These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Missions & Complexes

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
123Next page
 

Faction Standings Is not working - Now with Screenshots proving terrible standings gains!!

First post
Author
Evil D4rk
AMC.
Out of the Blue.
#1 - 2013-06-25 22:00:02 UTC  |  Edited by: Evil D4rk
Good evening good people of eve.

Update: Further down on page one there are some updated facts about standings increases not working correctly.

Update 2: More Evidence

UPDATE 3: Screenshots Proving terrible gains!!!


I have come to this wonderful forum to discuss a burning issue in eve at this very moment.
Yeah you guessed it, Pirate Faction Standings. (for this following post we will be discussing Sansha Faction but this can apply to any Pirate faction)

If young eve players lives in high sec most of his pod life and then progresses enough to do some incursions he/she can easily achieve a negative Sansha standing -5.00. Now to be able to ever work for the Sanshas you must achieve a minimum standing -1.9. Social Skills can hep with this, but if you already have maxed social skills (or close to it) then they are no help at all.

Therefore I give you the only possible way to acheive the required standing: LVL 1 Storyline missions which are given every 16 level 1 missions completed.

And you reward for completing a stroyline mission is increase in standing of 0.04!!

Let me say that again just incase you thought it was a typo.

For 1 Level 1 Storyline mission completed your Faction standing would go from -5.00 to -4.96!!

At approximately 5 mins per lvl 1 mission and 5 mins per storyline missions this would that you would increase your standing by 0.04 every 1hour and 25 mins of solid level one mission gameplay.

That means to move your standing from -5.00 t the required -1.90 you would need to level missions for a solid 90 hours??

Its actually to much of a calculation for my pretty little head to work out, maybe some brilliants maths genius could post the actual numbers, but the bottom line is.....ITS A LOT OF HOURS!!!!!

A recent response from CCP about the issue stated this:

"It is correct that making choices in who to shoot in eve will impact your future gameplay and can require a lot of work mend relationships with former enemies"

I am not aware of any notification to let players know that their choices in choosing to shoot rats in belts/run plexs/do incursions will mean that is could take months of gameplay to rectify this situation.

To summarise, Eve has come a long way since Beta, lots of changes and lots of improvements to make gameplay less of a grind, perfect example is getting your sec status back.

But this faction standing mechanic has not been changed since 2003. I believe this is completely broken and wrong and would like to think that could be improved.

yes there should be a grind to improve standings. But should it be a soul destroying experience, well the answer is nothing in Eve should be.

I'll be here all week, try the veil!!
GM Bunyip
Game Master Retirement Home
#2 - 2013-06-25 22:15:15 UTC
Evil D4rk wrote:
And you reward for completing a stroyline mission is increase in standing of 0.04!!

Let me say that again just in case you thought it was a typo.

For 1 Level 1 Storyline mission completed your Faction standing would go from -5.00 to -4.96


Standings gains aren't calculated linearly like that. I meant to explain this in our conversation and after re-writing the reply for a third time, completely forgot. Oops

Here is the EVElopedia page explaining how standings gains (and penalties) are applied: magical math.

In the case of -5.0 standing, being rewarded an 0.04% gain would result in a new standing of -4.4 (significantly better than -4.96!).

To put it simply, the closer you are to 10.0, the less the gain's impact. The closer to negative 10.0 you are, the greater the gain. So if you have utterly terrible standings, you can take some solace in the fact that each step up from rock bottom will be a big one, relative to those already near the perfect standing, trying to make those last steps.

Some math:

10 - Current Standing x percentage value gain represented as integer = Standings gain.
Standings gain + current standing = New standing.

Ergo:

10 - -5.0 = 15
15 x (0.04) = 0.6
0.6 + -5.0 = -4.4

P.S You may want to paraphrase the reply you've quoted, rather than quote it directly, as sharing GM correspondence isn't actually allowed.
Evil D4rk
AMC.
Out of the Blue.
#3 - 2013-06-25 22:38:13 UTC  |  Edited by: Evil D4rk
Hey thanks for the response here and ingame. I have edited my post regarding your repsonse ingame. :P

I wasnt aware that is how the standings increase was calculated, so that is good info.

I was using my own experiences to construct the above post.

My experience =

Current Faction Standing -2.64
Current Faction Corp Standing 9.97

My last lvl 1 storyline mission increased my standing from -.2.68 to -2.64.


Also I have been told by corp mates (and this to be confirmed by me) that sharing a higher level storyline mission does not increase faction standing among people in the gang, only the person who was given the mission.
Joshua Foiritain
Coreli Corporation
Pandemic Legion
#4 - 2013-06-25 23:33:34 UTC
If only there was a type of mission that you can access through an agent belonging to an empire faction but would result in a massive boost to a your pirate faction standings and thus almost fixing them in a single go.

Oh right, these do exist and have done so for years ;)

The Coreli Corporation is recruiting.

Evil D4rk
AMC.
Out of the Blue.
#5 - 2013-06-26 00:07:04 UTC
Joshua Foiritain wrote:
If only there was a type of mission that you can access through an agent belonging to an empire faction but would result in a massive boost to a your pirate faction standings and thus almost fixing them in a single go.

Oh right, these do exist and have done so for years ;)


Oh Joshua, Good to see you are still playing.

What a brilliant and helpful response......not lol

Maybe you should actually be clear about what you are referring to. Maybe its some magic mission i am not aware of, or that the gm forgot to mention, or are u referring to cosmos mission which can only be run once and once only after which they are no help what so ever.

ta ta.
Joshua Foiritain
Coreli Corporation
Pandemic Legion
#6 - 2013-06-26 00:20:01 UTC
I am always super helpful.

I'm talking about Epic Mission arcs. For pirates two of these arcs exist and as it happens the pirate factions in eve are divided into two blocks. They boost your faction standing for their primary faction by ~37% and they can be done every 3 months.

So; Run Epic arc however many times its needed to get your pirate faction standings above -5, use diplomacy skill to get it above -2. Share missions with someone who has level 4 agent access already for two days and boom, instant access to level 4 agents of your own.

The Coreli Corporation is recruiting.

GM Bunyip
Game Master Retirement Home
#7 - 2013-06-26 00:22:34 UTC
He's referring to the Regal Replacement branch of the Amarr Epic Arc. It's unique in that, unlike the other empire arcs, you can go rogue and work for the Nation (and get rewarded with Nation standings as a result).

We didn't mention that to because a) you don't qualify for it standings-wise and b) you can't get a friend who does and have them share the standings (epic arc faction standing rewards don't split like regular missions do*)

* Yes, sometimes they do in fact split, but this is not intended.
GM Bunyip
Game Master Retirement Home
#8 - 2013-06-26 00:23:01 UTC
Eh, should've known Josh was lurking too. It is good to see you around. Lol
Evil D4rk
AMC.
Out of the Blue.
#9 - 2013-06-26 00:24:36 UTC  |  Edited by: Evil D4rk
Now that is a helpful post. The most helpful yet. Thank you for the advice. I will get right on this tomorrow and let this wonderful community know the results.

TTFN!


Edit. Erm Ok even if I don't qualify for it I will still look into it tomorrow when I'm more awake.
Joshua Foiritain
Coreli Corporation
Pandemic Legion
#10 - 2013-06-26 00:31:32 UTC
GM Bunyip wrote:
He's referring to the Regal Replacement branch of the Amarr Epic Arc. It's unique in that, unlike the other empire arcs, you can go rogue and work for the Nation (and get rewarded with Nation standings as a result).

We didn't mention that to because a) you don't qualify for it standings-wise and b) you can't get a friend who does and have them share the standings (epic arc faction standing rewards don't split like regular missions do*)

* Yes, sometimes they do in fact split, but this is not intended.

Actually i was thinking of the Guristas epic arc as it should provide a bigger standing boost but that one would help as well.

The Coreli Corporation is recruiting.

Warde Guildencrantz
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#11 - 2013-06-26 06:52:00 UTC
This is exactly why pirate factions should be a part of faction warfare. To sidestep these headaches in obtaining pirate lp store stuff

TunDraGon ~ Low sec piracy since 2003 ~ Youtube ~ Join Us

Isbariya
State War Academy
Caldari State
#12 - 2013-06-26 07:11:06 UTC
Yea but that does not realy help as you have to have a high standing to one of the main factions which is not slways given.
I have ok standing with amarr and caldari the angels love me everyone else not that much. If I wanted to do mission for sansha I would have to grind my amarr standing like hell to be able to accept that epic arc, therefor I can just as well grind my standing with sansha instead.
Chi'Nane T'Kal
Interminatus
#13 - 2013-06-26 10:06:10 UTC
Isbariya wrote:
Yea but that does not realy help as you have to have a high standing to one of the main factions which is not slways given.
I have ok standing with amarr and caldari the angels love me everyone else not that much. If I wanted to do mission for sansha I would have to grind my amarr standing like hell to be able to accept that epic arc, therefor I can just as well grind my standing with sansha instead.


Please keep in mind that as long as your faction standing is above -2, you actually only need enough corp standing with the respective epic arc corps - which is easier to achieve and a lot harder to lose.
Joshua Foiritain
Coreli Corporation
Pandemic Legion
#14 - 2013-06-26 11:01:27 UTC
Isbariya wrote:
Yea but that does not realy help as you have to have a high standing to one of the main factions which is not slways given.

Sucks to be those people. You cant expect CCP to hand you everything on a silver platter.

Isbariya wrote:
I have ok standing with amarr and caldari the angels love me everyone else not that much. If I wanted to do mission for sansha I would have to grind my amarr standing like hell to be able to accept that epic arc, therefor I can just as well grind my standing with sansha instead.

Thats the price you pay for not planning ahead.

The Coreli Corporation is recruiting.

Evil D4rk
AMC.
Out of the Blue.
#15 - 2013-06-26 12:02:57 UTC  |  Edited by: Evil D4rk
No one is saying the eve should hand people things on silver platters. no one wants silver platters.

All we want is to be able to achieve the required faction standing with in a semi reasonable time scale. my current faction standing is now -2.55 after 2 storyline missions from a starting standing of -2.68.


That means after 34 level one missions I have a standings increase of plus 0.13.

But ofcourse joshua, all I really want is a silver platter. My situation isn't even that bad. How about the poor person in a similar position with a minus 8 standing and maxed social skills. The grind is not just hard it's near impossible.
Evil D4rk
AMC.
Out of the Blue.
#16 - 2013-06-26 17:41:22 UTC  |  Edited by: Evil D4rk
GM Bunyip wrote:
Standings gains aren't calculated linearly like that. I meant to explain this in our conversation and after re-writing the reply for a third time, completely forgot. Oops

Here is the EVElopedia page explaining how standings gains (and penalties) are applied: magical math.

In the case of -5.0 standing, being rewarded an 0.04% gain would result in a new standing of -4.4 (significantly better than -4.96!).



Evil D4rk > when you were doing level 1 missions what standing did you first start with?
Arissya > -4.70 wit all skill 5
Evil D4rk > and when you did storylines you only ever got either 0.04 or 0.09 increase?
Arissya > exactly
Evil D4rk > but one sec
Arissya > 0.09 for ore one
Arissya > and 0.04 for cargo storyline
Evil D4rk > did it go up like -4.70 to -4.66?
Evil D4rk > or higher first time cos of percentages?
Arissya > no was the same for me
Arissya > i think is standard
Evil D4rk > did the standings increase start off bigger when you were lower and then get smaller as you got closer to the -1.9?
Arissya > no the standing was the same for me
Evil D4rk > ok then it is wrong
Evil D4rk > that is not how it should work



I am sure CCP can examine this players standings increase and how many level 1 missions he ran over how many weeks to see if this is not working correctly. But it seems pretty clear to me it is wrong.


Evil D4rk > how many missions did u do do you think and for how long did u do them?
Arissya > i think i done like 600-700 mission
Arissya > and i still need around 400-500 so i can get lvl 3/4 mission
Evil D4rk > yeah it sucks mate


The Prosecution rests Your Honor.
Lady Ayeipsia
BlueWaffe
#17 - 2013-06-26 17:56:32 UTC
http://www.newedenlibrary.net/eon/faction_standings.shtml

Doesn't the above also apply? If you have a chance,you could work for a different pirate faction to slowly boost your sansha standing based on the derived value.
Qalix
Long Jump.
#18 - 2013-06-26 18:12:53 UTC
Lady Ayeipsia wrote:
http://www.newedenlibrary.net/eon/faction_standings.shtml

Doesn't the above also apply? If you have a chance,you could work for a different pirate faction to slowly boost your sansha standing based on the derived value.

If you read the derived standings table very carefully, you'll notice that there is a path through Thukker to pirate standings. Thukker faction agents are available in hisec.
Evil D4rk
AMC.
Out of the Blue.
#19 - 2013-06-26 18:15:04 UTC
Lady Ayeipsia wrote:
http://www.newedenlibrary.net/eon/faction_standings.shtml

Doesn't the above also apply? If you have a chance,you could work for a different pirate faction to slowly boost your sansha standing based on the derived value.


Now that is a very interesting prospect. And if this is correct would be very good.

But does anyone know if this actually works? It Seems as though you are not getting the required standing increase working for the correct faction at the moment, I'm not sure why I would get a higher standings increase working for another faction?
Lady Ayeipsia
BlueWaffe
#20 - 2013-06-26 18:31:05 UTC
Evil D4rk wrote:
Lady Ayeipsia wrote:
http://www.newedenlibrary.net/eon/faction_standings.shtml

Doesn't the above also apply? If you have a chance,you could work for a different pirate faction to slowly boost your sansha standing based on the derived value.


Now that is a very interesting prospect. And if this is correct would be very good.

But does anyone know if this actually works? It Seems as though you are not getting the required standing increase working for the correct faction at the moment, I'm not sure why I would get a higher standings increase working for another faction?


Faction standing gain is based on mission level. I may have a -10 standing with sansha because I lived my whole life in khanid kingdom. As you know, that limits me to level 1 missions. On the other hand I have 0 standing with serpentis. I could do 1 level 1 mission with the right skills and be able to access level 2 or 3 missions with serpentis. I raise serpentis up and that in turn can impact other standings gain.

It's still a long road, but it can help out.
123Next page