These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Missions & Complexes

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
123Next page
 

DEV's any information about changes to the changes of AI?

Author
Archa4 Badasaz
Vangazhi
#1 - 2012-12-05 20:15:36 UTC
So, when I first heard about the AI changes, i was a bit worried. "A bit" - cause I don't fly a drone boat.
Then i went to the Retribution page http://www.eveonline.com/retribution/upgraded-npc-ai/ about all those changes and read these things:

Q) Will NPC's kill my drones?
A) Yes, but they don't hate them nearly as much as sleepers. I ran 9 level 4 missions and lost 2 drones. It does mean you need to pay more attention though. We can adjust their hatred of drones though which is why we are asking for feedback when this hits a test server.

Q) Does this change things like spawns or range activation?
A) No. When the NPC decide to start hating you is still based on the individual mission.

I'm sorry, but what is this? This is a major change for missions, but even in the FAQ there is wrong information written.
World Collide, Blockade and such missions - how people are supposed to tank everything at once? "Still based on individual missions" - With these changes - no it's not. You get full room agro no matter what you do.
How are can you loose 2 drones in 9 missions, when if your drones are 30km out, attacking that pesky frig, and start taking damage, you call them back, but it's already to late. id the drones are 2-5 km out then yes, it's possible to save them in time. But, in my opinion, if you pay attention you should always be able to save every one of those drones.

And what about those people specializing in drone boats?

Please adjust the NPC's to be less hatred.
Void 0
Black Rabbits
Black Rabbit.
#2 - 2012-12-05 20:26:32 UTC
Lost 7 TIER 2 drones in Angel Extravaganza, without doing the bonus room.
And yes I did pull them back, but with the incredibly clunky UI it takes ages.

I was aggroed by whole room instantly in several missions.

CCP never changes, whenever they relase something new its either totally broken or a bad idea. This is both.

Unless they plan to start selling Tier 3 cruisers for real money, then it would be a genius buisness move from them.
Caellach Marellus
Stormcrows
#3 - 2012-12-05 20:37:58 UTC
The room wide aggro seems to be an unintended addition to the patch.

They're right about the Drones though, they certainly don't hate you the way Sleeper Drones do, infact pulling them in and redeploying them for me so far has resulted in them being completely ignored afterwards in each room.

When your gut instincts tell you something is wrong, trust them. When your heart tells you something is right, ignore it, check with your brain first. Accept nothing, challenge everything.

Archa4 Badasaz
Vangazhi
#4 - 2012-12-05 20:40:18 UTC
Caellach Marellus wrote:
resulted in them being completely ignored afterwards in each room.


About this I read somewhere that this IS a bug, and will be fixed
Caellach Marellus
Stormcrows
#5 - 2012-12-05 20:44:12 UTC
Archa4 Badasaz wrote:
Caellach Marellus wrote:
resulted in them being completely ignored afterwards in each room.


About this I read somewhere that this IS a bug, and will be fixed


Well that's a positive. Suppose trading that for the insta fullroom aggro situation will retain some difficulty.

I'll be honest, and this is the sadist in me, I actually enjoy Serpentis assault more now because of the amount of careful flying needed.



Also side note on AI, anyone else noticed NPC's randomly dropping basic tackle despite being well in range. Such as webs and points being switched off at 8k.

When your gut instincts tell you something is wrong, trust them. When your heart tells you something is right, ignore it, check with your brain first. Accept nothing, challenge everything.

Wolfman SS
4400 EVE
#6 - 2012-12-05 21:03:20 UTC
Void 0 wrote:
Lost 7 TIER 2 drones in Angel Extravaganza, without doing the bonus room.
And yes I did pull them back, but with the incredibly clunky UI it takes ages.

I was aggroed by whole room instantly in several missions.

CCP never changes, whenever they relase something new its either totally broken or a bad idea. This is both.

Unless they plan to start selling Tier 3 cruisers for real money, then it would be a genius buisness move from them.



Spot on!
Atossa Exior
Midnight Conclave
#7 - 2012-12-05 22:39:19 UTC
If you paint/web/ECM any rats they hate you more than your drones. It also helps to kill frigs first since it's them that aggro drones more often than other rats.

As for room aggro, maybe CCP means for lvl 4's to be more group based that solo pimp bltized. The revamped T1 logis are looking better and better....
Akuma Tsukai
State Protectorate
Caldari State
#8 - 2012-12-05 23:46:46 UTC
Atossa Exior wrote:
If you paint/web/ECM any rats they hate you more than your drones. It also helps to kill frigs first since it's them that aggro drones more often than other rats.

As for room aggro, maybe CCP means for lvl 4's to be more group based that solo pimp bltized. The revamped T1 logis are looking better and better....

EWAR doesnt help with mission rats, they still insta switched to drones. Guess they ARE different from sleeper AI, good work CCP What?
I foresee glorious return of the raven as only viable PVE boat.
Void 0
Black Rabbits
Black Rabbit.
#9 - 2012-12-06 14:41:14 UTC
Akuma Tsukai wrote:
Atossa Exior wrote:
If you paint/web/ECM any rats they hate you more than your drones. It also helps to kill frigs first since it's them that aggro drones more often than other rats.

As for room aggro, maybe CCP means for lvl 4's to be more group based that solo pimp bltized. The revamped T1 logis are looking better and better....

EWAR doesnt help with mission rats, they still insta switched to drones. Guess they ARE different from sleeper AI, good work CCP What?
I foresee glorious return of the raven as only viable PVE boat.


And how is that Raven going to deal with spawns of 3-4 frigs?
Anneliese Pollard
University of Caille
Gallente Federation
#10 - 2012-12-06 14:49:12 UTC
2 nights of missioning.

0 drones lost.

Aducat Ragnarson
Blootered Bastards
#11 - 2012-12-06 14:49:25 UTC
You claim that EWAR does not help, however many missionrunners have reported that one single web or target painter is enough to completely secure your drones. Maybe you should test that out instead of bitching about a change that one can easily adapt to if one is smart.
Void 0
Black Rabbits
Black Rabbit.
#12 - 2012-12-06 14:52:36 UTC
Aducat Ragnarson wrote:
You claim that EWAR does not help, however many missionrunners have reported that one single web or target painter is enough to completely secure your drones. Maybe you should test that out instead of bitching about a change that one can easily adapt to if one is smart.

It's enough to secure them against 1 frig(the one you put the ECM on) However should you face 4 or more your drones are doomed.
Void 0
Black Rabbits
Black Rabbit.
#13 - 2012-12-06 14:53:16 UTC
Anneliese Pollard wrote:
2 nights of missioning.

0 drones lost.


Let me guess. You are flying a Tengu :D?
Aducat Ragnarson
Blootered Bastards
#14 - 2012-12-06 15:00:58 UTC
Void 0 wrote:
Aducat Ragnarson wrote:
You claim that EWAR does not help, however many missionrunners have reported that one single web or target painter is enough to completely secure your drones. Maybe you should test that out instead of bitching about a change that one can easily adapt to if one is smart.

It's enough to secure them against 1 frig(the one you put the ECM on) However should you face 4 or more your drones are doomed.



That is utter bullshit and you would know it if you actually tried it, a single TP is enough that in full room aggro in WC and Blockade, my drones where never targeted once. Only downside, as soon as that TP drops your drones are toast, so you either need 2 TPs and have one of them active all the time, or activate your single TP on something you are not going to shoot. If you only have one TP and shoot that target, you will have a short time where you have no TP on something which will result in Dronetoast.
I am not saying the mechanic is great, I am only saying it is possible to do this. If you cannot muster a single midslot for a TP on either a shield or armor ship, you are doing something seriously wrong.
For these reasons, a dual TP torp Raven or RNI is in my opinion the best option for missions now as with t2 torps and a TP you will kill elite frigs in about 2-3 volleys since the precision skills affect torps now.
Void 0
Black Rabbits
Black Rabbit.
#15 - 2012-12-06 15:15:18 UTC
Aducat Ragnarson wrote:
Void 0 wrote:
Aducat Ragnarson wrote:
You claim that EWAR does not help, however many missionrunners have reported that one single web or target painter is enough to completely secure your drones. Maybe you should test that out instead of bitching about a change that one can easily adapt to if one is smart.

It's enough to secure them against 1 frig(the one you put the ECM on) However should you face 4 or more your drones are doomed.



That is utter bullshit and you would know it if you actually tried it, a single TP is enough that in full room aggro in WC and Blockade, my drones where never targeted once. Only downside, as soon as that TP drops your drones are toast, so you either need 2 TPs and have one of them active all the time, or activate your single TP on something you are not going to shoot. If you only have one TP and shoot that target, you will have a short time where you have no TP on something which will result in Dronetoast.
I am not saying the mechanic is great, I am only saying it is possible to do this. If you cannot muster a single midslot for a TP on either a shield or armor ship, you are doing something seriously wrong.
For these reasons, a dual TP torp Raven or RNI is in my opinion the best option for missions now as with t2 torps and a TP you will kill elite frigs in about 2-3 volleys since the precision skills affect torps now.

This is wrong . I had Angel Extravaganza today and my drones did get aggro even with TP active. Granted I only lost 3 of them instead of 7 but it does not fix the issue. Lets not forget fitting a relatively useless module...
Anneliese Pollard
University of Caille
Gallente Federation
#16 - 2012-12-06 15:43:59 UTC
Void 0 wrote:
Let me guess. You are flying a Tengu :D?


No.

Passive Rattlesnake. I snipe the frigs with 2 faction omnis and a TP. If they get into range, I wait until they actually web me, then pull the sentries and release the lights.

My strategy really hasn't changed.

1) Target all frigates
2) Snipe most, if not all with sentries
3) If frigs get up close and web me, pull sentries, release lights
4) When frigs are dead, pull lights, release sentreis
5) Cruisers, BCs, BSes, in that order

To hell with triggers. If I hit a trigger, pull the drones, wait until yellow boxed, then release them back, and do the same thing, starting with frigates.

Did this with The Blockade - twice now. I'm starting to think I have too much tank in a passive rattler now. Probably going to consider switching to active using XL ASBs and a couple of hardeners.

Oh, and yes, I paint the frigates before their destruction. It can get a little bit more tedious than normal, but it works, and I have not had a single problem with NPCs switching to my drones.

And my noctis alt sits in the pocket previous with its salvage drones.
Jenn aSide
Worthless Carebears
The Initiative.
#17 - 2012-12-06 16:17:23 UTC
Anneliese Pollard wrote:
Void 0 wrote:
Let me guess. You are flying a Tengu :D?


No.

Passive Rattlesnake. I snipe the frigs with 2 faction omnis and a TP. If they get into range, I wait until they actually web me, then pull the sentries and release the lights.

My strategy really hasn't changed.

1) Target all frigates
2) Snipe most, if not all with sentries
3) If frigs get up close and web me, pull sentries, release lights
4) When frigs are dead, pull lights, release sentreis
5) Cruisers, BCs, BSes, in that order

To hell with triggers. If I hit a trigger, pull the drones, wait until yellow boxed, then release them back, and do the same thing, starting with frigates.

Did this with The Blockade - twice now. I'm starting to think I have too much tank in a passive rattler now. Probably going to consider switching to active using XL ASBs and a couple of hardeners.

Oh, and yes, I paint the frigates before their destruction. It can get a little bit more tedious than normal, but it works, and I have not had a single problem with NPCs switching to my drones.

And my noctis alt sits in the pocket previous with its salvage drones.


You seem to believe that your experiences are universal. They aren't.

I took a Machariel in to an anomaly (anoms and mission suse the same NPCs) and barely made it out in structure. Every time i launched my hobgoblins the frigs pounded them, and not even my 1200 dps coming from my guns, my target painting or my NOSing could drag the aggro off my light drones before 2 or 3 would pop. if it weren't for a very lucky hit from my autocannons on a frig I was moving away from, i'd have lost it.

Hell, i couldn't even get the "launch drones, pull drones" bug to work, and ccp does intend to fix that defect.

You seem to think people are just whining because they don't want to adapt, this is not true of everyone or even most people, this AI change should have been a part of a comprehensive change to how things work, as it is it's just more frustration for no gain.
Coyote Reach
Perkone
Caldari State
#18 - 2012-12-06 16:35:00 UTC  |  Edited by: Coyote Reach
Ran a wyrmslayer V with carrier. Dropped my tankign ability and 2 smartbombs to be able to fit another rep and a target painter *shudder* Without painter fighters took aggro, with it the fighters were fine but ofc i was only in site >4 minutes.

Easy to get around if this is the case. It completely fucks my fit on that particular ship and still proves to me NPC AI are stupid and this 'enhancement' of NPC AI wasnt really an enhancement at all as they are still trying to kill something that is not killing them.


As jenn said "...this AI change should have been a part of a comprehensive change to how things work, as it is it's just more frustration for no gain."
Anneliese Pollard
University of Caille
Gallente Federation
#19 - 2012-12-06 20:21:50 UTC
Jenn aSide wrote:
You seem to believe that your experiences are universal. They aren't.

I took a Machariel in to an anomaly (anoms and mission suse the same NPCs) and barely made it out in structure. Every time i launched my hobgoblins the frigs pounded them, and not even my 1200 dps coming from my guns, my target painting or my NOSing could drag the aggro off my light drones before 2 or 3 would pop. if it weren't for a very lucky hit from my autocannons on a frig I was moving away from, i'd have lost it.

Hell, i couldn't even get the "launch drones, pull drones" bug to work, and ccp does intend to fix that defect.

You seem to think people are just whining because they don't want to adapt, this is not true of everyone or even most people, this AI change should have been a part of a comprehensive change to how things work, as it is it's just more frustration for no gain.


Look, I understand where some people are coming from. I do. My problem is that I'm posting things in an effort to help adapt and I'm getting slammed for it. Additionally, I'm getting Eve mails from people bitching about it too.

I can understand, even respect, people who are continuing to find ways to adapt. I don't know why my experience is different. If I can't snipe the frigs, I wait until they are all the way on top of me, then paint one and release the lights. Have had no problems with that practice.

It does not work with high slot modules. I've tested nos, neut, and RR. The AI doesn't care about those. Switching to a TP or webber in the mids did work. However, when I removed those items and put something like an omni in its place, the NPCs immediately went after the drones when I released them.

They went after lights and mediums.

Adding the Ewar back and using it resolved the problem for me.

There are others who are doing the same and having success. I don't know why its not working for others.
Annunaki soldier
Perkone
Caldari State
#20 - 2012-12-06 20:35:48 UTC
I am also a rattlesnake lover. But you cant talk for sure for everyone here. I give you an example. Doing 1 drone horde i have no prob. But the dps inside there is among the biggest you can encouter as high end anomalies. Rattlesnake tanks it easy. But sentries dont. And i always used a TP even before the ai change. The drones do get agro. And funny that i dont see em bleeding on shield first. Not all times. Some times rats change the target and that sentry ends up with armor damage with the first hit. Now imagine that on the long run. You will probably say carry armor reps drones. I am but guess what , every time you rep you dont have dps on the room. Please show me another weapon choice that has that . My point is that ? On all races of rats of course (because there are races that tracking disrupts, ecm etc but its your choice to be there for the LP store)

Ride hard, live with passionĀ 

123Next page