These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

EVE General Discussion

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Dear CCP please explain SP Reimbursement.

First post First post
Author
Steve Ronuken
Fuzzwork Enterprises
Vote Steve Ronuken for CSM
#41 - 2013-06-07 23:55:32 UTC
In the event that you're not agreeing with what Tippia has put up, you're wrong.

It may just be a mistake in your translation, as you're not a native English speaker. I am. And what was there is exactly the same as Tippia has said, just in a far more concise format.

Woo! CSM XI!

Fuzzwork Enterprises

Twitter: @fuzzysteve on Twitter

Amanda Chelian
#42 - 2013-06-07 23:59:36 UTC
People aren't trying to troll you, Namasta. We're just pointing out that you misread the dev blogs.

What you thought the dev blogs were saying:
"Your ability to train skills for ships will remain the same"

What the dev blogs said:
"Your ability to continue using the ships you can currently fly will remain the same"

CCP even went as far as specifying what you should do to take the most advantage of the changes (they specifically noted training BC to 5 and all cruisers to 3 was a good idea if you wanted to max out SP gain in Odyssey), but I don't think you understood that part very well.
Namasta
Doomheim
#43 - 2013-06-08 00:04:00 UTC
Amanda Chelian wrote:
People aren't trying to troll you, Namasta. We're just pointing out that you misread the dev blogs.

What you thought the dev blogs were saying:
"Your ability to train skills for ships will remain the same"

What the dev blogs said:
"Your ability to continue using the ships you can currently fly will remain the same"

CCP even went as far as specifying what you should do to take the most advantage of the changes (they specifically noted training BC to 5 and all cruisers to 3 was a good idea if you wanted to max out SP gain in Odyssey), but I don't think you understood that part very well.


kk. i see this way to make money from simple players. to make them pay other 3 month.
i remember reimbursement of learning skills. you spend time you get SP for that time. what i see now is you spend time to have able fly any BC at future, and get nothing.
why the ccp is going this way i dont understend. why just dont give players who have bc or destr skill the same skill of other race.
l0rd carlos
the king asked me to guard the mountain
#44 - 2013-06-08 00:07:01 UTC
Namasta wrote:

why the ccp is going this way i dont understend. why just dont give players who have bc or destr skill the same skill of other race.

Because you could not fly them before the patch.
You should have skilled all the cruisers to III before. You failed to do so.

Youtube Channel about Micro and Small scale PvP with commentary: Fleet Commentary by l0rd carlos

Amanda Chelian
#45 - 2013-06-08 00:07:11 UTC
Namasta wrote:
Amanda Chelian wrote:
People aren't trying to troll you, Namasta. We're just pointing out that you misread the dev blogs.

What you thought the dev blogs were saying:
"Your ability to train skills for ships will remain the same"

What the dev blogs said:
"Your ability to continue using the ships you can currently fly will remain the same"

CCP even went as far as specifying what you should do to take the most advantage of the changes (they specifically noted training BC to 5 and all cruisers to 3 was a good idea if you wanted to max out SP gain in Odyssey), but I don't think you understood that part very well.


kk. i see this way to make money from simple players. to make them pay other 3 month.
i remember reimbursement of learning skills. you spend time you get SP for that time. what i see now is you spend time to have able fly any BC at future, and get nothing.
why the ccp is going this way i dont understend. why just dont give players who have bc or destr skill the same skill of other race.


That's an extremely unfair comparison.

With learning skills, CCP actively took SP away from you, so it made sense to reimburse them with unallocated points.

With the battlecruiser change, CCP didn't take any SP away from you. They just restructured the skill trees different, in a way that allowed you to take advantage of and end up with A LOT more SP than you initially had. In no scenario did you end up with any less SP than you previously had, so there's no point at all to make any kind of SP reimbursement, and no valid argument you can make for it.
Tippia
Sunshine and Lollipops
#46 - 2013-06-08 00:10:22 UTC  |  Edited by: Tippia
Namasta wrote:
i remember reimbursement of learning skills. you spend time you get SP for that time. what i see now is you spend time to have able fly any BC at future, and get nothing.
Sure you do. You just didn't complete the entire process to get the most out of the switch.

You simply got skills worth exactly the time you've trained. No more, no less. Had you been given a straight SP reimbursement because you had no cruiser skills, it would have been the same (and would have mirrored how the learning skills were handled).

The only way to get more SP than you had actually trained for was to get all the cruiser skills at lvl III or more, and even then, all that happened was that you retained exactly the same abilities you had before. That's what this whole switch was about: to ensure that everyone could keep flying the same ships with the same bonuses. That's why they only handed out the BC (and destroyer) skills that covered the ships you could already fly, rather than hand out new abilities out of nowhere.
Namasta
Doomheim
#47 - 2013-06-08 00:29:21 UTC  |  Edited by: Namasta
Tippia wrote:
Namasta wrote:
i remember reimbursement of learning skills. you spend time you get SP for that time. what i see now is you spend time to have able fly any BC at future, and get nothing.
Sure you do. You just didn't complete the entire process to get the most out of the switch.

You simply got skills worth exactly the time you've trained. No more, no less. Had you been given a straight SP reimbursement because you had no cruiser skills, it would have been the same (and would have mirrored how the learning skills were handled).

The only way to get more SP than you had actually trained for was to get all the cruiser skills at lvl III or more, and even then, all that happened was that you retained exactly the same abilities you had before. That's what this whole switch was about: to ensure that everyone could keep flying the same ships with the same bonuses. That's why they only handed out the BC (and destroyer) skills that covered the ships you could already fly, rather than hand out new abilities out of nowhere.


kk i undersend that i was fuckend up by CCP as few times before as i not native english speacking user.
you can juggle words but all i see is before patch i able to fly any bc, destr at lvl 5 after spending few hours. now i must spend few month to have the same character as before patch.

p.s. i Dont need that ******* FREE SP!!! i just need character as before this ******* patch.
pps and i see i not only one who was ****** up.....
Tippia
Sunshine and Lollipops
#48 - 2013-06-08 00:35:07 UTC
Namasta wrote:
you can juggle words but all i see is before patch i able to fly any bc, destr at lvl 5 after spending few hours. now i must spend few month to have the same character as before patch.
…and the question on everyone's mind is why didn't you spend those few hours, especially given all the information and the explicit suggestion from CCP that you do?

You were not “fuckend up by CCP” — you made a bad choice and didn't follow their suggestion to maximise what you could get out of this patch. As a result, you can still fly exactly the same things you could before the patch… which was the intention of the design all along.
RubyPorto
RubysRhymes
#49 - 2013-06-08 00:38:06 UTC  |  Edited by: RubyPorto
Namasta wrote:
p.s. i Dont need that ******* FREE SP!!! i just need character as before this ******* patch.
pps and i see i not only one who was ****** up.....


And your character has the exact same capabilities it had before the patch.

It could fly one race's BCs at 5.

It can now fly one race's BCs at 5.

Absolutely none of your characters abilities has changed. The time it takes for you to gain other abilities has changed, but that's as irrelevant as if they altered the time it would take to train into Titans.

"It's easy to speak for the silent majority. They rarely object to what you put into their mouths." -Abrazzar "the risk of having your day ruined by other people is the cornerstone with which EVE was built" -CCP Solomon

Namasta
Doomheim
#50 - 2013-06-08 00:57:21 UTC
RubyPorto wrote:
Namasta wrote:
p.s. i Dont need that ******* FREE SP!!! i just need character as before this ******* patch.
pps and i see i not only one who was ****** up.....


And your character has the exact same capabilities it had before the patch.

It could fly one race's BCs at 5.

It can now fly one race's BCs at 5.

Absolutely none of your characters abilities has changed. The time it takes for you to gain other abilities has changed, but that's as irrelevant as if they altered the time it would take to train into Titans.


nope. tell that to someone else....

i understand position of that few players in this thread, and i think i will not hear any new. only that you have the same capability as before patch, but thats not true and if i tell that story to any lawyer thay will tell that im right and its not the same character.

P.S. im going to sleep, thank you all for your support.
Tsukino Stareine
Garoun Investment Bank
Gallente Federation
#51 - 2013-06-08 01:04:20 UTC
you only get SP reimbursed if you did not have any cruiser skill at 3 before patch
RubyPorto
RubysRhymes
#52 - 2013-06-08 01:11:06 UTC  |  Edited by: RubyPorto
Namasta wrote:
RubyPorto wrote:
Namasta wrote:
p.s. i Dont need that ******* FREE SP!!! i just need character as before this ******* patch.
pps and i see i not only one who was ****** up.....


And your character has the exact same capabilities it had before the patch.

It could fly one race's BCs at 5.

It can now fly one race's BCs at 5.

Absolutely none of your characters abilities has changed. The time it takes for you to gain other abilities has changed, but that's as irrelevant as if they altered the time it would take to train into Titans.


nope. tell that to someone else....

i understand position of that few players in this thread, and i think i will not hear any new. only that you have the same capability as before patch, but thats not true and if i tell that story to any lawyer thay will tell that im right and its not the same character.

P.S. im going to sleep, thank you all for your support.


CCP said "If you can fly it before the patch, you will be able to fly it after the patch."

Nowhere did they say "If you can't fly it before the patch, you'll have the same training time to fly it after the patch."

You could not fly those racial battlecruisers before the patch, now you still can't.

You knew the patch was coming. You knew skills were changing. You failed to adjust your training to make best use of that.

Depending on how definite an announcement you're counting, they gave you 18 months, 7 months, or 5 months warning to train at most ~38 days worth of skills (in your case, just 4 days of skills).

The only thing suing CCP will accomplish is likely getting you banned from EVE (and any other games CCP may eventually produce).

"It's easy to speak for the silent majority. They rarely object to what you put into their mouths." -Abrazzar "the risk of having your day ruined by other people is the cornerstone with which EVE was built" -CCP Solomon

hellcane
Never Back Down
#53 - 2013-06-08 01:21:55 UTC
Namasta wrote:

kk i undersend that i was fuckend up by CCP as few times before as i not native english speacking user.
you can juggle words but all i see is before patch i able to fly any bc, destr at lvl 5 after spending few hours. now i must spend few month to have the same character as before patch.

p.s. i Dont need that ******* FREE SP!!! i just need character as before this ******* patch.
pps and i see i not only one who was ****** up.....

You fuckend yourself. Think about why it is just you having issues. Yes, now your training time will be longer than it was, that is why CCP told you what to train a year ago.

Your char is the same as he was before the patch. The game has changed, like all MMOs do, but your char is the same. You won't get free sp because you now realize you should have spent a day training, didn't go to the forum, didn't go into a public in-game channel, or better yet...didn't ask in your own thread+language.

Long story short, this is a good life lesson about asking questions and understanding changes before they happen. You won't get anything.
hellcane
Never Back Down
#54 - 2013-06-08 01:24:32 UTC
Quote:

nope. tell that to someone else....

i understand position of that few players in this thread, and i think i will not hear any new. only that you have the same capability as before patch, but thats not true and if i tell that story to any lawyer thay will tell that im right and its not the same character.

P.S. im going to sleep, thank you all for your support.

Any lawyer would tell you that you are an idiot, but thank you for the money you spent to get a consultation.

PS nobody in this thread is supporting you
James Amril-Kesh
Viziam
Amarr Empire
#55 - 2013-06-08 02:25:14 UTC
Tippia wrote:
There are 17 cases:

  1. You had: Amarr Cruiser ≥3, Caldari Cruiser <3, Gallente Cruiser <3, Minmatar Cruiser <3, Battlecruiser N
  2.      → You gain Amarr Battlecruiser N.


I can feel the love from here.

Enjoying the rain today? ;)

SB Rico
Sumo Wrestlers
#56 - 2013-06-08 04:27:48 UTC
I understand why you are upset, however I can't see you getting the resolution you want because the rules for sp were pretty clear and you are not in a position where there has been an error.

However I think your case does highlight a need for CCP to consider announcing these things in more than one language in the future, there are multiple forums and recruitment channels for non-english speakers and there should be dev blog translations for all of those.

But yes, OP, CCP did state that the only way to get all the racial BC5 skills was to be able to fly all the racial BC before the patch and have the skill trained to level 5. This is unlike the learning skills scenario because they have not removed skills and/or an ability from your account just changed the skilling time, something they gave a large amount of notice for.

Scammers are currently selling killrights on this toon for up to 5mil, if you have paid for this service demand your money back at once.

Killing me should be for free.

Winter Unicorn
Requiem For Freedom
#57 - 2013-06-08 04:56:40 UTC  |  Edited by: Winter Unicorn
Summary.
TS has more SP than before the patch.
TS can fly on the ships that he can fly before the patch.
TS want to have a lot more SP, and he want to use a ships that he cant to use before the patch,
because he even didnt bother to learn the third skill level of cruisers.

Namasta wrote:

there is no dev blog on my language.



On your language: http://eve-ru.com/blogs/devblog/902

EN:
Quote:
It is noteworthy to point out that if you don’t have a racial Cruiser at 3, then you won’t receive the corresponding racial Battlecruiser skill. It is thus worthwhile to train all Racial Cruiser skill at 3, then focus on maximizing Battlecruisers before the reimbursement happens.


RU:
Quote:
Следует отметить, что если у вас нет Racial Cruiser 3, тогда вы не получите соответствующий навык Racial Battlecruiser. Таким образом выходит, что важнее сначала изучить все навыки Racial Cruiser 3, затем сосредоточиться на изучении навыка Battlecruisers перед обновлением.

_Обвинение компании в неуважении игроков, является недопустимым на форуме (с) Сотрудник CCP _

Keith Gavner
Nomura Industries
#58 - 2013-06-08 05:27:23 UTC
While OP is just one of the many idiots that failed at reading the devblog about the summer skill change, I am impressed that he/she had no access to anything preventing him/her from being "****** by CCP".

English is not my native language either. Yet, just among the websites I browse often, at least 5 of them listed the changes precisely giving every necessary skills for the change.
Similarly, the skills to get have been precisely documented in a handful of corp/alliance emails several times and were on the MOTD as well. Finally, they have been also discussed in my native language channel and may have been on the MOTD as well.

Therefore, I cannot help but wonder if OP has been living under a rock or something.
GreenSeed
#59 - 2013-06-08 05:38:03 UTC
Tippia wrote:
There are 17 cases:

  1. You had: Amarr Cruiser ≥3, Caldari Cruiser <3, Gallente Cruiser <3, Minmatar Cruiser <3, Battlecruiser N
  2.      → You gain Amarr Battlecruiser N.
  3. You had: Amarr Cruiser <3, Caldari Cruiser ≥3, Gallente Cruiser <3, Minmatar Cruiser <3, Battlecruiser N
  4.      → You gain Caldari Battlecruiser N.
  5. You had: Amarr Cruiser ≥3, Caldari Cruiser ≥3, Gallente Cruiser <3, Minmatar Cruiser <3, Battlecruiser N
  6.      → You gain Amarr Battlecruiser N, Caldari Ballecruiser N.
  7. You had: Amarr Cruiser <3, Caldari Cruiser <3, Gallente Cruiser ≥3, Minmatar Cruiser <3, Battlecruiser N
  8.      → You gain Gallente Battlecruiser N.
  9. You had: Amarr Cruiser ≥3, Caldari Cruiser <3, Gallente Cruiser ≥3, Minmatar Cruiser <3, Battlecruiser N
  10.      → You gain Amarr Battlecruiser N, Gallente Battlecruiser N.
  11. You had: Amarr Cruiser <3, Caldari Cruiser ≥3, Gallente Cruiser ≥3, Minmatar Cruiser <3, Battlecruiser N
  12.      → You gain Caldari Battlecruiser N, Gallente Battlecruiser N
  13. You had: Amarr Cruiser ≥3, Caldari Cruiser ≥3, Gallente Cruiser ≥3, Minmatar Cruiser <3, Battlecruiser N
  14.      → You gain Amarr Battlecruiser N, Caldari Battlecruiser N, Gallente Battlecruiser N.
  15. You had: Amarr Cruiser <3, Caldari Cruiser <3, Gallente Cruiser <3, Minmatar Cruiser ≥3, Battlecruiser N
  16.      → You gain Minmatar Battlecruiser N.
  17. You had: Amarr Cruiser ≥3, Caldari Cruiser <3, Gallente Cruiser <3, Minmatar Cruiser ≥3, Battlecruiser N
  18.      → You gain Amarr Battlecruiser N, Minmatar Battlecruiser N.
  19. You had: Amarr Cruiser <3, Caldari Cruiser ≥3, Gallente Cruiser <3, Minmatar Cruiser ≥3, Battlecruiser N
  20.      → You gain Caldari Battlecruiser N, Minmatar Battlecruiser N.
  21. You had: Amarr Cruiser ≥3, Caldari Cruiser ≥3, Gallente Cruiser <3, Minmatar Cruiser ≥3, Battlecruiser N
  22.      → You gain Amarr Battlecruiser N, Caldari Battlecruiser N, Minmatar Battlecruiser N.
  23. You had: Amarr Cruiser <3, Caldari Cruiser <3, Gallente Cruiser ≥3, Minmatar Cruiser ≥3, Battlecruiser N
  24.      → You gain Gallente Battlecruiser N, Minmatar Battlecruiser N.
  25. You had: Amarr Cruiser ≥3, Caldari Cruiser <3, Gallente Cruiser ≥3, Minmatar Cruiser ≥3, Battlecruiser N
  26.      → You gain Amarr Battlecruiser N, Gallente Battlecruiser N, Minmatar Battlecruiser N.
  27. You had: Amarr Cruiser <3, Caldari Cruiser ≥3, Gallente Cruiser ≥3, Minmatar Cruiser ≥3, Battlecruiser N
  28.      → You gain Caldari Battlecruiser N, Gallente Battlecruiser N, Minmatar Battlecruiser N.
  29. You had: Amarr Cruiser ≥3, Caldari Cruiser ≥3, Gallente Cruiser ≥3, Minmatar Cruiser ≥3, Battlecruiser N
  30.      → You gain Amarr Battlecruiser N, Caldari Battlecruiser N, Gallente Battlecruiser N, Minmatar Battlecruiser N.
  31. You had: Amarr Cruiser <3, Caldari Cruiser <3, Gallente Cruiser <3, Minmatar Cruiser <3, Battlecruiser N
  32.      → You are reimbursed the SP you had in Battlecruiser N.
  33. You had: Battlecruiser 0
  34.      → You gain nothing.
In all cases, you keep the cruisers skills and you lose your old battlecruiser skill. The same pattern holds true for the destroyers, only with Destroyer replacing Battlecruiser and with Frigate instead of Cruiser.

Pick the one that applies to you. Only if none of them apply to your situation before and after the patch has something gone wrong and you might have lost something; otherwise, all is as it should be and you have lost nothing.


im going to print this on a t-shirt. no, im not kidding.
CCP Explorer
C C P
C C P Alliance
#60 - 2013-06-08 10:39:32 UTC
Amanda Chelian wrote:
People aren't trying to troll you, Namasta. We're just pointing out that you misread the dev blogs.

What you thought the dev blogs were saying:
"Your ability to train skills for ships will remain the same"

What the dev blogs said:
"Your ability to continue using the ships you can currently fly will remain the same"

CCP even went as far as specifying what you should do to take the most advantage of the changes (they specifically noted training BC to 5 and all cruisers to 3 was a good idea if you wanted to max out SP gain in Odyssey), but I don't think you understood that part very well.
It's worth emphasizing this; we were changing skill training so training before and after was always going to be different. But we grandfathered all previous ability to fly ships. We then went out of our way to encourage people to train all racial frigates and cruisers in addition to destroyer 5 and battlecruiser 5 so people would get the most benefit out of the changes. Here's, e.g., what I posted on Twitter

https://twitter.com/erlendur/status/299628968179535872
https://twitter.com/erlendur/status/299635699408330752
https://twitter.com/erlendur/status/340781888765583360

and I know others re-tweeted and posted as well, in addition to forum replies, following http://community.eveonline.com/news/dev-blogs/the-great-skill-change-of-blessed-2013/

Erlendur S. Thorsteinsson | Senior Development Director | EVE Online // CCP Games | @CCP_Explorer