These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Player Features and Ideas Discussion

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Frighter "unfair rules"

Author
Wolf Kyosuke
Garoun Investment Bank
Gallente Federation
#21 - 2013-04-09 21:59:09 UTC
Is it really a surprise that a capital ship that is dedicated to only transporting goods may require support?
Steel Roamer
Southern Baptist Space Warrior Collective.
V0IDLINGS
#22 - 2013-04-09 23:12:12 UTC  |  Edited by: Steel Roamer
Cameron Cahill wrote:
Steel Roamer wrote:
Cameron Cahill wrote:
If you want to play with one account then you can still just not take high value loads, or go the safer, longer route that doesnt go through niarja.

Or, you know, make friends? Rediculous thing to suggest in an mmo i know.


Goons gank empty freighters.

I stopped using mine, there's no point to even bother.
CCP has stated before, bumping ships forever with throwaway toons (They keep aggressing you with noobships, and when the toon is too low Sec-Status to sit on gates, they just biomass and make a new one) in noobships is not bannable as stated in the EULA, but rather "Emergent Gameplay".

The minute goons stop doing it, it will revert back to being "an exploit".
This is what you get when you hire out of an Eve Alliance founded by members of a griefing forum.


And you wonder why they do it when you cry like this?

Tears?

I have not been ganked because I undestand that the risk is not worth undocking my freighter.

What you are reading is not tears, but continue to convince yourself so.




And to those asking whether or not I have a source for gankers Bio-massing bump/agression toons, the evidence lies directly in their method of ganking.
Why does an out of corp toon that is generally under 7 days old show up on these killmails, and when you search for them in-game no longer exist?

Ex1 http://eve-kill.net/?a=kill_detail&kll_id=17083818
Ex2 http://eve-kill.net/?a=kill_detail&kll_id=17021669

Because it's easier to roll a new alt than to bother grinding sec status on a 200,000k SP bump/agression toon.

The only way to fix this is to fix ship bumping in regards to ship mass. IE, noob ships don't bump freighters well, but a plated BS will send it rolling. This way people can't roll new alts every week because their bump toons need to fly a BC or larger to be effective. But then you will see the roles of Bump/Agression get split between 2 different characters to prevent the bump toon from losing sec status.
Pinky Feldman
Amarrian Vengeance
Ragequit Cancel Sub
#23 - 2013-04-09 23:23:41 UTC
Cameron Cahill wrote:
Viden Anzomi wrote:
I would like to say one thing. This topic is a reflection on the game mechanics. I'm not against principilen gank mechanics.

- The second character with web is acceptable tactic, I know her
- Carry less - ok why not.

But the purpose of this discussion is to consider the features of this game mechanics, which clearly favors some and harms others. My opinion is that the press should be proportionate to risk. These (gank-pirate) people are safe.

I apologize for my English.


The gankers are guarenteed to loose their ships, how is this safe? The only reason its done is because people make it easy, profitable and fun. It is the harderst (and least profitable) it has ever been to kill freighters in highsec. It has ben nerfed repeatedly and it is very easy to avoid. If you die now it is no ones fault but your own so there is no reason for a change in game mechanics.


So you're saying that its not just about the isk/hr but the fun/hr as well? 7o Bourbon
Powers Sa
#24 - 2013-04-09 23:24:06 UTC  |  Edited by: Powers Sa
Steel Roamer wrote:

Goons gank empty freighters.

I stopped using mine, there's no point to even bother.
CCP has stated before, bumping ships forever with throwaway toons (They keep aggressing you with noobships, and when the toon is too low Sec-Status to sit on gates, they just biomass and make a new one) in noobships is not bannable as stated in the EULA, but rather "Emergent Gameplay".

This is all incorrect data. If you are red, just assume you are dead regardless of your freighter contents valuation.

We have an alt-corp with standings, when your aggressor gets too low, the aggressor joins that altcorp, goes around with a TP frigate, and hops on the sec status safari that we hold no less than 3 times a week in each TZ. 3x2 hour sessions should have most people back up to space legal status. Sec safaris happen in both EU and US TZ's. It is a well oiled machine at this point, as we've been going strong since this past august. We've taken breaks here and there, and are currently on one for a big sec overhaul to make sure everyone is at 5.0, to ruin days for weeks to come.

No biomassing occurs whatsoever. We're just much more organized and definitely smarter than you. Everything is aboveboard and follows the letter of the law. We intentionally looked at the eula to avoid any bans with our active participants.

A lot of this process will be sidestepped when CCP publicizes the Sec for Tags program going live in Odyssey that they discussed in the CSM minutes this past summit.

So get dunked on nerds, CCP made it harder to loot, but gave us more bang for our sec status, and is now making it easier to get legal again.

Do you like winning t2 frigs and dictors for Dirt Cheap?https://eveninggames.net/register/ref/dQddmNgyLhFBqNJk

Remeber: Gambling addiction is no laughing matter unless you've lost a vast space fortune on the internet.

Montevius Williams
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#25 - 2013-04-09 23:31:14 UTC
Cameron Cahill wrote:
If you want to play with one account then you can still just not take high value loads, or go the safer, longer route that doesnt go through niarja.

Or, you know, make friends? Rediculous thing to suggest in an mmo i know.



Any answer that begins with having more than 1 account is a wrong answer.

Making friends is a good answer tho

"The American Government indoctrination system known as public education has been relentlessly churning out socialists for over 20 years". - TravisWB

Pinky Feldman
Amarrian Vengeance
Ragequit Cancel Sub
#26 - 2013-04-09 23:32:57 UTC
Powers Sa wrote:
Steel Roamer wrote:

Goons gank empty freighters.

I stopped using mine, there's no point to even bother.
CCP has stated before, bumping ships forever with throwaway toons (They keep aggressing you with noobships, and when the toon is too low Sec-Status to sit on gates, they just biomass and make a new one) in noobships is not bannable as stated in the EULA, but rather "Emergent Gameplay".

This is all incorrect data. If you are red, just assume you are dead.

We have an alt-corp with standings, when your aggressor gets too low, the aggressor joins that altcorp, goes around with a TP frigate, and hops on the sec status safari that we hold no less than 3 times a week in each TZ. 3x2 hour sessions should have most people back up to space legal status. Sec safaris happen in both EU and US TZ's. It is a well oiled machine at this point, as we've been going strong since this past august. We've taken breaks here and there, and are currently on one for a big sec overhaul to make sure everyone is at 5.0, to ruin days for weeks to come.

No biomassing occurs whatsoever. We're just much more organized and definitely smarter than you. Everything is aboveboard and follows the letter of the law. We intentionally looked at the eula to avoid any bans with our active participants.

A lot of this process will be sidestepped when CCP publicizes the Sec for Tags program going live in Odyssey that they discussed in the CSM minutes this past summit.

So get dunked on nerds, CCP made it harder to loot, but gave us more bang for our sec status, and is now making it easier to get legal again.


But don't you think that its a bit broken that I can take my freighter, walk away from my computer, and while i'm gone lose it to an extremely well oiled, well organized machine, that understands game mechanics?

Sounds pretty broken. If only there was a way that you could swap your freighter to a neutral toon through highsec.
Powers Sa
#27 - 2013-04-09 23:37:40 UTC
Pinky Feldman wrote:


But don't you think that its a bit broken that I can take my freighter, walk away from my computer, and while i'm gone lose it to an extremely well oiled, well organized machine, that understands game mechanics?

Sounds pretty broken. If only there was a way that you could swap your freighter to a neutral toon through highsec.

When you are flying around in a 1.X bil hull, you assume a degree of risk. CCP gave it a lot of HP. If you want to be lazy and in a hostile organization, then good luck.

But we're bros pinky, so I'd never do that to you.

Do you like winning t2 frigs and dictors for Dirt Cheap?https://eveninggames.net/register/ref/dQddmNgyLhFBqNJk

Remeber: Gambling addiction is no laughing matter unless you've lost a vast space fortune on the internet.

Ch3244
Native Freshfood
Minmatar Republic
#28 - 2013-04-09 23:37:45 UTC
Viden Anzomi wrote:
Hello,

I have couple of things to discuss as Freighter pilot that I am not happy with.

First of all I want to say that I am not campaigning for cancelling ganking or bumping, but I would like to see some improvement and logic in process of bumping.

Recently I was shot in highsec system Deltole. It started as most of the cases. I was bumped from gate by two Machariels and at the same time I was attacked by noobship from the same gang. I think many people know this and experienced same situation as I did before. I want to point out that I was not using autopilot.

1. Why did Freighter pilot, that didn't aggress or attack and does not have any modules, get 15 min timer and got penalty and can't log off because he would be seen in space anyway even after log off ? Why was penalised someone who did not do anything and didn't attack anyone?


Because if it wasn't this way you could just log off as soon as anyone shot you.


Viden Anzomi wrote:

Pilot (pirate) that attacks Freighter and his ship is destroyed can just dock on station and gets new noobship for free, undock and aggro the same Freighter again (even so the Freighter pilot is logged off but his ship is still in game) and so he can keep the Freighter in game indefinitely. Expenses for the pirate? None, he will get the noobship for free.


This is not true, it requires at least 2 pilots to keep a freighter constantly aggressed .


Viden Anzomi wrote:

2. Regarding the nature of Freighter ship (almost 0% resistance) it's really easy to shoot it down for other players (pirates). Why is this type of ship build like this ?

A non-combat ship.

Viden Anzomi wrote:

they are getting by shooting down Freighter then couple of Catalysts?

More like 20.


Viden Anzomi wrote:

I think that regarding to bumping, players that do this practice in highsec breaking the law but no one is persecuted for that behavior. On the other side I understand it is difficult to change this because I do not know how would it work on Jita and any other big hubs where you bumping when you undocking but usually no on purpose?

If EVE should be real as much as possible and you can do whatever you want (ganking, bumping)
there should be much better way to oppose these players and NPC corps should not accept these players and you could declare war against them and they woudn't be able to be hidden after NPC corp.


If you really wanted to you could disrupt their gank and cause them to lose all their ships.

Ch3244
Native Freshfood
Minmatar Republic
#29 - 2013-04-09 23:41:06 UTC  |  Edited by: Ch3244
Steel Roamer wrote:

And to those asking whether or not I have a source for gankers Bio-massing bump/agression toons, the evidence lies directly in their method of ganking.
Why does an out of corp toon that is generally under 7 days old show up on these killmails, and when you search for them in-game no longer exist?

Ex1 http://eve-kill.net/?a=kill_detail&kll_id=17083818
Ex2 http://eve-kill.net/?a=kill_detail&kll_id=17021669

Because it's easier to roll a new alt than to bother grinding sec status on a 200,000k SP bump/agression toon.

The only way to fix this is to fix ship bumping in regards to ship mass. IE, noob ships don't bump freighters well, but a plated BS will send it rolling. This way people can't roll new alts every week because their bump toons need to fly a BC or larger to be effective. But then you will see the roles of Bump/Agression get split between 2 different characters to prevent the bump toon from losing sec status.

You're an idiot.

That is not how it works at all.
Sura Sadiva
Entropic Tactical Crew
#30 - 2013-04-10 00:04:01 UTC
Viden Anzomi wrote:
If EVE should be real as much as possible and you can do whatever you want (ganking, bumping)
there should be much better way to oppose these players and NPC corps should not accept these players and you could declare war against them and they woudn't be able to be hidden after NPC corp.


Freighters are not designed for solo trading, are for corp and alliance logistic, their defence should be in the group having interest in them.

You move whole world with it, can earn huge amount of isk with a single trip, and heavly influence the market, people have nod efence against this conditioning too. So can share a bit of risk.

Sixx Spades
Republic Military School
Minmatar Republic
#31 - 2013-04-10 00:20:31 UTC
Steel Roamer wrote:
And to those asking whether or not I have a source for gankers Bio-massing bump/agression toons, the evidence lies directly in their method of ganking.
Why does an out of corp toon that is generally under 7 days old show up on these killmails, and when you search for them in-game no longer exist?

Ex1 http://eve-kill.net/?a=kill_detail&kll_id=17083818
Ex2 http://eve-kill.net/?a=kill_detail&kll_id=17021669

Because it's easier to roll a new alt than to bother grinding sec status on a 200,000k SP bump/agression toon.

The only way to fix this is to fix ship bumping in regards to ship mass. IE, noob ships don't bump freighters well, but a plated BS will send it rolling. This way people can't roll new alts every week because their bump toons need to fly a BC or larger to be effective. But then you will see the roles of Bump/Agression get split between 2 different characters to prevent the bump toon from losing sec status.


1. Rookie Ships are used for aggression. If you somehow build one to keep a Freighter bumped effectively, please enlighten me.
2. We fully understand that biomassing to launder sec status is a bannable offense according to the EULA, so we don't do it. Like Power Sa previously pointed out, our sec safaris help bring our alts back to "legal" status.
3. Aggression alts are never used for bumping for the obvious risks posed by killrights. Furthermore, bumping characters require specific skills to be of use at all. Hopefully that clears the obvious confusion you're currently experiencing.

Lastly, I would like to point out that being able to fly a Freighter in High-sec does not entitle you to some sort of gank-free environment. Just like flying a Carrier in Low or Null, it requires cooperation, intelligence, and most likely another alt. If you can't be asked to take the preventative measures to reduce the risk of being ganked, please consider contacting Seraphin Foad to discuss the option of purchasing a spot on our Whitelist.

Here's the relevant thread for more info:
https://forums.eveonline.com/default.aspx?g=posts&t=219697&find=unread

Using a weapon as a deterrent in a diplomatic situation is only viable when you have proven that you have deployed it in the past and are willing to use it in the future.

Daichi Yamato
Jabbersnarks and Wonderglass
#32 - 2013-04-10 00:21:48 UTC  |  Edited by: Daichi Yamato
if u were hauling fat loads of isk on ur billy, then u deserved it.

as a cyno alt, u probably have lots of friends. ask for some escorts next time.
Quote:

If EVE should be real as much as possible and you can do whatever you want (ganking, bumping)
there should be much better way to oppose these players and NPC corps should not accept these players and you could declare war against them and they woudn't be able to be hidden after NPC corp.


the very mechanics u use to stay safe in hi-sec now prevent u from attacking those attacking u...u could always haul through low sec.

Quote:
Lastly, I would like to point out that being able to fly a Freighter in High-sec does not entitle you to some sort of gank-free environment


dis!

EVE FAQ "7.2 CAN I AVOID PVP COMPLETELY? No; there are no systems or locations in New Eden where PvP may be completely avoided"

Daichi Yamato's version of structure based decs

Pinky Feldman
Amarrian Vengeance
Ragequit Cancel Sub
#33 - 2013-04-10 00:23:16 UTC
Powers Sa wrote:
Pinky Feldman wrote:


But don't you think that its a bit broken that I can take my freighter, walk away from my computer, and while i'm gone lose it to an extremely well oiled, well organized machine, that understands game mechanics?

Sounds pretty broken. If only there was a way that you could swap your freighter to a neutral toon through highsec.

When you are flying around in a 1.X bil hull, you assume a degree of risk. CCP gave it a lot of HP. If you want to be lazy and in a hostile organization, then good luck.

But we're bros pinky, so I'd never do that to you.


Hahaha. Whenever you are unsure about the work you do in EVE, Powers, just read threads like these and know you are doing Ghandi's work. <3
Loki Feiht
Warcrows
Sedition.
#34 - 2013-04-10 00:47:43 UTC
Gizznitt Malikite wrote:

There's several "omg freighters are being ganked" threads in this forum... You really should browse the top 2 pages at least, and ideally do a search to see what's been discussed and either add your experiences to those threads. When you are presenting a new spin/idea, I can understand then making a "new thread", but I don't see any new ideas in your post... making this a very duplicated thread!

Freighter Revamp Idea
Give Freighters Lowslots

Now, to reiterate what has been discussed already:

1.) If you carry a low value in cargo, your chances of getting ganked are very low.... like 1 in 10,000 trips through Uedema... (and that's using March data which was a fairly active month -- 50ish kills in Uedama. (Go see those other threads for citations). Of the last 50 kills in March... 2 were not suicide ganks, 4 were ganked empty, 4 were ganked for a double-wrapped package... and 4 were ganked with non-empty cargo's below 2b isk.

2.) The Aggression Flag change was an AWESOME and NECESSARY change, as people often used log-off mechanics to "save their ships" from destruction when they did something stupid.... (like jumped blind through a gate into a gate camp).

3.) Assuming freighter ganking is truly an issue, these are the potential remedies:
  • Simply buff freighters like mining barges were buffed....
  • -- In my opinion, this is the WORST thing CCP could do. It essentially stomps on the emergent game play rather than nurturing it.

  • Give freighters fitting options so they can add tank and/or agility at the expense of carge...
  • -- In my opinion, this is the Best thing CCP could do... Idiots are idiots, and there will still be plenty of targets to support the emergent game play. At the same time, it gives frieghter pilots the ability to optimize their ship to manage cargo, speed, and tank. Things to be aware of... No highslots... (cyno's cool, but cloaks inappropriate!!)... Midslots as long as no easy MWD-to-warp shenanigans... Give lots of low slots, but balance HP to cargo capacity.... Untanked, freighter EHP ~100k... Fully tanked... freighter cargo should be about 75k m3... Max cargo fits should be less than 1m m3.

  • Alternatives that enhance game play, rather than inhibit it (propose more as you think of them):
  • Decoy Cargo Containers -- Insure your ship, configure it so the suicide gankers think your hauling something valuable... and laugh when they destroy your ship and get nothing...
    Exploding Freight Containers -- If your ship dies, the loot inside these detonate too...
    Smuggler Holds -- Unscannable storage areas for your ship...


    I liked the exploding cans idea, maybe you should be able to insure your cargo although im thinking that would be highly susceptible to exploits

    More NPC - Randomly Generated Modular Content thread https://forums.eveonline.com/default.aspx?g=posts&t=220858

    Powers Sa
    #35 - 2013-04-10 00:49:32 UTC
    Just an FYI, my freighter has never been ganked while hauling the spoils back to jita, and i've run some 20-30bil freighters before.

    I think we only ever had one 4b freighter ganked on the way FROM jita TO inaro, and that was Warr Akini (our leader) autopiloting. I then trolled him and he rage-logged.

    If I can do it, then you nerds can do it. Goons are bad at ever remember? If you're losing your freighter, then you must be worse than goons, and that's saying a lot right there.

    Do you like winning t2 frigs and dictors for Dirt Cheap?https://eveninggames.net/register/ref/dQddmNgyLhFBqNJk

    Remeber: Gambling addiction is no laughing matter unless you've lost a vast space fortune on the internet.

    Sir Marksalot
    Aliastra
    Gallente Federation
    #36 - 2013-04-10 01:19:33 UTC
    Powers Sa wrote:
    Just an FYI, my freighter has never been ganked while hauling the spoils back to jita, and i've run some 20-30bil freighters before.

    I think we only ever had one 4b freighter ganked on the way FROM jita TO inaro, and that was Warr Akini (our leader) autopiloting. I then trolled him and he rage-logged.

    If I can do it, then you nerds can do it. Goons are bad at ever remember? If you're losing your freighter, then you must be worse than goons, and that's saying a lot right there.


    I remember when that happened. Best KM ever.

    But no really everything about this is broken. I can't believe killing freighters only takes 10-20 people who have an advanced understanding of game mechanics, about half a dozen dudes constantly doing logistics, about 10-20b worth of start-up money, a large section of 0.0 sov, a very large pool of active pilots to keep the group going on a regular basis, and an expensive (in terms of real money) infrastructure maintained by the great SOLODRAKBAN.

    Seriously, buff freighters until they can tank like an Aeon this is bullshit.
    Sir Marksalot
    Aliastra
    Gallente Federation
    #37 - 2013-04-10 01:20:31 UTC
    also I too carry too much in my freighter


    it just helps that I'm not mentally challenged
    Teckos Pech
    Hogyoku
    Goonswarm Federation
    #38 - 2013-04-10 02:30:34 UTC
    Viden Anzomi wrote:


    Snip to save space....




    Couple of questions, how much were you carrying, i.e. the isk value? Was it double wrapped? Were you war decced?

    You left this stuff out. It is very important to evaluate your post.

    If you were carrying a valuable cargo...your mistake. If you were carrying a double wrapped cargo, your mistake as it makes people think it is valuable else why hide it. If you were war decced....well very very much your mistake.

    "The curious task of economics is to demonstrate to men how little they really know about what they imagine they can design."--Friedrich August von Hayek

    8 Golden Rules for EVE Online

    Zan Shiro
    Doomheim
    #39 - 2013-04-10 03:12:19 UTC
    Viden Anzomi wrote:
    2. Regarding the nature of Freighter ship (almost 0% resistance) it's really easy to shoot it down for other players (pirates). Why is this type of ship build like this ?



    to foster the MMO aspect.


    Example:

    Security conscious null sec corps on massive logistic ops will give the freighters an escort fleet of some kind. Escort fleet protects the freighters at midpoints if neede be, the eventual low sec/high sec interface system and at least jump into empire to cover them when they jump in there to. Some basic scouting to free up the escorts to say jita and that is how moon goo gets from 0.0 to jita for some.


    Not in null sec, the empire aspect is seen as mentioned above with a scout at the minimum. Ask a buddy to scout your ride to the desto. Your boy jumps into a clean system gate, then checks outbound gate and its clear you jump. Your boy jumps in and sees 10 tier 3 bc's just chilling its decision time: jump or find a new route. Not in a corp and a lone wolf, make a new account and alt tab between the 2 the whole route.

    Or like said above limit load value. I assume average price of 10 tier 3' bc's for example. Give or take an isk or 2 an average of 800 mil (80 mil per ship) last time I bohtered to check prices....if off well adjust it.

    Then I go the RNG gods will take say 40-50% of cargo on the drop so maybe consider hauling a few hundred mil more.

    10 naga's generally will scan you before they engage. Unless they really just don't like you and that hate is enough to get 10 people to crap away 80 mil (or whateve a full fit tier 3 goes for these days) for the lolz a load worth 1 bil after loot reduced to say 600 mil after RNG takes away some cargo means you sail right on by.


    Low sec runs....jf's, end of story. Or lots and lots of transport hauling lol. Oh noze I lost my charon in tama. Taking charon to tama was a bad idea to start with.






    Scuzzy Logic
    Space Spuds
    #40 - 2013-04-10 03:50:22 UTC  |  Edited by: Scuzzy Logic
    Cameron Cahill wrote:
    Viden Anzomi wrote:
    I would like to say one thing. This topic is a reflection on the game mechanics. I'm not against principilen gank mechanics.

    - The second character with web is acceptable tactic, I know her
    - Carry less - ok why not.

    But the purpose of this discussion is to consider the features of this game mechanics, which clearly favors some and harms others. My opinion is that the press should be proportionate to risk. These (gank-pirate) people are safe.

    I apologize for my English.


    The gankers are guarenteed to loose their ships, how is this safe? The only reason its done is because people make it easy, profitable and fun. It is the harderst (and least profitable) it has ever been to kill freighters in highsec. It has ben nerfed repeatedly and it is very easy to avoid. If you die now it is no ones fault but your own so there is no reason for a change in game mechanics.


    Aaaaactually they can Just warp off to the nearest safe point and eject their pods, then have someone scoop their hull minutes afterwards. This is why even 0.6 and 0.5 systems are freighter-ganking heavens.

    Also, regarding ISK worth, I have been killed in my Fenrir carrying about 250Ms worth of courrier'd assembled ships. Twice. Thus leading me to never fly a freighter between Amarr and Jita ever again.