These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Warfare & Tactics

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
12Next page
 

Neutral Logistics or reppers get concorded

Author
Musashi Sunsu
Ministry of War
Amarr Empire
#1 - 2013-03-09 04:34:17 UTC
This is a request to CCP to change it so Neutral Logistics or reppers get concorded when repping a ship out of corp. Reason for this is very simple. When assessing a fight most the battle is in knowing your enemy, there capabilities, when and where to fight but it is impossible to know how many neutral logis they have before it’s too late. Example your fleet has 7 ships the enemy 4 and you engage in combat, just when first 1 is about to explode 3 logis not in there corp but on alt accounts show up and rep the first target. They do turn suspect but by that point in time fleet is scrammed and webbed and not able to get into range of logis and the fight is over. My corp gets war dec A LOT and this tactic is getting so common that really the only counters to this tactic is to go in with cheap ships and assume they have a fleet of neutral logis and flush out who they are and just go for the fleet loosing cheapos so next time your able to assesses there real strength, or dock up tell war deck is over, or everyone quit corp tell war dec is over. I’m not apposed to fighting closely matched odds or pvp by any means but would like to know who I’m fighting before the fighting starts. Most the mercenary corps out there has a corp of neutral logis as backup but the standard mixed corp doesn’t. The fix to this is simple neutral reppers get concorded and would make a war dec be between the 2 corps or alliance that are at war and no one else.
JAF Anders
Adenosine Inhibition
#2 - 2013-03-09 06:46:11 UTC
Incursions become all the more challenging, having to tank Sansha and Concord.

The pursuit of excellence and stabbed plexing alts.

Ohishi
Apocalypse Reign
#3 - 2013-03-09 09:58:41 UTC
I'm pretty sure that if you rep a concord target you get concodekken. So where is the problem?

Do not seek to follow in the footsteps of the wise. Seek what they sought.

Musashi Sunsu
Ministry of War
Amarr Empire
#4 - 2013-03-09 14:38:07 UTC
JAF Anders wrote:
Incursions become all the more challenging, having to tank Sansha and Concord.


Yes I see your point. You would have to have your logi support be in the same corp as you if they did change this.
Musashi Sunsu
Ministry of War
Amarr Empire
#5 - 2013-03-09 14:39:22 UTC
Ohishi wrote:
I'm pretty sure that if you rep a concord target you get concodekken. So where is the problem?


You should try and read the original post before responding.
Gary Bell
Therapy.
The Initiative.
#6 - 2013-03-09 14:44:10 UTC
You should try to stop making dumb posts. Logi is used in other places aside from your pointless wars. You can shoot the logi. If your not prepared that is your own fault.

K thanks bye.

Oh and WINE NUET LOGI WHINE TEAR WHINE
Ohishi
Apocalypse Reign
#7 - 2013-03-09 14:52:01 UTC
Musashi Sunsu wrote:
Ohishi wrote:
I'm pretty sure that if you rep a concord target you get concodekken. So where is the problem?


You should try and read the original post before responding.
The OP was a bunch of bitching. My pst was showing the benefit of the current system. GFY.

Do not seek to follow in the footsteps of the wise. Seek what they sought.

Bad Messenger
Rehabilitation Clinic
#8 - 2013-03-09 15:50:04 UTC
no
Vimsy Vortis
Shoulda Checked Local
Break-A-Wish Foundation
#9 - 2013-03-09 16:55:42 UTC  |  Edited by: Vimsy Vortis
Remember that what you personally think "neutral logistics" is and what the game thinks are not the same. There have already been a bucketfuls of whine from bad highsec PVPers and carebears alike complaining about their logistics becoming suspect flagged in situations that they personally don't feel constitute neutral logistics.

They probably should have thought about that before they told CCP what a great idea suspect flagging neutral logistics was prior to crimewatch 2.0 being implemented. Sucks to be them, they made that bed, time for them to lay in it.

If neutral logistics was considered a criminal action I gaurantee you'd be back on the forums in a few weeks bitching about how much it sucks that I can make it so nobody can rep you without going GCC by [SOME KIND OF THING].

Any change to game mechanics that you want to happen because it screws over people who're more prepared and capable than you is going to screw you over much more than it will, you just don't realize how because you're dumb.
Musashi Sunsu
Ministry of War
Amarr Empire
#10 - 2013-03-09 17:20:59 UTC
Neutral repper meaning, neutral to war dec. How do you prepare for them and how would you know the number of alt accounts your opponent has with logis on to prepare? Please enlighten me sense I am so dumb Vimsy Vortis how would YOU counter this and know there true numbers?

So far I haven’t heard any constructive criticism as to how anyone else counters this with example. But it is a lot easier to just call someone dumb or ill prepared but no examples as to how they would prepare which makes me believe so far I’m just hearing from people that dish it out with there logi alt accounts and not been on receiving end or haven’t experience it themselves and speaking from ignorance.

The interference with incursions fleet is the only augment that I’ve heard against this that has merit so far.
Musashi Sunsu
Ministry of War
Amarr Empire
#11 - 2013-03-09 17:36:45 UTC
In null it’s a bit easer because its safe to assume that anyone in system set to red or not in alliance is an enemy you’re fighting, In wormholes if they don’t show in scan then it’s a cloaky and depending on class of wormhole, how long you watched pos-es in wh, entrances, ya can make good guess as to what ya might fight. If you are against this idea of Neutral logis getting concorded please explain what you would to determined number of logis in a system with hundreds of people in that highsec system and then how you would counter and then tell me why you think it’s a bad idea for logis out of corp repping to not get concorded. This would be a lot more productive then name calling.
Vimsy Vortis
Shoulda Checked Local
Break-A-Wish Foundation
#12 - 2013-03-09 17:45:43 UTC
I fly a Bhaalgorn, that's how I counter neutral logistics.
Musashi Sunsu
Ministry of War
Amarr Empire
#13 - 2013-03-09 18:04:05 UTC
Vimsy Vortis wrote:
I fly a Bhaalgorn, that's how I counter neutral logistics.


You're up against a 2 T2 missile launching cruisers in your Bhaalgorn with a corp mate flying lets say any T2 cruiser ya choose. You get primaried and missiles don’t need cap and you almost have the first ship exploded when suddenly there shields are at full and you notice they have 2 logis that warped in to help them. The one ya didn’t have cap drain has ya webbed and scrammed. The logis are over 60k off. Your armor is almost gone by this time assuming ya have about 130ehp (been in fight about just like this before lol) how does your Bhaalgorn save you??
Marsan
#14 - 2013-03-09 19:16:31 UTC
It could be worse they use to not get a suspect flag, and you'd face folks with more x2 neutral repers than war targets. Now the trick against neutral repers is to field a neutral gank fleet to take out the neutral logi. Basically engage the war targets with fleet A, and the once their logi get flagged fleet B ecm, neuts, or alphas the logi. This way you can bring a neutral Bhaalgorn or Widow to counter the logi. In general all you'll need to do is lock the logi, and they tend get too scared to engage. If they start reshipping to fight back you can always reship to a cheap blackbird or the like.

Former forum cheerleader CCP, now just a grumpy small portion of the community.

Musashi Sunsu
Ministry of War
Amarr Empire
#15 - 2013-03-09 19:24:06 UTC
Marsan wrote:
It could be worse they use to not get a suspect flag, and you'd face folks with more x2 neutral repers than war targets. Now the trick against neutral repers is to field a neutral gank fleet to take out the neutral logi. Basically engage the war targets with fleet A, and the once their logi get flagged fleet B ecm, neuts, or alphas the logi. This way you can bring a neutral Bhaalgorn or Widow to counter the logi. In general all you'll need to do is lock the logi, and they tend get too scared to engage. If they start reshipping to fight back you can always reship to a cheap blackbird or the like.


I like this idea. Thank you for your costructive post Marsan. I'd still like to hear more ideas as to why (without name calling and with examples if possible like Marsan did) this is or isn't a bad idea and tactics for current gmae system.
Vimsy Vortis
Shoulda Checked Local
Break-A-Wish Foundation
#16 - 2013-03-09 19:57:35 UTC
Musashi Sunsu wrote:
Vimsy Vortis wrote:
I fly a Bhaalgorn, that's how I counter neutral logistics.


You're up against a 2 T2 missile launching cruisers in your Bhaalgorn with a corp mate flying lets say any T2 cruiser ya choose. You get primaried and missiles don’t need cap and you almost have the first ship exploded when suddenly there shields are at full and you notice they have 2 logis that warped in to help them. The one ya didn’t have cap drain has ya webbed and scrammed. The logis are over 60k off. Your armor is almost gone by this time assuming ya have about 130ehp (been in fight about just like this before lol) how does your Bhaalgorn save you??

I don't expect to be able to win a fight against 4 people by myself. I bring my buddies and my own logistics particularly when I'm dealing with other highsec mercenaries since they have neutral logistics approximately 100% of the time.

This is the absolute epitome of a reactionary whine thread. You're mad about your recent losses so you're complaining that local doesn't provide you with perfectly accurate intelligence about what you're going to be fighting, as if it's reasonable to expect a chat channel to do that.

The reality is that figuring out whether or not to expect neutral logistics is trivial, between actually scouting, occasionally hitting the D-Scan button and knowing who it is you're fighting it isn't hard. And countering neutral logistics is also trivial, either by actually being equipped to fight logistics yourself or bringing a neutral fleet with you.

You don't even have to fight them yourself anymore, anyone in the game can do it for you, quit your whining and do something about it, right now you're exactly the same as the carebears screeching to CCP to nerf bumping.
mossbit
Fortune's House
#17 - 2013-03-09 20:05:00 UTC  |  Edited by: mossbit
Musashi Sunsu wrote:
Vimsy Vortis wrote:
I fly a Bhaalgorn, that's how I counter neutral logistics.


You're up against a 2 T2 missile launching cruisers in your Bhaalgorn with a corp mate flying lets say any T2 cruiser ya choose. You get primaried and missiles don’t need cap and you almost have the first ship exploded when suddenly there shields are at full and you notice they have 2 logis that warped in to help them. The one ya didn’t have cap drain has ya webbed and scrammed. The logis are over 60k off. Your armor is almost gone by this time assuming ya have about 130ehp (been in fight about just like this before lol) how does your Bhaalgorn save you??


I'll take this i would keep a nuet on the already capped out ship, and through ecm drones and the rest of my nuets on the second. Assuming I have a ishtar buddy he throughs ecm drones on 2nd guy too. One is capped out so cant scram, the other cant target I take note of where the now suspect logis are before I warp, and if i think I can warp onto of them i'll be back.

Alternatively i pull in my own nuetral logi (if require may not even be needed) put ecm drones on theirs

Alternatively I warp an alt or friend on top of the now suspect logi's to kill them

Alternatively I unclock a falcon, arazu or warp in the t1 equivelents

Plenty of ways to win or draw that fight, you've got to learn to not show all your cards at the get go. Hell assuming that the logis arent cap transferring I'd be happy to fight all that in a nuet domi.

I used to fight solo for about 3 years with no alts. Ecm, damps and nuets are your friends in these situtations

P.s donations to this char please
Typherian
V.O.I.D.
Pandemic Legion
#18 - 2013-03-10 22:18:55 UTC
Do the smart thing and fly with logi yourself. I've fought all over eve against enemies that for all I know could bring double or triple my fleet in capitals alone. Suck it up about a few logis and adapt. If your logi pilots are competent they can either rep you till you de-aagress and jump/dock or hold you up and fight it out until you guys force the hostile fleet to make a mistake and explode. Stop whining start adapting.
Milan Nantucket
Doomheim
#19 - 2013-03-11 22:03:05 UTC
you could always get some friends with blackbird and jam the logis once they go suspect.... logistics are pretty useless if they can't target.
Marsan
#20 - 2013-03-11 23:40:03 UTC
Musashi Sunsu wrote:
Marsan wrote:
It could be worse they use to not get a suspect flag, and you'd face folks with more x2 neutral repers than war targets. Now the trick against neutral repers is to field a neutral gank fleet to take out the neutral logi. Basically engage the war targets with fleet A, and the once their logi get flagged fleet B ecm, neuts, or alphas the logi. This way you can bring a neutral Bhaalgorn or Widow to counter the logi. In general all you'll need to do is lock the logi, and they tend get too scared to engage. If they start reshipping to fight back you can always reship to a cheap blackbird or the like.


I like this idea. Thank you for your costructive post Marsan. I'd still like to hear more ideas as to why (without name calling and with examples if possible like Marsan did) this is or isn't a bad idea and tactics for current gmae system.


Getting involved in a High Sec war is an exercise in futility. It's all ganks at trade hubs, gate camps, and station games. The number of so called l33t high sec pvpers that will engage you in anything resembling a stand up fight is near zero. Any time a war target is willing to engage you should likely just run as it's a trap. Also giving them kills or "good fights" just encourages them to continue the war. Make them bored. Go play world of tanks, hop into low sec or a wormhole, or drop corp for a while. It's going to be this way until CCP puts in some way for a defender to win a war. There is no interesting pvp in high sec outside of RvB just gankers looking for easy kills, and tears. Give me wspace over a high sec war any day....

Former forum cheerleader CCP, now just a grumpy small portion of the community.

12Next page