These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

EVE General Discussion

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
Previous page123Next page
 

EVE - a society without priests

First post
Author
Leela LaRue
Republic University
Minmatar Republic
#21 - 2012-08-13 16:08:41 UTC
I’m imagining a development meeting, where CCP sat down and discussed putting religions in game and it went something like this.

Dev1 – So, what should we add to the game? Is there anything we left out?

Dev2 - What about religion, I mean most societies have some type of religious character. If we want it to be as immersive as possible shouldn’t we have religions, and have priestly skills.

Dev1 – Ok then, what skills would a priest have?

Dev3 – Well, they talk a lot. They seem to talk about everything like they’re authorities.

Dev 2 – We already added skills for negotiation, diplomacy etc under trade? Wouldn’t that cover it?

Dev 3 – Most of them aren’t very diplomatic, they’re mostly a, ‘my way or the highway’ bunch.

Dev 1 – We can’t skill for talking out of you’re ass anyway, The Mittani would sue.

Dev 2 – What about skilling them for inducing guilt in other players, they make me feel guilty for thinking about sex.

Dev 3 – Oh yeah, I know this gay couple, and man, are the religious people all over them trying to get them to repent.

Dev 1 – Come on guys, we can‘t give them a skill that will make players feel guilty, how would that even work?

Dev 2 – Well they like to talk about sex and marriage a lot, we could…

Dev 1 – The characters don’t have sex…and I don’t see how listening to a bunch unmarried virgins or pedophiles helps in the real world, why would we add it here?

Dev 3 – What about running soup kitchens and helping the poor, that’s good?

Dev 1 – No.

Dev 2 – Collecting for religious charity…

Dev 1 – Jita scammers.

Dev 3 – Peddling influence to politicians to get their way.

Dev 1 – CSM

Dev 2 – What about giving moral guidance…sorry I can’t say that without laughing

Dev 1 – So what you’re saying is that there isn’t a single thing that priests do in the real world that we could put into Eve to improve play, what a waste of time.

Dev 3 – Yeah pretty much, but I think I might be an Atheist now.

The End
stoicfaux
#22 - 2012-08-13 16:52:31 UTC
It's actually an interesting question. What value do priest provide in the real world? Purpose, meaning, putting an anthropomorphic face on a cold uncaring universe, etc.?

If so, well, Eve is a game. Games are a form of escapism to avoid dealing with the unknowns and general harshness of the universe, so it's not like people log in to Eve expecting the game to provide meaning in their life. Plus, Eve is a sandbox. You don't need priests because in order to play a sandbox, you need a goal. If you have a goal, then you don't need a priest to tell you what your goals should be. Finally, repercussions. You can walk away from Eve. You can't walk away from the universe, hence you can't "walk away" from priests in real life.

Pon Farr Memorial: once every 7 years, all the carebears in high-sec must PvP or they will be temp-banned.

Ravan Hekki
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#23 - 2012-08-13 17:06:54 UTC
I believe that the OP isn't talking game mechanics. (love how some players attribute priest to healer or character class).

The priesthood or shamans role in society is to teach that societies morals and tend to be the glue that keep it together.

If anything the priests of Eve are the traders. The Eve social model is based around hyper-capitalism. So naturally the traders, both in objects, favors or politics are our high priests.

In the meta game however we have a priesthood of various cults of personality. An example of this is that if you post something bad about mittens you get a deluge of goon related shenanigans. This is an act that is part of their social norm, indoctrinated by mittens. He is their priest, a guiding hand that molds the societies morals and taboos. Now i could go on to say the other things priests are sometimes know for ;) but that would be mean.
Now lets look at the carebear priests, they are there and their moral codes define others around them, in different ways.

So lets face it the Heirophants and Priests of Eve are it's CEO's, Alliance leaders and those cults of personalities that we all are guilty of following.

Hiyora Akachi
Blood Alcohol Content
T O P S H E L F
#24 - 2012-08-13 18:23:19 UTC  |  Edited by: Hiyora Akachi
Religion in EvE?

NEVER! No! Science is supreme here!
Hestia Mar
Calmaretto
#25 - 2012-08-13 19:27:56 UTC
Vera Algaert wrote:
EVE players and developers alike tend to praise the game for its emergent social structures and frequently express the hope that EVE as a "social experiment" can help us understand how similar structures came to be in real-life.

With this background in mind, I'd like to raise the question "How come there are no priests in EVE?"
(or if there are "priests", who are they?)

One feature of many real-life societies seems to be the division into a clerical class, a warrior class and a producing class.

And while the warrior class and the producing class are clearly separated in EVE (admittedly more clearly on the character level than on the player level), the metagame has not brought forth anything resembling an actual clerical class from my point of view.

The closest we have come to the development of a priest class is probably some 0.0 alliances that keep political leadership and (tactical) military leadership carefully separated - but even alliance leaders that never log into the game itself lack any association with the sacred (and the authority this creates).

How come we do just fine without priests in EVE (without even noticing their absence) when we apparently can't do entirely without them in our (enlightened, 21st century) real life societies?



Join the real world my friend - those of us who live in mainly secular countries (UK for me) do fine until the religious nuts are allowed to publicise their mental illness and screw our no-religious lives
Karim alRashid
Starboard.
#26 - 2012-08-13 19:33:08 UTC
Jita local is full of priests.

That is, full of people, who do the same thing as priests IRL. Twisted

Pain is weakness leaving the body http://www.youtube.com/user/AlRashidKarim/videos

Cede Forster
Deep Core Mining Inc.
Caldari State
#27 - 2012-08-14 07:23:55 UTC
and i thought it was

a political class, a warrior class and a producing class.

but wait ... there you go, you just have to assume religion = politics and there is your solution


... but that can not be, after all religion is not about controlling people, its about faith so, disregard what i said
Rordan D'Kherr
Imperial Academy
Amarr Empire
#28 - 2012-08-14 08:46:43 UTC
Vera Algaert wrote:
EVE players and developers alike tend to praise the game for its emergent social structures and frequently express the hope that EVE as a "social experiment" can help us understand how similar structures came to be in real-life.

With this background in mind, I'd like to raise the question "How come there are no priests in EVE?"
(or if there are "priests", who are they?)



Simple: Nobody needs them actually...

Don't be scared, because being afk is not a crime.

Abel Merkabah
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#29 - 2012-08-14 10:00:02 UTC
There are people that fit the clerical class description of being guides to others on "morality".

James315 comes to mind, whether you agree with him or not, he provides in game moral guidance to some players. That is part of the clerical role.

And as other people have stated the politicians in the game fill some of the clerical role functions as well.

James315 for CSM 8!

CCP Phantom
C C P
C C P Alliance
#30 - 2012-08-14 10:21:15 UTC
Off topic posts removed. This thread is about social structures in EVE Online formed by players and not about game mechanic aspects like a "healer class".

With close to 400.000 members in the New Eden Universe our population is bigger than the population of some real world countries (for example Iceland). As all the players are human beings (err, hopefully no aliens here!) it is quite legit and might be interesting to research the social structures forming and being existent in our universe here.

CCP Phantom - Senior Community Developer

Alayna Le'line
#31 - 2012-08-14 10:32:18 UTC
Vera Algaert wrote:
EVE players and developers alike tend to praise the game for its emergent social structures and frequently express the hope that EVE as a "social experiment" can help us understand how similar structures came to be in real-life.

With this background in mind, I'd like to raise the question "How come there are no priests in EVE?"
(or if there are "priests", who are they?)

One feature of many real-life societies seems to be the division into a clerical class, a warrior class and a producing class.

And while the warrior class and the producing class are clearly separated in EVE (admittedly more clearly on the character level than on the player level), the metagame has not brought forth anything resembling an actual clerical class from my point of view.

The closest we have come to the development of a priest class is probably some 0.0 alliances that keep political leadership and (tactical) military leadership carefully separated - but even alliance leaders that never log into the game itself lack any association with the sacred (and the authority this creates).

How come we do just fine without priests in EVE (without even noticing their absence) when we apparently can't do entirely without them in our (enlightened, 21st century) real life societies?


We can, and many of us in real life do. The function of priests in life is to "guide" their disciples, the fact that there is a "sacred" association here is fairly irrelevant (imho).

In the end we all depend on other people for guidance in certain matters, religious people turn to the representatives of their religion (priests, monks, imams, ...). Non-religious people tend to turn to science for their answers, as such you could consider their professors, researchers etc as their "priests", as they are the people we look to for answers when we ourselves have none.

As such in EVE you could see alliance/corp leaders, veterans and such as "priests" as they provide guidance to those following or listening to them.
Barrogh Habalu
Imperial Shipment
Amarr Empire
#32 - 2012-08-14 10:34:09 UTC  |  Edited by: Barrogh Habalu
Anslo wrote:
Because no one care about religion when science reigns supreme. We get enough evangelical nutters in the real world.

I still fail to see how religion and science are even intersect. Unless we are dealing with overzealous folks of whatever sort.

OT:
Corpus Popes anyone?
Nah, just kidding. But really, roleplayers have enough of those, especially those RPing Amarr and Sani Sabik related people.
If you ask why there is no natural need of those in crunchy EVE world... Well, probably because players tend to fulfil their culturar and spiritual needs IRL, that'll be my guess.
Vaerah Vahrokha
Vahrokh Consulting
#33 - 2012-08-14 10:36:44 UTC  |  Edited by: Vaerah Vahrokha
It's quite simple, actually.

About reality and stuff we see and live:

- Science tries to tell us the rational HOW (stuff happens, how is it made of etc). It's mostly matter and chemistry / physics based.

- Philosophy tries to tell us the rational WHY about stuff, it's mostly mind and think based (ofc we had ample expansions into economy, sociology etc).

- Religion tries to tell us the irrational WHY about stuff, it's mostly soul-spirit-faith based.


Unsurprisingly in the past Religion was possibly the first to have born. Humanity knew little, even a bolt would be some unknown worth seeking for an answer off a witch and similar.

From the above we see a branch: in history age we see the first philosophers, they try and put the unknown and the human mind into a more rational framework.

From the above we see a branch: in later history we see the first scientists, they try and put the unknown and the human *brain* into a more rational framework.


The more the time goes on the more we know about the unknown and our physical body. The less physical questions are left to philosophers and the less spiritual questions are left to "priests".

They are all 3 a pyramid of human values, what happens is that mankind are focusing more and more on the pure material life and putting their own kind in the place where once used to be gods.
Basically RL is slowly drifting towards EvE.


In EvE we are so full of ourselves that there's no space left, neither for philosophers nor for "priests".
Chainsaw Plankton
FaDoyToy
#34 - 2012-08-14 10:42:30 UTC
Nex apparatu5 wrote:
12/10


I have to agree with this, clerical as in clerk, throwing that priest word in was brilliant! a master troll

Quote:

cler·i·cal/ˈklerikəl/
Adjective:

(of a job or person) Concerned with or relating to work in an office, esp. routine tasks.
Of or relating to the clergy.

@ChainsawPlankto on twitter

Chainsaw Plankton
FaDoyToy
#35 - 2012-08-14 10:44:55 UTC
but I guess since the 14th of August is clearly make **** up day every time you do a spread sheet you do the work of god! you good little priests!

@ChainsawPlankto on twitter

Sara XIII
The Carnifex Corp
#36 - 2012-08-14 11:16:48 UTC
There is no God but God and The_Mittani is his prophet.

I'm sure I read that somewhere.....
Between Ignorance and Wisdom
Haethorn
I've Fixed it
#37 - 2012-08-14 11:22:21 UTC
Poe's Law
Scott PiIgrim
Doomheim
#38 - 2012-08-14 11:57:52 UTC
I think the clerical class is the ninja class in eve, i belive the term metagaming is where they thrive the best. Reason for this is the apt consequenses if knowledge falls into the wrong hands.
Ptraci
3 R Corporation
#39 - 2012-08-14 12:12:17 UTC
Vera Algaert wrote:
EVE players and developers alike tend to praise the game for its emergent social structures and frequently express the hope that EVE as a "social experiment" can help us understand how similar structures came to be in real-life.

With this background in mind, I'd like to raise the question "How come there are no priests in EVE?"
(or if there are "priests", who are they?)


I suspect we just found one.
Sabrina Solette
Center for Advanced Studies
Gallente Federation
#40 - 2012-08-14 12:43:29 UTC
We have priests, they're called command ships.
Previous page123Next page