multipliers. EW also gives newer players a role where they can make a difference on the battlefield.

If your opponent brings EW and you don't - odds are you are going to lose but the same would be true if they brought logistics and you didn't. The Griffin that manages to jam a Titan for a few important seconds could be the turning point in a battle - and that's the way it should be. As long as the playing field is level and the same options are available to both sides.
Billy Bojangle
Doomheim
#7 - 2015-08-03 14:30:45 UTC  |  Edited by: Billy Bojangle
Do Little wrote:
Griffin that manages to jam a Titan

You were doing so well...

Btr0n wrote:
Question: does anyone actually enjoy ECM? Does it provide exciting and dynamic player experiences? or is it only enjoyed through how many tears it may extract from a pilot?

Does it make sense that ECM acts as a counter to all other forums of ewar, when other forums of ewar are negated by certain moduals and tactics?


There's ECCM and related skills. If you were permajammed by a falcon while ECCM fit, he lucked out. Does this mean ECM is shite because it's so streaky and luck based? I dunno, should we do away with wrecking shots while we're at it?

Is ECM the best game mechanic in EVE, hell no, but I don't see reducing locked target count (unless you could reduce it to zero) being a worthwhile mechanic on the other extreme either.

ECM isn't a counter to all other forms of ewar, really unless they get the first jam off, which the same can be said of damps. Both damps and ecm are decided based on who locks up and gets his load off first. Both a celestis and blackbird can and often will be dumpstered before they can deliver much support unless ~solopvp~ in which case, just about any ewar support would have ****** you besides target painters.

tldr; ECM is like the untanked gank catalyst. It's amazing for a lop-sided gank and otherwise vulnerable to counter play like anything else. Just like that poor ***** freighter pilot who checked dotlan, intel channels, and still got broom-handled on the Udema gate; you got unlucky.
Tsukino Stareine
Garoun Investment Bank
Gallente Federation
#8 - 2015-08-03 17:59:38 UTC
there are plenty of counters to ecm, it's just too powerful in a small numbers situation.

mid to larger size fleets automatically assume ECM will be brought.
Legatus1982
Deep Core Mining Inc.
Caldari State
#9 - 2015-08-03 18:20:01 UTC
Btr0n wrote:
Question: does anyone actually enjoy ECM? Does it provide exciting and dynamic player experiences?


I get special personal pleasure from jamming enemies, and now that I know it has a chance to drop your tears I will try my hardest to find you, and jam your ibis with 5 bz-5s while orbiting you in a scorpion for days.
RavenPaine
RaVeN Alliance
#10 - 2015-08-04 01:45:06 UTC
The thing that makes it NOT OP, is that every fleet has the same opportunity to fly it.

Typical corps and fleets, everyone wants to be the DPS guy, so they have a hard time finding Logi and E-war pilots.
If you step up just a little in fleet organization, Logi or E-war is the next level.
E-war adds another dimension to the game, and I'm glad it's here.

E-war ships are generally primaried. That is an equalizer for having them. It makes them fun to fly, challenging to survive, and great kill mails if you kill them.
I don't fly them for the tears, I fly them to keep my fleet alive.
Mephiztopheleze
Laphroaig Inc.
#11 - 2015-08-04 02:09:03 UTC
Btr0n wrote:
Question: does anyone actually enjoy ECM?

Yes. Me for one.

Btr0n wrote:
Does it provide exciting and dynamic player experiences?

Yes. It can be very exciting flying a flimsy Kitsune that any opponent worth fighting is going to call as Primary.

Btr0n wrote:
or is it only enjoyed through how many tears it may extract from a pilot?

Tears are merely a delicious form of Special Sauce that spice up an encounter.
Being the ECM in my gang, I take joy in helping swing fights our way. I like that my presence in fleet can often give my FC that little extra leeway in choosing what fights to take. I like those times when we demolish an enemy gang that *should* have blown us off field because I managed to jam out their logi or big damage dealers.

I like those times when we're trying to extract from a losing fight and I jam out the enemy tackle and save my mate's ship.

I like being fairly independent in a fleet. I like that I don't anchor-up-follow-broadcasts-hit-F1. I like bouncing around grid like a maddening wasp annoying all and sundry.

I like getting intel on the enemy gang and stacking my jam rack to match (protip: good intel is more valuable than Signal Dispersion V).

Btr0n wrote:
Or perhaps ecm's should be changed so that each racial modual has 0 strength for other races, perhaps this could be enough of a nerf.


If you're going to do that, perhaps you'd also need to radically raise the racial jammer strength?

About the only things you can reliably jam with off-race jammers are frigates.

Btr0n wrote:
Any thoughts? (yes i did just lose a ship to ecm. and yes i did go and refit eccms, and was still perma jammed by an unlinked falcon)


Here's the thing: if you're being perma-jammed, chances are that the ECM pilot has made a significant skill training investment into ECM and/or they're getting lucky on their jams. Signal Dispersion V and Long Distance Jamming V are 5x and 4x skills respectively. I have both and I don't perma-jam everything. Thermodynamics V is also a solid skill for an ECM pilot, I regularly finish a fight with a lot of nearly complete red rings along my midrack.

The most valuable things any EWAR pilot, not just ECM, can have are bookmarks to bounce off and solid intel on the enemy.

Sometimes you get lucky and the critical jam goes off at the right time, sometimes you don't and bad things happen.

If you're having trouble with jams, get some friends along or adjust your targeting priorities to put the ECM boats at the top of the list. If you leave me sitting ongrid in my Kitsune, I will, most likely, totally wreck your day. It's rare for me to survive a fight that our gang lost (and remember: I'm pretty much always the primary)

Forcing me offgrid isn't hard, a single volley from a flight of light drones will put me in deep armour.

Occasional Resident Newbie Correspondent for TMC: http://themittani.com/search/site/mephiztopheleze

This is my Forum Main. My Combat Alt is sambo Inkura

Skelee VI
Appetite 4 Destruction
#12 - 2015-08-04 16:07:13 UTC
I love ecm. It is great part of the game. I been on both ends.
Harrison Tato
Yamato Holdings
#13 - 2015-08-04 17:07:27 UTC
Real 21st century ECM is very effective. I don't see why super duper pretend future ECM shouldn't be the same.
Stitch Kaneland
The Tuskers
The Tuskers Co.
#14 - 2015-08-04 17:18:46 UTC
I find it annoying but thats more my fault for solo play than the mechanics. Or, its annoying to me when i roam in a jaguar, and my opponents want to bring out a kitsune, hyena, and 3 other frigs because they are a bunch of risk averse cowards. That annoys me more than the mechanic itself.

However, ive adapted. Since i fly mainly minmatar i run HG jackals to boost SS. I have a typhoon FI that when ECCM is OH gets over 90 SS. Which makes even "wrecking" jams miss normally.
Seven Koskanaiken
Shadow Legions.
SONS of BANE
#15 - 2015-08-05 11:32:37 UTC
Btr0n wrote:
Question: does anyone actually enjoy ECM? Does it provide exciting and dynamic player experiences? or is it only enjoyed through how many tears it may extract from a pilot?


Replace "ECM" with "ganking".

Now imagine someone had come to the forum making this same post.

What would the response be?
Switch Savage
Center for Advanced Studies
Gallente Federation
#16 - 2015-08-05 13:11:32 UTC
Damps are a million times worse than ECM can ever be. That said i do not have a problem with either.
OverlordY
Interspan
#17 - 2015-08-05 14:26:06 UTC
Seen the o7 Show? Every roam they go on they are perma jammed...

But ECM is Ok...
Moxide Reddredi
Republic Military School
Minmatar Republic
#18 - 2015-08-05 14:35:33 UTC
I wouldn't have a problem with it if it was used correctly

Jamming a ship 1v20 so it cant kill anything while you destroy it is super lame (no hasn't happened to me not a QQ post)

With great power, comes great responsibility
Vimsy Vortis
Shoulda Checked Local
Break-A-Wish Foundation
#19 - 2015-08-05 15:14:16 UTC
I rarely use it, but when I do it is pretty great.
Demerius Xenocratus
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#20 - 2015-08-06 03:28:30 UTC
It's pretty ******, especially when you are already outnumbered and suddenly you don't even get a chance to do anything but die slowly.

Honestly though, I have come to accept that EVE rewards being a risk-averse, seal-clubbing, honorless coward. Join the blob. Love the blob. Bring 10x the necessary firepower whenever you blob something. If there's a bigger blob or the remote chance of a fair fight or they're too linked/snaked to catch, dock up and ship spin or explode freighters in Uedama on your dedicated ganking alt until the odds are once again 100% in your favor, then recommence blobbing.


Such is the path of elite PvP.

12Next page