These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Science & Industry

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
12Next page
 

"combat" supporting an Orca/Hulk

Author
Erinn Sylvanus
NovaTech Universal
#1 - 2012-06-14 12:48:36 UTC
Relatively new player here (just approaching 3m SP), and I usually hang out with a couple of others that do a lot of mining in highsec. They are currently working toward an Orca and a Hulk. Their plans are to tank the Hulk and the Orca out (more concerned with surviving than yield).

I have concentrated almost entirely on combat and support (engineering/electronics/mechanics/drones) skills. Up until now, when I'm hanging out with them I usually just rat in the area.

I'd like to be prepared to support them more when they get into the Hulk/Orca about a month from now. What would be the best way that I could support them? Should I be training toward a Logistics ship, to help them survive against gankers? If so, what advice/recommendations would you give regarding that?

Note that I've mostly trained Gallente-type ships and armor-tanking skills thus far, if that matters.
Brewlar Kuvakei
Adeptio Gloriae
#2 - 2012-06-14 13:02:35 UTC  |  Edited by: Brewlar Kuvakei
Taking out an Orca in high sec with out agro would require a significant investment from any suciders because of the raw HP and Orca can have.

The Hulk however can be sucide ganked fairly easily. You can deter people from doing this by fitting a good tank on your hulk and also providing remote reps from another ship however this is fairly intensive and will not generate a good ISK/hr investment. Another option would be to have an insta locking support ship with ECM that could prevent any gankers who go GCC from destroying the hulk. Yet again this is fairly pointless unless you were guarding a fleet of Hulks. Which I suppose is an option.

If you had 10 or more hulks in a belt insta locking ECM or DPS is a good defence and can protect from suciders but not 100% of the time more so if they attack with multiple gankers at once.
Erinn Sylvanus
NovaTech Universal
#3 - 2012-06-14 13:17:01 UTC
What about shield-repping the Hulk? Would that be worthwhile, or just a drop in the bucket to a Hulk that's got a decent tank and maybe even getting shield warfare linked (I think that's what its called) from the Orca?
Sturmwolke
#4 - 2012-06-14 13:24:14 UTC  |  Edited by: Sturmwolke
It's generally a waste of time and effort to standby a dedicated logistics ship for any gank attempts. You won't have the time to switch, even if you have it stored in the Orca's SMB.
On the flip-side, if you're almost guaranteed of bad company showing up at a known time/location, then yes, it's worth the effort.

You'd do better by :
a) Properly tanking all barges/exhumers (as best as possible within its limitations). Your goal is to survive sloppy attempts and make gankers spend more effort/resources to draw blood.
This means buffer tanks (high EHP), not active tanks (anything with shield boosters).
b) Keeping alert and warp away when you see several signature gank boats (Thrasher/Catalyst/Talos/Tornado) landing close.
c) Don't forget to maximize the tank on the Orca with proper shield tank + DCU + T2 Bulkheads. When miners forget this - tissue paper Orca goes boom.

Lastly, if you're bent on doing some sort of logistics work, T1 logis boats Osprey/Exequror makes nice starter standalone logis for shield/armor respectively.
You wont need much tank on those for the above purpose and they can be built as glass cannons. Skills needed are self explanatory.

P.S A note on repping mining barge/exhumers, they're better with a shield tank. In addition, shield repping starts immediately at the beginning of the cycle,
Armor repping starts at the end of the cycle and this is a weakness for the above circumstance.

P.P.S Also read the new devblog on mining barge changes.
Erinn Sylvanus
NovaTech Universal
#5 - 2012-06-14 13:37:31 UTC
Sturmwolke wrote:
It's generally a waste of time and effort to standby a dedicated logistics ship for any gank attempts. You won't have the time to switch, even if you have it stored in the Orca's SMB.


I'd be in the ship all the time, not switching to it (if I do this).

Sturmwolke wrote:

You'd do better by :
a) Properly tanking all barges/exhumers (as best as possible within its limitations). Your goal is to survive sloppy attempts and make gankers spend more effort/resources to draw blood.
This means buffer tanks (high EHP), not active tanks (anything with shield boosters).
b) Keeping alert and warp away when you see several signature gank boats (Thrasher/Catalyst/Talos/Tornado) landing close.
c) Don't forget to maximize the tank on the Orca with proper shield tank + DCU + T2 Bulkheads. When miners forget this - tissue paper Orca goes boom.


a) Definitely they'll be tanking the Hulk
b) No afk'ing with this group, that I know of at least.
c) Definitely the plan to have the Orca tanked

Sturmwolke wrote:

P.P.S Also read the new devblog on mining barge changes.


Just did! Wow - it will be interesting to see how that changes things.

Thanks much for the advice. Basically, I'm trying to figure out how I can support this little group without resorting to mining myself or hauling. I'll do that if that's the best thing, but I'd rather focus on a more protective role.
Karak Bol
Low-Sec Survival Ltd.
#6 - 2012-06-14 17:41:53 UTC
Get a cheap ship, maybe a griffin. Fit it with an ECM Burst and rigs that increase the ECM range. If you see a Gank squad drop, burst them. If you get the timing right, (between the first gankers shooting and the second locking up) you will jam part of the Hit squad. Alternatively, burst them while they drop. ECM Burst is an area of effect, it should efOh, and farm your sec status back up, because you will draw a GCC for jamming those helpless rocks. Try to learn the timing on Sisi before trying it at home.
Zetaomega333
High Flyers
#7 - 2012-06-14 23:16:16 UTC
Drone boat, Train for this, Not only will you get extra dps, but the domi can put Remote reps on it, Rep drones, Guns, a whole slew of things but also be prepared for anything that might attack from using ecm drone to heavys to sentrys to lights.
Ireland VonVicious
Vicious Trading Company
#8 - 2012-06-15 04:44:01 UTC
Get a shield repping logi.

Have orca with power transfers on it.

Have hulks built for balanced/high resist.
Have hulks over heat when gankers show.

Orca powers logi, and logi reps hulks.

Done right it can rep a couple thousand dps!

Waste of time to do this in small groups.
Five hulks minimum.
Daniel Plain
Doomheim
#9 - 2012-06-15 12:32:09 UTC
if you're dealing with destroyer gangs, RR can be effective. a tornado can alpha your hulk out of the belt, so no amount of RR will help there.

I should buy an Ishtar.

Celgar Thurn
Department 10
#10 - 2012-06-15 14:09:48 UTC
It is uneconomic and totally ineffective to have another account running to provide 'combat support' and will not save your mining ships once gankers have arrived on top of your mining vessel. I have written a large piece of text detailing what I personally believe to be best policy in the 'Safe Mining' OP in this section if you wish to read that. The basic idea being that you watch local channel in a quiet system. Investigate everyone that enters the system reading through their bio & corp details. As a rule gankers stick out like something distasteful on the sole of your shoe. Usually either their corp details mention PvP or pirating directly. More often they will be in NPC corps so you can't wardec them. They aren't called gutless cowards for nothing. Smile

Btw if your Orca pilot is skilled up in 'links' then its worth sticking the shield link on to give extra resists instead of the mining capacitor one. Gives a decent extra bit of resist and EHP to the Hulk and a lot more to the Orca. Although a 160,000+ EHP Orca is unlikely to go down even in 0.5 .
Trappist Monk
Doomheim
#11 - 2012-06-15 19:12:13 UTC
Brewlar Kuvakei wrote:
Taking out an Orca in high sec with out agro would require a significant investment from any suciders because of the raw HP and Orca can have.

The Hulk however can be sucide ganked fairly easily. You can deter people from doing this by fitting a good tank on your hulk and also providing remote reps from another ship however this is fairly intensive and will not generate a good ISK/hr investment. Another option would be to have an insta locking support ship with ECM that could prevent any gankers who go GCC from destroying the hulk. Yet again this is fairly pointless unless you were guarding a fleet of Hulks. Which I suppose is an option.

If you had 10 or more hulks in a belt insta locking ECM or DPS is a good defence and can protect from suciders but not 100% of the time more so if they attack with multiple gankers at once.

if you actually did this, you'd have to lock and fire after the gank began. In an alpha gank, you'd be useless. If you preemptively strike you get GCC and eventually go negative sec yourself.
Trappist Monk
Doomheim
#12 - 2012-06-15 19:16:05 UTC
Celgar Thurn wrote:
They aren't called gutless cowards for nothing. Smile

I'm not sure how you can call kamikazes cowards. It may be hard to believe, but some people don't do it "maliciously" to harvest your tears. Personally, i see hisec as the african savannah. you guys are zebras and i'm a cheetah. There is no good or bad, right or wrong, just predator and prey.
Cap James Tkirk
Baba Yagas
The Initiative.
#13 - 2012-06-15 22:47:05 UTC
hi sec = african safari............. fail
low sec and null are more like african safari where the preadtors eat the prey hs is for thoes that are prey and wish to remain prey i understand you might think your a mighty predator but your just a fish in a bowl. come out to lawlessness and practice being a predator

i know i was a bear in hs for a long time but im shifting into better gears

im not saying your prey but a predator ehhhhhhh thats up for debate

(im not a predator im a toon)
Jax Bederen
Dark Horse RM
#14 - 2012-06-16 00:34:18 UTC
Yea, ok Predator, put down that pizza and get some fresh air.Pirate
Kurfin
Kippers and Jam Developments
#15 - 2012-06-16 05:10:03 UTC
In the current atmosphere I'd use a covetor rather than a hulk. There are no rewards for popping them, and if someone decides to blow you up anyway you've only lost a faction of what you'd lose if someone popped your hulk.

If they you think they may need 2 or 3 rounds to get the job done though a Falcon could work. If they are bringing enough alpha to one shot your mining buddies the best option would be a running a shield harmonizing warfare link, preferably on a vulture or tengu though that would be a lot of training, but can be run on any tech 1 battle cruiser.
Smirky Dirk
Doomheim
#16 - 2012-06-16 16:05:41 UTC
Cap James Tkirk wrote:
hi sec = african safari............. fail
low sec and null are more like african safari where the preadtors eat the prey hs is for thoes that are prey and wish to remain prey i understand you might think your a mighty predator but your just a fish in a bowl. come out to lawlessness and practice being a predator

i know i was a bear in hs for a long time but im shifting into better gears

im not saying your prey but a predator ehhhhhhh thats up for debate

(im not a predator im a toon)

Low and null are not like the savannah, unless there's an army of gazelles and zebras with machine guns out on the plains. It isn't a Pixar or Disney film, as hard as that may be for the intellectually challenged to understand. low and null are active warzones in which everyone is both predator and prey. The analogy is a simple one. Herds of nearly defenseless prey graze while staying alert. It's pure hunting. A killer vs. a runner.

People with THIS kind of kill board should probably shut the **** up and avoid talking like a tough guy. Seriously, 13 kills in just over a year? That's pathetic.

In the last few days it's been hard to get a gank because the miners are finally, at long last, getting smarter. I think that's a good thing for everyone. It makes the stalk much more fun. Despite what p*ssies like you think and say, its actually fairly easy to avoid getting ganked if you LEARN HOW THE GAME MECHANICS WORK. Instead of spending time writing treatises on the unfairness of it all, how about you spend that time studying game mechanics?

Finally, I came IN from null sec to set up my hunting alts. You're just now going out. We'll meet again. I promise.
qDoctor Strangelove
Doomheim
#17 - 2012-06-16 22:56:24 UTC
Why tank the orca?
Dc2 + cpu rig + sieldextender rigs, inv field and emp hardners...
Might need a shield extender, but hey.

No alpha ship will touch you.

But screw brick tanking the orca, that is just dumb.
FlinchingNinja Kishunuba
Crunchy Crunchy
#18 - 2012-06-17 00:29:07 UTC
If I was you I would train up a scanning and use your skills to find grav sites. Then just keep an eye out on d-scan for probes.
Jorma Morkkis
State War Academy
Caldari State
#19 - 2012-06-17 04:22:18 UTC
qDoctor Strangelove wrote:
Why tank the orca?
Dc2 + cpu rig + sieldextender rigs, inv field and emp hardners...
Might need a shield extender, but hey.

No alpha ship will touch you.

But screw brick tanking the orca, that is just dumb.


Looks like someone wants easy Orca kills.

Do you know why some people like to brick tank their Orcas?
Orca can reach 280k EHP with just T2 mods and T1 shield rigs.

You want to gank that in 0.7 or higher? Prepare to lose ~1,5 bil worth of Tornadoes.
qDoctor Strangelove
Doomheim
#20 - 2012-06-17 06:28:45 UTC
Jorma Morkkis wrote:
qDoctor Strangelove wrote:
Why tank the orca?
Dc2 + cpu rig + sieldextender rigs, inv field and emp hardners...
Might need a shield extender, but hey.

No alpha ship will touch you.

But screw brick tanking the orca, that is just dumb.


Looks like someone wants easy Orca kills.

Do you know why some people like to brick tank their Orcas?
Orca can reach 280k EHP with just T2 mods and T1 shield rigs.

You want to gank that in 0.7 or higher? Prepare to lose ~1,5 bil worth of Tornadoes.



Please show one single killmail where gankers shoot an orca assisting in mining without agro...
12Next page