These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Science & Industry

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
12Next page
 

AFK-Indy Mining Perma-Passive Tank?

Author
Minnoh Ahishatsu
Minnoh Ahishatsu Corporation
Buy Low Die High
#1 - 2012-05-17 03:43:01 UTC
[Mammoth, High-Sec AFK-Indy Miner]
Expanded Cargohold II
Expanded Cargohold II
Expanded Cargohold II
Expanded Cargohold II

Explosive
Thermic Dissipation Field I
Medium Shield Extender I
Medium Shield Extender I
Medium Shield Extender I

Miner I
Empty

Empty
Empty
Empty

-About 17k cargo-

Will this Mammoth be able to perma-passive tank 0.5 sec Asteroid Belt rats? With my current skills it has about 7734.7 EHP, 15.2 Passive Shield HP/s, and 27.0 Passive Shield EHP/s. I use rat specific hardeners for the two types of pirate rats that spawn. I plan on flying an afk-indy every night to make a little pocket change while I happily dream of mining during the day Lol

I've contemplated the chance of being suicide ganked, especially during Hulkageddon, but considering my location (0.5 scarcely populated system), I believe the risk is well worth the reward. At my level, this ship is somewhat replaceable at about 5.6m including modules etc.

I'm much more worried about the asteroid belt rat spawns. To my knowledge, they only spawn in groups of three frigates at a time, and from where I am, mostly as Angel Cartel and occasionally as Serpentis. To get an idea of how strong they are, their bounties are usually between 8k-12k and can easily be handled by 3x Hobgoblin I's. Pretty weak, but I'm worried about the damage eventually out DPS'ing my tank over several hours. I've got the mammoth fitted with only MSE I's because I wasn't sure if I would overtank it with the much more expensive MSE II's. At one point I even considered fitting it with 3x Medium Core Defense Field Purgers I's just to ensure it's tank kept Shocked

The reason it's fitted with a Miner I instead of Miner II is because either way the cargo will fill up or the asteroid pop during the time I'm asleep.

I'm pretty sure this is more thank enough tank, but I just wanted others' thoughts, especially if there are holes in my plan. I hope I put in enough detail P




Skorpynekomimi
#2 - 2012-05-17 03:58:16 UTC
The isk you'd get is not worth the risk of getting it popped. T2 cargo expanders are expensive compared to the yield of that thing.

Economic PVP

Minnoh Ahishatsu
Minnoh Ahishatsu Corporation
Buy Low Die High
#3 - 2012-05-17 04:31:36 UTC  |  Edited by: Minnoh Ahishatsu
I if I get a full cargo every night, I'll make about 2.4m in 3.8 hours. Getting a full cargo isn't too realistic though, since I need 48.571k Plagioclase to fill up 17k cargo space. It's hard to find asteroids that big, so a more realistically sized asteroid would contain about 30-40k. 35k asteroids are still 1.75m in 2.76 hours each and are common here. It'd only take a few days to pay off a lost mammoth with that fit! And I bet I wouldn't get ganked more than once every other week Big smile
Wu Bei
Garoun Investment Bank
Gallente Federation
#4 - 2012-05-17 08:02:16 UTC
not worth it.
go for missions and buy minerals instead.
Boomhaur
#5 - 2012-05-17 08:18:08 UTC  |  Edited by: Boomhaur
Hulkageddon is going on, so people are out at belts looking to pop hulks they may just pop you for the heck of it. And the isk you make from that is so small it's not worth the risk. If you must do so, use T1 cargo expanders keep the cost down and insure the thing I fully expect someone bored to pop you. And I hope you don't have implants because they just may take your pod too.

And if you are going to mine with low skills, a destroyer will do better, or even a mining frig/cruiser.

Welcome to Eve. Everyone here is an Evil Sick Sadistic Bastard who is out to get you. Anyone who tells you otherwise is either trying to scam you or use you.

Pinstar Colton
Sweet Asteroid Acres
#6 - 2012-05-17 13:42:24 UTC
Mine properly and at the keyboard or don't mine at all. Even when Hulkageddon ends, anyone seeing a hauler mining will know you are afk and can gank you easily, especially since there is a chance they'll get a bunch of free mined ore out of the deal and have a hauler of their own nearby to scoop it.

If you are looking for afk passive income, dive into PI. Much less risky.

In the cat-and-mouse game that is low sec, there is no shame in learning to be a better mouse.

Selissa Shadoe
#7 - 2012-05-17 17:45:27 UTC
7.7K EHP is laughable, sadly. As mentioned before, don't fit T2 rigs of any kind to a miner, it's just not worth it.

"Whether suicide ganking or doing anything in eve, there are exorbitant amounts of people in the game and on the forums that are complete jerks." - Spikeflach

Minnoh Ahishatsu
Minnoh Ahishatsu Corporation
Buy Low Die High
#8 - 2012-05-17 20:08:55 UTC
Wu Bei wrote:
not worth it.
go for missions and buy minerals instead.


I actually switched from mission running to mining. I like the idea of doing the same thing every time, as sad as that may sound to some. I don't like too much variation in the way I try to make some isk. Even the little travel, and different types of objectives are too much for me. Leave the variation to when, and if, I start to PvP. Or maybe I'll end up switching back to mission running, but right now, my main focus is mining Smile

Boomhaur wrote:
Hulkageddon is going on, so people are out at belts looking to pop hulks they may just pop you for the heck of it. And the isk you make from that is so small it's not worth the risk. If you must do so, use T1 cargo expanders keep the cost down and insure the thing I fully expect someone bored to pop you. And I hope you don't have implants because they just may take your pod too.

And if you are going to mine with low skills, a destroyer will do better, or even a mining frig/cruiser.


I've already calculated the profit I'll be making and concluded that I'd be able to easily replace my ship within a few nights of afk-mining if it were to be ganked. And that's with afk-farming! I'd be able to replace it with active-mining if it were ganked every day, and still make a profit! I predict that I won't be ganked so often because of my location even with Hulkageddon going on, and if that's not true, then it's a lesson learned, right? With not too big of a loss at all. But your point on using the T1 expanded cargoholds to keep the cost down is really helpful. Cuts the ship price almost in half, with not too bad of a cargo space loss (17k-12k). In fact, this is even better than my current fit because now I only need 34k Plagioclase to fill up my cargo, and like I said before, that's about how big the asteroids are where I'm mining. Now, if I were to get popped with a full cargo ( using T1 expanded cargoholds), I'd only lose about 4.3m (2.6m for the ship and 1.7m for the ore), which is easily replaceable, and in my opinion, worth it for the profit I'll be making (1.7m per night, unganked and with 34k Plagioclase asteroids). And no, I don't have implants Big smile

I think the point of afk-mining with an Industrial is to take advantage of its exponentially larger cargo hold, albeit a much slower mining rate. Since I'm afk, the mining rate makes an insignificant difference. Active mining is a different story Big smile I use an Osprey fitted with T2 modules for that.

Pinstar Colton wrote:
Mine properly and at the keyboard or don't mine at all. Even when Hulkageddon ends, anyone seeing a hauler mining will know you are afk and can gank you easily, especially since there is a chance they'll get a bunch of free mined ore out of the deal and have a hauler of their own nearby to scoop it.

If you are looking for afk passive income, dive into PI. Much less risky.


Look above Smile

At the moment, I want to focus on mining. The dangers of low sec don't quite interest me yet at the moment. Thanks for the idea though! I'll let you know if I'm interested Big smile

Selissa Shadoe wrote:
7.7K EHP is laughable, sadly. As mentioned before, don't fit T2 rigs of any kind to a miner, it's just not worth it.


Yes, I'm sure it is, but the so are the little peashooters those three frigates are shooting Lol Maybe you are referring to the fact that if I'm ganked, 7.7K EHP is just about as protective as paper. I'm well aware of the fact that if I'm ganked, I'm going to lose my ship. (Look above for discussion on being ganked) I'm much more concerned about the frigates with their peashooters and if they will get through my tank with them Sad
Katja Faith
Doomheim
#9 - 2012-05-17 20:57:51 UTC
Not sure if trolling... Roll
Minnoh Ahishatsu
Minnoh Ahishatsu Corporation
Buy Low Die High
#10 - 2012-05-17 21:07:03 UTC  |  Edited by: Minnoh Ahishatsu
I wouldn't need to put in that much effort to effectively troll Smile The numbers are there. The logic is there. It's a serious question. Am I missing something? I may only have been playing for a couple weeks, but this makes sense doesn't it? All I want to know is if this fit will be able to perma-passive tank these tiny frigates! I don't care about being ganked, making minimal isk, waste of time etc. I've taken it all into account, and want to give it a shot Big smile
Iosue
League of Gentlemen
The Initiative.
#11 - 2012-05-17 22:26:24 UTC
if you're going to do this, do it in a mission belt. that way no one will just stumble upon you. you'll prolly also find larger roids in certain missions that may not pop before you fill up your cargo hold. in the future, i'd also suggest refraining from these types of questions on your main. its just asking gankers to run a locator agent and harass you.

as for your main question, i have no idea. though i seem to remember more than just frigates in .05 systems. if you're not concerned about the time and cost of losing a few of these haulers, why not just try it out? pretty sure you could attract a spawn quickly enough to test it out. there's also sisi if you really want to be cautious.
Minnoh Ahishatsu
Minnoh Ahishatsu Corporation
Buy Low Die High
#12 - 2012-05-17 22:43:12 UTC
Ah ok. I'll look into mining in mission belts. Especially now that I'm out in the open Cry Noob mistake. Still learning I guess. It's a 0.5 system. A bit of a difference from .05 Lol I wouldn't chance afk'ing in general in low sec P I'm not skilled up to the Mammoth yet heh. Still another 4 days. So I was just curious. Since no one has really come up with an answer, I just did some research on my own. Guess I shouldn't expect people to actually answer my question rather than question my motives X Maybe they just cared for my safety? With my skills, my passive tank HP/s is 15.2. And if you didn't already know, at 30% shields your passive regen doubles. So thats 30.4 max HP/s. The strongest frigate spawn does 9 dps. So that max DPS from a group of 3 of these is 27. The chances of three of these spawning together though is next to 0 I'd guess from past experience with belt rat spawns. The average dps from a group of three I've seen so far is about 18-20. So theoretically, I should be able to perma-passive tank these rats, correct?
Christina Tucker
Center for Advanced Studies
Gallente Federation
#13 - 2012-05-17 22:45:20 UTC
Yah i saw OP posting in rook chat a night or two ago...not gonna lie, i rolled my eyes and shook my head IRL.


Just do what the guy a few posts up suggested and do PI. I started this toon with the intention of becoming a miner, but i wanted to try PI out. When trained to the right levels PI can net you quite a bit of ISK. I only trained PI skills high enough just to get my feet wet, and in about 2-3 days both my high sec PI get me about 1.3mil each. If i train skills for another 2-3 days, i can upgrade my sites/add 1-2 more and probably net 3-4 mil per day off of the tier 2 products i make. At first i thought PI was complicated, but after reading up on PI, its actually very easy.

Minnoh Ahishatsu
Minnoh Ahishatsu Corporation
Buy Low Die High
#14 - 2012-05-17 23:08:56 UTC
I still don't understand why it's so looked down upon What? It's easy isk, low risk. I guess I'll start looking into PI, then. More afk isk to add onto afk-mining Big smile Since I pretty much answered my original questions (but still learned a lot of other things), I guess the rest of it is up to experimentation. Even though you guys have been less than supportive of my noobie ventures, I'll post here after I try it out in case this information could be useful to anyone. Cry
Sevastian Liao
DreamWeaver Inc.
#15 - 2012-05-18 00:11:38 UTC
I've done this before, up till the point where other forms of passive money making made AFK indy mining look about as attractive as scouring drains to pick up pennies. It becomes not worth it very soon, but ok - I can see where you're coming from.

If you really still want to go ahead with it:

- If you can't mine in a mission belt, or find it too much trouble - Do this in a system with no stations so there's significantly less chance of random people seeing you in the belt. Mission belts are still a better idea
- Consider not doing this as a nightly "earn ISK while I sleep", and instead make it an "earn ISK while I'm taking a shower, having dinner, running some errands, reading a book" activity
- Benefits of the above being - Your AFK times are shorter and more random, you can go ahead and fit a Miner II and MLUs to fill up your cargo faster, you can choose a higher sec system even though the roids are smaller, you'll actually be getting paid off for every minute of your AFK time as opposed to spending 2-3 hours mining and then then next 2-3 hours taking all the risks with no associated reward, which you'll be doing if you're sleeping. Unless you're functioning on only 3 hours of sleep every night.
- Remember to orbit the asteroid you're mining
- Don't count on being able to tank 0.5 sec belt rats with that setup, certainly not with that small margin of error. Rats can do higher than normal damage occassionally that slowly eat away at your tank. Best tank is being in a 0.9 or 1.0 security status system.
Hatt0ri Hanz0
Life sucks then you die Ltd.
#16 - 2012-05-18 02:38:57 UTC
Don't let these nay-sayers dissuade from what you want to do in this game. Yeah, it's true you won't make much every night. Peanuts really, and yeah it's only a matter of time until it gets ganked. But as long as you make more isk then you're putting into it, then go for it. I would agree with the PI though. If your looking to make isk while you sleep, look no further then PI.
Henry Haphorn
Killer Yankee
#17 - 2012-05-18 05:05:33 UTC
Minnoh Ahishatsu wrote:
[Mammoth, High-Sec AFK-Indy Miner]
Expanded Cargohold II
Expanded Cargohold II
Expanded Cargohold II
Expanded Cargohold II

Explosive
Thermic Dissipation Field I
Medium Shield Extender I
Medium Shield Extender I
Medium Shield Extender I

Miner I
Empty

Empty
Empty
Empty

-About 17k cargo-







Not worth it, easily gankable, and the mining yield is too low to compensate for the loss of a hauler. Best bet is to go for a destroyer. At least that gives a better yield/cargo ratio.

Adapt or Die

Implying Implications
Sebiestor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#18 - 2012-05-18 08:16:18 UTC
You need a deadspace shield booster on that mammoth.
Samillian
Angry Mustellid
#19 - 2012-05-18 08:35:36 UTC
Having read your post I can't fathom why you are even bothering to play this game but thats your choice. Abandon the mammoth plan, its sad and pathetic you could make far more ISK/hr sitting in a trade hub simply doing small scale station trading. Then all you would need to do is keep half an eye on your sell and buy order prices.

NBSI shall be the whole of the Law

Alyssa SaintCroix
Leihkasse Stammheim
#20 - 2012-05-18 14:37:56 UTC
Minnoh Ahishatsu wrote:
I still don't understand why it's so looked down upon What? It's easy isk, low risk. I guess I'll start looking into PI, then. More afk isk to add onto afk-mining Big smile Since I pretty much answered my original questions (but still learned a lot of other things), I guess the rest of it is up to experimentation. Even though you guys have been less than supportive of my noobie ventures, I'll post here after I try it out in case this information could be useful to anyone. Cry



It's not looked down upon, it's simply a poor management of your time. If you were to spend 45-60 minutes in a retriever of all things you'd probably make as much as you would have in 4 hours of "afk mining" in a hauler. Yes, the hauler has significant cargo capacity but there is a bottleneck between that big ole cardboard box floating in space and the tiny little hand dropping what amounts to pebbles into it.

I think at one point many people think wow cargo space! mining laser! WOOHOO! and then you come to the sad realization that filling the cargo hold is an exercise in futility.
12Next page