These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Science & Industry

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Is it possible, to "breed" heavier asteroids over a series of downtimes in high sec?: Disc

Author
Rio Bravo
Deep Core Mining Inc.
Caldari State
#1 - 2013-01-12 22:34:45 UTC
This has probably been talked about before...would really like to hear what people think about this. If it is something I can do on my own with a chosen belt would be nice. I don't know exactly how the spawn mechanics for static belts work,but a few experiences out in space have given me suspiscion to think that this engineering strategy has been practiced before. Hey, if a dev would weigh in, it would be great. Guess it could be called "selective mining" and "breeding" the rocks we harvest regularly. Is there such a method?
Smile

“You see, in this world there's two kinds of people, my friend: Those with loaded guns and those who dig. I dig.”  - Clint Eastwood, misquote.

Dave Stark
#2 - 2013-01-12 22:59:58 UTC
as far as i'm aware, at downtime all depleted asteroids are respawned with some ore in them, those that aren't depleted gain extra ore until they reach some unknown maximum.
hence, yes, if you leave asteroids over a period of downtimes they'll "grow" to their maximum (whatever that is).

or, so i've heard.

then again, i ain't got time for fiddling around with that **** so i just pop all the asteroids!
Skorpynekomimi
#3 - 2013-01-12 23:56:05 UTC
You'd need to shepherd the field very carefully, though.

Economic PVP

Lord Battlestar
CALIMA COLLABORATIVE
Atrox Urbanis Respublique Abundatia
#4 - 2013-01-13 03:03:35 UTC
It is somewhat possible to do theoretically, but likely impossible to do in game because not everyone is going to follow your system, in highsec especially.

I once podded myself by blowing a huge fart.

Rio Bravo
Deep Core Mining Inc.
Caldari State
#5 - 2013-01-13 16:23:13 UTC
Dave stark wrote:
as far as i'm aware, at downtime all depleted asteroids are respawned with some ore in them, those that aren't depleted gain extra ore until they reach some unknown maximum.
hence, yes, if you leave asteroids over a period of downtimes they'll "grow" to their maximum (whatever that is).

or, so i've heard.

then again, i ain't got time for fiddling around with that **** so i just pop all the asteroids!


Ok, so you have to monitor the rocks pretty closely then. Seen it in a 0.5 dead end system that was "owned" by a 50 man industrial corp that had an alt corp that would suicide gank other miners that came to "thier" system. The asteroids there were humongous!

“You see, in this world there's two kinds of people, my friend: Those with loaded guns and those who dig. I dig.”  - Clint Eastwood, misquote.

Salpad
Carebears with Attitude
#6 - 2013-01-13 16:34:51 UTC
Rio Bravo wrote:
This has probably been talked about before...would really like to hear what people think about this. If it is something I can do on my own with a chosen belt would be nice. I don't know exactly how the spawn mechanics for static belts work,but a few experiences out in space have given me suspiscion to think that this engineering strategy has been practiced before. Hey, if a dev would weigh in, it would be great. Guess it could be called "selective mining" and "breeding" the rocks we harvest regularly. Is there such a method?
Smile


I certainly know of a few rarely-visited systems, on the edges of high-sec, that have some huge asteroids. I haven't actually taken a survey scanner to them, but in terms of diameter most are multiple kilometers. The only way for that to happen is if they keep growing each downtime, either until they reach a certain limit and then stop, or else so that growth slows down and become asymptotic after a certain threshold. But even if so, that limit is threshold seems to have been set very high.
Randolph Rothstein
whatever corp.
#7 - 2013-01-13 23:38:41 UTC
but why would you want to do that?

lets say you wont mine for a week and let an asteroid field grow - then you will mine it but the yield will be only that one week you didnt mine,so you will actually have to 1,police the field and 2, be ready for a reaaaaaly long day in office mining all that ore

i find that too much work for the same yield as i would get mining every downtime

i can see doing it for ***** and giggles tho Lol
Salpad
Carebears with Attitude
#8 - 2013-01-14 05:59:06 UTC
Because it's less work when you have to switch target roids often, because they all pop after 2 cycles.
Kestrix
The Whispering
#9 - 2013-01-14 07:29:46 UTC
Go to a system without a station. These are ignored to a certain degree by miners becasue they require more work hauling the ore away to another system. Your find belts that have been let for quite a time here.
Styth spiting
Brutor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#10 - 2013-01-14 10:39:15 UTC
Watch for systems that have incursions that frequently spawn in their constellations.


Many of the belts in these systems will not be possible to be mined for the duration of the incursion, and based on the type/place the incursion happens players might not be involved and it will expire after a number of days (5 days IIRC). This means once the incursion ends, either by players or timing out all the belts will have had several days to re-spawn and build up minerals.

The down side though is like everything in eve the players in the EU time zones have the best advantage as they can get to these belts right after reset, so you need to be ready to head out and take advantage of these belts as early as possible.
Bugsy VanHalen
Society of lost Souls
#11 - 2013-01-14 17:04:31 UTC
I have read a lot of theories about this over the years.

The idea is that if you leave rocks with a ore left they will respawn at down time larger than they would if you pop them. It is believed that doing this over many months you can build up the belt to larger rocks each down time. I have not tested this myself, as it only takes one miner to come in an cherry pick/pop the rocks you left.

I have also read this can be used to farm certain types of rocks. by always leaving the higher value rocks not popped and popping the veldspar for example the popped rocks could respawn as a different type while the rocks left unpopped will grow with each downtime. This would allow you to culture a belt an maximize not only the size of the rocks, but the types as well. I have also not tested this theroy.

There is another story which I have actually seen happen before. All belts spawn in a semi circle. different belts spawn in different sizes around a predefined arc. Some larger belts can have large gaps in that arc, while still being on the same circular path but appearing almost as two separate belts on the same grid. Many belts have a very large radius to the arc, even to the point where much of the circle is off grid from the warp in. At times a portion of the belt can spawn at other points around the circle/arc, even off grid from the main part of the belt. These can be found by flying off grid from the main belt following the arc/circle that main belt is on(easier to judge with the tactical over lay on). Using this method I have found segments of static belts spawned actually off grid from the warp in. These generally contain larger rocks as they are often over looked by the average miner. These are not hidden belts, but just rocks spawned further along the circle/arc of the main belt when that arc has a radius larger than 450km. It is rare but it does happen, I have seen it.

One thing I do know, is that when ever I have mined a belt out completely, leaving not a single rock no matter how small, the next day the respwaned belt was very small, not even worth mining. So popping the whole belt does not trigger a respawn of a fresh full belt. It seems that it takes time to grow as mentioned above.
Govind
Parity Labs
#12 - 2013-01-16 15:57:52 UTC
I seem to remember a dev blog from a few years back that dispelled all the myths about 'cultivating' asteroid fields but I don't have the link anymore. My understanding is that for a given constellation (or some other grouping of systems) there is a set amount of ore to distribute. As people mine it it goes back into the pool to distribute at DT. Upon DT, the pool of ore to distribute is randomly strewn over all belts in each system.

If that theory is correct, if everyone in EvE stopped mining then roids would grow over the next DT but without ore in the pool to distribute they would not grow after subsequent DTs. Likewise, if everyone in EvE mined only a single system then each downtime some of that ore would repopulate that same system but the rest would scatter in other systems, eventually leading to that one system having nearly no ore after each downtime.

If all of that is true, the best strategy is to adopt multiple systems to mine in and only mine in whichever you can harvest the most efficiently and with the most gain at the time. You could camp a system and hope that others drive ore to your system over several DTs, but it is a sub-optimal strategy.
Apelacja
Sad Najwyzszy
#13 - 2013-01-17 01:48:57 UTC  |  Edited by: Apelacja
as long as belt can be mined in few h there is no need to change anything. and with some corp op u clean whole system.

right now the respawn rate is somehow like 1/3 -1/2 of full asteroid so if u leave system for 2 days u get full field.
sabre906
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#14 - 2013-01-17 18:33:17 UTC
Rio Bravo wrote:
Dave stark wrote:
as far as i'm aware, at downtime all depleted asteroids are respawned with some ore in them, those that aren't depleted gain extra ore until they reach some unknown maximum.
hence, yes, if you leave asteroids over a period of downtimes they'll "grow" to their maximum (whatever that is).

or, so i've heard.

then again, i ain't got time for fiddling around with that **** so i just pop all the asteroids!


Ok, so you have to monitor the rocks pretty closely then. Seen it in a 0.5 dead end system that was "owned" by a 50 man industrial corp that had an alt corp that would suicide gank other miners that came to "thier" system. The asteroids there were humongous!


Unless they gank Rokhs and be online 23/7, I don't see how this works in highsec.
Mizuno Kalfren
Doomheim
#15 - 2013-01-17 18:33:46 UTC
There is also the fact of the security of the system in question,

While not mining in a system for while might alow the roid to increas in size to s cirten extent that would not alow them to reach the max size for that type of ore, if you are located in a high security system. For example in the system that we live in nulsec, even if we compleatly empty the system out over the cousre of the day the roids come back masive in comparison to higher security space. Though from past experiance from living in high sec, systems that were almost never mined would only have a very small amount in the astroids in comparison.

So i belive if you are wanting to farm astroids i would find the most isolated system posible to mine in, this would both alow you to some what more control the "growth" of the astroid and also the mining of them. But in all ohnasty i would just recomend that you find a system that is to your likeing and stick with it. And over time you might bulld up a routine of mining the belts that allows for the astroid yeiled that you are looking for.

Hope this helps a little bit,

Fly Safe
Rio Bravo
Deep Core Mining Inc.
Caldari State
#16 - 2013-01-19 11:29:15 UTC
Hmmm...all sounds interesting. I would have to overcome my mental lazyness, and tag each roid in a spreadsheet like a farmer. Looks like I would have to set up scarecrows and some how chase away critters coming to nibble on the rocks too. Sounds like too much work without practical returns. Seems there is a dynamic of some sorts, I mean, more than just a full respawn after every downtime. I will just call it magic, and label anyone who understands it a witch!
Big smile

“You see, in this world there's two kinds of people, my friend: Those with loaded guns and those who dig. I dig.”  - Clint Eastwood, misquote.

Dave Stark
#17 - 2013-01-22 12:23:43 UTC
going to call bullshit on this theory.

4 days.
600k m3 from the belt on the first and second day,
just shy of 300k the third day.
and today is looking like another 600k based on how fast i'm stripping the belt, will confirm when i'm done.

however, it seems to be completely random, since i've been stripping every asteroid from the same belt every day.