These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Warfare & Tactics

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Caldari wiped out of FW?

First post
Author
X Gallentius
Black Eagle1
#141 - 2014-09-02 14:11:55 UTC  |  Edited by: X Gallentius
Don't know what the fuss is all about. Most of the time, taking a home system generates a ton of content (Okkamon, Pav/Kinakka, Asakai), and sometimes it doesn't (Heyd, Ladistier). Whatever. We were in "Take Warzone Beast Mode" and accept that one of the consequences was no fights at the end.

The only thing lolworthy here is Squatdog's assessment only because he was spot on in his analysis. The way to beat the blob is to spread out and force fights in many places. The Amarr did this exact thing to the Minmatar when they were down to just Sahtogas and it worked for them. Caldari could have potentially royally griefed us Gallente militia neckbeards if they had employed this strategy BEFORE all the systems were taken. Maybe we would have adjusted, maybe we wouldn't have - we'll never know.

Whatever. Good to see you back. Never thought you'd leave.

I think it's time to add "We didn't want to maintain total warzone control anyways" Big smile

Edit: Also, you guys still have us in total time warzone controlled with a score of about 180 days to 4. Big smile
Squatdog
State Protectorate
Caldari State
#142 - 2014-09-02 16:31:25 UTC
X Gallentius wrote:
Squatdog wrote:
Then you lose the systems in a matter of days because Gallente can't blob everywhere at once...and as we all know, if Gallente can't blob, they can't fight.
If that's true, why didn't you try it BEFORE we took all the systems?

Possible Reasons:
1. Lack of competitive spirit.
2. Enjoy giving up the entire warzone.
3. Wait for Gallente to achieve goal so they don't try as hard.


4. The teeming hordes of stabbed, cloaky farming alts who 'defend' the contested Gal systems for free LP once they get over 30%.

But you already knew that.

Quote:
Just LOL , remind me which systems we lost? hysera and heyd .. 2 systems of UCF/REVO/old man gang and all the Russians pirates of lowsec , did'nt see many calmil in the area when the fell and i don't think calmil has something to do with this sov swap..


Probably because Gallente were blobbing with fleets of 50+ after spending hours running from even fights.

There was a Gallente blob of 17+ attempting to prevent Heyd and Hysera from being flipped, but it got completely slaughtered because they didn't have the magical 2 to 1 odds Gallente need to win at PVP.
Thanatos Marathon
Moira.
#143 - 2014-09-02 16:33:16 UTC
Looks like we got lucky and a nullsec group already joined caldari and are trying to revive them. Hopefully they can cap 20-50 systems quickly and revive some of the other Caldari.
Bad Messenger
Rehabilitation Clinic
#144 - 2014-09-02 16:40:21 UTC
X Gallentius wrote:
Don't know what the fuss is all about. Most of the time, taking a home system generates a ton of content (Okkamon, Pav/Kinakka, Asakai), and sometimes it doesn't (Heyd, Ladistier). Whatever. We were in "Take Warzone Beast Mode" and accept that one of the consequences was no fights at the end.

The only thing lolworthy here is Squatdog's assessment only because he was spot on in his analysis. The way to beat the blob is to spread out and force fights in many places. The Amarr did this exact thing to the Minmatar when they were down to just Sahtogas and it worked for them. Caldari could have potentially royally griefed us Gallente militia neckbeards if they had employed this strategy BEFORE all the systems were taken. Maybe we would have adjusted, maybe we wouldn't have - we'll never know.

Whatever. Good to see you back. Never thought you'd leave.

I think it's time to add "We didn't want to maintain total warzone control anyways" Big smile

Edit: Also, you guys still have us in total time warzone controlled with a score of about 180 days to 4. Big smile


Thing is simple, it is not profitable to plex on tier 1 anymore, so no one does it , game mechanics is broken just like it was last time gallente took all systems.
Crosi Wesdo
War and Order
#145 - 2014-09-02 16:59:06 UTC  |  Edited by: Crosi Wesdo
Bad Messenger wrote:
Thing is simple, it is not profitable to plex on tier 1 anymore, so no one does it , game mechanics is broken just like it was last time gallente took all systems.


But they were fine when you guys held the warzone. Im beginning to notice a pattern!

As for squatdog, i imagine he is just trolling. He wasnt even there for any of the systems that put up a defence. All he did was sit in Ladister for the 13 day campaign keeping it stable as though that was going to stop us.

Okkamon took us nearly a week to capture, numerical superiority swung from fairly even in EU tz, though they often stayed docked due to lack of FC, sometimes we would sit there plexing with 20-25 people in local as they logged in. They would be sat with equal numbers for sometimes 2 hours before making a move. Twice during Okkamon siege there were over 100 squids in 3 separate fleets during US tz compared to our 40-60 number. But ultimately their procrastination in the EU, lack of AU tz and inconsistent US tz cost them the system.
Arla Sarain
#146 - 2014-09-02 17:01:19 UTC
I heard

Gallente
next 36h
Tama
Something
Something

Confirm?
Deacon Abox
Black Eagle5
#147 - 2014-09-02 17:16:20 UTC
Bad Messenger wrote:
Thing is simple, it is not profitable to plex on tier 1 anymore, so no one does it , game mechanics is broken just like it was last time gallente took all systems.

Whereas it wasn't way back when you took the warzone? Roll

To be serious with you BM, we all agree that the lp system is ******. And we've been saying so. But it wasn't lp farmers that plexed your home systems and flipped the bunkers.

Anyway, love the tears of those others that complain about gallente "blobs". Love the claims of "200 Gallente in local" (obviously someone who's overview is so ****** up he can't differentiate between neutrals and Galmil but only sees those that aren't blue or purple to himUgh). Love to see ole' Squat Dog back and posting.

As was just said above, don't worry, you'll have a nullsec alliance join you soon. Eventually your Navy Raven farming hordes will be back and all will be well.Ugh

CCP, there are off buttons for ship explosions, missile effects, turret effects, etc. "Immersion" does not seem to be harmed by those. So, [u]please[/u] give us a persisting off button for the jump gate and autoscan visuals.

Bad Messenger
Rehabilitation Clinic
#148 - 2014-09-02 17:32:24 UTC  |  Edited by: Bad Messenger
Deacon Abox wrote:
Bad Messenger wrote:
Thing is simple, it is not profitable to plex on tier 1 anymore, so no one does it , game mechanics is broken just like it was last time gallente took all systems.

Whereas it wasn't way back when you took the warzone? Roll

To be serious with you BM, we all agree that the lp system is ******. And we've been saying so. But it wasn't lp farmers that plexed your home systems and flipped the bunkers.

Anyway, love the tears of those others that complain about gallente "blobs". Love the claims of "200 Gallente in local" (obviously someone who's overview is so ****** up he can't differentiate between neutrals and Galmil but only sees those that aren't blue or purple to himUgh). Love to see ole' Squat Dog back and posting.

As was just said above, don't worry, you'll have a nullsec alliance join you soon. Eventually your Navy Raven farming hordes will be back and all will be well.Ugh



Back when Caldari took all systems there was no isk/lp reward at all, so making isk was not driving everyone to join one side and farm easy money :).

I bet there is no single Caldari who is mad about losing system for their own farming alts, but thing that even everyone is happy with current easy isk with tier 4 for ever system, it is not still working as game mechanics CCP inteded it to be.
Bad Messenger
Rehabilitation Clinic
#149 - 2014-09-02 17:40:25 UTC
Crosi Wesdo wrote:
Bad Messenger wrote:
Thing is simple, it is not profitable to plex on tier 1 anymore, so no one does it , game mechanics is broken just like it was last time gallente took all systems.


But they were fine when you guys held the warzone. Im beginning to notice a pattern!

As for squatdog, i imagine he is just trolling. He wasnt even there for any of the systems that put up a defence. All he did was sit in Ladister for the 13 day campaign keeping it stable as though that was going to stop us.

Okkamon took us nearly a week to capture, numerical superiority swung from fairly even in EU tz, though they often stayed docked due to lack of FC, sometimes we would sit there plexing with 20-25 people in local as they logged in. They would be sat with equal numbers for sometimes 2 hours before making a move. Twice during Okkamon siege there were over 100 squids in 3 separate fleets during US tz compared to our 40-60 number. But ultimately their procrastination in the EU, lack of AU tz and inconsistent US tz cost them the system.


CCP designed FW on way that isk keeps it flip flopping, but then they nerfed farmers on tier1, so best is to farm on one side with high tier.

If you can do easily bigger plexes you can sure do lvl4 fw missions too , so why to plex with tier1 when you can do missions with tier4.
Crosi Wesdo
War and Order
#150 - 2014-09-02 18:21:08 UTC  |  Edited by: Crosi Wesdo
Bad Messenger wrote:
Deacon Abox wrote:
Bad Messenger wrote:
Thing is simple, it is not profitable to plex on tier 1 anymore, so no one does it , game mechanics is broken just like it was last time gallente took all systems.

Whereas it wasn't way back when you took the warzone? Roll

To be serious with you BM, we all agree that the lp system is ******. And we've been saying so. But it wasn't lp farmers that plexed your home systems and flipped the bunkers.

Anyway, love the tears of those others that complain about gallente "blobs". Love the claims of "200 Gallente in local" (obviously someone who's overview is so ****** up he can't differentiate between neutrals and Galmil but only sees those that aren't blue or purple to himUgh). Love to see ole' Squat Dog back and posting.

As was just said above, don't worry, you'll have a nullsec alliance join you soon. Eventually your Navy Raven farming hordes will be back and all will be well.Ugh



Back when Caldari took all systems there was no isk/lp reward at all, so making isk was not driving everyone to join one side and farm easy money :).

I bet there is no single Caldari who is mad about losing system for their own farming alts, but thing that even everyone is happy with current easy isk with tier 4 for ever system, it is not still working as game mechanics CCP inteded it to be.


So if isk is the driving factor then the mechanic is broken? When will-power and bragging rights are the driving factor the mechanics are sound? No matter how utterly skewed and biased the mechanics actually were?

Well, by that standard we still win. We were at tier 4 before the push, and were at tier 4 now. People didnt earn a great deal of LP in this push. So its pretty clear that our motivation here was the same as your motivation back then. To win, not make isk.

Since the specific mechanics dont matter (by your standards) when judging if mechanics are broken, and all that matters is that occupancy is driven by the will to win and not isk, its pretty clear that our victory is every bit as valid as yours. Well, tbh a lot more valid since more than 20 people dominating the after downtime spawn can play now :)
Bad Messenger
Rehabilitation Clinic
#151 - 2014-09-02 18:37:20 UTC
Crosi Wesdo wrote:
Bad Messenger wrote:
Deacon Abox wrote:
Bad Messenger wrote:
Thing is simple, it is not profitable to plex on tier 1 anymore, so no one does it , game mechanics is broken just like it was last time gallente took all systems.

Whereas it wasn't way back when you took the warzone? Roll

To be serious with you BM, we all agree that the lp system is ******. And we've been saying so. But it wasn't lp farmers that plexed your home systems and flipped the bunkers.

Anyway, love the tears of those others that complain about gallente "blobs". Love the claims of "200 Gallente in local" (obviously someone who's overview is so ****** up he can't differentiate between neutrals and Galmil but only sees those that aren't blue or purple to himUgh). Love to see ole' Squat Dog back and posting.

As was just said above, don't worry, you'll have a nullsec alliance join you soon. Eventually your Navy Raven farming hordes will be back and all will be well.Ugh



Back when Caldari took all systems there was no isk/lp reward at all, so making isk was not driving everyone to join one side and farm easy money :).

I bet there is no single Caldari who is mad about losing system for their own farming alts, but thing that even everyone is happy with current easy isk with tier 4 for ever system, it is not still working as game mechanics CCP inteded it to be.


So if isk is the driving factor then the mechanic is broken? When will-power and bragging rights are the driving factor the mechanics are sound? No matter how utterly skewed and biased the mechanics actually were?

Well, by that standard we still win. We were at tier 4 before the push, and were at tier 4 now. People didnt earn a great deal of LP in this push. So its pretty clear that our motivation here was the same as your motivation back then. To win, not make isk.

Since the specific mechanics dont matter (by your standards) when judging if mechanics are broken, and all that matters is that occupancy is driven by the will to win and not isk, its pretty clear that our victory is every bit as valid as yours. Well, tbh a lot more valid since more than 20 people dominating the after downtime spawn can play now :)


Are you mad about something? is it so hard to admit that once again CCP nerfed victory for gallente, sad thing that they used same method than last time and you do not still get it.
Veskrashen
Deep Core Mining Inc.
Caldari State
#152 - 2014-09-02 18:42:49 UTC
Personal opinion, but folks who claim ISK UBER ALLES as the only valid determinant of the FW mechanics are missing the large number of folks for whom it's KMS UBER ALLES and GUDFITES UBER ALLES and EPEEN UBER ALLES. Sure, Tier and isk/LP ratios matter in terms of sustainability for a lot of pilots, but we Gallente haven't been in it for the iskies. Lots of us in the more active GalMil corps have relied on incursions / exploration / WHs / PI / industry for our isk rather than missions and plexing.

Point being - incentives matter, but the amount of influence they have is exactly how much influence you give them.

We Gallente have a saying: "CCP created the Gallente Militia to train the Fighters..."

Bad Messenger
Rehabilitation Clinic
#153 - 2014-09-02 18:49:23 UTC
Veskrashen wrote:
Personal opinion, but folks who claim ISK UBER ALLES as the only valid determinant of the FW mechanics are missing the large number of folks for whom it's KMS UBER ALLES and GUDFITES UBER ALLES and EPEEN UBER ALLES. Sure, Tier and isk/LP ratios matter in terms of sustainability for a lot of pilots, but we Gallente haven't been in it for the iskies. Lots of us in the more active GalMil corps have relied on incursions / exploration / WHs / PI / industry for our isk rather than missions and plexing.

Point being - incentives matter, but the amount of influence they have is exactly how much influence you give them.


point is that you won war without enemy. ofc some people fight but reason is not always to keep systems, it is just to have fights.
Veskrashen
Deep Core Mining Inc.
Caldari State
#154 - 2014-09-02 20:17:12 UTC
Bad Messenger wrote:
point is that you won war without enemy. ofc some people fight but reason is not always to keep systems, it is just to have fights.

Not our fault if they looked at us and said "Gallente too stronk. Too manly. We run now."

It would have been more satisfying to have a momentous, climatic battle when we finally too Heyd and Lad, but if you don't bother to show up to defend your homes and then say our victory is cheaper as a result... yeah. Doesn't really add up my friend.

We Gallente have a saying: "CCP created the Gallente Militia to train the Fighters..."

Crosi Wesdo
War and Order
#155 - 2014-09-02 20:17:45 UTC  |  Edited by: Crosi Wesdo
Bad Messenger wrote:
point is that you won war without enemy. ofc some people fight but reason is not always to keep systems, it is just to have fights.


Thats kinda ironic. Most of the gallente give caldari props for their warzone domination back in the day, but by your own standards it was meaningless.

You guys won occupancy during the 1h after downtime with the non random spawns, leaving all plex to spawn randomly for the rest of the day. The defensive advantage this presented to defending any system of your choice was paramount to caldari success back then. I doubt there were more than 3 gallente even trying to fight back given how irrelevant the mechanic was.

Im sure you got fights here and there, but i doubt they had anything at all to do with occupancy since hardly anyone ever fought in plexes. On the other hand, i have more than 2x the kills and 3xthe isk destroyed this month than you have ever had in a single month over the last 8 years. And its nearly all occupancy related. Interesting to know who actually did fight to win the warzone huh?

And with regards station lockouts making FW broken, i was against them too. But there is no denying that it killed ****** station games and forces people to come out and fight wheras before there was no penalty for apathy. Also, low-sec was utterly dead before LP for plex and station lockouts.

Only downside is people might have to travel to find pvp, THE HORROR!!!
X Gallentius
Black Eagle1
#156 - 2014-09-03 00:37:21 UTC
So if it was deplexing alts earning massive isk at Tier 4 that kept Caldari at bay, then what happened to those deplexing alts? Why'd they let you guys capture three systems?

Really, it's a combination of deplexing alts and full neckbeard attention to capturing the warzone. One alone can be defeated, but deplexing alts at higher tiers + neckbeards is almost impossible to stop. That's a fair assessment.

Now that we have it out of our system, we can expect the Caldari neckbeards to try to do the same thing to us in a few months.
X Gallentius
Black Eagle1
#157 - 2014-09-03 00:39:55 UTC
Bad Messenger wrote:
point is that you won war without enemy. ofc some people fight but reason is not always to keep systems, it is just to have fights.
Our (fail) leadership at the time did the same thing when you guys took the warzone. They quit at about Aldranette/Esesier and hoped that you'd move on to something else once you took the warzone.

Pinky Feldman
Amarrian Vengeance
Ragequit Cancel Sub
#158 - 2014-09-03 00:52:10 UTC
X Gallentius wrote:
Don't know what the fuss is all about. Most of the time, taking a home system generates a ton of content (Okkamon, Pav/Kinakka, Asakai), and sometimes it doesn't (Heyd, Ladistier). Whatever. We were in "Take Warzone Beast Mode" and accept that one of the consequences was no fights at the end.

The only thing lolworthy here is Squatdog's assessment only because he was spot on in his analysis. The way to beat the blob is to spread out and force fights in many places. The Amarr did this exact thing to the Minmatar when they were down to just Sahtogas and it worked for them. Caldari could have potentially royally griefed us Gallente militia neckbeards if they had employed this strategy BEFORE all the systems were taken. Maybe we would have adjusted, maybe we wouldn't have - we'll never know.

Whatever. Good to see you back. Never thought you'd leave.

I think it's time to add "We didn't want to maintain total warzone control anyways" Big smile

Edit: Also, you guys still have us in total time warzone controlled with a score of about 180 days to 4. Big smile


Yeah, but how many Caldari leaders were actually active that had a reason to do that compared to the number of active Gallente. Saying that Caldari could have done that when the only people with the skills and knowledge to push back a warzone were only there for PVP in an already small room isn't really comparable.

The only reason that I know that your push against little opposition actually took a respective amount of coordination is because our push back took a considerable effort too and the Minmatar militia we faced at the time in my opinion was less motivated than the Gallente militia was as a group. Another big motivating factor for us as well was the fact that the Minmatar wanted to get a medal for the first time. If they were going for a second medal attempt, I highly doubt any of us would have cared enough.
Irya Boone
The Scope
#159 - 2014-09-03 01:23:42 UTC
We knew it !! after all these moanings and crying a 0.0 alliance came to rescue our eternal frenemies :)

Welcome in Pasta , and welcome in leading Calmil they had waited for you to save them

(now they won't have to cynobitch to get some 0.0 alliance to come handle their fights for them , that a goo thing for liquid ozone availabilty Roll

CCP it's time to remove Off Grid Boost and Put Them on Killmail too, add Logi on killmails .... Open that damn door !!

you shall all bow and pray BoB

X Gallentius
Black Eagle1
#160 - 2014-09-03 01:43:32 UTC
Irya Boone wrote:
We knew it !! after all these moanings and crying a 0.0 alliance came to rescue our eternal frenemies :)

Welcome in Pasta , and welcome in leading Calmil they had waited for you to save them

(now they won't have to cynobitch to get some 0.0 alliance to come handle their fights for them , that a goo thing for liquid ozone availabilty Roll

It usually happens right BEFORE we take Ladistier. This time it took three days after... Big smile

Pasta is former Draketrain, so they know what's up - at least Lacco does. Should be some fun pew.