These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Intergalactic Summit

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Peace between the Empire and the Republic, a Moderate viewpoint

Author
Constantin Baracca
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#21 - 2013-09-30 12:23:14 UTC
Fredfredbug4 wrote:


Democracy is the only thing we force a society to embrace when they wish to become a member of the Federation. Unless the basic tenants of Democracy are against every belief of the culture, it's usually not a destructive process. If anything, it leads to further development and reform of a society's cultural practices. The Jin-Mei's caste system proved to be quite compatible with Democracy, with a few slight changes. Even today, major Jin-Mei planets still use their caste system while remaining loyal members of our Democracy. On newly colonized planets of mostly Matari, Tribal laws and customs are worked in while remaining compatable with Democracy. It's very rare that a member state has to completely change their ways in order to fit into the Federation, I don't think it's ever happened to be honest.

I will agree that I simplified the matter, albeit unintentionally, but I apologize regardless. To keep things contemporary, how about Jamyl's promise of a "new" reclaiming? She hasn't acted on this promise, and hasn't shown signs of it, but a lot of holders and people in the Amarr Empire are seriously expecting it and willing to get to work.

Regardless, I am willing to be open minded and accepting, and I believe that most of the time I am though it may not always look like it. I am just really bothered when a "moderate" view is nothing more than apologist nonsense, and even more bothered with how easily one can get away with it. Imagine if I made a thread claiming that say, the Caldari forced Admiral Noir to make his suicide attack on the Malkalen station. There would be an angry mob outside my captain's quarters in minutes.

I truly don't believe that all Amarrians are "Grrrr lets go fetch some slaves and feed children to hounds!" I think the Amarr people have a beautiful culture and are honestly good at heart, but I do admittedly get riled up when a "moderate" view is nothing more than "lets blame everyone but ourselves". All I want is to see some responsibility being taken, is that too much to ask?


Without delving too much into democracy as it pertains to the cluster and the Amarr (perhaps a discussion for another time?) I did want to touch on the New Reclaiming. It seems a lot of people, especially in our own cluster, are talking about this as if it is time for an invasion. In essence, that would have been a continuation of the old Reclaimings.

Given the wisdom we've seen in the Pax Amarria, we know that all-out invasion is not the answer to our current crisis. That may be exactly why we are in our current crisis. God may be placing us in a position where force simply is not the answer, thus preparing to teach the entirety of the cluster about kindness.

The inviolate commandment still stands, though. God's Word must be spread through the cluster until all people live under his message. So, how do we do that without the "grrr....slaves" thing?

The simple answer is, we don't know yet. The more complicated answer is that we have several ideas that we're kicking around. Some people are looking for financial power and know that our system simply has a higher means of production than others. Given industrialization and the slave labor at our disposal, this idea simply means we can win the economic war and take the cluster that way. Some believe that showing our military might in the current factional warfare would give our Empire a good name. My experiment is to test how well we can recruit from outside the cluster and thus form religious organization outside of the Empire. When more and more convert, so too shall the political system. I'm also involved in testing the moral tenets, seeing if perhaps we can train people in the Amarr Empire and release them, learned, as citizens.

Really, the New Reclaiming is a call for new ideas. The old ones will obviously not work. You can't simply trapse into Gallente territory and shoot everyone. Not only does that make conversion much more difficult, but it leaves a lot fewer people to convert.

Some people do still like lasers, though. I suppose every Empire will have some people who think shooting things will solve their problems, even though our own Empire is a fairly decent example that this isn't the case.

Which relates back to the original subject matter. Shakor is one of those laser people, and its somewhat sad to see considering how much respect many of us had for Midular. Not universal, obviously, but respect nonetheless. She really was trying to better her people in her own way.

"What good will it be for someone to gain the whole world, yet forfeit their soul? Or what can anyone give in exchange for their soul?"

-Matthew 16:26

Fredfredbug4
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#22 - 2013-09-30 20:02:40 UTC
Katrina Oniseki wrote:

It is when you're not willing to listen. They are taking responsibility for it.

This is the entire problem here. You think the Empire did something wrong, the Empire does not. Because they don't agree with you, you claim they aren't taking responsibility and are blaming others for it. This is where you're wrong.

The Empire has openly taken responsibility for every Reclaiming in history. They not only take complete responsibility for it, but they openly and willingly challenge others to do something about it. They are proud of it. Just because they haven't said, "We were wrong and we're so very sorry" and still believe they did the right thing doesn't mean they have not taken responsibility.


By responsibility I mean not apologizing or trying to redeem themselves for their heinous actions against the cluster. Apologies if I was not being clear.

Katrina Oniseki wrote:
This is entirely beside the point of the OP, which clearly states that Shakor broke international laws in order to prosecute a war on the Empire. Incidentally, this allowed Tibus Heth to prosecute his war on the Federation. If anything, you should be agreeing with the OP in saying this was a bad idea and the Republic is responsible for it. But no, the Republic can do no wrong, can it? Shitting all over international law is okay, because slavery and stuff!


Where have I claimed that the Republic can do no wrong? I'm quite confident that I clarified earlier in this thread that I did not support the Elder attacks.

Even still, the Elder attacks did do one thing good. It was a wake up call. The Amarr finally realized that they couldn't sit on a throne and play with the fate of the cluster thinking they are safe from retribution. I'm not trying to justify the attacks, far from it, it's just that for so many years the Amarr treat war like going to the office. For centuries they felt they could do whatever they want as long as they justify it with "cause God told us so" without considering the consequences for their actions. Again, this doesn't lessen Shakor's atrocities, but it does show that even still, the Amarr feel they can do no wrong.

Katrina Oniseki wrote:
I find it laughable that the only part in the OP's post you had a problem with and the nerve to quote was the bit where she praised Emperor Heideran VII for not replying in kind to the full scale invasion. Instead of agreeing and saying, that was a noble show of restraint (one I doubt you could emulate), you have the gall to whine and complain about it being 'apologist', which it actually isn't.


And I find it laughable that you and other people here are seriously thinking that a "moderate" view consists of nothing but blaming others while patting yourselves on the back while totally not being an apologist about it.

So a "noble show of restraint" is now the same as ceasing the fighting because you know you can't keep it up. By your logic, the Ultra-Nationalist made a "noble show of restraint" by only seizing Caldari Prime and not launching a full scale invasion...even though they couldn't if they wanted too... but it's still noble for sure! Hell, why not talk about more noble restraint? Shakor was clearly nobly restraining himself by only slaughtering Amarrians on some planets instead of all of them! How merciful! Why not go even further? I think Tibus Heth was showing noble restraint when he ordered a doomsday weapon to be fired on Caldari Prime! He could of fired it on Gallente Prime but instead to destroy his own homeworld! How honorable!

Also, the part about Heideran wasn't the only thing I disliked, just the one that stood out the most. It's simply preposterous to do nothing but blame others while talking about how awesome you are and call that a "moderate" approach. If that's moderate that I shudder to think what a conservative view would be.

Watch_ Fred Fred Frederation_ and stop [u]cryptozoologist[/u]! Fight against the brutal genocide of fictional creatures across New Eden! Is that a metaphor? Probably not, but the fru-fru- people will sure love it!

Fredfredbug4
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#23 - 2013-09-30 20:17:01 UTC  |  Edited by: Fredfredbug4
Constantin Baracca wrote:


Without delving too much into democracy as it pertains to the cluster and the Amarr (perhaps a discussion for another time?) I did want to touch on the New Reclaiming. It seems a lot of people, especially in our own cluster, are talking about this as if it is time for an invasion. In essence, that would have been a continuation of the old Reclaimings.

Given the wisdom we've seen in the Pax Amarria, we know that all-out invasion is not the answer to our current crisis. That may be exactly why we are in our current crisis. God may be placing us in a position where force simply is not the answer, thus preparing to teach the entirety of the cluster about kindness.


Then perhaps it would be better to use a different term in the political sphere. "Reclaiming" has an extremely negative stigma associated with it. Amarrians may interpret it as simply spreading the word of your God, but to us outsiders the imagery of slaves and genocide come into mind when we hear the word "Reclaiming".

Constantin Baracca wrote:
The inviolate commandment still stands, though. God's Word must be spread through the cluster until all people live under his message. So, how do we do that without the "grrr....slaves" thing?


Do what we Gallenteans have been doing for hundreds of years, cultural warfare. Give people a reason to come to your faith, not a reason to break away from it. Show the cluster how it's helps people, not how it harms them. Accept people's own unique beliefs and show them how your faith is compatible with them.

It won't be as efficient or effective as simply flying in and taking slaves, but it will make people in the cluster say "Hey! This Amarr thing isn't so bad afterall!" You may want people to convert to you, but the first step will have to be making them accept you. When people who aren't of the faith walk by your cathedrals and churches, they often look uneasy or outright disgusted. Change your ways so that when someone not of the faith walks by one of your holy structures across the cluster, make them want to stop and admire it, and possibly even enter inside.

Constantin Baracca wrote:
The simple answer is, we don't know yet. The more complicated answer is that we have several ideas that we're kicking around. Some people are looking for financial power and know that our system simply has a higher means of production than others. Given industrialization and the slave labor at our disposal, this idea simply means we can win the economic war and take the cluster that way. Some believe that showing our military might in the current factional warfare would give our Empire a good name. My experiment is to test how well we can recruit from outside the cluster and thus form religious organization outside of the Empire. When more and more convert, so too shall the political system. I'm also involved in testing the moral tenets, seeing if perhaps we can train people in the Amarr Empire and release them, learned, as citizens.


Your experiment is just and I wish you the best of luck. Despite all my qualms with the Empire, I truly want to see them as a force of good in New Eden, and not the war hungry zealots the majority of outsiders believe you are. I highly doubt one of you will manage to convert me, even with more humane methods, but hey, I've been wrong before.

Constantin Baracca wrote:

Which relates back to the original subject matter. Shakor is one of those laser people, and its somewhat sad to see considering how much respect many of us had for Midular. Not universal, obviously, but respect nonetheless. She really was trying to better her people in her own way.


With Heth out of the way, Shakor is the next biggest threat to the peace and stability of the cluster. I hope the Republic gets rid of him in due time, preferably peacefully, but violently if need be.

Watch_ Fred Fred Frederation_ and stop [u]cryptozoologist[/u]! Fight against the brutal genocide of fictional creatures across New Eden! Is that a metaphor? Probably not, but the fru-fru- people will sure love it!

Eran Mintor
Metropolis Commercial Consortium
#24 - 2013-09-30 20:21:53 UTC  |  Edited by: Eran Mintor
Fredfredbug4 wrote:
Katrina Oniseki wrote:

It is when you're not willing to listen. They are taking responsibility for it.

This is the entire problem here. You think the Empire did something wrong, the Empire does not. Because they don't agree with you, you claim they aren't taking responsibility and are blaming others for it. This is where you're wrong.

The Empire has openly taken responsibility for every Reclaiming in history. They not only take complete responsibility for it, but they openly and willingly challenge others to do something about it. They are proud of it. Just because they haven't said, "We were wrong and we're so very sorry" and still believe they did the right thing doesn't mean they have not taken responsibility.


By responsibility I mean not apologizing or trying to redeem themselves for their heinous actions against the cluster. Apologies if I was not being clear.


You seem to have a misconception of Amarr ideology. The only thing most of them would feel the need for apology and redemption is failing to succeed the first time. Their 'heinous actions' are a product of their cultural and religious beliefs, and are certainly not seen in the same light by them that you cast upon it.

-Eran
Fredfredbug4
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#25 - 2013-09-30 20:37:44 UTC
Eran Mintor wrote:


You seem to have a misconception of Amarr ideology. The only thing most of them would feel the need for apology and redemption is failing to succeed the first time. Their 'heinous actions' are a product of their cultural and religious beliefs, and are certainly not seen in the same light by them that you cast upon it.

-Eran


Which just goes to show how backwards their ideology can occasionally be. Virtually every other entity in New Eden regards slavery and mass genocide as something abhorrent and unforgivable. If they didn't, then I'm quite certain CONCORD wouldn't mind if the Empire continued what they started during the Unchallenged Era.

Watch_ Fred Fred Frederation_ and stop [u]cryptozoologist[/u]! Fight against the brutal genocide of fictional creatures across New Eden! Is that a metaphor? Probably not, but the fru-fru- people will sure love it!

Eran Mintor
Metropolis Commercial Consortium
#26 - 2013-09-30 20:48:03 UTC
Yet the Empire has made no apologies and CONCORD still allows them a place in the council, as well as the other nations recognizing them and initially seeking peace with the Empire. I would say all four main nations are just as guilty of genocide and slavery is so often debated issue that it isn't really a factor in the ability of the Empire to entertain peace with the others. People scream of the Reclaiming but in reality it is nothing like it once was, even being almost non-existent outside of it's own borders. It's only recently gotten worse since the peace was broken by Shakor.

-Eran
Katy Moore
J. S. Radioactive Sheep Farm
#27 - 2013-09-30 20:57:35 UTC
Fredfredbug4 wrote:
I shudder to think what a conservative view would be.


The conservative Reclaimer view would be that Peace with the Minmatar Republic would only be achieved by the enslavement of all Republic persons. As history shows, the great and merciful Emperor Heideran VII disagreed with that view.

As for the Empress Jamyl 1. Well, she did say that what people gave to the Empire, she would give to them. The Shakor Republic did not give any peace offer, instead choosing more war.
Zelarrs Elkoth
PIE Inc.
Khimi Harar
#28 - 2013-09-30 23:11:09 UTC
Fredfredbug4 wrote:
Constantin Baracca wrote:

Which relates back to the original subject matter. Shakor is one of those laser people, and its somewhat sad to see considering how much respect many of us had for Midular. Not universal, obviously, but respect nonetheless. She really was trying to better her people in her own way.


With Heth out of the way, Shakor is the next biggest threat to the peace and stability of the cluster. I hope the Republic gets rid of him in due time, preferably peacefully, but violently if need be.


Katy Moore wrote:
Fredfredbug4 wrote:
I shudder to think what a conservative view would be.


The conservative Reclaimer view would be that Peace with the Minmatar Republic would only be achieved by the enslavement of all Republic persons. As history shows, the great and merciful Emperor Heideran VII disagreed with that view.

As for the Empress Jamyl 1. Well, she did say that what people gave to the Empire, she would give to them. The Shakor Republic did not give any peace offer, instead choosing more war.


Excellent points, worthy of repeating.

As I like to say, "We always offer peace; it is not always accepted."

Praetoria Imperialis Excubitoris Captain, Head of Diplomacy, Recruiting Officer Contact on channel: "PIE Public" "I walk the razor's edge of embracing the future while protecting what we value of the past."

Constantin Baracca
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#29 - 2013-09-30 23:18:25 UTC
Well, starting in line, Fred, we really do need to use the word Reclaiming. It's the Scriptural term and, in the end, I think it is somewhat disingenuous to change a policy's name but then continue it. The New Reclaiming is just that, a new way of performing the Reclaiming. Which is cultural warfare, I suppose, but that has been a part of our Empire as well for a long time. We didn't conquer everyone who is part of our Empire, nor are we completely culturally homogenous. Where the Scripture does not necessarily give direction, we are given some space for interpretation. The Khanid are probably the best example, having been a part of the Empire since the earliest part of the Reclaiming, on our home planet. They retain quite a bit of cultural distinction. As I've recently been informed, quite a bit of distinction.

As such, we aren't ones to re-brand and then stick to the same policy, I suppose. To call it the Recongregation or something of that nature feels somehow dirty. It's hard to put into words, but it does seem very slimy and political to just change the name in order to court popular opinion. Perhaps that's another Amarr thing. I'm not entirely sure. Either way, I think that view is fairly common throughout the Empire. You need to confront ignorance, not placate it.

Regardless, the Pax Amarria has served our Empire fairly well. Without focusing completely on conquest, we've been able to invest a considerable portion of our wealth and resources into infrastructure and domestic issues. We are a very large empire, so this has had the effect of raising the standard of living. With factional warfare now reduced to a few now sparsely-populated systems, ones which are relatively easy to reinforce the borders of, we've really only had to hold the Minmatar at bay since the Elder Fleet was destroyed by our Empress and the grace of God. So the wisdom of the idea of peace isn't simply that we've had success converting foreigners, but because our domestic faith has become more stable. It's very hard to quantify average quality of life, but we've certainly not seen bad times domestically.

The best way to view us is the way I've come to view the Gallenteans. You really need to forget the stereotypes you're taught as a child. I know what I've heard about your people being degenerate pushers and addicts of every stripe. Some more conservative members of the town I visited as a child said Gallenteans had more members among the Sani Sabik than we did (unfounded, of course). While there are elements of truth to everything, we are given the worst of minorities as a model for foreign societies. The idea of the zealous, slave-devouring mining company owner who makes even his employees kneel and give official address might exist, but it isn't necessarily the median of our culture. Even if there are elements of it you disagree with, you will really only ever see through a certain lens if you don't view the universe objectively.

My rules of intercultural relations is to first look at yourself and your own culture before you say something. See if you can find a corollary in yours, because that will be the first thing anyone will think. Try to think about not what you've been told about a culture nor even what you see, but what a member of that culture must think like. They've probably been taught certain ways all their lives and never questioned them or held them up objectively to other societies. You have to almost let your mind be free of every prejudice you've ever had and to truly try to understand what would make a person, almost all of whom think they are doing the right thing in the universe, behave the way they do. Very few of us are distinctly trying to do wrong.

After that, things are simpler. People have certain things they value, and certain things they look down on. It changes not just from empire to empire or culture to culture, but even person to person. The greatest joy I've had in my ministry has not been learning about other cultures, but seeing people distinct from them. As individuals who are struggling to do right the way that they were taught to, whether it really is objectively beneficial or not.

You would be amazed how, strikingly, it doesn't seem that we are all different but that we are all very similar. I have more in common with you than in contrast, and with most of the people I meet. In the end, maybe that is the true lesson of the Reclaiming. Here we are, all trying desperately to give value and meaning to our differences in order to somehow obscure that we are already more alike than unalike. Some people will see it and will be able to live with real confidence in their culture, because they know what is right and what needs corrected in it. Some people are going to fight it, kicking and screaming, trying to convince everyone we're the good guys versus all the of universe's bad guys. You simply have to see the good everyone is trying to do first and proceed from there.

Shakor, as a case in point, really does believe we are a threat for precisely the same reasons you do or did. He has taken the stereotypes from centuries ago and made them realities in his mind. He really does think guns will solve his people's problems, because the Republic in his mind suffers due to everyone outside it. However incorrect, he believes in his stereotype so blindly that he can no longer objectively view either us or his own people.

That is why he must be removed from power. He is fighting a ghost to the cost of his own people. We all have common problems to deal with, and we would deal with them better if we could act with unity. I think we will eventually; we're moving in that direction. Then maybe we can deal with these pirate problems once and for all.

Imagine what we could be doing to our local pirate threats if we weren't shipping all of our resources to these factional battlefronts.

"What good will it be for someone to gain the whole world, yet forfeit their soul? Or what can anyone give in exchange for their soul?"

-Matthew 16:26

Fredfredbug4
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#30 - 2013-09-30 23:34:19 UTC
Eran Mintor wrote:
Yet the Empire has made no apologies and CONCORD still allows them a place in the council, as well as the other nations recognizing them and initially seeking peace with the Empire. I would say all four main nations are just as guilty of genocide and slavery is so often debated issue that it isn't really a factor in the ability of the Empire to entertain peace with the others. People scream of the Reclaiming but in reality it is nothing like it once was, even being almost non-existent outside of it's own borders. It's only recently gotten worse since the peace was broken by Shakor.

-Eran


The reason why the Empire is allowed in CONCORD is because they stated they would stop this whole reclaimy wamey business, now they are claiming that they want to start it up again, which would violate their promise to CONCORD and the three other major empire. You could make the argument that each of the big four committed genocide (it would be difficult to make a case for say, the Caldari) but you can't possibly argue that they were just as bad as the Amarr or even officially sanctioned. The Starkmanir were thought to be extinct for centuries as a result of an officially ordered genocide by Amarr high command.

Even if the cries for reclaiming are still no more than chest beating at this point, I would still be cautious. A lot of Jamyl's support came from her promise of the dawn of a new reclaiming. She could of lied about it, or she could of really meant it. The possibility of the latter is enough to be weary of the intentions of the Empire from a military standpoint.

Katy Moore wrote:

As for the Empress Jamyl 1. Well, she did say that what people gave to the Empire, she would give to them. The Shakor Republic did not give any peace offer, instead choosing more war.


Except that Shakor's antics were before Jamyl's declaration and I don't recall either side making attempts at peace.


Watch_ Fred Fred Frederation_ and stop [u]cryptozoologist[/u]! Fight against the brutal genocide of fictional creatures across New Eden! Is that a metaphor? Probably not, but the fru-fru- people will sure love it!

Anabella Rella
Gradient
Electus Matari
#31 - 2013-09-30 23:36:58 UTC
Yawn. More Matari bashing and more condescending, paternalistic half-truths made by the slavers and their apologists. Nothing new to see here, move along.

Prove to me that your hands are virginal and clean of blood, Pilot Moore. Maybe then I'll be able to take your "discussion" seriously and not just another in a long string of cheap propaganda attempts.

When the world is running down, you make the best of what's still around.

Fredfredbug4
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#32 - 2013-10-01 00:21:23 UTC
Father Constantin, I had a lengthy response pretty much agreeing and adding onto what you said, though I regret to say that it appears the forum gremlins ate it up before I could post it.

I'm a bit short on time at the moment and can't really rewrite it fully, so I apologize that I can't deliver a response that does justice to yours.

In a nutshell, I do agree with your thoughts on our upbringings. Everyone here would laugh at what I was told as a kid when I was living on a Federation Navy station. I remember a children's holobook about a ugly Amarrian man who transforms into a slaver hound in the middle of the night for example.

Also, while I do understand the importance the term "Reclaiming" has to your people, it's going to take hundreds, possibly even thousands of years of good work to try and reverse the negative stigma associated with it. It may sound like a bad and political thing to try and use a different term or clarify the original term, but keep in mind it will be difficult to convince people that the "new" reclaiming isn't going to be defined with blood and vitoc.

And yeah, Shakor is bad news. Even though I don't like how the OP did nothing but blame Shakor, I still have to agree he's no good. Shakor has proven time and time again that he is willing to harm his own people and allies to get what he wants. He is driving the Republic into the dirt and trying to take the Federation with it. Put it this way, sending out trillions of ISK worth of aid and only seeing it being spent on warships isn't so good for our economy.

Watch_ Fred Fred Frederation_ and stop [u]cryptozoologist[/u]! Fight against the brutal genocide of fictional creatures across New Eden! Is that a metaphor? Probably not, but the fru-fru- people will sure love it!

Diana Kim
State Protectorate
Caldari State
#33 - 2013-10-01 02:43:21 UTC
Fredfredbug4 wrote:

Democracy is the only thing we force a society to embrace...


This is one of the main reasons why the Federation must be destroyed.

Democracy is degenerated form of management, relying on wishes of grey masses. Democratic leaders are clowns, who work for public, making shows to get better places instead of working for the sake of society. Such management system is way inferior to any other and leads to stagnation. By ensuring this stagnation to other societies, gallenteans bring them down to their level, preventing them from successful developing, that otherwise make them way stronger and efficient than their gallentean "masters".

And this is why the Federation must be destroyed.

Honored are the dead, for their legacy guides us.

In memory of Tibus Heth, Caldari State Executor YC110-115, Hero and Patriot.

Fredfredbug4
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#34 - 2013-10-01 03:41:12 UTC
Diana Kim wrote:

This is one of the main reasons why the Federation must be destroyed.

Democracy is degenerated form of management, relying on wishes of grey masses. Democratic leaders are clowns, who work for public, making shows to get better places instead of working for the sake of society. Such management system is way inferior to any other and leads to stagnation. By ensuring this stagnation to other societies, gallenteans bring them down to their level, preventing them from successful developing, that otherwise make them way stronger and efficient than their gallentean "masters".

And this is why the Federation must be destroyed.


And speaking of cultural stereotypes....

Watch_ Fred Fred Frederation_ and stop [u]cryptozoologist[/u]! Fight against the brutal genocide of fictional creatures across New Eden! Is that a metaphor? Probably not, but the fru-fru- people will sure love it!

Slaver Filth
Council of Apostles
#35 - 2013-10-01 05:32:58 UTC
The Amarrian Empire has and always will offer peace to all the races of New Eden, the peace of devotion to God, the peace of the Glaive-collar, and the peace of the grave.

Our undeniable history both proves and compels each generation to enforce the will of God. It is an elemental force of nature within Amarrian society and as such it will not be long deterred.

"Child of Amarr seek not warmth in our cold hearts, we are the old serpent of New Eden and you must do your part, revel in our viciousness, we rule by venom and our strike is merciless, "

Lyn Farel
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#36 - 2013-10-01 08:50:28 UTC
Fredfredbug4 wrote:

Do what we Gallenteans have been doing for hundreds of years, cultural warfare. Give people a reason to come to your faith, not a reason to break away from it. Show the cluster how it's helps people, not how it harms them. Accept people's own unique beliefs and show them how your faith is compatible with them.


How is that different from what is explained in the Pax Amarria ? And I mean the part where it speaks about ideals of cooperation and joint ventures of all sorts, not the gallente part of economic and cultural slavery.

Every coin usually has two sides.

Fredfredbug4 wrote:

Which just goes to show how backwards their ideology can occasionally be. Virtually every other entity in New Eden regards slavery and mass genocide as something abhorrent and unforgivable. If they didn't, then I'm quite certain CONCORD wouldn't mind if the Empire continued what they started during the Unchallenged Era.


The only thing that is backward is pre Vak'Atioth thinking, the kind to be strangely subject to resurgence these days with the recent words of Merimeth Sarum.
Ava Starfire
Khushakor Clan
#37 - 2013-10-01 11:32:25 UTC
Until the Empire admits fault and accepts responsibility for 700 years of murder, ****, torture, and kidnapping, and stops hiding behind that hateful "God" there will be no peace.

You want peace?

Stop pointing fingers and making ******* excuses. "Oh, but we could have been worse! Oh, but you attacked us!"

YES we attacked you. What the hell did you THINK would happen? What people, having endured what we did, and then having learned that an entire Tribe, believed to be lost, was in fact alive, what do you EXPECT us to do? Anything else is a delusion at best, period.

The Empire is a nation of war criminals, people who daily commit crimes against humanity.

You want peace? So do I.

Withdraw from our space. All of it. Immediately cease all hostilities.

Return Arzad to us. It is not yours. It never was.

Prosecute those holders who have used poison and torture for generations under international tribunal, as any war criminal should be tried.

Release ALL people held in generational slavery. Aww, its bad for your economy? Suck it up. Occupation and enslavement was pretty ******* bad for ours.

Not willing to do it, are you?

Then you dont want peace. You want to try and shift blame, to feel better about yourself and your hateful mockery of a faith.

"There is no strength in numbers; have no such misconception." -Jayka Vofur, "Warfare in the North"

Zsaryna Adrelana
Imperial Shipment
Amarr Empire
#38 - 2013-10-01 12:40:52 UTC
If I may.
The Empire has shown a willingness to negotiate. The republic has not.
This makes the question of a peace summit or any kind of peace talk laughable.
You want us to prosecute our Holders?
Then start curbing the influences of your terrorist friends like the Bloody Hands or whatever they're called this week.
You want us to give you territory?
Then reassure us that it won't be used as a springboard for some kind of revenge attack.
You want us to release our slaves?
Then compensate us for our loss. Obviously your economy isn't tanking as badly as you want us all to think if you can attack CONCORD then us, then your friends with capital fleets.

Bottom line: the Empire has taken steps towards peace, releasing our ninth generation slaves. I like to think the republic has intelligent people in it, so consider this. We've shown we are willing to make steps, we've demonstrated a willingness t commit to a peace process. We have not seen anything in return from the Republic, not even a bouquet of flowers and a cake to say thank you. Thus it is easy to see why efforts toward a peace summit are somewhat lethargic on our side. Ultimately Ava, I'm seeing a lot of 'give us' and not a lot of 'we can offer you this in return'. This is part of negotiations at any level.

I do this for many reasons. I do it because I believe it is right. I do it because I will profit by it. These all consolidate into one reason: I do it because I can.

Pieter Tuulinen
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#39 - 2013-10-01 14:43:42 UTC
Ava, you have just asked the Empire to hand you a brimming cup of poison. I understand your anger, Winds know I do, and I sympathise with it, but what you have just asked for will destroy the Matari far more surely than it would destroy the Empire.

Even if all those people could be gotten to Minmatar space, you would bury half of them within a year.

For the first time since I started the conversation, he looks me dead in the eye. In his gaze are steel jackhammers, quiet vengeance, a hundred thousand orbital bombs frozen in still life.

Ray Mitar
Ganksters Inc
#40 - 2013-10-01 16:37:22 UTC
The highly respected Tribeswoman Ava Starfire has put forth above a sincere and moderate proposal.

It correctly balances the reality of proper justice versus the passions of righteous vengeance. Criminal acts have been committed and can not be swept away with polite words alone. Centuries of horrific slavery and pillaging can not be counter balanced by the few years of armed resistance and sabotage enacted by freedom fighters and or terrorists.

The Amarr conquered our worlds and killed untold millions with inhumane orbital bombardments, they still hold some of our ancestral worlds and billions of Matari in vicious slavery and speak of being compensated if they should ever return said worlds and free those held in illegal bondage.

Compensation for what you stole? Compensation for the generations you enslaved? To be allowed to remain an Empire after you have released our worlds and freed our people is a greater compensation then you could ever hope for.

War criminals must be prosecuted, Concord must enforce that Amarr will not trespass in Minmatar space ever again, and a modest tax on every transaction made by Amarrians anywhere in New Eden of say 3% should be levied and administered by the Sisters of Eve to help defer the cost of relocation and recovery from slavery by the Matari freed from slavery for the next twenty years.

To not accept the fair terms presented by the highly respected Tribeswoman Ava Starfire with the addition of the relocation and recovery tax means any talk of peace between the Minmatar Republic and the Amarr Empire is just that, talk.