These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

EVE New Citizens Q&A

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
12Next page
 

HiSec mining PEAK of profit?

Author
Ghanima Vorias
Pandemic Horde Inc.
Pandemic Horde
#1 - 2014-04-13 05:48:21 UTC  |  Edited by: Ghanima Vorias
To begin, this isn't a QQ thread, or an OMG HISEC IS GREAT thread. I want in the worse way to get out of CrapSec and see something more enjoyable and actually not revolving around being AFK amongst a bunch of rocks and repetitvely scripted, uninventive, and unengaging missions, I just can't figure this sh** out.

So far I have been mining ice with an ALT in HiSec all the way up to near 6M SP. ALL in industry. Generally the character pulls 100M-150M ISK a day in a few hours. Fairly important since I am a broke bastard trying to scratch by in life and pay for this game purely through ISK, easily I might add.

Skills in ice mining are maxed, I'm not getting anymore out of a barge (ISK/Hr Wise) with any other skill then I am now. Sadly this isnt even a major increase over what I was making at say 3M SP.

Now on this char, I am just sitting under 3M SP. All in combat, mostly battlecruiser + missiles + shields.

The problem is I have tried a bit of EVERYTHING trying to find something that makes close to mining and is at least a bit enjoyable, because circling a rock all day is god damn boring, but it never pans out.

I tried LowSec PVP, turns out that its going to be another 6 months before I am even close to being able to do anything, even with a partner. So lets scratch that, unprofitable, fighting with no chance of winning is just boring as well, and chasing people who warp out/dock on sight of a local blip greatly reduces the pool of targets within my range. +1 Vote for remove F'n local BTW.

Next is wormholes. This one really pissed me off. I thought well, when risk is higher, so should the reward be equally higher. Then if you throw on the amount of effort + the amount of people, not only should this be exciting and fun, but make me get close to my miner. SO I talked to a friend who has very high SP, believe close to 50M, and talked it out. Well he's never on, so he's poor as hell and couldnt afford to bring a BattleShip into wormhole, so I dropped 500M for one for him, wrote it off as an investment in fun and new revenue.

Figured we would take a shot at some relic/data sites. They got to be good if there behind all that right? What did I find? (And yes, using a cargo scanner), nothing valued any higher then doing it in HiSec (Which is pathetically low by the way, like 10K/Hr low)! Not a damn thing was valued in anything higher then a 4 digit number.

Then I figured we would take out some combat sites. Damn were they overwhelming. With me in a drake, and him sitting in a BattleShip, 50M SP into a BattleShip mind you, we were taking FOREVER to clear one site, at least an hour. So it breaks down to roughly 2M more an hour than mining in HiSec by my math.

My question. What. The. F***.

How is it that doing something you can do AFK with little to no effort (not that I AFK when mining, thats bad for profit margins - [Support Code]) is so many times more profitable then something that takes immense amount of effort, hundreds of times more dangerous, and patrolled by armed to the teeth players and rats? I see 100X Risk and 1.01X Reward. In fact I LOSE money when I try to do any of this crap if you take into account the fact that I now have to bring my miner as a salvager / free DScanner and Combat Scanner.

Am I missing something? Is the battlegrounds closing down to a more alluring theme park? Or do you just compensate for fun == no profit with your RL wallet and PLEX? I just can't fathome how HiSec is more profitable then LowSec AND Wormhole. No, this is not a rant about lost ships, or afk cloakers, or not wanting to do it. I never lost a ship in these places due to being diligent and careful, dont give two flying f***s about afk cloakers, and I did try, I mean REALLY tried.

So, what am I missing here?
Chinwe Rhei
Syn Interstellar
#2 - 2014-04-13 06:19:15 UTC
Yes, you seem to not really understand how the game works.

Your minerals are not bought by the game, they're bought by players. So the ammount of money you're making mining represents how much isk other players are willing to give you for your work. It's prefectly balanced risk/reward (ok maybe boredom/reward).
It's like going into some other MMO and complaining about how much gold someone's making trading at the auction house compared to you who kill goblins all day.

Saying that, as you have noticed the maximum ammount of isk you can make mining peaks early, at 6m sp you're maxed out. Lowsec is not very profitable except for faction warfare farming, but once you've built up your ship and character farming combat missions is potentially much more profitable than mining, so is doing incursions, doing nullsec combat sites, living in a wormhole, etc...

Sounds like you went into a wormhole unprepared and then got mad when you didn't come back rich. Calm down, EvE is not ruled by miners.
Ghanima Vorias
Pandemic Horde Inc.
Pandemic Horde
#3 - 2014-04-13 06:27:27 UTC  |  Edited by: Ghanima Vorias
For one, I am not comparing my self to others, I actually am basing my comparisons on my self lol.

I was more pissed that I made less than I did in HiSec, not that I didnt come out rich. That is my concern. That The only way for me to maintain profitability is to cut out the fun.

As for incursions and missions, just not a fan. I made the combat toon for the purpose of higher risk activities because I feel that the fun in this game revolves around the activities that takes place amongst areas of danger. Things that are not static and repetitive. However I just don't see how financially it works when I can make so incredibly much more in HiSec, and the thought of HiSecing it up for the next 6-12 months while a strict plan queue progresses sends chills down my spine. I honestly don't want to be stuck in HiSec simply because I want to PLEX my account with the account I am playing with but every venture into something dangerous and exhilarating is a bust and so far a waste.

If there is something profitable out of HiSec that a person can do I would love to know, right now I just feel like I am treading water, and other times I just feel like I'm drowning trying to achieve venturing out of HiSec.
Baneken
Arctic Light Inc.
Arctic Light
#4 - 2014-04-13 06:29:09 UTC
Okay, now if you want revenues from you minerals you should start looking in to production if you like mining stuff.
also mining in null is hugely more profitable then doing it in high sec, however purely mining in null is like "painting a bullseye on your forehead and shouting that gods are ass-holes in the middle of thunderstorm while wearing a copper armour" (a not so subtle Terry Pratchett quote).

Anyway you can make a good living in WH however doing it solo can only lead to ruin and / or low income.
Lower class WH (up to 3) are soloable any higher and you either get creamed or it takes forever to kill anything also WH effects get stronger the more dangerous the WH is (10% in class 1 vs. 100% in class 6).

Chinwe Rhei
Syn Interstellar
#5 - 2014-04-13 06:55:59 UTC
Ghanima Vorias wrote:
For one, I am not comparing my self to others, I actually am basing my comparisons on my self lol.

I was more pissed that I made less than I did in HiSec, not that I didnt come out rich. That is my concern. That The only way for me to maintain profitability is to cut out the fun.

As for incursions and missions, just not a fan. I made the combat toon for the purpose of higher risk activities because I feel that the fun in this game revolves around the activities that takes place amongst areas of danger. Things that are not static and repetitive. However I just don't see how financially it works when I can make so incredibly much more in HiSec, and the thought of HiSecing it up for the next 6-12 months while a strict plan queue progresses sends chills down my spine. I honestly don't want to be stuck in HiSec simply because I want to PLEX my account with the account I am playing with but every venture into something dangerous and exhilarating is a bust and so far a waste.

If there is something profitable out of HiSec that a person can do I would love to know, right now I just feel like I am treading water, and other times I just feel like I'm drowning trying to achieve venturing out of HiSec.


If you want to make money in dangerous space join a null-sec alliance or wormhole corporation (that is a corp that lives in wormhole space, not just goes there once). That's where the money lies.
Either that or farm FW plexes.

But if you want to buy a PLEX each month whatever you do will involve some farming that's not going to be very fun. That's just the way things are, again you must consider the market, PLEXes are sold by real players for isk, why would they sell something that cost them real money for isk if getting isk was painless.
If you want to pay for your game with isk you're signing up to grind in someone else's place, unless you're one of those clever market players that makes loads of money with speculation.

Ghanima Vorias
Pandemic Horde Inc.
Pandemic Horde
#6 - 2014-04-13 07:32:26 UTC
I dont mind farming. I'de farm relics/datas all damn day if the trash it contained was worth more than 1,000 ISK a piece (Accross all containers in 5 sites so far). I just mind farming HiSec. Its boring and the very idea of "HiSec" in what seems to be a PVP oriented game is broken. Theres no excitement, hell theres not even interaction with the game half the time, and more disturbingly, the more you AFK, the more ISK you make!

I have actually been to WH several times, I scouted it out several times before hand. Just trying to figure where the appeal is after seeing what it has to offer me compared to the carebear alternatives.

Where is the excitement, the fun, AND the reasonability of reward for the amount of work and lack of AFK.

The painful part is that I am tied to a corp, I cant and wont back out, but it is very small. The amount of time it would take getting everyone skilled up and ready for a move to nullsec is absurd, and we are still trying, and then we have to 4 man enough ISK for rent/protection. It's just not feasible as we are already working on the move / alliance choosing and are just not ready for that huge of a change due to low funds and low SP characters (no way to defend a POS). But is HiSec going to be the highlight of EVERYTHING for 6-12 months? No middle ground or a ramp up? Something I can pop out to do and on my own with a very small group and still maintain some reasonable ISK income while we wait and prepare?

I just want one decent idea or point in the direction to something profitable, and not in HiSec, that at least 2 active players can do that doesnt involve AFK'ing in a f'n safe zone. I feel as if that should not feel like such an absurd request without having to have a corp hold my damn hand the whole way.
Daniel Plain
Doomheim
#7 - 2014-04-13 07:42:14 UTC
this may sound wild and unorthodox, but have you ever considered playing for fun instead of farming ISK?

I should buy an Ishtar.

Iria Ahrens
Space Perverts and Forum Pirates
#8 - 2014-04-13 07:45:47 UTC  |  Edited by: Iria Ahrens
[quote=Ghanima Vorias] But is HiSec going to be the highlight of EVERYTHING for 6-12 months? No middle ground or a ramp up? Something I can pop out to do and on my own with a very small group and still maintain some reasonable ISK income while we wait and prepare?

/quote]

err. low-sec?

If you're only making 10k isk average, even in high-sec in relic/data sites, you're doing something wrong. Don't harvest all containers, only the ones that have stuff worth the effort.

Pvp is generally not for income generation.

What to do? Really the question is what not to do. Exploration, trading, mission running, incursions, LP farming, faction warfare.

Also, in the op you said your combat character is focused on BCs? Focus on frigates for pvp, don't move up until you get good at frigates, otherwise you'll just be an easy killmail for someone in a frigate.

My choice of pronouns is based on your avatar. Even if I know what is behind the avatar.

Ghanima Vorias
Pandemic Horde Inc.
Pandemic Horde
#9 - 2014-04-13 07:46:28 UTC  |  Edited by: Ghanima Vorias
Daniel Plain wrote:
this may sound wild and unorthodox, but have you ever considered playing for fun instead of farming ISK?


I'de love to, and thats what I am trying desperately to do, but fun doesnt buy ships and fittings nor does it keep my combat account live on its own.

Iria Ahrens wrote:
[quote=Ghanima Vorias] But is HiSec going to be the highlight of EVERYTHING for 6-12 months? No middle ground or a ramp up? Something I can pop out to do and on my own with a very small group and still maintain some reasonable ISK income while we wait and prepare?

/quote]

err. low-sec?

If you're only making 10k isk average, even in high-sec in relic/data sites, you're doing something wrong.

Pvp is generally not for income generation.

What to do? Really the question is what not to do. Exploration, trading, mission running, incursions, LP farming, faction warfare.

Also, in the op you said your combat character is focused on BCs? Focus on frigates for pvp, don't move up until you get good at frigates, otherwise you'll just be an easy killmail for someone in a frigate.


I actually originally picked up BC's for incursions but then decided against anything even remotely similar to the "WoW" HiSec experience. So I currently am training up for T2 Frigates as we speak.

What in exploration am I missing? Is there something? All I have seen all day was trash in a puzzle box? Is there a trick? Or is WH just crap to begin with?
Lost Greybeard
Drunken Yordles
#10 - 2014-04-13 07:49:17 UTC
If you cannot balance enjoyment/entertainment against sustainability, this is a bad game for you. That balance is quite literally the entire point of the game.

Low-risk/high-profit activities have the lowest entertainment value. High-risk/high-entertainment value activities have the lowest profit margins (PvP in many cases COSTS isk net).

Not to put too fine a point on this, most people have already worked out the basic concept of balancing trade-offs like these before signing up for a game that advertises itself explicitly as an MMO with a strong economic component. If it's beyond you then you should probably have a go at something else... probably a single-player game, honestly, since even MMOs that do have an "every aspect is better" activity (e.g. raiding in WoW) require that you ignore 90% of the game's content to do it.

My recommendation is Borderlands or Borderlands 2. Plenty of min/maxing but with unarguably "superior" gear upgrades mostly rather than managing tradeoffs. Also there's an awesome D&D module expansion in there that's hilarious.
Iria Ahrens
Space Perverts and Forum Pirates
#11 - 2014-04-13 08:00:37 UTC
Ghanima Vorias wrote:


I actually originally picked up BC's for incursions but then decided against anything even remotely similar to the "WoW" HiSec experience. So I currently am training up for T2 Frigates as we speak.

What in exploration am I missing? Is there something? All I have seen all day was trash in a puzzle box? Is there a trick? Or is WH just crap to begin with?


there is a thread on this forum's main page, 4 down that we give help to someone with relic/data sites.

Mining and Mission running are the two most CONSISTENT income generators, with missioning being much better than mining at level 4, especially in teams where one is salvaging while the rest kill stuff quickly and then move on to the next mission.


Really, in general all income generation is considered dull and boring, like doing dailies or whatever. You just choose the one that pays for your losses that is the least aggravating. Trading has the biggest payoff of all, scamming and corporate theivery are probably in close second, mining is generally dead last place. Most people who mine, don't mine because they want to get uber rich, they mine because they enjoy it, kinda like people that enjoy fishing or gardening. wtf?

Exploration is very hit and miss, but should average a couple 100m, assuming you have the playerskills and character skills to do the sites quickly and move. It is pretty horribad at first, but that applies to every income generator in game. There is a growing pains period that will suck, but then things level out later.

My choice of pronouns is based on your avatar. Even if I know what is behind the avatar.

Iria Ahrens
Space Perverts and Forum Pirates
#12 - 2014-04-13 08:07:37 UTC  |  Edited by: Iria Ahrens
Incursions - Good income. But don't think of it as "WOW" hi-sec experience. Incursions is fleet battles, it is preferred by a lot of pvp players because the Fleet experience is similar to a pvp fleet, and the character skills translate well between income generation and pvp, which enables incursion specialists to generate income and play with one character. Although, if you decide to specialize in incursions, you should really skip bc and shoot for BS asap.

Don't feel the need to wait for t2 frigates. T1 frigates are perfectly viable in pvp and with proper player skills and fittings can take out their t2 counterparts. They are also cheaper and easier to support when you don't have a strong income stream.

Anyway, like I said, everything has a growing pains period. What you should do now is explore the different options available and focus on the TECHNIQUES involved and not be to focused on the income amount yet. Do you enjoy the process of exploring or not? If you don't enjoy, or at least tolerate it, it is not worth doing for an income stream.

My choice of pronouns is based on your avatar. Even if I know what is behind the avatar.

Nick Starkey
Native Freshfood
Minmatar Republic
#13 - 2014-04-13 09:21:16 UTC  |  Edited by: Nick Starkey
Mining in highsec is indeed the best isk/effort. Afteral, you can't divide by 0 but it's very close. It also peaks faster than other activities, but stagnates after the point you have access to exhumers and ice harvesters while other activities scale up much further. But there are other activities that potentially pay out much more and can be more interesting than that (from my views anyway). For example I can make twice as much a day as you do by just logging on a trader and spending 30 minutes in the market a day, and you can also easily make the equivalent of ~3 hours of daily mining with just production planets alone (which take like 2 hauling runs a week to sustain).

These are just examples. There is plenty more, like Incursions. Level 4 missions aren't particulary SP intensive and can be an easy source of ~70m ISK/hr with a good LP corp for example. As for highsec being drastically more profitable than low/null. try multiboxing lv 4 FW missions for a faction that's at tier 4 or higher and talk to us again. Cool

You're also forgetting the point of this game... it's to have fun. I can endure a lower isk/hr activity as long as it's entertaining on its own. If this game revolved purely about making ISK everyone would be a trader with 20 multiboxed miners/PI accounts.

I've made a signature. I hope you're enjoying it. www.evetrademaster.com - web based asset manager & profit tracker

Bethan Le Troix
Krusual Investigation Agency
#14 - 2014-04-13 09:26:40 UTC
Lost Greybeard wrote:
If you cannot balance enjoyment/entertainment against sustainability, this is a bad game for you. That balance is quite literally the entire point of the game.

Low-risk/high-profit activities have the lowest entertainment value. High-risk/high-entertainment value activities have the lowest profit margins (PvP in many cases COSTS isk net).

Not to put too fine a point on this, most people have already worked out the basic concept of balancing trade-offs like these before signing up for a game that advertises itself explicitly as an MMO with a strong economic component. If it's beyond you then you should probably have a go at something else... probably a single-player game, honestly, since even MMOs that do have an "every aspect is better" activity (e.g. raiding in WoW) require that you ignore 90% of the game's content to do it.

My recommendation is Borderlands or Borderlands 2. Plenty of min/maxing but with unarguably "superior" gear upgrades mostly rather than managing tradeoffs. Also there's an awesome D&D module expansion in there that's hilarious.


This ^^.

You have three choices as I see it:

1) You and your members join a nullsec corporation.

2) Start paying to play EVE with RL cash subscription. Depending how much you earn in RL or how much of your benefit money you have left spare it only costs about one hours pay to play for one month. I don't consider that expensive and it takes away the hassle of having to worry about saving for the next PLEX for ISK.

3) Play another game. As the guy I quoted said Borderlands is a very good choice. You can pick the game up very cheaply for PC or console and four players can play together. I haven't played it for a while but it is very enjoyable. Big smile
Runini
Deep Core Mining Inc.
Caldari State
#15 - 2014-04-13 10:23:30 UTC
Ghanima Vorias wrote:
For one, I am not comparing my self to others, I actually am basing my comparisons on my self lol.

I was more pissed that I made less than I did in HiSec, not that I didnt come out rich. That is my concern. That The only way for me to maintain profitability is to cut out the fun.


But if your not having fun, then its work (at least to me) and if its work then why do it?
Yarda Black
The Black Redemption
#16 - 2014-04-13 10:31:01 UTC
I would not change a thing. Based on your posts, you have a stable income that doesn't cost alot of effort and with low risk. You also have a combat-character. The way I see it, you appear to be able to fund your PvP and pay for your accounts. Which is an excellent achievement.

I'd say you start hunting/killing stuff while you train skills.

"Come to null so you can get rich" is the most terrible idea ever. Players that do that end up in renteralliances and sit there grinding anoms all day while the rest of us are having fun shooting stuff. The appeal of space outside h-sec is danger. Players there are just way more capable in general, even n00bs. Combine that with "gloves off" and you're up for a proper challenge.
Iria Ahrens
Space Perverts and Forum Pirates
#17 - 2014-04-13 10:49:41 UTC  |  Edited by: Iria Ahrens
Quote:
"Come to null so you can get rich" is the most terrible idea ever. Players that do that end up in renteralliances and sit there grinding anoms all day while the rest of us are having fun shooting stuff.


better to say, players that do that end up sitting in station for weeks afraid to come out because someone is afk cloaking in system.

Poor and frustrated, welcome to null.

My choice of pronouns is based on your avatar. Even if I know what is behind the avatar.

J'Poll
School of Applied Knowledge
Caldari State
#18 - 2014-04-13 11:19:08 UTC
Hmz, so much QQ in the OP, and so many errors:

Low-sec not profitable...obviously haven't talked or looked into FW.

WH not profitable...obviously you are doing it wrong (I know people who make close to 1 bil / hour running sites, the issue is that you have to learn how to do the sites efficiently).


But above all:

DO NOT grind for Pay2Play, EVE is the shittiest job in the world. With your post, it takes you up to 1 complete week to grind for a single PLEX. That is 1 week of playing for $15 (or less with longer subscriptions) / month, that is some crappy income/hour that any parttime job will beat.

And if you need to grind to keep your combat account alive, maybe you should NOT use 2 accounts and use 1 single account.

Personal channel: Crazy Dutch Guy

Help channel: Help chat - Reloaded

Public roams channels: RvB Ganked / Redemption Road / Spectre Fleet / Bombers bar / The Content Club

Baneken
Arctic Light Inc.
Arctic Light
#19 - 2014-04-13 11:28:02 UTC
You know there is that place called providence where if you abide "the laws" and behave like a good citizen, the locals wont shoot you in sight.
If you can rat in lv4's you can survive in null and thats about 6mil SP or maybe 3-6 months or so.

Find the local CVA diplo, get your behind on intel channels and off with your corp to the vastness of null sec though they say Provi is the crappiest space there is but at least it's habited space unlike most of "good" null as a bonus you can even dock in stations in Provi without being blue to holders.
Haedonism Bot
People for the Ethical Treatment of Rogue Drones
#20 - 2014-04-13 11:45:59 UTC
You should give up on the idea of paying for your subscription with PLEX and just play for fun. If you can't afford to pay your subscription with actual money then you may want to consider not playing EVE before you consider grinding your life away for your monthly PLEX.

You seem to be operating under a lot of false assumptions and foolish notions. Until you ask an actual question (rather than just whining), I'm not sure where to begin.

www.everevolutionaryfront.blogspot.com

Vote Sabriz Adoudel and Tora Bushido for CSMX. Keep the Evil in EVE!

12Next page