These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Player Features and Ideas Discussion

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

[Kronos] Mining Barges and Exhumers

First post First post First post
Author
Aalysia Valkeiper
Imperial Shipment
Amarr Empire
#781 - 2014-06-03 00:25:43 UTC
Rowells wrote:
Aalysia Valkeiper wrote:
Hey guys, don't worry.

High-sec mining is done by noobs and care-bears, remember?

These are the people PvPers love to gank, so CCP wants to make it easier for them.

It doesn't matter to CCP that the noobs won't be converting their trial accounts to subscriptions. CCP makes enough money off the Gankers. PvPers who cry if they don't have easy targets (who can't fight back) to pad their killmails with.

I am a player who will ONLY leave High Sec Mining when I leave EvE online.

CCP will NOT convince me to EVER mine in Low Sec or Null Sec until I can operate a ship that can SHOOT BACK when a ganker approaches.

I'm not talking about a warship hull, either. I'm talking about a hull the ganker sees as a juicy, fat miner, but turns out to be hellfire and death to the ganker.

It won't matter if I can actually MINE with that ship as long as that coward ganker finds out miners are no longer guarenteed killmails.

*points at buffed skiff/procurer


CAN...
NOT...
SHOOT...
BACK.
Paranoid Loyd
#782 - 2014-06-03 00:28:59 UTC
Aalysia Valkeiper wrote:
Rowells wrote:
Aalysia Valkeiper wrote:
Hey guys, don't worry.

High-sec mining is done by noobs and care-bears, remember?

These are the people PvPers love to gank, so CCP wants to make it easier for them.

It doesn't matter to CCP that the noobs won't be converting their trial accounts to subscriptions. CCP makes enough money off the Gankers. PvPers who cry if they don't have easy targets (who can't fight back) to pad their killmails with.

I am a player who will ONLY leave High Sec Mining when I leave EvE online.

CCP will NOT convince me to EVER mine in Low Sec or Null Sec until I can operate a ship that can SHOOT BACK when a ganker approaches.

I'm not talking about a warship hull, either. I'm talking about a hull the ganker sees as a juicy, fat miner, but turns out to be hellfire and death to the ganker.

It won't matter if I can actually MINE with that ship as long as that coward ganker finds out miners are no longer guarenteed killmails.

*points at buffed skiff/procurer


CAN...
NOT...
SHOOT...
BACK.


When did drones lose their ability to shoot?

"There is only one authority in this game, and that my friend is violence. The supreme authority upon which all other authority is derived." ISD Max Trix

Fix the Prospect!

Aalysia Valkeiper
Imperial Shipment
Amarr Empire
#783 - 2014-06-03 00:36:06 UTC
I counter that question with another.

When have the drones a miner can carry been able to stop a ganker (unless the ganker is woefully unprepared)?
Paranoid Loyd
#784 - 2014-06-03 00:42:37 UTC
When the procurer/skiff have a 50% drone damage bonus and a properly fit tank

"There is only one authority in this game, and that my friend is violence. The supreme authority upon which all other authority is derived." ISD Max Trix

Fix the Prospect!

Rowells
Blackwater USA Inc.
Pandemic Horde
#785 - 2014-06-03 00:46:31 UTC  |  Edited by: Rowells
Aalysia Valkeiper wrote:
I counter that question with another.

When have the drones a miner can carry been able to stop a ganker (unless the ganker is woefully unprepared)?

guns won't help you then either.

If dps from drones cant kill them in time what makes you think turrets will?

E: also, I have stopped a bomber from killing my rat-tanking mack with only valkyries before. It can be done.
Aalysia Valkeiper
Imperial Shipment
Amarr Empire
#786 - 2014-06-03 00:48:56 UTC  |  Edited by: Aalysia Valkeiper
In the year I have been playing, I have lost 3 Ventures, 9 Retreivers, and four Mackinaws to gankers while mining in high sec (I mine no where else).

Before I retired this character to forum duty, her last loss was a mackinaw with tech 2 drones, shield rigs, shield boosts and shield extenders.

I was watching (and tried to escape while the drones attacked) as a catalyst killed that mack in 7 seconds.

Thankfully, that mack had already paid for itself, but the new rules coming in tuesday will make that even harder.
Paranoid Loyd
#787 - 2014-06-03 00:50:32 UTC  |  Edited by: Paranoid Loyd
None of those were a procurer/skiff Roll

"There is only one authority in this game, and that my friend is violence. The supreme authority upon which all other authority is derived." ISD Max Trix

Fix the Prospect!

Rowells
Blackwater USA Inc.
Pandemic Horde
#788 - 2014-06-03 00:54:16 UTC
Aalysia Valkeiper wrote:
In the year I have been playing, I have lost 3 Ventures, 9 Retreivers, and four Mackinaws to gankers while mining in high sec (I mine no where else).

Before I retired this character to forum duty, her last loss was a mackinaw with tech 2 drones, shield rigs, shield boosts and shield extenders.

I was watching (and tried to escape while the drones attacked) as a catalyst killed that mack in 7 seconds.


you see, theres your problem. You want to be able to tank gankers with a mackinaw. I pointed to the skiff/procurer earlier, but I guess you forgot.Skiff/proc have excellent tank and now even better dps to fend off angry things. You are flying the wrong ship if survivability is your problem.

I have mined in null with skiffs for over a year now and only lost to 1/3 attacks by hostiles.in one situation I killed the attacker. in the other I lasted long enough for help to arrive and scare him off.
Aalysia Valkeiper
Imperial Shipment
Amarr Empire
#789 - 2014-06-03 01:01:49 UTC
give the miners a way to turn the tables on gankers and watch the flow to low sec.

The best way is easy.

Rigs

have a rig that takes so much cargo or ore hold (maybe 1500 m3 for a small one) that warships can't mount it.
make that rig mount a turret for a weapon (a small turret for that 1500 m3 rig)
give flat bonuses ( not % bonuses) to one or more of the following:

Total shield
Shield regen
Total capacitor
Capacitor regen

Such a setup would make even a venture rigged fully a tough costumer for a 'ganker-fitted' destroyer.
That destroyer would have to be fully fitted for combat to fight that venture, but then the ganker would lose a hell of a lot more isk if that ship was destroyed.

That would cause the ganker to hesitate before engaging a miner (is it a disguised combat ship?) and possibly give the true miner a chance to escape.
Rowells
Blackwater USA Inc.
Pandemic Horde
#790 - 2014-06-03 01:08:24 UTC
Aalysia Valkeiper wrote:
give the miners a way to turn the tables on gankers and watch the flow to low sec.

The best way is easy.

Rigs

have a rig that takes so much cargo or ore hold (maybe 1500 m3 for a small one) that warships can't mount it.
make that rig mount a turret for a weapon (a small turret for that 1500 m3 rig)
give flat bonuses ( not % bonuses) to one or more of the following:

Total shield
Shield regen
Total capacitor
Capacitor regen

Such a setup would make even a venture rigged fully a tough costumer for a 'ganker-fitted' destroyer.
That destroyer would have to be fully fitted for combat to fight that venture, but then the ganker would lose a hell of a lot more isk if that ship was destroyed.

That would cause the ganker to hesitate before engaging a miner (is it a disguised combat ship?) and possibly give the true miner a chance to escape.
nobody mines in low because it can be very dangerous and the rewards aren't great.

Venture tanking a ganker? I don't even know where to start, but I'll just say +2 warp core strength is there for a reason.

and for the third time *FURIOUSLY POINTS AT SKIFF/PROCURER*
Aalysia Valkeiper
Imperial Shipment
Amarr Empire
#791 - 2014-06-03 01:08:31 UTC  |  Edited by: Aalysia Valkeiper
Rowells wrote:
Aalysia Valkeiper wrote:
In the year I have been playing, I have lost 3 Ventures, 9 Retreivers, and four Mackinaws to gankers while mining in high sec (I mine no where else).

Before I retired this character to forum duty, her last loss was a mackinaw with tech 2 drones, shield rigs, shield boosts and shield extenders.

I was watching (and tried to escape while the drones attacked) as a catalyst killed that mack in 7 seconds.


you see, theres your problem. You want to be able to tank gankers with a mackinaw. I pointed to the skiff/procurer earlier, but I guess you forgot.Skiff/proc have excellent tank and now even better dps to fend off angry things. You are flying the wrong ship if survivability is your problem.

I have mined in null with skiffs for over a year now and only lost to 1/3 attacks by hostiles.in one situation I killed the attacker. in the other I lasted long enough for help to arrive and scare him off.


were you a solo miner?

I am. I have had several bad experiances joining player corps who promised I would only mine. EVERY SINGLE ONE expected me to jump in a warship and participate in a declared war less than twenty-four hours after I joined. This is AFTER I told them I WOULD NOT PvP.

I am not a Pvp player and I am a solo player. I will stay mining in High sec until I can turn the tables on gankers while pretending to be a solo miner.

My outlook is NOT as rare as you or CCP seem to think it is.

I am aware CCP wants this to be a 'team game' with the corps being the teams
Paranoid Loyd
#792 - 2014-06-03 01:13:57 UTC
I got bad news for you, this is an MMO, if you dont want to play with others you will continue to struggle

"There is only one authority in this game, and that my friend is violence. The supreme authority upon which all other authority is derived." ISD Max Trix

Fix the Prospect!

Aalysia Valkeiper
Imperial Shipment
Amarr Empire
#793 - 2014-06-03 01:24:16 UTC  |  Edited by: Aalysia Valkeiper
That is not news to me.

I am not struggling, BTW.

I just passed off a fleet numbering more than 100 ships to a new character (I don't run game alts, just this forum alt).

That character is quietly and steadily building skills to pilot those ships.

there are 9 BBs, 14 BCs, a freighter from EACH of the main factions, and four orcas in that fleet. The bank account now boasts in excess of 2 billion isk, which I think is good for a solo player.

I know other players can boasts bigger fleets/bank accounts, but I am satisfied, not struggling.

I suspect CCP does not want players to succeed in the manner I have and I couldn't care less.

When they finally force me out of High Sec mining, it will be out of EvE online.

I am more worried about them forcing new players who are testing the game (with trial accounts) to decide other games are better.
Aalysia Valkeiper
Imperial Shipment
Amarr Empire
#794 - 2014-06-03 01:33:12 UTC
Paranoid Loyd wrote:
None of those were a procurer/skiff Roll


which is why EACH of them were paid off before they were ganked.

Macks and retreivers are more productive.
Rowells
Blackwater USA Inc.
Pandemic Horde
#795 - 2014-06-03 01:43:36 UTC
Aalysia Valkeiper wrote:

were you a solo miner?

I am. I have had several bad experiances joining player corps who promised I would only mine. EVERY SINGLE ONE expected me to jump in a warship and participate in a declared war less than twenty-four hours after I joined. This is AFTER I told them I WOULD NOT PvP.

I am not a Pvp player and I am a solo player. I will stay mining in High sec until I can turn the tables on gankers while pretending to be a solo miner.

My outlook is NOT as rare as you or CCP seem to think it is.

I am aware CCP wants this to be a 'team game' with the corps being the teams

yes i was for quite a while, then i eventually gathered myself a few alts to increase my production.

even during my solo times, even if i couldn't fly whatever the doctrine was or i didnt have the ship on hand i would find some way to participate (every fleet can use some cheap tackle or ewar frigs). No one is going to blame you if you do what you can.

You don't want to help defend or fight for the space you are using? then you don't belong there. You could always find a quiet system in NPC null and try there, theres even a new prospect coming out which will make this trivially easy.

Worst case scenario go join provi block. You don't even have to be in one of the corps to use their space last I checked (i used to have my alts there).
Rowells
Blackwater USA Inc.
Pandemic Horde
#796 - 2014-06-03 01:45:06 UTC
Aalysia Valkeiper wrote:
Paranoid Loyd wrote:
None of those were a procurer/skiff Roll


which is why EACH of them were paid off before they were ganked.

Macks and retreivers are more productive.

Theres this idea called "trade-offs". You can't have it all in any one ship. and if you are getting ganked that often it might increase your productivity to switch to a procurer since you will have to pay for less losses.
Aalysia Valkeiper
Imperial Shipment
Amarr Empire
#797 - 2014-06-03 01:59:13 UTC
Rowells wrote:

Theres this idea called "trade-offs". You can't have it all in any one ship. and if you are getting ganked that often it might increase your productivity to switch to a procurer since you will have to pay for less losses.


If I actually believed the Skiff or Procuror would actually survive that ganker, I'd agree.

I'm not saying these Retreivers or Macks are barely paying themselves off beffore they're ganked.

Look at the timing.
That's not very many ganks for a year.
Especially when I have a system developed which could (before this next update) pay off a mack in 10 days.

I'm satisfied with the return rate off my mining in high sec before this KRONOS update.
It may take a while to 'tweak' my system to become productive after this tuesday, but I will.
The gankers hit me too often to be productive, I sure as hell wouldn't be convinced to go to low sec if I can't shoot back.
Aalysia Valkeiper
Imperial Shipment
Amarr Empire
#798 - 2014-06-03 03:45:26 UTC  |  Edited by: Aalysia Valkeiper
Rowells wrote:

yes i was for quite a while, then i eventually gathered myself a few alts to increase my production.

even during my solo times, even if i couldn't fly whatever the doctrine was or i didnt have the ship on hand i would find some way to participate (every fleet can use some cheap tackle or ewar frigs). No one is going to blame you if you do what you can.

You don't want to help defend or fight for the space you are using? then you don't belong there. You could always find a quiet system in NPC null and try there, theres even a new prospect coming out which will make this trivially easy.

Worst case scenario go join provi block. You don't even have to be in one of the corps to use their space last I checked (i used to have my alts there).


first of all, I'm on a scholarship budget. I don't have the funds, the computer, or the desire to run multiple characters at one time.

I used to do PvP. I got my first BB from a fleet fight. I was supporting a dozen other ships with my augoror logistics cruiser. When the enemy finally died, my log cruiser and an armeggeddon were the ONLY remaining ships left. The 'Geddon's player said he would not have survived without my support, so he gave me the BB.

I still have that 'Geddon, though it has now passed thru 3 other characters.

When I tell a corps I want to mine, I'm not expecting to immediately get into a war that was declared before I was even recruited. I'm expecting to MINE.

Yes, I'll defend and even lose ships in the defense, but don't expect me to dedicate my resources and ships to it when you purposely break promises (that I'll be mining) just so I'll be available for a war... especially when I tell you before hand I won't PvP.
Erutpar Ambient
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#799 - 2014-06-03 06:47:24 UTC
Rowells wrote:
you see, theres your problem. You want to be able to tank gankers with a mackinaw. I pointed to the skiff/procurer earlier, but I guess you forgot.Skiff/proc have excellent tank and now even better dps to fend off angry things. You are flying the wrong ship if survivability is your problem.

I have mined in null with skiffs for over a year now and only lost to 1/3 attacks by hostiles.in one situation I killed the attacker. in the other I lasted long enough for help to arrive and scare him off.

Null sec is one thing of course. Using a Skiff anywhere would be the least gankable ship possible. But even in high sec Mackinaws and Hulks are on the ganking menu. Why? Because you can drop a 10mil catalyst on a 200mil+ mack/hulk and get a kill.... IN HIGH SEC! The cost vs EHP is too low.

As you mentioned in one of your situations, you lasted long enough for help to arrive and scare off your attacker. Why should that be limited to just Skiffs? Especially now that they've given it a Drone damage/hp bonus.

Would it really be so bad to give the hulk a tank as great or greater than the Skiff in exchange for losing it's drone bay? With it's small ore bay it wouldn't be the pinnacle solo miner again, but it would be useable in fleet mining unlike now. And with the buffed drones, Skiffs would be able to defend them in fleets since they wouldn't just evaporate immediately. What if Mackinaws got a bonus to Shield Repair Drones?

Wouldn't that make for a pretty cool and dynamic fleet set up?

The way things are now, Hulks are pretty much limited to dead-end null pocket mining with very good intel.
Daichi Yamato
Jabbersnarks and Wonderglass
#800 - 2014-06-03 09:25:39 UTC
Vhelnik Cojoin wrote:

The tanked Hulk fit you posted previously currently has a yield of 1367 m3 / min., while a max. yield Mackinaw hauls in 1718 m3 / min. with little compromise in tank, it costs less and has a much larger ore bay. The Hulk yield buff coming in Kronos won't change this.

A Hulk needs to be fitted for max. yield, or it is pointless to fly one. Saying differently just demonstrates a lack of experience with the subject matter.

PS: Many gankers has started to fit ECCM in their otherwise mostly empty mid slots, something which makes ECM drones even more ineffective.


i suspect my hulk tanks more than that mack, add drones to the hulk (because it can passive tank rats) and the difference in yield is insignificant. After these changes, that tanked hulk will tank more and yield more than a max yield mack.

no ganker ive seen uses eccm on their 2x already utilised mid slots. link the fit of ur mack and mail me these many kill mails with gankers using a dessie with eccm.

if u think mining for nearly 4 years is a lack of experience then sure. cant wait to see this.

EVE FAQ "7.2 CAN I AVOID PVP COMPLETELY? No; there are no systems or locations in New Eden where PvP may be completely avoided"

Daichi Yamato's version of structure based decs