These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Science & Industry

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Mining ship choices

Author
Reezor
State War Academy
Caldari State
#1 - 2013-12-13 05:21:56 UTC
Okay so I have just returned to Eve after being away for a very long time and have forgotten more than I remember. I was doing some mining but really ended up researching more than anything. I don;t seem to have a big mining ship at all but I do have a little money and a couple PLEX so if I need to sell I can. I figure I will get back in by mining for a while and see what happens.
I have a Raven that I really don't know how to use effectively so here are my questions
For now I will run high sec until I get used to the game again and can work my way to low sec (never did make it to low sec when I played years ago)

1) Should I just outfit my Raven and use that to mine?
2) I have mining barge 5 skill, should I get a ship based on that?
3) I see postings saying the Retriever or Procurer are the way to go. I seem to have the skills to use one of those already also.

What ship do you recommend? what fit/rigs? I will be playing solo if that makes a difference.

I played with a friend back in the day and I do have a badger for transport if that matters at all.

Thanks in advance for any advice, and I hope I posted this in the right place.
Tau Cabalander
Retirement Retreat
Working Stiffs
#2 - 2013-12-13 06:42:55 UTC  |  Edited by: Tau Cabalander
Best for mining in lowsec is probably a Venture Mining Frigate (new ship and skill).

However, if you have Mining Barge 5, you can easily pilot a Procurer or Retriever. The Procurer has more tank, and is less expensive to lose than a Retriever, but a Retriever is also fairly cheap, and has a very convenient large ore hold.

Ship Balancing: Mining Barges
List of newly added skills, sorted by date
Reezor
State War Academy
Caldari State
#3 - 2013-12-13 07:08:54 UTC
Hey thanks for the reply. The links were very helpful also. I think I will try strip mining with a procurer first. It seems with the 200% strip mining bonus I would be more able to get the ore and fill my hold faster in those more hostile environments. The hold on the venture seemed pretty tiny and I would assume that using cans would be the best idea.
please correct me if I am wrong.
I know I can just looks some up but do you have any recommended fits, rigs for the procurer for me?
Do we still benefit a lot from the implants as well?

Thanks again
Selaria Unbertable
Bellator in Capsulam
#4 - 2013-12-13 08:10:45 UTC
This is the retriever fit I use for high sec mining missions (except for the t2 mining lasers, still using t1 due to lacking refining skills for the mining crystals):

[Retriever, Missions - Ore]
Damage Control II
Mining Laser Upgrade II
Mining Laser Upgrade II

Limited Adaptive Invulnerability Field I

Modulated Strip Miner II, Veldspar Mining Crystal I
Modulated Strip Miner II, Veldspar Mining Crystal I

Medium Anti-EM Screen Reinforcer I
Medium Core Defense Field Extender I
Medium Core Defense Field Extender I

About 18k EHP, that's about as tanky as it gets, without sacrificing too much yield. For lower security high sec (0.6 and 0.5) I would recommend a procurer fit like this, if you are afraid of ganks or have gankers in your system:

[Procurer, Ore]
Damage Control II
Mining Laser Upgrade II

Adaptive Invulnerability Field II
Adaptive Invulnerability Field II
Medium Shield Extender II
Survey Scanner II

Modulated Strip Miner II, Veldspar Mining Crystal I

Medium Core Defense Field Extender I
Medium Core Defense Field Extender I
Medium Anti-EM Screen Reinforcer I

Warrior II x5

Switch drones to hobgoblins unless you are mining in minmatar space. With 75k EHP and shield resists of 62% and higher this thing is relatively safe to fly. The ore hold is smaller than the retriever's, but you are much safer.
Selaria Unbertable
Bellator in Capsulam
#5 - 2013-12-13 08:20:19 UTC
Reezor wrote:
Hey thanks for the reply. The links were very helpful also. I think I will try strip mining with a procurer first. It seems with the 200% strip mining bonus I would be more able to get the ore and fill my hold faster in those more hostile environments. The hold on the venture seemed pretty tiny and I would assume that using cans would be the best idea.
please correct me if I am wrong.
I know I can just looks some up but do you have any recommended fits, rigs for the procurer for me?
Do we still benefit a lot from the implants as well?

Thanks again


Basically, all mining barges are bonused in a way, that their yield (without mining barge/exhumer skill bonus) equals 3 strip miners. Retriever/Mackinaw are currently the best solo ships, Procurer/Skiff the tankiest ones (70k EHP are easily possible with both, Skiff even more, with lots of PG and CPU to fit all modules you need).
Due to the increased activity of gankers in certain areas (I've recently moved to a 0.5 system with ice anomalies, and within the past days, have watched several ganks take place, mostly Retrievers and Covetors so far), I would recommend a procurer if you wish to feel safe, otherwise a Retriever if it's a relatively quiet system.
Regarding Implants, yes, we still benefit from those, 5% mining yield resp. 5% decreased ice cylcle time do add up in the long run. If you plan on mining for a longer time, those are worth the ISK imho.
Reezor
State War Academy
Caldari State
#6 - 2013-12-13 15:06:49 UTC
Thanks! I think I am gonna try either the procurer or retriever, can't decide yet which. I have the skills for the ships but lack some for the equipment you listed. I am just a few days away from that so really not bad at all. Great info to work with!
Salpad
Carebears with Attitude
#7 - 2013-12-13 19:28:58 UTC
Reezor wrote:
Hey thanks for the reply. The links were very helpful also. I think I will try strip mining with a procurer first. It seems with the 200% strip mining bonus I would be more able to get the ore and fill my hold faster in those more hostile environments. The hold on the venture seemed pretty tiny and I would assume that using cans would be the best idea.
please correct me if I am wrong.
I know I can just looks some up but do you have any recommended fits, rigs for the procurer for me?
Do we still benefit a lot from the implants as well?


Dude, don't look at the yield multiplier in isolation! Look at the yield multiplier multiplied by the number of strippers you can fit.

One hull can fit 3 strippers, but has a 0% yield multiplier, thus 3 effective strippers.
Another hull can fit 2 strippers, but has a 50% yield multiplier, thus 3 effective strippers.
The third hull can fit 1 stripper, but has a 200% yueld multiplier, thus - again - 3 effective strippers.
Paranoid Loyd
#8 - 2013-12-13 19:55:06 UTC
Reezor wrote:

1) Should I just outfit my Raven and use that to mine?


This Lol

"There is only one authority in this game, and that my friend is violence. The supreme authority upon which all other authority is derived." ISD Max Trix

Fix the Prospect!

Caelestina
0.0 Massive Dynamic
Pandemic Horde
#9 - 2013-12-13 20:13:16 UTC
Salpad wrote:
Reezor wrote:
Hey thanks for the reply. The links were very helpful also. I think I will try strip mining with a procurer first. It seems with the 200% strip mining bonus I would be more able to get the ore and fill my hold faster in those more hostile environments. The hold on the venture seemed pretty tiny and I would assume that using cans would be the best idea.
please correct me if I am wrong.
I know I can just looks some up but do you have any recommended fits, rigs for the procurer for me?
Do we still benefit a lot from the implants as well?


Dude, don't look at the yield multiplier in isolation! Look at the yield multiplier multiplied by the number of strippers you can fit.

One hull can fit 3 strippers, but has a 0% yield multiplier, thus 3 effective strippers.
Another hull can fit 2 strippers, but has a 50% yield multiplier, thus 3 effective strippers.
The third hull can fit 1 stripper, but has a 200% yueld multiplier, thus - again - 3 effective strippers.



All the strippers!
Kate stark
#10 - 2013-12-14 07:36:59 UTC
the moment you put a DC II on a retriever or a mackinaw, i assume you're ********. don't do it.

if you're concerned about your tank, and hence are considering a DC II on your ret/mack just buy a procurer/skiff. the mining yield is identical and the tank is bigger on the proc/skiff.

Yay, this account hasn't had its signature banned. or its account, if you're reading this.

MicDeath Titan
No Mans Corp
#11 - 2013-12-14 09:29:51 UTC
Here are some numbers to help you choose.
Max skills - Ice
Covetor: 168
Hulk: 177
Diff: 9 blocks
Time to cover diff cost: 120 hours high sec ice
Time to cover diff cost: 38 hours top null sec ice
Time to cover base cost: ~50minutes high sec ice
Time to cover base cost: ~15min top null sec ice

Retriever: 158
Mack: 166
Diff: 8
Time to cover diff cost: 111 hours high sec ice
Time to cover diff cost: 35 hours top null sec ice
Time to cover base cost: ~1hour high sec ice
Time to cover base cost: ~20min top null sec ice

Procurer: 143
Skiff: 151
Diff: 8
Time to cover diff cost: 82 hours high sec ice
Time to cover diff cost: 26 hours top null sec ice
Time to cover base cost: ~25min high sec ice
Time to cover base cost: ~7min top null sec ice

The difference between hulk and a procurer is about 6,460,000 per hour in high sec ice weighted avg. and 20,400,000 per hour in the highest null sec ice weighted avg.

In my opinion, the procurer-retriever-and hulk are the best mining ships period.
Procurer due to high tank per isk.
Take this build for example: Cost about 28million, on a character that is freshly made and only skilled up to us it, has 60k OMNI EHP. takes 19 days to do it too. Right off the bat, plug in cybernectic 1-3, remap to max memory with rest int.
then once you fill out the supporting skills it will reach as high as 80k EHP omni, ship fit still only costing ~28mill. you can reach as high as 100k+ omni EHP simply by swaping out the t1 core rigs and replacing em with t2, but that increases the cost little past 100mill per ship.
Major weakness to this build and pretty much all procurers. is being capped. You can safely swap the thermic mod for a cap injector and time each use with the shield cycles as much as you can.
Build
---
[Low]
DCU II
Ice Harvestor T2
[Mid]
Em Ward T2
Thermic Diss. T2
Adaptive inv x2 T2
[High]
Ice harvester t2
REQUIRED IMPLANTS
Genolution: Ca-1, Ca-2

Strengths of this build: It has even resistance spread, on EveHQ shows: 75.87% EM / 72.83% Kin / 77.36% Exp / 80.70% Therm (63.78% if you swap for a cap injector)

Weakness of this build; While cap stable, it can be capped out fairly fast, like all other procurers.
I keep hearing people tell me skiffs are better, better this, better that and so on, but only marginally and have a massive cost to the upgrades they provide. I have yet to find a reason to field a fleet of them.


Retrievers are great due to their low cost and massive ore holds. If you can mine safely I'd recommend the retriever above all else.
An ok build is:
[Low]
DCU II
Ice harvester Upgrade x2 T2
[Mid]
Empty - put in anything you want here, as long as it keeps you cap stable
[High]
Ice Harvestor x2 T2
15k EHP Omni, and it costs only ~40mill per ship. The Tank on it is not very high, but it is enough to help you survive a solo gank.

Hulk is a fleet ship. Fit for the operation. If there is going to be a mining operation where hulks are involved, it better come with security. If fit for tank, they are only slightly better than a procurer, and I do mean SLIGHTLY. At this point the procurer overshadows the hulk massively. So it is pretty much required to fit for mining yield/speed.
If there is no security, downgrade to a retriever if safe, or a procurer. There is simply no reason to field a very expensive fleet if there is no security.
Reezor
State War Academy
Caldari State
#12 - 2013-12-14 16:47:12 UTC
Some great info here guys. Thanks for taking the time!!
Gislin D'ahl
Perkone
Caldari State
#13 - 2013-12-15 07:29:24 UTC
Reezor wrote:
Okay so I have just returned to Eve after being away for a very long time and have forgotten more than I remember. I was doing some mining but really ended up researching more than anything. I don;t seem to have a big mining ship at all but I do have a little money and a couple PLEX so if I need to sell I can. I figure I will get back in by mining for a while and see what happens.
I have a Raven that I really don't know how to use effectively so here are my questions
For now I will run high sec until I get used to the game again and can work my way to low sec (never did make it to low sec when I played years ago)

1) Should I just outfit my Raven and use that to mine?
2) I have mining barge 5 skill, should I get a ship based on that?
3) I see postings saying the Retriever or Procurer are the way to go. I seem to have the skills to use one of those already also.

What ship do you recommend? what fit/rigs? I will be playing solo if that makes a difference.

I played with a friend back in the day and I do have a badger for transport if that matters at all.

Thanks in advance for any advice, and I hope I posted this in the right place.


Don't use your Raven to mine.

Use a Procurer or Retriever in high sec. Use a Procurer when you're not in a (friendly) group. Use a retriever when you're part of a fleet. Make sure to install some tanky modules to fend off the NPC rats and maybe last long enough to flee if gankers show up.

The badger is useful if you're hauling in a fleet or to sell your ore when you're done. If you can afford one, a Kryos or Miasmos is "better" just for the hauling ore/minerals part. A badger is always great for hauling other stuff.

You'll want to do some missions to build standings with useful NPC corps. The corps you choose will be based on what use you want to make of them. At a minimum, having standings with corps with a selection of L4 security missions, at least a couple R&D agents, and a good selection of 50% refining stations can't hurt anything, even if you don't decide to stick with mining. I'd suggest Kaalakiota if you have no idea what corps to look at. I've found found their stations in at least three of the racial empires.

When you move to low sec, you can either use a nimble and slippery Venture (with its tiny ore hold) or a Procurer. I wouldn't use either a Retriever or Covetor in low sec.

Since you're returning after a long break and you don't have an existing network of friends, considering joining the Eve University. It's a great resource and you'll find people willing and able to teach you all the elements of Eve. We have a specialized mining group as well as campuses in Low and Null Sec...and even a Wormhole group. We have lessons for every activity in Eve. You don't have to be super social to be a member, I'm part of the mining campus but I spend a fair amount of time doing things on my own. When I'm feeling in a social mood I'll fleet up in a mining op or run missions with other campus members.

Welcome back to eve and most importantly, have fun while you're fl

Reezor
State War Academy
Caldari State
#14 - 2013-12-15 18:47:51 UTC
Gislin D'ahl wrote:


Don't use your Raven to mine.

Use a Procurer or Retriever in high sec. Use a Procurer when you're not in a (friendly) group. Use a retriever when you're part of a fleet. Make sure to install some tanky modules to fend off the NPC rats and maybe last long enough to flee if gankers show up.

The badger is useful if you're hauling in a fleet or to sell your ore when you're done. If you can afford one, a Kryos or Miasmos is "better" just for the hauling ore/minerals part. A badger is always great for hauling other stuff.

You'll want to do some missions to build standings with useful NPC corps. The corps you choose will be based on what use you want to make of them. At a minimum, having standings with corps with a selection of L4 security missions, at least a couple R&D agents, and a good selection of 50% refining stations can't hurt anything, even if you don't decide to stick with mining. I'd suggest Kaalakiota if you have no idea what corps to look at. I've found found their stations in at least three of the racial empires.

When you move to low sec, you can either use a nimble and slippery Venture (with its tiny ore hold) or a Procurer. I wouldn't use either a Retriever or Covetor in low sec.

Since you're returning after a long break and you don't have an existing network of friends, considering joining the Eve University. It's a great resource and you'll find people willing and able to teach you all the elements of Eve. We have a specialized mining group as well as campuses in Low and Null Sec...and even a Wormhole group. We have lessons for every activity in Eve. You don't have to be super social to be a member, I'm part of the mining campus but I spend a fair amount of time doing things on my own. When I'm feeling in a social mood I'll fleet up in a mining op or run missions with other campus members.

Welcome back to eve and most importantly, have fun while you're fl



Hey thanks for the good advice. I will join the EVE University as I am already having more questions about the types of asteroids and such that I am sure people can answer easily in game. I also think it would be a great way to get introduced to low and null sec since I have never been there.
I didn't realize running missions could make a difference in mining either.
Bethan Le Troix
Krusual Investigation Agency
#15 - 2013-12-15 22:57:22 UTC
Mostly great info here but always be aware of misinformation. Twisted Notably Kate Starks comment about NOT fitting a DCII or tank on your mining vessel. Certainly on a Mackinaw you will want to fit a Damage Control II module as a bare minimum. So many mining ships nowadays fit no tank at all and are suicide ganked as a result. Mackinaws are not cheap to replace.

Also no one mines in low sec. Anything you can find as far as ores are concerned can be found in high sec nowadays. As for nullsec you won't probably have the connections to do that. Most mining in nullsec happens in 'deep blue' ie deep in alliance controlled territory.
Gislin D'ahl
Perkone
Caldari State
#16 - 2013-12-16 05:10:18 UTC  |  Edited by: Gislin D'ahl
Selaria Unbertable wrote:
This is the retriever fit I use for high sec mining missions (except for the t2 mining lasers, still using t1 due to lacking refining skills for the mining crystals):

Switch drones to hobgoblins unless you are mining in minmatar space. With 75k EHP and shield resists of 62% and higher this thing is relatively safe to fly. The ore hold is smaller than the retriever's, but you are much safer.


For any high sec space, you can get by with only one or two scout drones (I usually fly with only 1 since I have T2 scouts). You don't necessarily want your drones for defense against gankers. They're probably not going to do much good but they will get you an aggression timer. I find them more useful against belt rats.

I fly with 1 scout, 1 salvage drone, and 3 mining drones in a high sec belt. I like to salvage the belt rats. I use the parts for rigs.

As far as fittings go, Selaria's is very nice. I've been playing with passive shield tanking, and my passive procurer does very well even in mining missions (where you often face a wave of rats rather than one or two). For my passive retriever I jam in either a medium or large Shield extender II (I forget which one fits) and three rigs that increase shield recharge. Even without a DCU II it's survivable in mining missions but the DCU II really helps. In a retriever, if you have two mining laser upgrades and one DCU II you don't sacrifice much yield but you get significantly more defense.

I use the mining missions as a gauge for what to fly in belts. If it can't tank a wave of mission rats while my drones eat them, it can't handle being attacked by a ganker. Unfortunately, just because it can tank mission rats doesn't mean it can tank gankers. Still, we all need a metric for what's good enough to fly and that's mine.
erg cz
Federal Jegerouns
#17 - 2013-12-16 15:43:54 UTC
Here is what I am aiming to:
[Procurer, Procurer high yield in high sec]
Mining Laser Upgrade II
Mining Laser Upgrade II

Adaptive Invulnerability Field II
Kinetic Deflection Field II
Thermic Dissipation Field II
Medium Shield Extender II

Modulated Strip Miner II

Medium Processor Overclocking Unit I
Medium Anti-EM Screen Reinforcer I
Medium Drone Mining Augmentor I

Read more: http://eve.battleclinic.com/loadout/67755-Procurer-high-yield-in-high-sec.html#ixzz2neX9MP7Y

Cheap and should has reasonable yield with 2 mining upgrades. Covetor will make job done quickier, but you have to risk jet can or fly to base more often (like after every 3 mining cycles) and it is much bigger gank magnet. With Retriever you tempted to go afk mining sinse it will take time to fill its cargo hold. So I thing procurer is the gold middle here... ;)
Darryn Lowe
Sebiestor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#18 - 2013-12-16 18:31:35 UTC
I'd just like to add my two cents worth because I'm finding it incredibly useful.

With Rubicon CCP added the Mastery tab to the ship info window. Training these skills will help you get the best out of the ship you want to fly. It's really nice to have a clear and concise training plan.

I mine in High Sec with no armour or shield modules and my Mack will only drop to about 70% shields in 0.5 space but I also use 5 drones. That much isn't needed but it just slaughters belt rats quicker. I mission farm so I'm largely out of the view of others unless they scan me down so I don't really worry about gankers. I wouldn't use Mack in low sec. Been bit too hard with that. Losing a Venture is much easier on the pocket. Just make sure you're in a crap clone as well.

I also use the new Mobile Tractor Unit then once that's grabbed any loot I deploy Salvager drones (5 again) but I also use the tractor unit to take a load of around 22,000 ore then keep mining until my Mack's hold is full. I then fly back to station and grab my Miasmos to collect the ore. It's a cheap and nasty solo-mine operation but it is also safer than jet can mining by far.
MicDeath Titan
No Mans Corp
#19 - 2013-12-16 23:12:10 UTC  |  Edited by: MicDeath Titan
erg cz wrote:
Here is what I am aiming to:
[Procurer, Procurer high yield in high sec]
Mining Laser Upgrade II
Mining Laser Upgrade II

Adaptive Invulnerability Field II
Kinetic Deflection Field II
Thermic Dissipation Field II
Medium Shield Extender II

Modulated Strip Miner II

Medium Processor Overclocking Unit I
Medium Anti-EM Screen Reinforcer I
Medium Drone Mining Augmentor I

Read more: http://eve.battleclinic.com/loadout/67755-Procurer-high-yield-in-high-sec.html#ixzz2neX9MP7Y

Cheap and should has reasonable yield with 2 mining upgrades. Covetor will make job done quickier, but you have to risk jet can or fly to base more often (like after every 3 mining cycles) and it is much bigger gank magnet. With Retriever you tempted to go afk mining sinse it will take time to fill its cargo hold. So I thing procurer is the gold middle here... ;)

deep EM resist hole, 154,440 m3 per hour, 35k Omni EHP fresh character, 48k Omni EHP skilled
Take my fit posted, swap out the ice harvest high and low mod, add MLU T2, add mod strip miner II.
Same resistance profile as stated before, high Omni EHP, and it mines 141,552 m3 per hour. A difference of 12,888 m3 per hour.
your build does indeed mine more per hour, but you give up so so soooo much to get that extra 12,888 m3 per hour.

*edit: also add the mining drones, forgot to add that, to be comparative to your fit.
with out mining drones, your fit mines 139,572 m3 per hour, and mine 128,052 m3 per hour, a difference of 11,520 m3 per hour.