These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Ships & Modules

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
Previous page12
 

Another Hulk Thread

Author
Leto Atraities
Ministry of War
Amarr Empire
#21 - 2012-04-15 18:55:36 UTC
Jorma Amatin wrote:

As far as people thinking hulks need more EHP, they were never meant to be combat-ready ships, that's why mining fleets would sometimes run with combat support to guard them. If they wanted to be very cheap in highsec, have an ECM trained pilot take a Falcon so he can jam any aggressors.


and yet you seem to think it's perfectly fine for a throw away trail alt to be able to hop into a catalyst and solo a 300MIl isk T2 hulk in under 14 days right?
baltec1
Bat Country
Pandemic Horde
#22 - 2012-04-15 18:58:17 UTC
Leto Atraities wrote:


and yet you seem to think it's perfectly fine for a throw away trail alt to be able to hop into a catalyst and solo a 300MIl isk T2 hulk in under 14 days right?


Thats what happens when people can profit from you failing to fit a tank.
Leto Atraities
Ministry of War
Amarr Empire
#23 - 2012-04-15 19:20:33 UTC
baltec1 wrote:
Leto Atraities wrote:


and yet you seem to think it's perfectly fine for a throw away trail alt to be able to hop into a catalyst and solo a 300MIl isk T2 hulk in under 14 days right?


Thats what happens when people can profit from "others" failing to fit a tank.



Fixed.

personally, i've only lost one hulk. my 1st hulk. and that's because back in '09 when i quite mining i gave that hulk to a friend who saw fit (against me screaming at him not to do so) to fly it around during a war dec.

and hell no that shouldn't be what happens to anybody in high sec. no throw away alt should solo a hulk in high sec before concord arrives. and i don't give a damn what kind of tank said hulk has at the time of it's demise. only wat this should be possible is to a covetor because those can have no tank compared to the hulk.
Prince Kobol
#24 - 2012-04-15 19:32:57 UTC
Leto Atraities wrote:
Jorma Amatin wrote:

As far as people thinking hulks need more EHP, they were never meant to be combat-ready ships, that's why mining fleets would sometimes run with combat support to guard them. If they wanted to be very cheap in highsec, have an ECM trained pilot take a Falcon so he can jam any aggressors.


and yet you seem to think it's perfectly fine for a throw away trail alt to be able to hop into a catalyst and solo a 300MIl isk T2 hulk in under 14 days right?


Please show me this amazing T1 catalyst fit that can solo my hulk that has 27k EHP before you get concorded?


baltec1
Bat Country
Pandemic Horde
#25 - 2012-04-15 19:34:37 UTC
Leto Atraities wrote:



Fixed.

personally, i've only lost one hulk. my 1st hulk. and that's because back in '09 when i quite mining i gave that hulk to a friend who saw fit (against me screaming at him not to do so) to fly it around during a war dec.

and hell no that shouldn't be what happens to anybody in high sec. no throw away alt should solo a hulk in high sec before concord arrives. and i don't give a damn what kind of tank said hulk has at the time of it's demise. only wat this should be possible is to a covetor because those can have no tank compared to the hulk.


News just in, ships with no tank dont tend to tank very well. Want a tank? then fit a tank.
Leto Atraities
Ministry of War
Amarr Empire
#26 - 2012-04-15 19:39:51 UTC
Prince Kobol wrote:
Leto Atraities wrote:
Jorma Amatin wrote:

As far as people thinking hulks need more EHP, they were never meant to be combat-ready ships, that's why mining fleets would sometimes run with combat support to guard them. If they wanted to be very cheap in highsec, have an ECM trained pilot take a Falcon so he can jam any aggressors.


and yet you seem to think it's perfectly fine for a throw away trail alt to be able to hop into a catalyst and solo a 300MIl isk T2 hulk in under 14 days right?


Please show me this amazing T1 catalyst fit that can solo my hulk that has 27k EHP before you get concorded?



don't try and play me. you've seen kill mails just like anybody else. and i'm not talking about your buffer hulk. i'm talking about any hulk. like i said already i don't give a damn how it's tanked. thats meaning even if said hulk was using a small booster tank setup a throw away trail alt shouldn't be able to beat concord to the punch in high sec.
Leto Atraities
Ministry of War
Amarr Empire
#27 - 2012-04-15 19:43:05 UTC
baltec1 wrote:
Leto Atraities wrote:



Fixed.

personally, i've only lost one hulk. my 1st hulk. and that's because back in '09 when i quite mining i gave that hulk to a friend who saw fit (against me screaming at him not to do so) to fly it around during a war dec.

and hell no that shouldn't be what happens to anybody in high sec. no throw away alt should solo a hulk in high sec before concord arrives. and i don't give a damn what kind of tank said hulk has at the time of it's demise. only wat this should be possible is to a covetor because those can have no tank compared to the hulk.


News just in, ships with no tank dont tend to tank very well. Want a tank? then fit a tank.



are you trying to get me to respond a "no sh*t sherlock" back to you or sumthin?
Prince Kobol
#28 - 2012-04-15 19:44:36 UTC  |  Edited by: Prince Kobol
Leto Atraities wrote:
Prince Kobol wrote:
Leto Atraities wrote:
Jorma Amatin wrote:

As far as people thinking hulks need more EHP, they were never meant to be combat-ready ships, that's why mining fleets would sometimes run with combat support to guard them. If they wanted to be very cheap in highsec, have an ECM trained pilot take a Falcon so he can jam any aggressors.


and yet you seem to think it's perfectly fine for a throw away trail alt to be able to hop into a catalyst and solo a 300MIl isk T2 hulk in under 14 days right?


Please show me this amazing T1 catalyst fit that can solo my hulk that has 27k EHP before you get concorded?



don't try and play me. you've seen kill mails just like anybody else. and i'm not talking about your buffer hulk. i'm talking about any hulk. like i said already i don't give a damn how it's tanked. thats meaning even if said hulk was using a small booster tank setup a throw away trail alt shouldn't be able to beat concord to the punch in high sec.


I haven't seen any kill mails because personally I think they are pointless and I don't waste my time looking at them.

You have lost me.. you are not talking about my buffer hulk, your talking about any hulk.

Well surely if you are talking about any hulk that would include my buffer tank hulk as well.

Actually.. what are you trying to say because you post makes no sense what so ever.
Leto Atraities
Ministry of War
Amarr Empire
#29 - 2012-04-15 19:53:28 UTC
Prince Kobol wrote:
I haven't seen any kill mails because personally I think they are pointless and I don't waste my time looking at them.

You have lost me.. you are not talking about my buffer hulk, your talking about any hulk.

Well surely if you are talking about any hulk that would include my buffer tank hulk as well.

Actually.. what are you trying to say because you post makes no sense what so ever.


KMs are pointless? you no pay attention to them? lol

since you're not trying to follow what i'm trying to convey then i'll do it another way.

it should not be possible for a throw away trial alt to solo a hulk in high sec when it's fitted with a tank using a small booster cap stable.

clearly this is the more than common setup for allot of high sec peeps. and that should be enough to survive a solo throw away suicide trial alt in a catalyst in high sec before concord arrives.
drdxie
#30 - 2012-04-15 20:26:46 UTC
everybody knows hulks are prime targets.. so fit accordingly... my hulk has 26k EHP before I boost it with the orca with a Shield Harmonizing fitted. I also have a large S95 shield rep on the orca.. yea it not the optimal mining setup, but has survived countless gank attempts, you'd think gankers would do a quick scan before they warp in and start shooting...

Caldari Loving needed.. https://forums.eveonline.com/default.aspx?g=posts&m=1608277&#post1608277

Prince Kobol
#31 - 2012-04-16 06:20:37 UTC
Leto Atraities wrote:
Prince Kobol wrote:
I haven't seen any kill mails because personally I think they are pointless and I don't waste my time looking at them.

You have lost me.. you are not talking about my buffer hulk, your talking about any hulk.

Well surely if you are talking about any hulk that would include my buffer tank hulk as well.

Actually.. what are you trying to say because you post makes no sense what so ever.


KMs are pointless? you no pay attention to them? lol

since you're not trying to follow what i'm trying to convey then i'll do it another way.

it should not be possible for a throw away trial alt to solo a hulk in high sec when it's fitted with a tank using a small booster cap stable.

clearly this is the more than common setup for allot of high sec peeps. and that should be enough to survive a solo throw away suicide trial alt in a catalyst in high sec before concord arrives.


So what your saying is that because so many people fail to fit there hulks accordingly that CCP should either buff the hulks base EHP or increase concords response time?

baltec1
Bat Country
Pandemic Horde
#32 - 2012-04-16 08:41:51 UTC
Leto Atraities wrote:


it should not be possible for a throw away trial alt to solo a hulk in high sec when it's fitted with a tank using a small booster cap stable.

clearly this is the more than common setup for allot of high sec peeps. and that should be enough to survive a solo throw away suicide trial alt in a catalyst in high sec before concord arrives.


A sheild booster does nothing at all to stop an alpha ship.
Lenier Chenal
Offensive Upholder
#33 - 2012-04-16 13:42:47 UTC
Endeavour Starfleet wrote:
Again it needs to be said that the issue with these ships is not tank (As in the ability to resist damage over time) but susceptibility to alpha (High alpha quickly overwhelms defence before CONCORD or blues can respond)

A nullsec hulk that can tank NPCs should cost nearly a billion. That is normal. What isn't normal is these craft falling to such cheap gank craft in hisec.

They dont need more sustained tank. They need alpha prevention via a massive boost to structure HP. That way it becomes stupid not to fly with a DCU and with said DCU it costs more per gank which will equalize things out.


Cost over a billion? Nope. A hulk fitted to tank NPC rats in belts isn't expensive at all, certainly not almost 800 million ISK over the hull price.
Tanya Powers
Doomheim
#34 - 2012-04-16 17:50:29 UTC
baltec1 wrote:
The hulk can tank 3 alpha tornados with ease. The problem is people don't tank them then whine when this happens. The other month BATs went and killed 707 exhumers. None of them were tanked.



I don't see anything else in that KM than the simple fact that isn't even worthy put tank modules on that ship for what they bring. Also that guy must be a rich player or probably a bot, who would mine with an hulk when you WILL ALWAYS have much better yeld doing other activities?

Doesn't your argument also means that if your alliance looses so many Tornados is because they are too lazy to fit tank on those, or because like the hulk, they fit for a specific task?
baltec1
Bat Country
Pandemic Horde
#35 - 2012-04-16 17:56:31 UTC
Tanya Powers wrote:
baltec1 wrote:
The hulk can tank 3 alpha tornados with ease. The problem is people don't tank them then whine when this happens. The other month BATs went and killed 707 exhumers. None of them were tanked.



I don't see anything else in that KM than the simple fact that isn't even worthy put tank modules on that ship for what they bring. Also that guy must be a rich player or probably a bot, who would mine with an hulk when you WILL ALWAYS have much better yeld doing other activities?

Doesn't your argument also means that if your alliance looses so many Tornados is because they are too lazy to fit tank on those, or because like the hulk, they fit for a specific task?


Because tanking a nado makes a difference with concord...
Retar Aveymone
GoonWaffe
Goonswarm Federation
#36 - 2012-04-16 17:59:21 UTC
Cpt Greagor wrote:
Hulks have always had a weak tank, and for good reason, it isn't a ship meant to tank.

Anyway, as I said, they've always been this way, so what's with all the tears about it now?

Hulkageddon V
Retar Aveymone
GoonWaffe
Goonswarm Federation
#37 - 2012-04-16 18:01:24 UTC  |  Edited by: Retar Aveymone
Endeavour Starfleet wrote:
Again it needs to be said that the issue with these ships is not tank (As in the ability to resist damage over time) but susceptibility to alpha (High alpha quickly overwhelms defence before CONCORD or blues can respond).

i have murdered more hulks than i can count: you're wrong

ehp is what saves hulks, alpha only comes in when you try to use repping alts (and alpha only really works when the idiot only has repping buddies, no local ehp)

it's quite possible to tank a hulk to the point it's hard for me to gank it dual-boxing, it's just the common miner is pond scum who can't imagine how to fit a hulk without a full rack of mlus and cargo rigs
Previous page12