These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

EVE General Discussion

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Role-playing racism

First post
Author
HankMurphy
Pelennor Swarm
Outer Planets Association
#81 - 2014-08-23 14:37:21 UTC
What do you mean... ' you people ' ??

Yang Aurilen
State War Academy
Caldari State
#82 - 2014-08-23 14:42:49 UTC
HankMurphy wrote:
What do you mean... ' you people ' ??



Hush minmatar real people are talking on the people table.

Post with your NPC alt main and not your main main alt!

Riot Girl
You'll Cowards Don't Even Smoke Crack
#83 - 2014-08-23 14:44:03 UTC
CCP Falcon wrote:
Abrazzar wrote:
I guess if you restrict yourself to prejudice described in the lore and only apply it to the appropriate in game races, it would be hard to construct a real life case of racism out of it. Just avoid using terms deemed racist in real life.


Pretty much.


Why does the CCP legal team work with CCP staff instead of CSM? Can't we drop restrictions for this particular environment?
Ion Kirst
KIRSTONE ALLIANCE
#84 - 2014-08-23 20:00:21 UTC
. . . now on another note, I guess it is allowed to make fun of RL challenged people. I have a daughter who has Downs. When I complained to CCP about some bios, they said they'd "look into it". No other responses, the bios haven't been changed.

So, I guess it's hard to see where CCP's morals/ethics are really at. If they allow that, then anything else is OK.

-Kirst


Always remember Tovil-Toba, and what was done there.

SFX Bladerunner
Brutor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#85 - 2014-08-23 21:42:00 UTC
Jenn aSide wrote:
Fictional in game-racism = ok. Real racism directed at other players = not OK.

Pretty simple, however let me say as a IRL person of 'color' it was....not the best thinking on CCPs part to go with the whole 'space slavery' theme then put the ...most ethnic looking New Eden race in the enslaved faction.......


I Disagree.

While current day society we might (openly) frown upon slavery and the concept of 'owning' people, the desire of mankind to accumulate wealth and 'own' all kinds of things hasn't changed.
While there are certain groups of people around that abolish the concept of ownership or wealth accumulation (for example Amish, certain monks and religious groups) most of mankind continues to desire ownership and capitalism runs rampant.

Throughout RL human history slavery has been a pretty constant occurrence and it's only been recently that we've striven to completely abolish it. It would make sense for a fictional world where groups of people are cut off from their homeworld (the New Eden wormhole collapse) would revert back to slavery.

Do not think us so enlightened as to be able to not revert back to slavery were '****' ever to 'hit the fan'.
If you look realistically at current day society and certain anarchistic movements you'd realise slavery is still alive and kicking, only now we call it something else. Workers are owned by their employees. Citizens are owned by their government (which in turn is owned by those wealthy enough to lobby said government into submission).

Greed and desire of private ownership will always facilitate and lead to slavery. Until human nature itself changes, this will not change. The only thing we've learned so far is how to mask this slavery better and pretend it is something else.
Grog Aftermath
Doomheim
#86 - 2014-08-23 22:47:12 UTC
Riot Girl wrote:
CCP Falcon wrote:
Abrazzar wrote:
I guess if you restrict yourself to prejudice described in the lore and only apply it to the appropriate in game races, it would be hard to construct a real life case of racism out of it. Just avoid using terms deemed racist in real life.


Pretty much.


Why does the CCP legal team work with CCP staff instead of CSM? Can't we drop restrictions for this particular environment?



There's nothing to stop people roleplaying someone who's prejudice as long as it's in keeping with the game, i.e. directed at the character and not the person behind the character.

Although roleplaying in such a way always runs the risk that someone will take it personally regardless of your intent. Have to wonder if it's even worth the risk.

Seen roleplayers roleplaying in this manner in another game in relation to PvP, tends to lead to a fairly crappy feel in relationship to the community as it becomes more like gangs and gang mentality.
Arkus Kane
UNN Heavy Industries
#87 - 2014-08-23 23:19:09 UTC
IMO it's like the term "mudbloods" in Harry Potter. It's racist, but it's completely make-believe, so it's not "bad". It's used as an example to demonstrate the unpleasantries of racism.

If I play a pirate, that doesn't (necessarily) mean I'm a murdering psychopath in real life. If you steal money in EVE, a cut-throat world built on deception, that probably doesn't make you dishonest in RL.

Similarly, if I play an Amarr supremacist of some kind, that doesn't make me racist in real life, because I'm essentially role-playing an imaginary bad guy.

I don't really role-play, but Arkus did do missions for the Amarr Empire that involved killing slaves. As a result, I see him as a cold, calculating man who'll take all but the most abhorrent jobs for the cash. He probably sees the Minmatar as traitors, given his Amarr upbringing.

This stuff only crosses the line if you start using real life racist or derogatory language, or really abuse people for no reason with no intelligence or tact.
Tassin en Lone
University of Caille
Gallente Federation
#88 - 2014-08-23 23:37:31 UTC
Ion Kirst wrote:
. . . now on another note, I guess it is allowed to make fun of RL challenged people. I have a daughter who has Downs. When I complained to CCP about some bios, they said they'd "look into it". No other responses, the bios haven't been changed.

So, I guess it's hard to see where CCP's morals/ethics are really at. If they allow that, then anything else is OK.

-Kirst

It's not okay if players make fun of challenged people and I'm convinced that the rules about discrimination ingame include this particular form as well.

In my experience however, you usually get better results confronting the person in question. People don't always think about their choice of wording much. Some of them might not even be aware of how it would be interpreted by those who have to deal with it on a daily basis.

While CCP shouldn't let this one slide, I think they should be a last resort when it comes to social policing.

Carebear Extraordinaire

Ion Kirst
KIRSTONE ALLIANCE
#89 - 2014-08-23 23:53:16 UTC  |  Edited by: Ion Kirst
Tassin, you are probably right. I could have personally contacted the individual/s.

You know what would happen, I'd get cussed at, flipped the bird, told to mind my own business, etc., and then I'd cuss them back as I sank to their level. So, I just avoided all that, hoping that CCP would step up to the plate. They did not.

thanks

-Kirst

Always remember Tovil-Toba, and what was done there.

Chopper Rollins
Republic Military School
Minmatar Republic
#90 - 2014-08-23 23:55:47 UTC
Jenn aSide wrote:
Fictional in game-racism = ok. Real racism directed at other players = not OK.

Pretty simple, however let me say as a IRL person of 'color' it was....not the best thinking on CCPs part to go with the whole 'space slavery' theme then put the ...most ethnic looking New Eden race in the enslaved faction.......


Yeah but Winmatar got all the viking sounding system names and once had a powerful, refined and shiny empire.
Amarr are the story of "We are so great oh hello Jove..." Splat.
Money is the great leveller in EvE, money is worth the same whatever the source and there's no mechanic to limit the buying power of races.
This thread is begging for twisted little racists to indulge their inferiority complexes though.

Goggles. Making me look good. Making you look good.

Cainan Amaro Cathak
Royal Amarr Institute
Amarr Empire
#91 - 2014-08-24 00:01:47 UTC
You're all forgetting:

Amarr get these badass jedi robes.

#amarrprivilege

"Here we are, born to be kings/We're the Princes of the Universe!"

Grog Aftermath
Doomheim
#92 - 2014-08-24 00:09:06 UTC
Cainan Amaro Cathak wrote:
You're all forgetting:

Amarr get these badass jedi robes.

#amarrprivilege



No prejudice there, that's just a cultural difference.
Chopper Rollins
Republic Military School
Minmatar Republic
#93 - 2014-08-24 00:11:32 UTC
Arkus Kane wrote:
Similarly, if I play an Amarr supremacist of some kind, that doesn't make me racist in real life, because I'm essentially role-playing an imaginary bad guy..


This ↑↑↑↑ implies that racism is the action of a bad guy.
The last racist skinhead i saw in Sydney, Australia was in 1994. He was mid thirties, looked intelligent and fit. Squatting looking at the main strip in town he looked wistful, thoughtful and defeated. All kinds and colors of people walking around without a care in the world.
Those people went invisible and wouldn't dare assemble on a streetcorner the way they used to in the 80s, punching whites for walking with 'others'. They were not convinced to put away the costumes and regalia by reason, or well thought out arguments, or appeals to their better nature and human decency. Their victims, mainly asians, applied foot to buttock at every opportunity and in great numbers.
Society regulates behaviour with consequences, just like CCP does. I have always loved this corner of the internets that is largely clear of sectarian static.
Grrgewns





Goggles. Making me look good. Making you look good.

Sentamon
Imperial Academy
Amarr Empire
#94 - 2014-08-24 03:42:53 UTC
HankMurphy wrote:
What do you mean... ' you people ' ??



Easy there Al Sharpton, there's no money to be made race baiting here.

~ Professional Forum Alt  ~

Sentamon
Imperial Academy
Amarr Empire
#95 - 2014-08-24 03:44:31 UTC
Ion Kirst wrote:
. . . now on another note, I guess it is allowed to make fun of RL challenged people. I have a daughter who has Downs. When I complained to CCP about some bios, they said they'd "look into it". No other responses, the bios haven't been changed.

So, I guess it's hard to see where CCP's morals/ethics are really at. If they allow that, then anything else is OK.

-Kirst




Oo oh please. And apparently you have a case of immature.

~ Professional Forum Alt  ~

Herzog Wolfhammer
Sigma Special Tactics Group
#96 - 2014-08-24 03:53:23 UTC
Celthric Kanerian wrote:
CCP Falcon wrote:
Abrazzar wrote:
I guess if you restrict yourself to prejudice described in the lore and only apply it to the appropriate in game races, it would be hard to construct a real life case of racism out of it. Just avoid using terms deemed racist in real life.


Pretty much.



Alright thank you.




There was a thread like this back in 2010 I think - same conclusions were drawn.

The most racism I have seen in Eve lore comes not from the Amarr and their attitude towards Matari, though that is systemic in Amarrian culture. The most racism ever depicted in the Lore was from Heth and the Dragonaurs.

Yeah I know Caldari and Gallente are whitey McWhitebreads for the most part but then racism is not logical to begin with.

Bring back DEEEEP Space!

Jarod Garamonde
Jolly Codgers
Get Off My Lawn
#97 - 2014-08-24 04:53:23 UTC
Herzog Wolfhammer wrote:

Yeah I know Caldari and Gallente are whitey McWhitebreads for the most part but then racism is not logical to begin with.



Considering that the Amarr Empire is twice the population of all four of the other main races, combined, white folks are actually a minority.

And, to be fair, Squids are half-Japanese/half-German, so they're not even really white.
And, aren't Gallente a mix of French, English, and all the Mediterranean ethnicities? I guess that's white-ish. But, not really, because Italians, Greeks, Turks, and whatever people from Monaco are called.... not white.
Minmatar are black Vikings. I don't even understand how it's physically possible to hate them... but, since when do Amarrians make any bleedin sense?

As long as I can still call Caldari "fish-eating squirrel bastards", we're in good shape.

That moment when you realize the crazy lady with all the cats was right...

    [#savethelance]
Sentamon
Imperial Academy
Amarr Empire
#98 - 2014-08-24 05:12:28 UTC
Jarod Garamonde wrote:
Herzog Wolfhammer wrote:

Yeah I know Caldari and Gallente are whitey McWhitebreads for the most part but then racism is not logical to begin with.


Considering that the Amarr Empire is twice the population of all four of the other main races, combined, white folks are actually a minority.


Kind of like in the real world.

~ Professional Forum Alt  ~

Herzog Wolfhammer
Sigma Special Tactics Group
#99 - 2014-08-24 05:39:46 UTC
Jarod Garamonde wrote:
Herzog Wolfhammer wrote:

Yeah I know Caldari and Gallente are whitey McWhitebreads for the most part but then racism is not logical to begin with.



Considering that the Amarr Empire is twice the population of all four of the other main races, combined, white folks are actually a minority.

And, to be fair, Squids are half-Japanese/half-German, so they're not even really white.
And, aren't Gallente a mix of French, English, and all the Mediterranean ethnicities? I guess that's white-ish. But, not really, because Italians, Greeks, Turks, and whatever people from Monaco are called.... not white.
Minmatar are black Vikings. I don't even understand how it's physically possible to hate them... but, since when do Amarrians make any bleedin sense?

As long as I can still call Caldari "fish-eating squirrel bastards", we're in good shape.




Yeah CCP really throws us for loops with the lore behind these races. Every attempt to compare them to a RL race or nation fails too. I have given up on understanding them years ago.

Bring back DEEEEP Space!

Avaelica Kuershin
Paper Cats
#100 - 2014-08-24 05:59:41 UTC
Herzog Wolfhammer wrote:
Jarod Garamonde wrote:
Herzog Wolfhammer wrote:

Yeah I know Caldari and Gallente are whitey McWhitebreads for the most part but then racism is not logical to begin with.



Considering that the Amarr Empire is twice the population of all four of the other main races, combined, white folks are actually a minority.

And, to be fair, Squids are half-Japanese/half-German, so they're not even really white.
And, aren't Gallente a mix of French, English, and all the Mediterranean ethnicities? I guess that's white-ish. But, not really, because Italians, Greeks, Turks, and whatever people from Monaco are called.... not white.
Minmatar are black Vikings. I don't even understand how it's physically possible to hate them... but, since when do Amarrians make any bleedin sense?

As long as I can still call Caldari "fish-eating squirrel bastards", we're in good shape.




Yeah CCP really throws us for loops with the lore behind these races. Every attempt to compare them to a RL race or nation fails too. I have given up on understanding them years ago.


There'd be a good reason for that. If we can't peg the EVE races to any RL races then it's possible to RP (for instance) an anti-Amarr patriot without worrying about coming across as being an RL racist.
At least, that's how I see it.